
IRS
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
So I just received this random refund from the IRS (CP134R) for my second quarter 941 taxes and I'm completely baffled. My Q2 941 form is 100% accurate and matches all the deposits I made during that period. I can't make heads or tails of their explanation: "We found the amount reported as total Federal Tax Deposits for the tax period shown above (June 30, 2023 Form 941) differs from the amount we have credited to your account. We've corrected this error. As a result, your refund is $4,782.33" The back of this CP134R lists all my EFTPS payments, which are completely accurate according to my EFTPS payment history. How could they not be crediting my account properly? There's a phone number on the notice to call for more details, but shocking surprise - nobody's answering that line! Has anyone dealt with this kind of random 941 refund before? I'm worried this will cause problems down the road. UPDATE: After calling for THREE DAYS, I finally got through to someone at the IRS. Turns out they entered my 941 completely wrong in their system. Instead of $87,500 in wages, they only recorded $8,750 in their system, which obviously messed up all the calculations. Now I have to file a 941-X to correct their mistake and return the voided refund check with my 941-X form. What a headache!
I work as a personal assistant while also being a full-time student. Right now I'm trying to file my taxes and I'm totally confused about how to categorize my income. I earned roughly $16,000 last year working part-time during school and full-time over summer break. I didn't have any taxes withheld throughout the year (I know, probably not smart), but I usually get decent education credits as a student so I'm hoping to at least break even. I'm using TurboTax which is pretty straightforward, but I'm stuck on this classification issue. Should I be putting all my income ($16,000) as business income? I don't have an LLC or anything formal - I'm just working directly for a family as their personal assistant. I handle scheduling, errands, some light bookkeeping, and occasional childcare. They pay me directly, no withholdings. I'm worried about making a mistake that could cost me later. Does this count as self-employment where I need to pay self-employment tax? Or is there a better way to classify this income? I don't want to overpay but I definitely don't want to underpay and deal with the IRS later!
This might be a dumb question but have you received any tax forms from the family you work for? Like a 1099-NEC or a W-2? That would tell you exactly how they're classifying you. If they haven't sent any forms, you should ask them ASAP how they're reporting your pay to the IRS. If they're treating you as an independent contractor (which seems likely), they should give you a 1099-NEC if you made over $600. Either way, you need to report the income. Based on what you described, you're probably self-employed and will need to file Schedule C.
No tax forms at all, which is part of what's confusing me. I've just been getting paid directly to my bank account. When I asked about it, they said since I'm "just helping out" they didn't think they needed to provide anything. I'll definitely ask them more directly about this. Do you think I should request a 1099 from them?
Yes, you should definitely request a 1099-NEC from them. They're actually required to provide one if they paid you $600 or more during the year as an independent contractor. If they're not treating you as an employee with a W-2, then the 1099-NEC is the correct form. Even if they don't provide a 1099, you still need to report all your income. The IRS has a matching system where they can see deposits to your accounts, so it's important to declare everything. Without a 1099, you'd report it the same way on Schedule C, but you'll need to keep good records of all payments received in case of questions later.
Just wanted to add that as a personal assistant, you're almost certainly self-employed unless they control exactly when and how you do your work and provide all equipment. Make sure you're tracking ALL your expenses for next year! I've been a PA for 3 years and these deductions add up: - Mileage when running errands (not commuting to their house) - Portion of cell phone bill used for work - Any supplies you buy for work purposes - Professional services subscriptions - Home office deduction if you do admin work from home Also, since you haven't paid taxes all year, prepare for a potentially large tax bill. Self-employment tax alone is 15.3% on your net profit!
Can you really deduct part of your cell phone as a PA? I've been paying for a separate "work phone" thinking that was the only way to get the deduction!
Yes! You can absolutely deduct the business portion of your personal cell phone. You don't need a separate work phone. Just calculate what percentage you use it for work vs personal and deduct that percentage of your monthly bill. For example, if you use your phone 40% for work calls/texts with clients, you can deduct 40% of your phone bill as a business expense. Keep good records though - track work calls/texts for at least a few months to establish the percentage. Way easier than maintaining two phones!
I'm trying to understand the new Secure 2.0 provisions for rolling over education savings accounts into Roth IRAs. I know the Act allows 529 plans to be rolled over into Roth IRAs for the beneficiary, which is great. But I'm confused about whether Coverdell ESAs qualify for this same treatment. My daughter has about $18,000 in a Coverdell ESA that we set up years ago, and I'd love to convert this to a Roth IRA for her since she got scholarships and didn't need all the education funds. Since Coverdell ESAs are treated like 529s in many other ways, can they be directly rolled over to a Roth IRA under the new rules? If that's not allowed, I'm thinking about a two-step process - first rolling the Coverdell funds into a 529 plan in her name, then eventually moving those to a Roth IRA. But would we need to wait the full 15 years after creating the 529 before doing the Roth conversion? That seems like a long time just to make this work. Has anyone navigated this specific scenario yet? Any insights would be super helpful!
This is such a helpful thread! I'm dealing with a similar situation with my son's Coverdell ESA. One additional consideration I discovered is the timing of when you do the Coverdell-to-529 rollover within the tax year. My tax preparer pointed out that if you roll the Coverdell funds to a 529 late in the year, you might miss the window to use any of those funds for qualified education expenses in that same tax year (if your beneficiary is still in school). This could be relevant if you're trying to maximize the educational use of the funds before eventually converting to Roth. Also, for anyone considering this path, make sure to keep detailed records of the original Coverdell contribution dates and amounts. Even though they don't carry over to the 529 for the 15-year rule, you'll want this documentation for your own tax planning and to verify any calculations your financial institution makes. The complexity of these rules really makes me appreciate having professional guidance, whether that's through tax software, advisors, or the various services people have mentioned here!
Thank you all for this incredibly detailed discussion! As someone who's been wrestling with a similar Coverdell ESA situation, this thread has been a goldmine of information. I wanted to add one more consideration that my CPA brought up - the impact of Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) on this strategy. Since Roth IRAs don't have RMDs during the owner's lifetime, converting unused education funds to a Roth can be a great long-term estate planning tool. However, if you're planning this conversion for a young beneficiary, you need to factor in that they'll eventually have RMDs from any traditional retirement accounts they accumulate. The timing of when to do these conversions (once the 15-year period is satisfied) might be strategic - doing them during years when the beneficiary has lower income could minimize the tax impact, since the conversions count as taxable income. Also, I noticed several people mentioned state tax implications. Don't forget that some states don't tax Roth IRA distributions at all, while others do. So the long-term state tax treatment of the converted funds could be another factor in deciding whether this strategy makes sense for your situation. The complexity of all these rules really reinforces why getting professional guidance is so valuable for these decisions!
Great question! As someone who just went through this process myself, I'd definitely recommend starting with a comprehensive review of what accounts you already have before diving into tax advice. Here's the order that worked well for me: 1. **Account inventory first** - Dig up all your old 529 and Coverdell statements. Like Sophia discovered, you might have forgotten accounts that could save you years of waiting. Check with grandparents too - sometimes they opened accounts you weren't aware of. 2. **State tax research** - This is actually pretty quick to do yourself. Most state tax authority websites have specific guidance on 529 deductions and recapture rules. Knowing this upfront helps your tax professional give better advice. 3. **Professional consultation** - Once you know what accounts exist and your state's rules, a good CPA or fee-only financial planner can help you model different scenarios. For $12,000, the stakes aren't enormous, but the learning curve is steep. I'd suggest doing the account inventory and basic state research yourself first - it's free and might reveal game-changing information. Then invest in professional advice to optimize the strategy. The tools people mentioned here seem helpful for modeling scenarios, but I'd want to understand the basics first before diving into complex analysis tools.
Great question! As someone who just went through this process myself, I'd definitely recommend starting with a basic inventory of what you have before diving into professional advice. Here's the order that worked well for me: 1. **Account Discovery First** - Check if you have any existing 529 plans that might already meet the 15-year requirement (like Sophia found with her 2009 account). This could completely change your timeline and strategy. 2. **State Tax Research** - Look up your state's specific rules about 529 deduction recapture. This is often available on your state's revenue department website and doesn't require professional help to get the basic info. 3. **Professional Consultation** - Once you know what accounts you have and your state's rules, a CPA or tax advisor can help you model the different scenarios. With $12,000, the potential tax implications are significant enough to warrant professional guidance. 4. **Tools/Services** - Consider the analysis tools others mentioned after you have a clearer picture of your options. They're most helpful when you understand the basic framework. One thing I learned is that the "do nothing" option of just leaving the Coverdell alone until your daughter needs it for graduate school or other qualified expenses might actually be better than the complex conversion path, depending on your situation. A professional can help you run those numbers!
I have a question about my 2023 tax return situation. I mailed my return back in March 2024 along with my first tax payment in the same envelope. The IRS cashed that check which cleared on March 25th. Then I sent my second payment in June and they cashed it with the check clearing on June 29th, but that second payment isn't showing on my IRS account at all. The weird part is they're still showing my 2023 tax return as 'not received' or 'processing' even though they've cashed both payment checks. This happened to me once before with an amended return and it was a nightmare to resolve. Anyone know why they'd cash my checks but claim they haven't received my return, and why the second payment isn't showing up in my account?
According to Internal Revenue Manual section 3.30.123, payments received with returns should be processed and credited to your account even if the return is still in the processing queue. Per Notice 2024-05, the IRS is still experiencing significant delays with paper-filed returns. If you need to confirm the status of your return, I would recommend using Claimyr (https://claimyr.com) to get through to an IRS agent quickly. I've found that under Treasury Regulation 301.6402-3, having a record of your payments can establish filing intent, but you'll need to speak with an agent to ensure your return is properly associated with those payments.
The IRS is like a restaurant where the host seats you but never tells the waiter you're there. Your money goes straight to the bank, but your paperwork sits in a pile waiting for someone to notice it. Best thing to do is get proof of everything - certified mail receipts, copies of checks, and printouts of your account. Then be prepared to send it all again when they inevitably claim they never got it.
I think I might be experiencing something similar... I'm a bit worried about potential penalties if they don't properly connect my payments to my return. Has anyone had issues with the IRS charging penalties even when they've cashed your checks? I'm wondering if I should maybe file again electronically, but I'm concerned that might just complicate things further.
@Miguel Harvey Don t'file again electronically - that will definitely create a duplicate return issue that s'even harder to resolve! The IRS won t'charge you penalties for late payment if they ve'already cashed your checks. Your payment date is established by when they processed the checks, not when they finally get around to processing your return. Just keep all your documentation cancelled (checks, bank statements, certified mail receipts and) wait it out. If you get any penalty notices later, you can dispute them with proof that you paid on time.
So I'm trying to file my taxes using TurboTax for the 2024 tax year, and I'm completely stuck on this digital asset question. I've never owned cryptocurrency or NFTs or anything like that, but TurboTax is asking me if I've "received, sold, exchanged, or otherwise disposed of any financial interest in digital assets." I do have some regular stocks and mutual funds through Robinhood, but I don't think those count as "digital assets" in the crypto sense. I also use Venmo and PayPal occasionally to split costs with roommates for our apartment. This is only my second time filing taxes (got my first real job last summer), and I'm worried about answering incorrectly. If I answer "yes" it looks like it opens up a whole bunch of other complicated questions, but I don't want to say "no" if my regular investments count as digital assets. Does anyone know what exactly counts as a "digital asset" for tax purposes? Should I be checking yes or no on this TurboTax screen?
I totally mess this up every year lol... Last year I answered "yes" because i thought my robinhood account was "digital assets" and spent like an hour trying to figure out all the crypto questions before realizing my mistake. Turbo tax really should make this clearer!!! Such a waste of time.
Just wanted to add some clarity here since I see a lot of confusion in the comments! The IRS definition of "digital assets" is very specific - it includes cryptocurrencies (Bitcoin, Ethereum, etc.), NFTs, and other blockchain-based tokens. It does NOT include: - Traditional stocks and ETFs (even if held electronically through Robinhood, E*TRADE, etc.) - Payment app transactions like Venmo/PayPal for personal use - Online savings accounts or digital banking - Free fractional shares from stock apps However, it DOES include even small amounts of crypto - so if you got $5 of free Bitcoin from Coinbase or bought $50 of Dogecoin, you need to answer "Yes" and report it. The key test is: if it's built on blockchain technology, it's probably a digital asset for tax purposes. If it's a traditional investment that just happens to be held electronically, it's not. Hope this helps clear things up for anyone still confused!
Dylan Campbell
Has anyone had the IRS make the same mistake again after filing the 941-X? We had a similar situation in 2022 and even after submitting the correction, they made the exact same data entry error again the following quarter. wondering if this is a systemic issue with certain employer accounts.
0 coins
Sofia Torres
Yes! This happened to us three quarters in a row. Turned out there was something wrong with how our EIN was flagged in their system. We finally resolved it by having an IRS Taxpayer Advocate get involved. They can dig deeper into systemic issues than regular agents.
0 coins
Mason Kaczka
This exact same thing happened to my business last year! The IRS transcribed my Q3 941 wages as $45,000 instead of $450,000 - apparently someone missed a zero during data entry. Got a CP134R refund for over $12,000 that I knew was wrong. What made it even more frustrating was that I e-filed through my payroll software, so there shouldn't have been any manual transcription errors at all. Turns out their system had a glitch that corrupted some electronically filed returns during processing. The 941-X process you're going through is correct, but make sure to explicitly state in Part 4 that this is correcting an IRS processing error, not your filing error. I also recommend calling the Practitioner Priority Service line (if you have a tax pro) since they tend to be more knowledgeable about these systematic processing issues. Regular customer service agents often don't understand how these transcription errors happen in the first place. Keep detailed records of everything - this type of error sometimes repeats itself in their system even after correction.
0 coins