


Ask the community...
Is anyone else lowkey impressed by how quick these scammers are? Like, I can barely figure out how to update my own info sometimes 😂
Not funny. People are losing money and going through hell because of this.
Same thing happened to me last month! Even after changing everything, they were still getting in somehow. Turns out they had set up email forwarding rules in my account so they could see all my EDD correspondence. Make sure to check your email settings and look for any forwarding rules you didn't create. Also, enable two-factor authentication if EDD offers it. The whole process was a nightmare but I eventually got it sorted out. Don't give up!
I'm so sorry you're going through this - the stress of dealing with EDD while also managing health issues is absolutely overwhelming. From what I've read in these responses, it sounds like you have several potential avenues to explore. The most important thing right now is getting that detailed breakdown of what exactly you owe and why. When you have your interview this week, definitely emphasize that you never received any notification about the false statement penalty - this could be key to getting it dismissed or reduced. Also, don't forget to ask about financial hardship exemptions since you mentioned needing the SDI money for medical expenses. I've heard these can sometimes reduce or eliminate penalties, especially when there are serious health issues involved. Document everything from your interview and keep pushing for answers. The system is frustrating but there are people here who've navigated similar situations successfully. Hang in there!
This is such helpful advice, thank you! I'm feeling a bit more hopeful knowing there might be options like hardship exemptions. I'm definitely going to document everything during my interview this week and push for that detailed breakdown. It's comforting to know I'm not alone in dealing with EDD's confusing system. I'll make sure to emphasize that I never got any notification about the original penalty - hopefully that will help my case. Really appreciate everyone sharing their experiences and advice here!
I went through something very similar a few years ago and wanted to share what worked for me. EDD did initially try to take my SDI benefits for an old UI penalty, but I was able to get it resolved. Here's what I did: 1) I immediately requested a "Notice of Overpayment" form (DE 1444) which shows the exact breakdown of what they think you owe 2) I filed an appeal using form DE 1000M specifically stating I never received proper notification 3) Most importantly, I requested a financial hardship waiver since I needed the SDI money for medical bills. The key is acting fast - you have limited time to appeal once they officially notify you. During your interview this week, ask specifically for the DE 1444 form and mention that taking your SDI would cause undue financial hardship due to your medical condition. Also ask about form DE 8714 which is the financial hardship waiver request. In my case, they ended up reducing the penalty by 75% and let me pay the rest in installments without touching my SDI benefits. Don't lose hope - there are definitely options available if you're persistent!
This is incredibly helpful - thank you so much for the specific form numbers! I had no idea about the DE 1444 and DE 8714 forms. It gives me so much hope to hear that you were able to get your penalty reduced by 75% and set up a payment plan. I'm definitely going to ask for both of those forms during my interview this week and emphasize the financial hardship aspect since I really do need the SDI money for my medical expenses. Quick question - do you remember roughly how long the appeal process took? I'm worried about how long I might have to wait for SDI benefits if they get tied up in all this. But your success story is exactly what I needed to hear right now!
Just wanted to add that you should also ask your doctor about temporary disability accommodations through your employer if you have them. Some employers have short-term disability insurance that can help bridge gaps between SDI claims. Also, if you're union member, check if your union has any emergency assistance programs. I had to go through this exact situation last year with a knee surgery right after my SDI ended, and having multiple backup plans really helped. The key is starting the paperwork process early - don't wait until the last week of your current claim!
That's really smart advice about checking with employers and unions! I didn't even think about short-term disability insurance through work. I'm not union but I should definitely look into what my company offers. It's crazy how you have to become an expert in all these different programs just to get through a medical situation. Thanks for mentioning the early paperwork tip too - seems like that's the key thing everyone is emphasizing.
I went through almost the exact same thing two years ago with my shoulder surgery! The timing was awful - my SDI was ending in August and surgery was scheduled for September. What saved me was that my doctor was really proactive about the paperwork. Since your surgery is for the same condition (back issues), make sure your doctor explicitly states on the DE 2500A form that this spinal fusion is a "medically necessary progression" of your current disability. The key phrase that worked for me was having the doctor write that the surgery was "required due to failure of conservative treatment" - this helped EDD understand it was a continuation, not a separate issue. Also, definitely file the relapse claim about 2-3 weeks before your current benefits end, not after! EDD took about 10 days to process mine and I would have had a payment gap otherwise. The good news is that since it's the same condition, you shouldn't have to serve another waiting period. Hang in there - the surgery will hopefully give you the relief you need!
This is such a helpful thread! I'm actually about to go on SDI myself next month and had no idea about this timing difference between payments and the debit card. It's really reassuring to see that this is completely normal and that EDD starts payments right away even before the card arrives. The breakdown from @ApolloJackson about how the two systems work separately was super clear. I'm definitely going to bookmark this post and set up direct deposit right away to avoid any confusion. Thanks Emma for asking this question and everyone for sharing their experiences - this kind of real-world info is so much more helpful than trying to decode EDD's official documentation!
Miguel, I'm so glad this thread is helpful for you too! It really shows how many people go through the same confusion with SDI. The direct deposit option definitely seems like the way to go - no waiting for cards in the mail or worrying about lost mail. Good luck with your upcoming claim, and at least now you'll know what to expect with the timing!
This thread is SO helpful! I'm currently waiting for my SDI approval decision and had no idea about this timeline difference between payments and debit cards. It's really reassuring to see that EDD starts payments immediately even before the physical card arrives - that actually seems like a good system since mail delays are so common. The fact that so many people experience the exact same confusion shows how poorly EDD communicates their process. Definitely going to set up direct deposit right away if I get approved to avoid the whole card waiting game. Thanks Emma for asking this question and everyone for sharing such detailed experiences! This is exactly the kind of real-world info you can't find on EDD's website.
Dmitry Sokolov
I'm going through the exact same thing right now! Been on SDI for 8 weeks and just got the recertification notice. Reading through all these comments is both helpful and terrifying - sounds like this delay is pretty normal but the stress is real when you're counting on that payment. Thanks everyone for sharing your experiences, especially @CosmicCruiser for the update that it worked out! Going to make sure my doctor's office has the right fax number on file before they send anything.
0 coins
Angelina Farar
•You're smart to get ahead of the fax number issue! That seems to be where a lot of people get tripped up. I'd also suggest taking a screenshot or photo of your online recertification submission confirmation just in case there are any questions later. The waiting is definitely nerve-wracking but it sounds like most people do get their payments eventually, even if EDD takes their sweet time about it. Good luck with your recertification!
0 coins
Carmen Ruiz
I'm dealing with something similar right now - been on SDI for 6 weeks after a workplace injury and just dreading when I hit that 10-week mark after reading all this! It's ridiculous that EDD makes this process so stressful when people are already dealing with health issues. @CosmicCruiser glad everything worked out for you in the end! For anyone else going through this, it might be worth calling your doctor's office proactively to make sure they know to expect something from EDD and have all their contact info updated. The fax number mixup seems to be a common problem that just adds unnecessary delays to an already slow process.
0 coins