


Ask the community...
I'm so sorry you're going through this Isabella! Your situation sounds incredibly frustrating but also very winnable on appeal. The advice from everyone here is excellent - definitely don't give up! One thing I wanted to add that I haven't seen mentioned yet: when you're preparing for your hearing, practice explaining your case out loud beforehand. I know it sounds silly, but when I had my EDD appeal hearing, I was so nervous that I started rambling and almost forgot to mention some key points. Also, regarding the security footage - even if your employer won't provide it, the fact that you can specifically reference what the cameras would show (you completing the audit on time, reporting the system issue immediately) can still be powerful evidence. The judge will note that you're being very specific about verifiable facts. Your case has all the elements of a successful appeal: - Technical failure beyond your control - You followed proper procedures by reporting the issue - The task wasn't in your official job description - You were performing supervisor duties without supervisor pay The initial EDD interviewer probably just checked boxes without really understanding the nuances of your situation. The appeals process is where you'll get a fair hearing from someone who actually reviews the details. Keep us updated on how it goes! This community is rooting for you, and your experience will definitely help others in similar situations. You've got this! 💪
@Logan Chiang - that s'such great advice about practicing out loud! I never would have thought of that but it makes total sense. When you re'stressed and nervous it s'so easy to forget important details or ramble instead of staying focused on the key points. I m'also really glad you mentioned that even without the actual security footage, being specific about what it would show can still help the case. That takes some pressure off since getting cooperation from former employers can be tricky. @Isabella Costa - I hope you re feeling'encouraged by all this support! Your case really does sound like a textbook example of an unfair denial that should be overturned on appeal. The combination of the technical issue being beyond your control, you following proper procedures, and the task not being in your job description is exactly the kind of thing appeals judges look for. It s honestly'inspiring to see how this community comes together to help each other navigate these bureaucratic nightmares. EDD s initial'denial process seems designed to discourage people from fighting for their rights, but threads like this show that with the right preparation and evidence, justice can prevail. Wishing you the best of luck with your appeal! Please keep us posted on how it goes - your experience will definitely help others facing similar situations.
I'm new to this community but currently going through my own EDD appeal process, so reading through everyone's advice here has been incredibly helpful! @Isabella Costa - your situation sounds almost identical to what happened to me. I was terminated for not completing a task that was actually outside my official job duties, and like you, I got denied initially. The frustration is real, but don't let it discourage you! Based on what I've learned from my own research and the excellent advice in this thread, you definitely have a strong case. The key points that stand out for your appeal: 1. **Job description mismatch** - This is HUGE. The fact that inventory audits were supervisor duties but you were required to do them as a regular associate shows they were holding you to standards outside your job classification. 2. **Technical failure beyond your control** - You completed the audit on time but couldn't upload due to a system freeze. That's not misconduct, that's a technical issue. 3. **Proper reporting** - You immediately told your shift lead about the problem, showing you followed appropriate procedures. I'd definitely recommend getting that job description in writing ASAP, along with any documentation showing the pay difference between your role and supervisors who were supposed to handle inventory audits. The appeals judges are much more fair than the initial EDD reviewers. From what I've learned, they actually take time to review the facts rather than just rubber-stamping denials. Keep fighting this - you've got solid grounds for an appeal and this community is here to support you! 💪
@Anita George - thanks for sharing your experience! It s'so reassuring to know that others have gone through similar situations and that the appeals process really can work when you come prepared with the right evidence. I m'also new to this community but have been following this thread closely because I m'dealing with my own EDD issues. The level of support and practical advice here is amazing - it s'given me so much more confidence about challenging my own denial. @Isabella Costa - I hope you re feeling'more optimistic after reading all these success stories and detailed strategies! Your case really does check all the boxes for a successful appeal. The job description evidence alone should be compelling, but combined with the technical issue and your immediate reporting of the problem, it s a'very strong foundation. One small addition to all the great advice already shared - when you re documenting'everything, consider creating a simple folder physical or (digital to keep) all your evidence organized. Having everything in one place makes it much easier when you re preparing'for the hearing and ensures you don t accidentally'leave out any important documents. The fact that EDD seems to deny so many initial claims hoping people won t appeal'is really frustrating, but it s encouraging'to see how many people in this community have successfully fought back and won their cases. Don t let'their intimidation tactics work - you deserve those benefits and have every right to appeal this unfair decision! Rooting for you and everyone else going through this process! 🙏
Hi everyone, just made a video about how to call the EDD and reach a live human agent: https://youtu.be/-R4SqP7_JUA
I'm dealing with a similar situation - filed in December and still haven't received any payments despite submitting all requested documents. The "waiting period" status seems to be EDD's way of saying they're reviewing your for potential flags. From what I've read in other threads, this can take anywhere from 6-12 weeks unfortunately. Have you tried faxing your proof of residency in addition to mailing it? Sometimes that gets processed faster. Also, keep detailed records of every interaction and document you've submitted - dates, confirmation numbers, etc. This will help when you contact your assembly member. Hang in there, you're not alone in this frustrating process!
Just wanted to add my experience for anyone else going through this nightmare! I finished a 15-week penalty period last summer (yeah, 15 weeks - longest penalty possible for false statement). The key thing everyone's saying is correct - no additional waiting period after penalties end. You just pick up where you left off with regular certifications. BUT here's what nobody mentioned yet: make sure to log into your EDD account a few days before your next certification date to check if there are any notices or requirements. Sometimes they'll post additional forms or questionnaires that need to be completed before you can certify again. I almost missed my certification deadline because I didn't see a "return to work" questionnaire they posted. Also, pro tip: if you haven't already, screenshot or print your penalty completion notice from your account. I had to reference mine later when there was confusion about my payment status. The EDD system sometimes glitches and shows old penalty info even after it's completed. You've survived the worst part - 10 weeks of financial stress is no joke! Just stay on top of all the requirements and you should be getting paid again soon. 💪
Thanks Zoe! That's a great tip about checking for additional forms before certification. I would have definitely missed that since I've been avoiding logging in during the penalty period (too depressing to look at zero payments). The screenshot idea is smart too - I've learned not to trust the EDD system to keep accurate records of anything! 15 weeks sounds absolutely brutal, I can't imagine how you got through that. Really appreciate everyone sharing their experiences here, it's way more helpful than anything on the official EDD site.
Just want to echo what everyone else is saying - you're in the clear! No additional waiting period after penalty weeks. I went through an 8-week false statement penalty last fall and was terrified about the same thing. The moment my penalty period ended, I certified on my regular schedule and got paid for both weeks within the normal timeframe. One thing I'd add that helped me mentally prepare: don't panic if your first payment after penalties takes an extra day or two to hit your account. Mine took 4 business days instead of the usual 2-3, but EDD told me that's normal as they do a final review on post-penalty payments. Just wanted you to know in case yours is slightly delayed too. You've made it through the hardest part! Those penalty weeks feel endless when you're living on fumes, but you're about to get back to regular payments. Make sure to keep being extra careful with your certifications going forward - they definitely keep a closer eye on accounts that have had penalties.
I experienced this exact same problem and it was driving me crazy! After missing 3 callbacks, I discovered that my 's "Do Not Disturb" settings were automatically enabled during certain hours. Even though my showed it was off, there was a scheduled DND that I had forgotten about. Check your DND settings thoroughly - sometimes there are multiple layers of call filtering that can interfere. Also, if you're using Google Voice or any call forwarding services, those can sometimes cause issues with receiving callbacks. I ended up temporarily disabling all call filtering features and finally got through on my next callback. The relief when that actually rang was incredible! Don't give up - there's usually a solution hiding in your settings somewhere.
This is such a comprehensive breakdown of potential issues! I never considered that Do Not Disturb might have scheduled settings that I forgot about. Just checked mine and found I had it set to automatically turn on during "work hours" which is exactly when EDD would be calling. Also didn't realize that Google Voice could interfere - I do have that set up for some of my business calls. Going to disable everything temporarily like you suggested. It's reassuring to know that others have figured this out and there are actual solutions. The stress of missing these callbacks is unreal, especially when you've been waiting so long just to get one scheduled. Thanks for sharing your experience - it gives me several new things to try!
I had this exact same frustrating experience! After missing several callbacks, I discovered it was a combination of issues. First, check if your has any "Scam Shield" or similar carrier-level blocking - I called my carrier and they had automatically enabled spam protection that was flagging the EDD number. Second, make sure your box isn't full or close to full, as this can cause to fail before they even ring. Third, try restarting your completely before your next scheduled callback - sometimes there are background processes interfering with incoming calls. I also recommend testing by having a friend call you from an unknown number to see if it rings through properly. After fixing these issues, my next callback came through perfectly. It's such a relief when you finally hear that ring! Don't lose hope - there's usually a technical solution hiding somewhere in your or carrier settings.
This is incredibly thorough and helpful! I never thought about testing with a friend calling from an unknown number - that's such a smart way to diagnose if the issue is actually with your settings. I just checked and my is indeed almost full, which could definitely be causing problems. Also going to call my carrier tomorrow about any automatic scam protection they might have enabled. The restart suggestion makes sense too - sometimes the simplest solutions are the ones we overlook. It's so reassuring to see that multiple people have dealt with this and found ways to fix it. The anxiety of waiting for a callback and then missing it is terrible, especially when you don't even know why it's happening. Thank you for taking the time to share all these troubleshooting steps!
Natasha Volkova
I just went through this same exact situation last month! Got the address verification letter about 3 weeks after my benefit year ended and I was totally convinced it was a scam at first. The timing felt so random and suspicious. But after doing some research and talking to others who'd been through it, I learned this is EDD's new normal process - they're doing way more post-payment audits now as part of their fraud prevention efforts that started ramping up in 2023. The dead giveaway that yours is legitimate is that it only asked for address proof, not sensitive info like SSN or banking details that scammers typically want. I submitted a utility bill through their official portal and never heard back, which I later found out means everything was approved. You definitely did the right thing responding quickly with your bank statement - that's perfect documentation for address verification. Don't stress about not getting a confirmation; EDD's system is terrible at communication but silence usually means you're good to go!
0 coins
Keisha Thompson
•This is so helpful! I'm actually dealing with a similar situation right now - got an address verification letter yesterday and have been going back and forth on whether it's legit or not. The timing really does seem suspicious when it comes after everything is already done, but hearing from so many people who've been through the exact same thing is really reassuring. It sounds like EDD's communication about this new process is just terrible, but the process itself is legitimate. Thanks for mentioning that silence means approval - that's something I definitely wouldn't have known otherwise!
0 coins
StarSurfer
This is such a common concern now! I went through something very similar about 5 months ago - got an address verification request about 3 weeks after my claim ended and I was completely done with benefits. Like you, I was super paranoid it was a scam because the timing seemed so weird. But after calling EDD directly (took forever to get through) they confirmed it was part of their new post-payment audit system that they started implementing more heavily in 2023. The representative explained that these verifications are completely separate from the initial ID.me process and can happen months after your claim closes. I ended up submitting a recent credit card statement and never heard back, which I learned means everything was processed successfully. You definitely made the right call responding quickly with proper documentation - a bank statement is perfect for this type of verification. The whole process is really poorly explained by EDD but it's become their standard operating procedure now unfortunately.
0 coins