


Ask the community...
I went through something similar with NYS Department of Labor last year. One thing that really helped my case was writing down everything I could remember about the hostile incidents - even small details like dates, times, and exactly what was said. I also reached out to former coworkers who witnessed some of the behavior and asked if they'd be willing to provide statements if needed. The adjudicator told me later that having multiple sources backing up my story made a big difference. Your sister should also keep records of her job search efforts since she'll need to show she's actively looking for work. The whole process was stressful but definitely worth it - I ended up getting approved after the initial review. Tell her not to get discouraged if it takes a while to hear back!
@Andrew Pinnock This is really helpful! I m'curious about the timeline - how long did the whole process take from when you first filed to getting your final approval? And did you have to do any interviews or hearings, or was it all handled through documentation? My sister is trying to plan financially while she s'job searching, so it would be good to know what kind of timeframe to expect. Also, when you were documenting incidents, did you focus more on specific examples of hostile behavior, or did you also include how it affected your work performance and mental health?
@Andrew Pinnock This is incredibly helpful advice! I m'dealing with a similar situation right now where I had to quit due to a toxic manager, and I ve'been hesitant to file because I wasn t'sure I had enough documentation. Your point about writing down even small details really resonates - I kept thinking I needed formal HR complaints or emails as proof, "but" I do remember specific dates and incidents pretty clearly. Quick question: when you were documenting everything, did you organize it chronologically or by type of incident? And did you include incidents that happened to other employees that you witnessed, or just focus on what directly happened to you? I want to make sure I m'presenting the strongest case possible to NYS Department of Labor.
I've been following this thread and wanted to share some additional resources that might help your sister. The NYS Department of Labor website has a specific section called "Voluntary Quit - Good Cause" that lists all the acceptable reasons for quitting that still qualify you for benefits. Besides hostile work environment, other qualifying reasons include unsafe working conditions, significant changes to job duties or pay, discrimination, and domestic violence situations. They also have a phone line specifically for questions about eligibility before filing - though as others mentioned, it can be hard to get through. One tip I learned is to call right when they open at 8 AM for the best chance of reaching someone. Your sister should also know that if she gets denied initially, the appeals process is pretty straightforward and many people who get denied on first review are approved on appeal. The most important thing is that she files soon and is completely honest and detailed about her situation.
@Giovanni Greco Thanks for mentioning that Voluntary "Quit - Good Cause section" on the NYS Department of Labor website! I ve'been trying to help my sister navigate this whole process and it s'been overwhelming trying to figure out what documentation she needs. The tip about calling at 8 AM is gold - we ve'been trying to reach them at random times during the day with no luck. I didn t'realize domestic violence situations also qualified, which is important information that more people should know about. Do you happen to know if there s'a specific form or format they prefer for documenting incidents when filing the initial claim, or is it just a narrative description in the application? My sister has been putting together her timeline but wants to make sure she s'presenting it in the most effective way possible.
@Giovanni Greco This is such helpful information! I had no idea there was a specific section on their website for voluntary quit situations. My sister has been struggling with whether to file because she s'worried about being denied, but it sounds like even if that happens initially, the appeals process gives her another chance. The 8 AM call tip is definitely something we ll'try - we ve'been calling during lunch hours and getting nowhere. One question: when you mention being completely "honest and detailed, how" much detail is too much? My sister has pages of notes about different incidents but she s'worried about overwhelming whoever reviews her case. Should she focus on the most serious incidents or try to paint the full picture of the pattern of behavior? Also, do you know if they prefer everything submitted in writing initially, or if there s'an interview process where she can explain verbally?
Pro tip for everyone struggling with the NY unemployment website - if you're using an older browser or have strict privacy settings, some of the navigation elements might not load properly. I had this issue where the Payment History section wasn't showing up at all until I switched to Chrome and disabled my ad blocker temporarily. Also, make sure you're fully logged out and back in if you've been on the site for a while - sometimes the session gets wonky and certain pages won't display correctly. The website definitely has its quirks but these tricks usually help when things aren't working as expected!
This is super helpful! I've been having issues with certain sections not loading properly and never thought it could be a browser compatibility thing. I'm usually pretty stubborn about using Firefox but might need to switch to Chrome for this. The session timeout issue makes total sense too - I've definitely been logged in for hours trying to figure this out. Thanks for the technical troubleshooting tips!
Just wanted to add that if you're still having trouble finding these documents, you can also request them by mail if needed. I had to do this once when the website was down for maintenance during tax season. You can call the NYSDOL customer service line and request they mail you a paper copy of your 1099-G and payment history - it takes about 7-10 business days to arrive, but it's a good backup option if you're running into technical issues with the website or need official hard copies for your records.
That's really good to know about the mail option! I didn't realize you could request paper copies if the website isn't cooperating. 7-10 business days isn't too bad if you're planning ahead for tax season. Do you know if there's a fee for getting the documents mailed, or is it free? This could be a lifesaver for people who are having persistent technical issues or don't have reliable internet access.
I went through something similar when I first applied. One thing that really helped me was creating a spreadsheet with all my pay periods, hours worked, and what was actually reported vs what I earned. It made it much easier to spot discrepancies when I compared it to what NYS Department of Labor had on file. Also, don't forget that your base period might not include your most recent earnings - there's often a lag, so your highest earning quarters might not even be in the calculation period. You can check this by looking at exactly which quarters they used for your base period in your determination letter.
That's really smart to create a spreadsheet! I wish I had thought of that before filing. I'm realizing now that I probably should have been more organized about tracking my actual earnings vs what was reported. It's frustrating that the base period doesn't include recent work - I actually got a small raise about 6 months ago but it sounds like that won't even count toward my benefits. Do you know if there's any way to use more recent quarters instead of the standard base period, or are we just stuck with whatever quarters they automatically select?
@Mei Liu There is actually an alternative base period you can request! It s'called the alternate "base period and" uses the four most recently completed quarters instead of the standard base period. You have to specifically request this when you file your claim or during the appeals process. However, they ll'only use it if it results in you being eligible for benefits when you wouldn t'be under the standard base period, or if it gives you a higher weekly benefit amount. So if your recent raise was significant and you have good wage records for those newer quarters, it might be worth requesting. You d'need to contact NYS Department of Labor to see if you can still switch to the alternate base period for your current claim.
I'm dealing with a similar issue and it's so frustrating! I worked as a server for almost 3 years and my weekly benefit is only $195. What really gets me is that I was actually pretty good about claiming most of my tips compared to other servers I knew, but it still wasn't enough to make a real difference in my benefit calculation. The whole system seems set up to penalize service industry workers who rely on tips. Has anyone had any luck getting their employer to provide additional documentation about actual earnings? My old manager said they might be able to help but I'm not sure what kind of paperwork would even be useful since most of our tip income was never formally tracked anyway.
@Zara Malik I feel your frustration! Unfortunately, informal tip tracking won t'help much with NYS Department of Labor since they can only use officially reported wages. However, your manager might be able to provide documentation if there were any wages that should have been reported but weren t'- like if you worked extra shifts that didn t'get properly recorded, or if there were payroll errors. Things like W-2 corrections or amended wage reports could potentially help. Also, even though you claimed more tips than others, it might still be worth checking if all your base wages the (non-tip hourly pay were) reported correctly across all your quarters. Sometimes there are small errors that add up. Have you tried looking at your actual W-2s from those years to compare against what NYS Department of Labor has on file?
I'm dealing with this same exact issue! Started yesterday afternoon and I've been pulling my hair out trying to get in. Reading through all these comments is such a relief - I was convinced something was wrong with my specific account. Just tried the mobile browser approach that everyone's recommending and I'm still getting the session expired error, but I'm going to keep trying different combinations. The NY.gov ID app trick sounds really smart - going to try logging into that first then switching to browser like @StarStrider suggested. Really grateful that so many people have shared what worked for them. It's frustrating that this is such a recurring issue, but at least we know NYSDOL is aware and will allow backdated certifications. Going to keep trying the mobile/tablet route since that seems to be the most successful workaround. Thanks everyone for sharing your experiences! This thread has been more helpful than hours of trying to call their support line. 🙏
@Miguel Ortiz I m'in the exact same boat! Just started having this issue this morning and was getting so frustrated thinking it was just me. This thread has been incredibly helpful - way better than trying to navigate their phone system during an outage like this. I just tried the mobile browser approach and the NY.gov ID app trick but still no luck yet. Going to keep cycling through different devices and browsers though since it seems like persistence is key. The fact that @StarStrider and others got through using tablets/mobile gives me hope that it s'just a matter of finding the right combination. Really appreciate everyone documenting what worked for them! It s'such a relief knowing NYSDOL will backdate certifications for this system-wide issue. Definitely going to try hitting it during off-peak hours like @StarSailor mentioned too - maybe early morning will be the magic window. Thanks for keeping us all updated on your progress!
I'm going through this exact same nightmare right now! Been locked out since yesterday trying to certify and getting that same misleading "session expired" message. This thread has been SO helpful - I was starting to panic thinking my account was specifically broken. Just tried the mobile browser trick that so many of you mentioned and I'm still getting the error, but I'm not giving up! Going to try the NY.gov ID app approach next, then maybe hit it during off-peak hours like early morning. It's such a relief to know this is a system-wide issue and that NYSDOL will allow backdated certifications. I was seriously stressing about losing my benefits over what's clearly a technical problem on their end. Thanks everyone for sharing your workarounds and experiences - this community support is honestly better than their official help resources right now! Will keep trying and update if I find anything that works. 🤞
Maya Patel
I'm going through the exact same situation and it's absolutely infuriating! Filed my claim in late July and have been stuck in pending for over 2 months now. Called in early October and got the identical "high priority unit" script with that same 518 number - surprise, surprise, no call ever came. What really gets me angry is how they act like 8-12 weeks is somehow normal processing time when their own website used to say 2-4 weeks. I've been certifying weekly without fail, documenting every job application, checking my messages constantly - basically jumping through every hoop they've set up - and still absolutely nothing. The financial strain is becoming impossible. I'm borrowing money from friends just to keep my car insurance active so I can continue job searching. Meanwhile, DOL acts like telling us to "keep waiting" with zero timeline or accountability is acceptable customer service. After reading everyone's experiences here, I'm convinced the "high priority unit" is just where they dump claims they don't want to deal with. I'm going to try the early morning calling strategy this week and also look into contacting my assembly member like Matthew suggested. At this point we clearly need to escalate outside of DOL's broken system. Thanks for sharing your stories everyone - it's both comforting and terrifying to see how widespread this disaster has become. We need to keep pushing and sharing what actually works because they're clearly not going to fix this mess on their own!
0 coins
Dmitry Volkov
•Maya, I completely understand your anger and frustration! The fact that they changed their processing timeframes without any real explanation while we're all stuck waiting indefinitely is just insulting. You're absolutely right that the "high priority unit" seems to be their dumping ground for claims they don't want to handle properly. I'm new here but have been reading through this entire thread because I'm in a nearly identical situation - filed around the same time as you and getting the same runaround. What really strikes me is how systematic this problem has become. We're all getting the exact same script, the same fake phone number to "watch for," and the same non-answers when we call back. Your plan to try the early morning calling and contact your assembly member sounds smart. From what Matthew shared earlier, the elected officials have liaisons specifically for DOL issues, so that might actually get some traction where the normal phone system fails us completely. The financial stress you mentioned really hits home - having to borrow just for basic expenses like car insurance while waiting for benefits we've earned is absolutely ridiculous. It's clear we can't rely on DOL to fix this on their own, so we need to keep sharing strategies and putting pressure on them through every channel we can find. Hang in there and definitely keep us updated on what works. We're all fighting the same broken system and need to support each other through this nightmare!
0 coins
Nick Kravitz
I'm also dealing with this exact same issue and it's incredibly frustrating! Filed my claim back in early August and have been stuck in pending status for almost 3 months now. Called DOL in late September and got the identical story about the "high priority unit" and that 518 number - naturally, never received any call. What's really disheartening is seeing how many of us are going through this exact same experience. The consistency of everyone getting told about this mysterious "high priority unit" but then waiting months with no follow-up really suggests it's become their standard stalling tactic. I've been doing everything they asked - certifying weekly, keeping detailed job search records, checking my online account religiously - but still nothing. The financial pressure is becoming overwhelming. I'm now having to choose between paying utilities or buying groceries, and I've had to ask family for help which is humiliating when I should be receiving benefits I've paid into for years. It's maddening that they can just tell us to "keep waiting" indefinitely with zero accountability or realistic timelines. Reading through all these experiences, I'm definitely going to try the strategies people have shared - the early morning calling approach, visiting my local DOL office in person, and maybe even that Claimyr service if I can't get through otherwise. I'm also going to look into contacting my state representative as Matthew suggested, since it's clear we need to escalate outside of DOL's broken system. Thank you all for sharing your stories and suggestions. It helps to know we're not alone in this nightmare, even though it's terrifying to see how widespread this problem has become. We need to keep supporting each other and sharing what actually works since DOL clearly isn't going to fix this mess on their own!
0 coins