


Ask the community...
As someone who went through a similar situation, I'd strongly recommend being very cautious here. The IRS has specific criteria for medical expense deductions, and gym memberships rarely qualify even with a doctor's recommendation. The key issue is that they view fitness facilities as having a "personal pleasure" component that disqualifies them as purely medical. For a gym membership to potentially qualify, you'd need: 1) A specific diagnosed medical condition (not just general health improvement), 2) A doctor's prescription (not recommendation) stating the facility is necessary for treatment, 3) Documentation that the treatment can't be performed elsewhere, and 4) Evidence you're using it solely for medical treatment. Since you're self-employed, remember you'd still need to itemize deductions and exceed the 7.5% AGI threshold for medical expenses. Given the audit risk others have mentioned and the strict IRS interpretation, you might want to focus on other legitimate medical deductions instead. Keep your doctor's documentation though - it could be useful for other related medical expenses.
This is really helpful advice, thank you! I'm curious about that 7.5% AGI threshold you mentioned - is that for all medical expenses combined, or does each expense need to individually exceed that threshold? I have some other medical costs this year like prescription medications and physical therapy sessions, so I'm wondering if bundling them together might help me reach that threshold even if the gym membership itself doesn't qualify.
The 7.5% AGI threshold applies to all qualifying medical expenses combined, not individually! So you'd add up all your legitimate medical expenses for the year (prescriptions, physical therapy, doctor visits, etc.) and only the amount that exceeds 7.5% of your adjusted gross income is deductible. For example, if your AGI is $50,000, you'd need more than $3,750 in total qualifying medical expenses before any of it becomes deductible. Then you can only deduct the amount over that threshold. So if you had $5,000 in qualifying medical expenses, you could deduct $1,250. This is why it's often worth bundling medical procedures or expenses into one tax year if possible - it helps you cross that threshold. Your prescriptions and PT sessions definitely count toward this total, which makes reaching the threshold more realistic than trying to qualify the gym membership alone.
Based on my experience as a tax professional, I have to echo what others have said - gym memberships are extremely difficult to deduct, even with a doctor's recommendation. The IRS has consistently ruled that health club memberships have too much "personal benefit" to qualify as pure medical expenses. However, since you mentioned you're self-employed, there might be a different angle worth exploring. If your back problems are directly related to your work (like if you have a desk job that caused the issues), you might be able to argue for a business expense deduction instead of a medical one. This would require documenting that the gym membership is primarily to address work-related health issues that affect your ability to perform your job. That said, this is still a risky deduction that could trigger scrutiny. The safest approach would be to focus on clearly qualifying medical expenses - your doctor visits, any physical therapy, prescribed medications, etc. These definitely count toward your medical expense total and are much less likely to raise red flags. Keep that doctor's documentation though - it might be useful if you end up needing specific therapeutic treatments that can only be done at certain facilities.
That's a really interesting point about the business expense angle! I hadn't thought about that approach. Since I do work from home at a computer most of the day, my back issues are definitely work-related. Would I need specific documentation from my doctor linking the back problems to my work setup, or is it enough that the issues interfere with my ability to work effectively? Also, would this still need to go through the same 7.5% AGI threshold, or do business expenses work differently for self-employed folks?
don't overthink this! i've been a single-member llc for 6 yrs on my wife's insurance. the insurance company doesn't care about your business structure - they only care that you're legally married to the employee. my wife's HR said it's actually super common. the only time it gets tricky is if ur business grows and you want to offer your OWN health insurance plan. but for a one-person shop just starting out, ur totally fine!
I'm in a very similar situation and was worried about the same thing! I've been on my husband's insurance for years while running my freelance graphic design business as a sole proprietor. The key thing I learned is that your eligibility for spousal coverage is based on your marital status, not your employment status or business structure. When I first started my business, I called his HR department just to double-check, and they confirmed that as long as I'm his legal spouse, I can stay on the plan regardless of whether I'm unemployed, self-employed, or have my own business. The only thing that would potentially change this is if his employer has very specific policies about it (which is rare), or if you eventually grow your business large enough to offer your own group health plan. One tip: keep really good records of any business-related health expenses since you might be able to deduct some of them on your Schedule C. Good luck with your new venture - it's so nice to have that security of knowing your health coverage is stable while you're building something new!
This is exactly the reassurance I needed to hear! I was getting so anxious about potentially losing coverage, but hearing from someone who's actually been doing this for years makes me feel so much better. I think I was overthinking it because health insurance feels so complicated and scary to mess with. Your tip about keeping records of business-related health expenses is really smart - I hadn't even thought about potential deductions. Do you track things like mileage to medical appointments if they're business-related somehow, or is it more like equipment that might help with health issues while working? Thank you for sharing your experience - it's giving me the confidence to move forward with starting my little business!
I'm in almost the exact same situation! Just got married last month and we moved to a new apartment right after our honeymoon. My transcript updated this morning showing my refund check was mailed yesterday, so I'm really anxious about whether it'll reach us. Reading through everyone's experiences here has been so eye-opening - I had no idea the IRS keeps separate address records from USPS mail forwarding! That's honestly a bit scary since we've been relying on our forwarding service to handle everything. Based on all the advice here, I'm definitely calling the IRS first thing Monday morning to verify they have our current address and my new married name on file. Better to spend time on hold now than potentially wait months for a returned check to get reprocessed. Also signing up for that USPS Informed Delivery service immediately - the tip about Treasury checks coming in plain envelopes is really valuable. Thanks to everyone who shared their timelines and experiences, it's so helpful for those of us going through this for the first time!
Congratulations on your recent marriage! I'm also new to this community and going through something similar - filed our first joint return after getting married and I'm still waiting for my refund check. It's so reassuring to read everyone's experiences here. The advice about calling the IRS to verify your address seems to be the consistent theme from everyone who's been through this successfully. I'm learning so much from all these shared experiences - like the fact that Treasury checks come in plain envelopes and that USPS forwarding doesn't automatically update IRS records. Definitely going to set up Informed Delivery too after seeing how many people recommend it. Best of luck with your call on Monday, and thanks for sharing your situation - it helps to know others are navigating the same challenges!
As someone who just went through this exact situation, I can definitely relate! Got married last year and moved right before tax season - it's stressful not knowing if your refund will find you. Based on everyone's experiences here, it sounds like the most important thing is calling the IRS to verify your address ASAP rather than assuming USPS mail forwarding will handle it. I made that call and discovered they still had my old address even though I'd updated everything else. The representative was able to fix it immediately, and my check arrived 7 days later. Also, definitely sign up for USPS Informed Delivery - the Treasury envelope really does look like regular mail, so it's easy to miss. Don't wait the full 2 weeks if you're concerned about the address change; being proactive saved me potentially months of waiting for a returned check to be reprocessed. The phone wait can be brutal, but it's worth the peace of mind knowing your refund is heading to the right place!
A tip from someone who's been doing this for years: You can adjust your W-4 to have ADDITIONAL withholding rather than messing with deductions. On the new W-4, there's a line for additional withholding. You can put a NEGATIVE number there (like -$50) and your employer's system might process it, resulting in less withholding without claiming fake deductions. Some payroll systems catch this, but many don't.
Ummm isn't that actually illegal though? Putting a negative number when the form clearly asks for additional withholding seems like fraud to me.
@Connor Gallagher is absolutely right - putting a negative number on the additional withholding line is definitely not something you should do. That s'essentially falsifying a tax form, which could get you in serious trouble with the IRS. The legitimate way to reduce withholding is to adjust the other sections of the W-4 properly - like claiming dependents you re'entitled to, accounting for deductions you ll'actually take, or using the multiple jobs worksheet if applicable. The tools mentioned earlier in this thread like taxr.ai can help you figure out the right approach without resorting to questionable tactics. Remember, the IRS has seen every trick in the book. It s'always better to stay above board and work within the system rather than risk penalties or worse.
For professional guidance, I'd recommend starting with a CPA (Certified Public Accountant) rather than a tax attorney. CPAs are perfect for tax planning strategies like optimizing your W-4 withholding, and they're generally more affordable than attorneys. Tax attorneys are typically needed for more serious issues like tax disputes, audits, or complex legal matters. A good CPA can help you calculate exactly how much you can reduce your withholding while staying within the safe harbor rules. They can also help you set up a system to save the extra money from each paycheck so you're prepared for tax time. One thing to consider: if your income varies significantly from year to year, the safe harbor calculation based on last year's taxes might not work as well. In that case, you'd want to base your withholding on 90% of this year's expected tax liability, which requires more careful planning. Also, don't forget that some states have their own underwithholding penalties separate from federal taxes, so make sure you account for state taxes in your calculations too.
This is really helpful advice about going with a CPA first! I'm actually in a situation where my income does vary quite a bit year to year (freelance work), so the 90% of current year approach sounds like what I'd need to use. Do you happen to know how often you can update your W-4 with your employer? Like if I start the year with one withholding amount but realize halfway through that my income is tracking higher or lower than expected, can I submit a new W-4 to adjust? Also, when you mention state underwithholding penalties - do most states follow similar rules to the federal safe harbor provisions, or is it completely different calculations for each state?
Alice Pierce
Been waiting since April 2024 here and this is super helpful info! Had no idea they'd include the interest in the same check. At 7% that's actually not terrible considering how long we've all been waiting. Thanks for the heads up about the 1099-INT too - would've definitely forgotten to report that interest as income next year.
0 coins
Caleb Stark
ā¢Same here! Been waiting since May and had no clue about the 1099-INT thing. Good to know they bundle it all together now - makes things way simpler than tracking multiple checks. At least the 7% makes the wait slightly less painful š
0 coins
Melina Haruko
Just wanted to chime in as someone who finally got their refund check last month after waiting since February! Can confirm everything comes in one check - the original refund amount plus all the accumulated interest. The breakdown was actually printed right on the stub that came with the check, so you can see exactly how much was interest vs the original refund. Really helpful for record keeping before that 1099-INT shows up next January. Hang in there everyone, the wait sucks but at least we're earning something on it!
0 coins
Brianna Schmidt
ā¢That's awesome info about the breakdown being on the stub! I've been wondering how to track everything for tax purposes. Quick question - did your check come pretty quickly once your transcript finally updated to show it was being issued, or was there still a long wait after that status change?
0 coins