

Ask the community...
Alberto, my heart goes out to you during this difficult time. I lost my spouse three years ago and remember how overwhelming all these benefit decisions felt while grieving. You've received such wonderful advice in this thread, and I wanted to add one small but important detail that helped me: when you go to your August appointment, consider asking the SSA representative to give you a written estimate of your monthly benefit amount both with and without the early filing reduction. Having those numbers side by side really helped me visualize the long-term impact of my decision. Also, don't be afraid to ask them to repeat information or explain things multiple times - they're used to working with people during difficult circumstances and should be patient with your questions. The 6-month retroactive benefit combined with starting at 66 sounds like a smart approach given your situation. You're doing everything right by researching thoroughly and asking all the right questions. Wishing you peace as you navigate this process.
Thank you so much for this thoughtful advice, Evelyn. Asking for a written estimate with both scenarios is such a practical suggestion - having those numbers in black and white would definitely help me feel more confident about my decision. You're absolutely right that I shouldn't hesitate to ask for clarification or repetition. I've been worried about taking up too much of their time, but this is such an important decision that I need to make sure I fully understand everything. Your reminder about SSA representatives being used to working with people in difficult circumstances is reassuring. I'm feeling much more prepared for my August appointment thanks to all the wisdom shared in this thread. Thank you for your kind words and for taking the time to help someone else navigate this challenging process.
I'm so sorry for your loss, Alberto. This thread has been incredibly educational - I had no idea about the 6-month retroactive option for survivor benefits! As someone who may face this decision in the future, I'm saving all this information. The advice about explicitly requesting the retroactive benefits when you apply seems crucial since it's not automatic. It's also reassuring to know that taking reduced survivor benefits doesn't permanently affect your own retirement benefits if you decide to switch later. Thank you for asking such an important question and creating this helpful discussion. The community's responses show just how valuable it is to have people share their real experiences with these complex Social Security rules. Best wishes for your appointment in August - you're clearly going in well-prepared!
Thank you, Gabriel. I'm really touched by how supportive and helpful everyone in this community has been during such a difficult time. When I first posted my question, I was feeling so confused and overwhelmed by all the Social Security rules, but this thread has given me the confidence and knowledge I need to move forward with my application. It's amazing how much clearer everything becomes when you have real people sharing their actual experiences rather than just trying to decipher government websites. I hope the information here helps you and others who might face similar decisions in the future. Nobody should have to navigate these complex benefit rules alone, especially while grieving. Thank you for the well wishes - I'm definitely feeling much more prepared for August now!
This thread has been incredibly informative! I'm in a similar situation - 64, on SSDI for 6 years, divorced after 14 years of marriage. What I'm taking away from all these responses is that it's definitely worth applying, even if the benefit increase is modest. The dual entitlement explanation really helped clarify how this works - I was confused about whether I'd lose my SSDI. I'm also relieved to learn that SSA can look up my ex's record without needing his SSN, since we haven't been in contact for years. I'm going to try the online appointment scheduling option rather than calling. For those who have successfully applied, did you notice any delay in receiving your first adjusted payment, or did it come through on your regular payment date once approved?
I'm so glad this thread has been helpful for you too! Your situation sounds very similar to mine and others here. From what I've gathered, it really does seem worth applying even for a modest increase - every bit helps with the cost of living these days. I'm also planning to try the online appointment scheduling since everyone seems to agree that's much better than waiting on hold. I'm curious about the payment timing question you asked too - I hope someone who's been through this process can share their experience with how quickly the adjusted payments started coming through once approved.
I've been following this discussion with great interest as someone who recently went through this exact process! I'm 65, was on SSDI for 8 years, and divorced after 18 years of marriage. I applied for ex-spousal benefits about 6 months ago and wanted to share my experience to help answer some of the questions that have come up. Regarding payment timing - once my application was approved (took about 10 weeks), my first adjusted payment came on my regular payment date. There wasn't any additional delay, which was a relief. They also paid me the retroactive benefits as a separate deposit about 2 weeks later. For those asking about the SSN issue - I didn't have my ex's SSN either, but SSA was able to locate his record easily using just his full name, birth date, and our marriage dates. They asked a few verification questions about where we lived during the marriage, but it was straightforward. One thing I'd add that hasn't been mentioned much - keep copies of everything you submit and take notes during your appointment. The process involves a lot of technical details, and having your own records really helped when I had follow-up questions later. Also, don't be surprised if they need to contact you for additional information even after your initial appointment - this seems to be pretty normal and doesn't mean there's a problem with your application. The online appointment scheduling worked great for me too. Much easier than trying to call during busy hours!
This is exactly the kind of detailed, real-world experience I was hoping to hear about! Thank you so much for sharing your timeline and specifics. It's really reassuring to know that the adjusted payment came on your regular date without extra delays, and that the retroactive benefits followed shortly after. The 10-week timeline is also helpful to know - longer than some estimates I've seen here, but not unreasonably so. Your advice about keeping copies and taking notes is spot on - I can imagine there will be a lot of information to track. I'm definitely going to try the online scheduling approach you and others have recommended. Quick question - when you mention they asked verification questions about where you lived during the marriage, was that during your initial appointment or did they follow up later with those questions?
Thank you for sharing such detailed information about your experience! This is incredibly helpful. I'm particularly relieved to hear that the payment timing worked smoothly and that SSA could find your ex's record without his SSN. Your point about keeping copies and taking notes is really smart - I can see how easy it would be to forget important details from what sounds like a complex conversation. I'm definitely going to follow your advice about using the online appointment scheduling. One question - you mentioned they might contact you for additional information after the initial appointment. What kind of additional information did they need in your case, if you don't mind sharing? I want to be prepared for any follow-up requests so I can respond quickly and keep the process moving.
As someone who just turned 64 and is facing a similar decision, this thread has been incredibly eye-opening! I was actually considering filing for benefits next month while still working, but after reading through all these calculations and experiences, I'm now leaning toward waiting until my FRA at 67. The math seems pretty clear - if you're going to lose most of your benefits to the earnings test anyway, plus miss out on the delayed retirement credits, it really doesn't make financial sense to claim early while working full-time. The 33% increase in monthly benefits that Jamal mentioned for waiting from 63 to 67 is substantial when you think about it over 20+ years of retirement. One question though - for those who did withdraw their applications, how long did the process take? I want to understand the timeline in case I do file and then change my mind within that 12-month window.
Great question about the withdrawal timeline! From what I've researched, SSA typically processes withdrawal requests (Form SSA-521) within 30-60 days, but it can vary depending on their workload and whether they need additional documentation. The key thing is that you have to request the withdrawal within 12 months of your entitlement date, not 12 months from when you first receive a payment. Once approved, you'll need to repay all benefits received (including any that were withheld due to the earnings test), but then it's as if you never filed. Definitely worth getting professional advice before making that decision, but it sounds like you're thinking through all the right factors!
I'm a federal employee nearing retirement and have been following this discussion with great interest. One additional consideration for government workers that hasn't been mentioned - if you're receiving a federal pension (CSRS or FERS), this does NOT count toward the earnings test limit since pension payments aren't considered "earned income" by SSA. However, if you're still actively employed by the government and receiving wages (not pension), those wages absolutely do count toward the $22,320 limit just like any other job. I've seen colleagues get confused about this distinction. Also, for those considering the withdrawal option, keep in mind that if you withdraw your Social Security application, you might want to double-check how this affects any spousal or family benefits that might be based on your record. Sometimes there are ripple effects that aren't immediately obvious. The complexity of these rules really highlights why so many people benefit from professional guidance when navigating Social Security timing decisions!
This is such an important distinction to highlight! I work in the private sector but have friends who are federal employees, and I can see how that pension vs. wages difference could be really confusing. It makes sense that only active work earnings count toward the limit, not retirement income, but I bet a lot of people don't realize that. Your point about checking ripple effects on family benefits is also really smart - there are so many interconnected pieces with Social Security that it's easy to miss something. Thanks for adding this perspective from the federal employee side!
I'm in a similar situation and want to add something that might help with your decision-making process. Since you mentioned you have savings to live on, you might want to run a "break-even" analysis to see at what age waiting until 70 becomes more profitable than taking reduced benefits at 62. For example, if your benefit at 62 would be $1,200/month but waiting until 70 gets you $2,000/month, you'd collect $96,000 over 8 years by taking it early. But the higher benefit would "catch up" in about 12 years (around age 82). Given your family longevity, waiting could mean significantly more lifetime income. Also, don't forget that your Social Security benefits might be partially taxable depending on your other retirement income, so factor that into your calculations too. The SSA representatives should be able to help you with the benefit estimates, but they won't do the break-even math for you - that's something you'll need to calculate yourself or with a financial advisor. Good luck with your appointment! The wait times have gotten better at most offices lately.
This break-even analysis approach is exactly what I needed to hear! I never thought about calculating the crossover point like that. Your example really helps put it in perspective - if I'm likely to live past 82 (which seems probable given my family history), then waiting makes financial sense even though it's hard to turn down money now. I'm definitely going to ask the SSA rep to run the numbers for both my own benefits and the divorced spouse benefits at different claiming ages. Then I can do the math myself to figure out which strategy maximizes my lifetime income. Thank you for mentioning the tax implications too - I hadn't considered that my other retirement accounts might push me into a higher tax bracket. Has anyone here actually done this type of break-even calculation? I'm wondering if there are any online calculators that might help with the math.
There are actually several good online calculators that can help with Social Security break-even analysis! The AARP Social Security Calculator and the SSA's own retirement estimator are decent starting points, but for more detailed scenarios involving divorced spouse benefits, I'd recommend the calculators at FidSafe or Social Security Solutions. One thing to keep in mind with your break-even analysis - don't just look at the monthly benefit amounts. Also factor in potential cost-of-living adjustments (COLAs) over time, since a higher base benefit means larger dollar increases each year when they adjust for inflation. Also, since you mentioned good family longevity, consider that Social Security benefits continue for life and include survivor protections that other investments don't offer. That guaranteed income stream becomes more valuable the longer you live, especially if healthcare costs increase as you age. The math can get complex, but once you have your actual benefit estimates from SSA, plug those numbers into a few different calculators to see if they give you consistent results. Most show that if you expect to live past your early 80s, delaying benefits usually wins out financially.
Thank you for the calculator recommendations! I just tried the AARP one and it's really eye-opening to see the numbers laid out visually. The difference between claiming at 62 vs 70 is much larger than I expected - almost double the monthly benefit! I'm curious about something you mentioned - how do the COLAs work exactly? Does a higher base benefit really mean I get more dollars each year from cost-of-living increases? That would be another advantage to waiting that I hadn't considered. Also, when you mention survivor protections, does that apply to divorced spouse benefits too? I'm not planning to remarry, but I want to understand all the implications of each choice. The guaranteed income aspect is definitely appealing given how volatile my 401k has been lately!
GalacticGuardian
I'm sorry for your loss, Zoe. This thread has been incredibly helpful - I'm facing a similar situation as my husband passed away 6 months ago and I'll be turning 60 in September 2025. Based on everyone's advice, I'm planning to apply in June. One thing I wanted to add that hasn't been mentioned yet - if your late husband ever worked for the railroad, make sure to check if he was covered under the Railroad Retirement system instead of regular Social Security. My neighbor discovered this after her husband passed, and it completely changed which benefits she was eligible for. Railroad Retirement has different rules and benefit amounts than SSA. Also, if your husband was a federal employee (CSRS/FERS), there might be additional survivor benefits to consider alongside Social Security. It's worth checking with OPM (Office of Personnel Management) if that applies to your situation. Thank you to everyone who shared their experiences - you've all made this process feel much more manageable!
0 coins
Dmitry Popov
•Thank you for bringing up the Railroad Retirement and federal employee benefits! Those are really important distinctions that could completely change someone's benefit eligibility. I hadn't thought about those scenarios at all. My husband worked in the private sector his whole career, so regular Social Security applies to my situation, but your point about checking different systems is so valuable for others reading this thread. It's a good reminder that not all work history falls under the standard Social Security system. I'm sorry for your loss as well, and I hope your June application goes smoothly. It sounds like you're well-prepared and the timing should work perfectly for your September birthday. This whole thread has been such a lifeline - it's amazing how much practical knowledge everyone has shared from their real experiences!
0 coins
Anastasia Popova
I'm so sorry for your loss, Zoe. This entire thread has been incredibly informative and I wanted to add one more consideration that might be helpful. When you call SSA in August to apply, ask them specifically about the "deemed filing" rules for survivor benefits. Essentially, when you apply for survivor benefits, SSA will also check if you're eligible for retirement benefits on your own record and may automatically file for both if it's advantageous. However, since you mentioned planning to switch to your own higher retirement benefit later at 67, you want to make sure you understand exactly what you're filing for and when. Sometimes the deemed filing rules can affect your strategy, especially if your own benefit amount is close to the survivor benefit amount. It's worth having them walk through the scenarios so you can make the most informed decision. Also, keep in mind that once you start receiving survivor benefits, you'll get annual statements showing your projected retirement benefit amounts, which can help you plan the optimal time to switch. Best wishes with your application process!
0 coins