Has your daughter checked with other students in her program? I'm betting they all got the same change on their 1098-Ts this year. Universities sometimes make these reporting changes across the board due to updated interpretations of IRS guidelines or changes in their financial systems. My school did something similar last year and it freaked everyone out, but it turned out to be a non-issue tax-wise.

I'm a tax professional and see this situation frequently with graduate students. The key thing to understand is that the 1098-T is primarily an informational document - what matters for tax purposes is the actual nature of the payments your daughter receives, not how they're reported on this form. If her stipend is compensation for teaching or research services (which it sounds like it is), then it should be reported as taxable income regardless of whether it appears on the 1098-T. The fact that she's been correctly reporting it as income all these years means she's been doing exactly what she should. Universities often change their reporting practices due to updated guidance from the IRS, changes in accounting systems, or shifts in how they classify different types of funding. This doesn't retroactively change the tax treatment of previous years or create any problems with the IRS. I'd recommend having your daughter contact her university's financial aid office to ask about the change - they should be able to explain why they updated their reporting method. But from a tax perspective, if she continues to report the stipend as income (which she should), this change shouldn't affect her tax liability at all.

One thing I haven't seen mentioned yet is the importance of understanding the "predominantly used" test if your business use ever drops below 50%. Even if you start at 100% business use, if your business use percentage falls below 50% in ANY year during the recovery period, you'll trigger recapture of ALL excess depreciation you claimed. This is especially important for consulting businesses where your travel patterns might change. For example, if you land a long-term client contract that requires less travel, or if you start working from home more, you could inadvertently trigger this rule. My recommendation would be to track your mileage religiously (as others have mentioned) and maybe even plan for some flexibility. If you see your business use dropping toward that 50% threshold, you might want to consider increasing business travel or potentially selling the vehicle before you hit that trigger point. The good news is that with a heavy SUV over 6,000 lbs that you're using 100% for business, you're in a great position tax-wise. Just make sure you maintain that business use percentage and keep excellent records. The IRS is particularly scrutinous of vehicle deductions, so documentation is key.

As someone who just joined this community and is navigating business vehicle depreciation for the first time, this thread has been incredibly educational! I purchased my first business vehicle (a pickup truck over 6,000 lbs GVW) six months ago and took the full Section 179 deduction, but I had no idea about all these recapture complexities. A couple of follow-up questions for the group: 1. If I'm required to keep detailed mileage logs, what happens if I have a few gaps in my records? Like if I forgot to log a week's worth of trips but can reconstruct them from calendar appointments and receipts? 2. For those who mentioned entity structure changes affecting recapture - does this also apply if you're a single-member LLC that gets disregarded for tax purposes but then adds a partner later? The advice about maintaining well above 50% business use is noted! I'm currently at 95% business use but want to make sure I understand all the potential pitfalls before they become expensive mistakes. Thank you all for sharing your experiences - it's saving me from learning these lessons the hard way!

I'm going through the exact same nightmare with our small marketing agency - filed our ERC claim in March 2023 for about $19,000 and we're now approaching 21 months with absolutely zero communication from the IRS. The complete lack of transparency is maddening. After reading through all these incredibly helpful responses, I'm going to implement the multi-pronged strategy that seems to be working for others: filing Form 911 with the Taxpayer Advocate Service immediately, contacting my congressional representative's office, and starting systematic documentation of every interaction (or failed attempt at interaction) with the IRS. What really strikes me about this thread is how we're all essentially having to become experts in IRS bureaucracy just to get information about our own legitimate refunds. The fact that businesses are turning to third-party services, congressional intervention, and advocacy services just to get basic status updates shows how fundamentally broken the ERC processing system has become. As a small business that kept employees during the worst economic crisis in decades, we did everything right and qualified for relief that was explicitly promised by the government. Now we're stuck in this bureaucratic black hole while the IRS apparently can't manage a program they created and promoted. I'll definitely report back on which approaches work for our situation. Thanks to everyone for sharing real, actionable solutions instead of the useless "keep calling and be patient" advice that clearly isn't working. This thread has been more helpful than months of trying to get information through official IRS channels.

I'm going through the exact same frustrating experience with our small accounting firm's ERC claim. We filed in September 2023 for around $41,000 and are now at 19 months with zero communication from the IRS. The complete lack of transparency is absolutely maddening. After reading through all these incredibly helpful responses, I'm planning to take immediate action using the strategies that seem to be working: filing Form 911 with the Taxpayer Advocate Service today, reaching out to my representative's office this week, and implementing the systematic documentation approach that @Amara Torres suggested with a detailed spreadsheet of every interaction attempt. What really frustrates me is that we did everything by the book - qualified legitimately, kept our staff employed during the worst of COVID, filed through a reputable CPA, and now we're being penalized by the IRS's complete inability to process claims in any reasonable timeframe. Small businesses like ours operated on good faith that the government would deliver on these promised programs. The fact that so many of us are sharing identical nightmare experiences really demonstrates this is a massive systemic failure, not isolated incidents. We shouldn't need to become amateur IRS investigators or rely on congressional intervention just to get basic information about our own legitimate refunds. I'll definitely update everyone on which approaches work for our situation. This thread has been more valuable than months of attempting to get information through official IRS channels. Thanks to everyone for sharing real, actionable solutions - it gives me hope that we can eventually get the relief we rightfully earned.

As a newcomer to this community, I'm incredibly grateful to have found this comprehensive thread! I just encountered the exact same "Object reference not set to an instance of an object" error this afternoon while attempting to import my 2023 LLC return into H&R Block Business 2024. After spending hours on the phone with H&R Block support (getting nowhere with their standard "restart and reinstall" responses), discovering this community discussion feels like finding a goldmine of actual solutions. The detailed troubleshooting approaches shared by @QuantumLeap, @Maya, and others are exactly what I needed to see. I'm particularly interested in the Feb 2nd update that resolved the issue for @Emma and several others. It's encouraging to know there's an official fix available, though I wish H&R Block had been more proactive about notifying users about this critical update. I'm also planning to try the Windows Event Viewer diagnostic approach that @Maya suggested - it never occurred to me to look there for additional error details beyond H&R Block's generic crash dialog. The section-by-section import strategy sounds like a smart fallback plan if the update doesn't completely resolve my LLC import issues. Has anyone had success with the compatibility mode approach specifically for LLC returns? My return includes some complex partnership distributions that might be contributing to the crash, and I'm wondering if running in Windows 10 compatibility mode could provide additional stability during the import process. Thank you all for creating such a valuable resource for those of us struggling with these import errors. This community support is genuinely better than what we're getting from the software company itself!

As a newcomer to this community, I'm so relieved to have found this thread! I'm dealing with the exact same "Object reference not set to an instance of an object" error when trying to import my 2023 business return into H&R Block Business 2024. What's really frustrating is that I'm a small business owner who switched from doing my own taxes to using professional software for the first time this year, and now I'm spending more time troubleshooting than actually working on my return. The timing couldn't be worse with tax deadlines approaching. I'm definitely going to try the Feb 2nd update that fixed the issue for @Emma and others. It's reassuring to see so many people had success with that specific update. If that doesn't work, I'll follow @Maya's advice about checking the Windows Event Viewer for more detailed error information. The community support in this thread is incredible - you've all provided more useful troubleshooting guidance in one discussion than I got from hours of searching H&R Block's official support resources. It's clear that real users sharing their actual experiences is far more valuable than generic tech support responses. Has anyone noticed if this error is more common with first-time imports versus people who have been using H&R Block Business for multiple years? I'm wondering if there's something about the initial setup or data conversion process that makes new users more susceptible to these crashes. Thank you all for sharing your solutions - this gives me hope that I can actually get through this tax season without having to start over with different software!

I just went through this exact same situation a few months ago! Filed my 1040NR-EZ in February, got Form 9143 in March for signature issues, and finally got my refund in early May after resubmitting. The waiting period after resubmitting is absolutely nerve-wracking, especially when you're depending on that money for expenses. What helped me was understanding that once you resubmit after Form 9143, you're essentially at the back of the processing queue again - so the 6-8 week timeline starts from your resubmission date, not your original filing date. A couple of things that might help while you wait: 1. Keep checking "Where's My Refund" but don't expect it to update frequently - mine stayed on the original filing info until literally the day before my refund was deposited 2. If you sent it certified mail (smart move!), you have proof of delivery which puts you in a good position if you need to call later 3. The fact that it's been over 30 days but under 6 weeks means you're still well within normal processing time The signature verification issue is so frustrating because it feels like such a minor thing, but apparently their scanning systems are really sensitive. I used a gel pen too and learned the hard way that standard ballpoint is the way to go for paper tax forms. Hang in there - based on your timeline, you should hopefully hear something within the next 2-4 weeks. The good news is that once they process it, the refund usually comes pretty quickly after that!

I went through almost the exact same thing last year as an international student! Filed my 1040NR-EZ in March, got Form 9143 about signature issues, and the waiting after resubmitting was absolutely brutal. Here's what I learned: the 6-8 week processing time everyone mentions is pretty accurate, but it can feel like forever when you're counting on that refund. Since you resubmitted in mid-April and it's been about a month, you're actually still well within the normal timeframe. The certified mail was definitely the right call - having that proof of delivery is crucial if you need to follow up later. I made the mistake of not doing that initially and spent weeks wondering if they even received my resubmission. One thing that helped me was understanding that Form 9143 responses go into a completely separate processing queue. That's why the normal refund tracking tools often don't update properly during this period. My "Where's My Refund" status stayed basically frozen until the day my refund was actually deposited. If you don't hear anything by the 6-week mark (early June in your case), that's when I'd recommend calling. But honestly, based on your timeline and the fact that you followed all the instructions correctly, I'd expect to see movement in the next 2-3 weeks. The gel pen signature issue is way more common than people realize - apparently their scanning systems flag anything that looks "too perfect" or uniform. Lesson learned for all of us to stick with basic ballpoint pens on paper tax forms! Hang in there - the waiting is the worst part, but it sounds like you did everything right. Your refund should come through soon!