

Ask the community...
I just went through this exact situation last year with my husband adopting my daughter. We were devastated to learn about this rule AFTER we had already started the adoption process. Fortunately, our attorney caught it and we were able to halt everything before it was finalized. What really helped us was meeting with both a family law attorney AND a Social Security disability attorney who specialized in benefits. The disability attorney knew all the ins and outs of the POMS manual and confirmed there were no workarounds for our situation. We ended up doing a legal guardianship instead, which gave my husband all the practical parental rights he needed - medical decisions, school authorization, emergency contacts, etc. The only real difference is that if something happened to me, custody wouldn't automatically go to him, but we addressed that with additional estate planning documents. My daughter is now 12 and still receiving her $1,200 monthly survivor benefits. We plan to do the adoption when she turns 18 if she wants us to. Honestly, she doesn't even realize there's a legal difference - to her, he's been "dad" for years regardless of what the paperwork says. The hardest part was explaining to family members why we weren't doing the adoption right away, but once we explained the financial impact, everyone understood. That money is going straight into her college fund and will give her opportunities her biological father would have wanted her to have.
@083b056e733b This is such valuable insight from someone who actually went through the process! I'm really glad your attorney caught this before it was too late. The idea of consulting with both a family law attorney AND a Social Security disability attorney is brilliant - I hadn't thought about getting that specialized expertise on the benefits side. It's reassuring to hear that the legal guardianship has worked well for your family and that your daughter sees your husband as "dad" regardless of the paperwork. That's what really matters in the end. The college fund angle is such a positive way to frame this decision too - her biological father's benefits continuing to secure her future opportunities. Did you find it difficult to locate a Social Security disability attorney who was knowledgeable about survivor benefits specifically? I want to make sure we get the right expertise before making any final decisions.
@083b056e733b Thank you for sharing your experience - it's so helpful to hear from someone who actually navigated this successfully! I'm curious about the estate planning documents you mentioned for ensuring custody would go to your husband if something happened to you. What specific documents did you put in place? We're realizing we need to think about all these contingencies since we're not going the adoption route. Also, how did your daughter's school and doctors handle having your husband listed for decisions when he wasn't the legal adoptive parent? Were there any situations where the guardianship wasn't sufficient?
I'm new to this community but going through a very similar situation right now. My fiancé and I are planning to get married in a few months, and I was considering adopting his 6-year-old daughter who receives survivor benefits. After reading through all these responses, I'm honestly shocked that this rule exists and that SSA doesn't make it more widely known. The financial impact is staggering when you actually calculate it out over the remaining years until 18. For us, we're looking at potentially losing around $95,000 in total benefits. That's literally a full college education at many schools. What I'm struggling with is the emotional side of this. I really want to make our family "official" through adoption, but I also can't ignore the financial reality. It feels like the system is forcing blended families to choose between legal recognition and financial security for their children. I'm definitely going to follow the advice here about consulting with attorneys who specialize in both family law and Social Security benefits. The legal guardianship option sounds like it might be the best compromise - giving me the parental rights I need while preserving her benefits. Has anyone found resources or advocacy groups working to change this rule? It seems like there are so many blended families affected by this, and the current law doesn't reflect how modern families actually work.
@3a2e6e3eb0c6 Welcome to the community! Your feelings about this are completely valid - it really is frustrating how this rule forces families into an impossible choice between legal recognition and financial security. I went through the same emotional struggle when I first learned about this. You're absolutely right that $95,000 is life-changing money for a 6-year-old's future. What helped me process this was reframing it as another way of being a loving parent - protecting her financial future IS an act of love and commitment, even if it means delaying the legal paperwork. As for advocacy groups, I haven't found any specifically focused on changing this Social Security rule, but it might be worth reaching out to organizations like the National Stepfamily Resource Center or contacting your representatives in Congress. If enough families share their stories, maybe we can get some attention on this outdated policy. The legal guardianship route really has worked well for many families here. Your stepdaughter will know you chose to be her parent regardless of what any legal document says. And who knows - maybe by the time she's 18, you'll be able to celebrate with an adult adoption ceremony that she can fully participate in and understand. Hang in there - you're making a wise and loving decision by researching this thoroughly first.
Thank you all for the helpful information! I've learned a lot. To summarize what I understand now: 1. My current wife gets 50% of my benefit at her FRA (if that's more than her own benefit) 2. She'd get 100% survivor benefits after I pass away 3. My ex-wife can't claim on my record since she remarried I'll try using that Claimyr service to confirm these details directly with SSA. It's frustrating how difficult it is to reach them by phone these days.
You've got it exactly right! Just one small clarification on point #1 - your wife will receive the higher of either her own Social Security benefit OR 50% of yours, but not both added together. So if her own benefit ends up being $1,200 and 50% of yours would be $1,500, she'd get the $1,500 spousal benefit. Also, since you mentioned you're delaying past your FRA until 69, those delayed retirement credits will increase your benefit amount, which means your wife's spousal benefit calculation (50% of your Primary Insurance Amount) and eventual survivor benefits will be based on your higher delayed amount. Good planning on your part! Hope the Claimyr service works out better for you than the regular SSA phone lines. Getting official confirmation is always wise with these complex situations.
This is really helpful information! I'm new to understanding Social Security benefits and this thread has been incredibly educational. Quick question - when you mention "Primary Insurance Amount" vs the delayed retirement credits, does that mean the spousal benefit stays at 50% of the original PIA even if the worker delays, but survivor benefits get the full delayed amount? Or do both get calculated from the higher delayed amount?
Hi everyone! As a newcomer to receiving Social Security benefits, I found this entire thread incredibly reassuring and educational. I'm only a couple months into getting my payments and had no idea that holiday adjustments were even a thing! When I first noticed payment dates seeming "off" in my MySocialSecurity account, I immediately panicked thinking there was an error. Reading everyone's explanations about how SSA always pays early rather than late for federal holidays, and that they publish payment calendars in advance, has been such a relief. I particularly appreciate how welcoming this community is to newcomers - everyone has been so patient in explaining these details that experienced recipients probably take for granted. I'm definitely going to download that payment schedule and start marking federal holidays on my calendar so I can anticipate these adjustments going forward. Thank you all for creating such a supportive space where people feel comfortable asking questions and learning from each other!
Welcome to the community, NeonNova! As another newcomer to Social Security benefits, I completely understand that initial panic when payment dates don't match your expectations. I'm also just a few months into receiving payments and had the exact same reaction when I first noticed schedule changes. This thread has been absolutely invaluable - I had no clue about holiday adjustments, payment calendars, or any of these important details before reading everyone's explanations. It's such a relief to know that SSA consistently pays early rather than making recipients wait when holidays interfere with regular schedules. I'm definitely joining you in downloading that payment calendar and marking federal holidays! It's wonderful to find such a patient and knowledgeable community where newcomers like us can ask questions without feeling embarrassed. Thanks for sharing your experience - it really helps to connect with others who are navigating this learning process alongside me!
Hi there! As someone who's also pretty new to receiving Social Security benefits, I completely understand your initial confusion about the payment date change. I'm only about 6 months into getting my payments and I remember having the exact same worry when I first noticed a date that didn't match what I expected! This entire thread has been so educational - I had no idea that holiday adjustments were standard practice or that SSA always pays early rather than late when federal holidays interfere with regular schedules. The Veterans Day explanation makes perfect sense for your November 12th payment. I'm definitely going to look up that payment calendar that several people mentioned and start keeping track of federal holidays so I can anticipate these changes going forward. It's really reassuring to find such a knowledgeable and welcoming community where newcomers like us can ask questions and get such thorough, helpful explanations. Thanks for posting this question - it's helped me understand the system better too!
Hi Mikayla! I'm also a newcomer to Social Security benefits and can totally relate to that initial confusion about payment dates. I've only been receiving payments for a few months myself, and when I first saw a date that seemed "wrong," I immediately thought there was an error with my account. This thread has been such a lifesaver - I had absolutely no idea that holiday adjustments were routine or that SSA publishes those payment calendars in advance. The explanation about Veterans Day affecting the November payment makes so much sense now! I'm definitely going to start marking federal holidays on my calendar so I can plan for these early payments. It's amazing how much less stressful navigating Social Security becomes when you have a supportive community like this to learn from. Thanks for sharing your experience - it really helps knowing other newcomers are going through the same learning process!
I'm new to this community but wanted to share my recent experience since it might help. I just went through a similar situation with my disability benefits review that took 3+ months. What finally worked for me was using the "Contact Us" feature in my online SSA account rather than calling. I was able to submit a message asking for a status update on my application, and they responded within 5 business days with specific information about what was causing the delay. It turned out they needed additional documentation from one of my previous employers, but for some reason that request never made it to me. Once I provided what they needed, my case was processed within 2 weeks. The online messaging system seems to be more reliable than phone calls right now, and you get a written record of all communications. Might be worth trying that route alongside calling - sometimes multiple touchpoints help move things along faster.
That's a really helpful tip about using the online messaging system! I hadn't thought about trying that approach. It's frustrating that they needed additional documentation but never communicated that to you - seems like that's a common theme with SSA unfortunately. I'm definitely going to try the online contact feature in addition to calling. Having a written record sounds much better than trying to remember phone conversations. Thanks for sharing your experience!
I'm sorry to hear about the stress you're dealing with - waiting months without communication from SSA is incredibly frustrating! I wanted to add another perspective based on what I've seen in this community. You mentioned your application was straightforward, which is actually good news. Sometimes the simplest cases get delayed not because there's a problem, but because they get deprioritized in favor of more complex cases that require immediate attention. It's backwards, but that's how the system sometimes works. One thing I'd suggest is documenting everything from this point forward - dates you call, who you speak with, what they tell you. If there are any issues with your payment timing later, having that documentation can be really helpful. Also, don't be afraid to escalate if the first person you talk to can't give you specific answers. Ask to speak with a supervisor if needed. The February payment date is still achievable if they process your application in the next couple of weeks, so there's still hope you won't experience any payment delays. Keep us posted on what you find out when you contact them!
Thank you for that insight about simple cases sometimes getting deprioritized - that actually makes sense in a frustrating way! I never thought about it like that, but it would explain why my straightforward application has been sitting there for so long. I'm definitely going to start documenting everything from now on like you suggested. I've already been kicking myself for not keeping better track of dates and details up to this point. The idea about asking for a supervisor if needed is good too - I tend to be too polite sometimes and just accept whatever the first person tells me. Fingers crossed I can get some real answers this week and hopefully still make that February payment date!
Oliver Becker
This is such a helpful and thorough discussion! As someone who's been on the fence about returning to work while on SS benefits, reading through everyone's experiences has really clarified a lot of my own questions. One thing I want to add that might be useful - I recently attended a Social Security workshop at our local senior center, and the presenter mentioned that SSA has been working to improve their online tools for tracking earnings. They now have a feature in your my Social Security account where you can view your posted earnings and see how they compare to the annual limits. It's not real-time, but it does get updated more frequently than just once a year after tax filing. The presenter also emphasized something that several people here have touched on - that the earnings test is designed to be fair, not punitive. The whole point is that if you're earning significant income, you temporarily need less support from Social Security, but you get credit for those withheld benefits later when you reach FRA. StarSeeker, your plan sounds really solid, and I think you're going to do great with this temporary position. The fact that you're planning ahead and asking the right questions puts you way ahead of the game. Thanks to everyone who shared their experiences - this thread is going to be a valuable resource for a lot of people!
0 coins
Benjamin Johnson
•Thanks for mentioning that online tool in the my Social Security account! I had no idea they had a feature for tracking earnings against the annual limits. That sounds like it could be really helpful for keeping tabs on where I stand throughout the year, even if it's not completely real-time. I'll definitely log in and check that out. And you're absolutely right about the earnings test being designed to be fair rather than punitive. It's easy to get anxious about all the rules and potential overpayments, but when you step back and look at the bigger picture, it makes sense that they're just temporarily adjusting support based on current need and then giving you credit later at FRA. This whole discussion has been incredibly educational and reassuring. I started out feeling pretty nervous about the whole situation, but now I feel like I have a solid plan and understand what to expect. Thanks to everyone who shared their experiences and advice - this community is amazing!
0 coins
Connor Murphy
This thread has been incredibly informative! As someone who's been considering going back to work while on SS benefits, I really appreciate everyone sharing their experiences and practical advice. One thing I'd like to add that might help others - I discovered that some local AARP offices offer free one-on-one counseling sessions specifically about working while receiving Social Security. They helped me understand my specific situation and even walked through some earnings scenarios with me. It might be worth checking if there's something like that available in your area as another resource beyond calling SSA directly. StarSeeker, your methodical approach to planning this out is really smart. The 90% safety buffer suggestion from Yara is excellent - I think I'm going to use that rule myself if I decide to take on some part-time work. And keeping those monthly calendar reminders to check earnings totals is such a simple but effective way to stay on track. Thanks to everyone for making this such a valuable discussion. I feel much more confident about the possibility of returning to work now that I understand how the earnings test actually works in practice!
0 coins