


Ask the community...
I went through this exact same situation a few months ago! The key is to report it BEFORE your first day of work if possible. I called the NYS Department of Labor the Friday before I started my new job on Monday, and they were really helpful about walking me through the process. They'll ask for your exact start date and make sure your benefits stop at the right time. Don't worry too much - as long as you're proactive about reporting it, you'll be fine. The worst thing you can do is keep filing weekly claims after you start working. Congrats on the new job!
Thanks for sharing your experience! That's really helpful to know that calling on Friday before starting Monday worked well for you. I'm definitely going to be proactive about this - I'd rather spend a few minutes reporting it properly than deal with overpayment issues later. It's reassuring to hear from people who've actually been through this process successfully. The timing aspect seems to be the most important thing based on everyone's responses here.
I just went through this exact process two weeks ago! Definitely report it immediately - I used the my.ny.gov portal to report my return to work the day I got my job offer, even before my actual start date. The online system is pretty straightforward - there's a "Report Return to Work" section where you just enter your employer info and start date. The most important thing is to NOT file your weekly claim for any week you're working full-time. I was paranoid about messing it up too, but as long as you report it promptly and stop filing claims when you start working, you'll be fine. NYS Department of Labor actually prefers when people are proactive about reporting employment changes. Good luck with the new job!
This is really helpful advice everyone! I'm in a similar boat - making about $825/week and worried about potential layoffs at my company. @Omar Zaki that's a great point about keeping records now. I just started downloading all my pay stubs and employment docs just in case. One question - does anyone know if the base period includes the most recent quarter or is there a lag? I'm trying to figure out if my recent raise would be factored into the calculation or if they'd use older, lower earnings.
@PaulineW Great question! The base period typically has a lag - it usually uses the first 4 of the last 5 completed quarters before you file your claim. So if you file in Q1 2025, they'd look at Q1 2024 through Q4 2024, not including the most recent quarter. This means your recent raise might not be reflected in the calculation, which is frustrating but that's how the system works. You might want to check the exact dates on the NYS DOL website to be sure, but generally there's about a 3-month delay before earnings count toward your base period.
I was in almost the exact same situation last year - making $780/week when I got laid off. Like others mentioned, the benefit calculation isn't straightforward but I ended up getting about $375/week. One thing I wish I'd known is that you can actually do a rough estimate yourself: they typically take your highest quarter earnings, divide by 26, then apply the benefit formula (around 50% but varies). Also worth noting that benefits are taxable, so factor that in when budgeting. The good news is that at your income level, unemployment should cover most basic expenses, though you'll definitely need to tighten the belt a bit. Start organizing your paperwork now like others suggested - having everything ready makes the application process much smoother!
Thanks for sharing your experience @Ethan Clark! That's really reassuring to hear from someone who was in almost the exact same situation. The 50% calculation makes sense and $375/week sounds manageable for basic expenses. I didn't realize the benefits are taxable though - that's definitely something to factor in when planning. Did you have them withhold taxes from your weekly payments or did you just handle it at tax time? I'm trying to get all my ducks in a row now just in case the layoffs at my company actually happen.
@Nia Thompson I just went through this exact same frustration a few weeks ago! Here's what finally worked for me: I called my assembly member's office (you can find yours by putting your address into nyassembly.gov) and they got me a callback from DOL within 48 hours. Also try the online message center super early in the morning around 6-7am when there's less traffic - I actually got responses that way. The physical offices are basically useless right now except for scheduled appointments. Don't waste your time going in person, focus on the assembly rep route and early morning online attempts. The system is completely broken but these workarounds actually get results! Hang in there 🙏
@Zoe Papadakis this is exactly the kind of actionable advice I needed to see! Just looked up my assembly member and gonna call first thing Monday morning. The early morning online tip is genius too - makes total sense that the system would be less overwhelmed at 6am. Been banging my head against the wall for weeks trying the normal "routes." Really appreciate everyone in this thread sharing what actually works instead of the usual keep "trying advice" 🙏
Just wanted to chime in as someone who's been lurking here dealing with the same nightmare! Reading through all these responses has been incredibly helpful. I've been trying the regular phone line for over a month with zero success. Definitely gonna try the assembly rep route first thing Monday - seems like that's the most consistent success story here. Also setting my alarm for 6:30am to try the online portal when traffic is low. Really appreciate everyone sharing actual solutions instead of just venting (though the venting is totally justified lol). This community has been more helpful than any official government resource. Will report back if any of these methods work for me! 🤞
Just wanted to add that timing matters too when you're thinking about filing. If you're still in that 6-week probationary period and things aren't working out, you might want to consider whether leaving would be considered "good cause" versus being terminated. NYS Department of Labor distinguishes between quitting for good cause (like unsafe working conditions, significant changes to job duties, etc.) and just quitting because the job isn't a good fit. If you're terminated during probation through no fault of your own, that's usually fine for unemployment eligibility. But if you quit just because it's not working out, that could complicate things even if you meet all the wage requirements everyone mentioned.
@Mikayla Davison brings up a really important distinction that I think gets overlooked a lot. The good "cause requirement" can be tricky to navigate, especially during probationary periods. I ve'seen people get denied benefits because they quit for reasons that seemed valid to them but didn t'meet NYS Department of Labor s'specific definition of good cause. @Lydia Santiago if you re concerned'about the job fit, it might be worth documenting any issues that arise - like if expectations weren t clearly'communicated during hiring, working conditions differ from what was described, or if there are safety concerns. That way if you do need to leave, you have evidence to support a good cause claim rather than it just being about personal preference or job fit.
I've been through a similar situation where I wasn't sure about my eligibility after starting a new job. What really helped me was calling the NYS Department of Labor directly to go over my specific work history and wage credits. They can tell you exactly where you stand based on your individual circumstances. The representatives are usually pretty helpful once you get through - though I know that can be the challenging part! They can also explain how your previous employment would factor into the base period calculation, which varies depending on when exactly you file. It's worth having that conversation before you make any decisions about the job, especially since you're still in the probationary period where things could go either way.
@Malik Johnson that s'solid advice about calling directly. I m'actually in a really similar position to @Lydia Santiago - been at my current job for about 2 months now and the fit isn t great.'It s helpful'to know that they can walk you through your specific situation over the phone. Did you find the wait times reasonable when you called, or did you have to try multiple times to get through? I ve been'hesitant to call because I ve heard'horror stories about being on hold forever, but it sounds like it might be worth the effort to get personalized info about my wage credits and eligibility before making any moves.
Tyrone Johnson
Hey Marcus! I just went through this exact situation a few months ago when I got laid off from my restaurant job and started doing Uber Eats. You can absolutely file for unemployment while doing DoorDash part-time - it's called partial unemployment. The main things to remember: 1) Apply immediately, don't wait! There's a waiting week and you're missing out on money. 2) Report your DoorDash earnings honestly every week when you certify - they want the gross amount before DoorDash takes their commission. 3) Keep screenshots of your weekly earnings summaries for your records. 4) You'll still get benefits, just reduced based on what you earn from DoorDash. Since you're only making $200-300/week, you should still qualify for a decent partial benefit. The hardest part honestly is getting through to someone on the phone if you have questions, but the online system works okay once you understand how to report gig work earnings. Don't stress too much about it - thousands of people are in your exact situation and the system does handle it, even if it's not always intuitive. Good luck!
0 coins
Natalia Stone
•This is super helpful, thank you! I was getting overwhelmed reading all the different advice but your breakdown makes it clear. One quick follow-up - you mentioned keeping screenshots of weekly earnings summaries. Do you know if DoorDash keeps these available for a while in the app, or should I be screenshotting them immediately each week? I want to make sure I have good records from the start.
0 coins
Edwards Hugo
I actually just went through this process last month after getting laid off from my retail job! You can definitely file for unemployment while doing DoorDash part-time. Here's what worked for me: Apply right away - don't wait because you're losing money every week you delay. When you certify weekly, report your GROSS DoorDash earnings (the full amount before they take their cut). The system will reduce your benefits but you'll still get something, which is way better than nothing. I was making about $250/week with gig work and still got partial unemployment benefits of around $280/week. The key is being 100% honest about your earnings - they will eventually cross-check with tax records so don't try to hide anything. Also, make sure to keep doing your work search requirements even though you're dashing. The whole process was less scary than I thought it would be once I actually started. You've got this!
0 coins