
California Unemployment
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
So I just got a determination letter from California EDD saying my unemployment claim was denied and honestly I'm completely blindsided. I've been working at the same warehouse job for almost two years and got laid off last month when they downsized our whole department. Thought this would be a straightforward claim but apparently not. The letter mentions something about 'not meeting base period wage requirements' but I genuinely don't understand what that means. My coworker filed the same week I did after the same layoff and got approved no problem. I've been racking my brain trying to figure out why would unemployment be denied in my situation when I clearly lost my job through no fault of my own. Is it possible EDD made a mistake? What are the most common reasons they deny claims? I really need this figured out fast because rent is coming up and I have zero other income right now.
So I got let go from my warehouse job about six weeks ago and filed for unemployment right away. Everything seemed fine until I got a notice saying my claim was denied because of 'misconduct.' I was completely blindsided because I never did anything wrong - I was laid off due to budget cuts, my supervisor even told me that to my face. Somehow when California EDD contacted my former employer, they told them something totally different. I have no idea what they said exactly but the denial letter says I was terminated for policy violations which is 100% false. I reported my hours and everything correctly and now I'm stuck with zero income while this company lies through their teeth. My question is can I sue my employer for lying to unemployment? I've heard of employers doing this to avoid paying into unemployment insurance but I figured it was rare. I do have text messages from my supervisor saying it was a budget thing and nothing to do with my performance. Not sure if that counts as evidence or anything but I'm holding onto everything I can find. Has anyone else dealt with an employer lying to California EDD and actually won their appeal? What steps did you take?
following this thread because I might have a similar situation coming up with my current job. bookmarking so I can reference all this advice if I need it
One last thing - if you end up needing to call California EDD multiple times through this process (and you probably will, there are multiple stages), Claimyr at claimyr.com is genuinely worth bookmarking. I know it was mentioned earlier but I want to second it because the EDD phone situation is just brutal and having a reliable way to get through without losing entire mornings to hold music is valuable when you have appeal prep work to do. The demo at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 is short and shows exactly what you're working with.
Saving this for sure. I've already wasted probably 6+ hours of failed calling attempts and I have a feeling I'll need to reach them several more times before this is over.
So I got laid off from my warehouse job about six weeks ago and I've been trying to figure out if I'm actually eligible for unemployment benefits through California EDD. My situation is a little complicated because I was technically part-time but working close to full-time hours for the last eight months, and before that I had a gap where I freelanced for a few months. I know you need to have earned a certain amount during your base period but I'm honestly confused about how they calculate all of that. I also wasn't sure if I count as 'able and available' since I have some back issues that limit what kind of jobs I can take. Can someone break down the basic eligibility requirements for California EDD unemployment? Like what do they actually look for when they decide if you qualify?
I want to add something about the job search requirement because I see a lot of confusion about this. The three contacts per week requirement - you need to actually log these in your UI Online account or on paper if you're doing phone certifications. California EDD can and does audit job search records. If you can't produce documentation of your contacts, you could be found ineligible for those weeks and face an overpayment. Keep records of every application, every call to an employer, every resume submission. Date, employer name, contact method, position applied for. It takes like two minutes per entry and protects you.
I keep a Google Sheet with columns for date, employer, position, how I applied, and any response. Takes seconds to update and gives me peace of mind that I could produce records if ever asked.
Rooting for you! Once it comes through the direct deposit is usually pretty quick. Hopefully you're approved without any adjudication issues.
Thanks everyone seriously. This thread answered like 10 questions I didn't even know how to google properly. The California EDD system is a lot to navigate but at least I understand the basics now - the base period wages, job search requirements, able and available, weekly certifications. Feeling a lot more confident about my claim.
So I've been doing gig work and contract jobs for about four years now, always getting 1099s at the end of the year, never W-2s. My main client basically ended our contract last month with zero warning — they just said they were restructuring and didn't need my services anymore. I know traditionally unemployment was only for regular W-2 employees but I've been hearing conflicting things about whether 1099 workers can actually file for California EDD unemployment now. I pay my own self-employment taxes every quarter so I'm wondering if that counts for anything. Has anyone here actually tried to file as a 1099 contractor and had any success? What happens when you go through the application — does it ask about 1099 income specifically or does the whole thing just fall apart when they see you were self-employed?
Last thing to add for anyone reading this later — California has a Voluntary Plan Disability Insurance (SDI) system separate from UI. Some 1099 workers who have paid into SDI through certain arrangements might also have disability benefit options if they're unable to work for health reasons. That's a completely separate track from UI but worth knowing about if unemployment isn't an option for your situation.
Yes — EDD administers Unemployment Insurance (UI), State Disability Insurance (SDI), and Paid Family Leave (PFL). They're funded and accessed separately. For the purposes of this thread though UI is the relevant one for job loss situations.
Good comprehensive thread. Summary for 1099 workers finding this: file anyway if you have any W-2 wages in last 18 months, consider misclassification argument if your work looked like employment, report ALL income during certifications, verify your identity through ID.me promptly, and if you need to actually talk to an EDD agent about your specific situation try Claimyr at claimyr.com since getting through by regular phone is nearly impossible right now. Good luck everyone.
So I just got laid off last Friday and I've been trying to figure out when exactly I'm supposed to file my claim. My manager said I could apply right away but my coworker told me to wait until my last paycheck clears? I'm really confused about the timing. I work in the restaurant industry and it was a full layoff, not a reduction in hours or anything like that. Is there a waiting period before you can apply for California EDD unemployment benefits or can I just go file right now on their website? I don't want to mess anything up by filing too early or too late. Also does it matter that I got two weeks of severance pay? Would that push back when I can start collecting?
Last Claimyr plug because I genuinely think it's useful for people just starting out - if you file and something seems stuck or you're not sure why your claim is in pending status, getting an actual EDD agent on the phone makes a massive difference vs just watching the website and hoping. claimyr.com and the demo video is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. Having that resource bookmarked before you need it is smart.
For anyone wondering about the severance question specifically - California EDD treats different types of severance differently. A lump sum payment that isn't tied to specific weeks of work usually doesn't delay your benefit start date. But continuation pay where your employer is essentially paying your salary for X more weeks IS considered wages for those weeks and does push back when your UI benefits can begin. Ask your HR department which type of severance you're receiving before you apply so you can answer accurately.
Most likely not but report it honestly and let EDD make the determination. The key phrase in your application would be noting it as a lump sum severance not tied to specific future weeks of employment.
Freya Pedersen
One final thing worth knowing - if you do appeal and have a hearing, you're allowed to bring a representative or have someone help you prepare. It's not a formal court proceeding but having someone who knows California unemployment law review your case before the hearing can make a real difference. Many legal aid organizations in California offer free help with EDD appeals. Worth looking into if your denial amount is significant.
0 coins
CosmicCruiser
Bay Area Legal Aid and similar orgs have helped a lot of people I know with EDD issues. Don't be shy about reaching out to them.
0 coins
Omar Hassan
Also the hearing officer at the appeal is not on EDD's side - their job is to make a neutral determination. A lot of people go in expecting an adversarial process and are surprised that the hearing is actually pretty fair if you can clearly explain your situation and have any documentation to back it up.
0 coins
StarStrider
UPDATE: I finally got through to EDD (used Claimyr like someone suggested, worked way faster than calling on my own). The rep confirmed that they had NOT checked the alternative base period and once they ran the calculation using my most recent four quarters, I actually DO qualify. She's submitting a correction and said my claim should be updated within 5-7 business days. Cannot believe something this important was just... overlooked. Thank you all so much for the advice in this thread, especially the tip about the alternative base period - that's literally what saved my claim.
0 coins
Anastasia Fedorov
Awesome news! And yes this is exactly why getting a human on the phone makes such a difference - an automated denial letter would never catch that kind of oversight.
0 coins
Sean Doyle
Love a happy ending on these threads. Hope the payment comes through quickly for you!
0 coins