< Back to California Unemployment

EDD disqualified my claim - when should I expect the overpayment notice?

So I just got notification that EDD disqualified me for UI benefits going back 3 months. My certification was pending for like 5 weeks, then suddenly I got a notice saying I was disqualified for all previous payments (almost $7,500). The message on UI Online just says 'disqualification - false statement' but doesn't explain what I supposedly said wrong. I'm freaking out because I honestly answered everything truthfully! My question is - when will they actually send the official overpayment notice? I need to know how much time I have to figure out how to appeal this or start making payments. Has anyone dealt with this before? I don't have $7,500 just sitting around!

I've been there before - it's super stressful but don't panic yet. The overpayment notice typically comes about 2-3 weeks after the disqualification notice. When it arrives, you'll have 30 days to file an appeal, which I HIGHLY recommend doing. The appeal form will be included with the notice. Make sure to request a hearing and clearly explain why you believe the disqualification is incorrect.

0 coins

Thank you! Do you know if I need to start paying it back while the appeal is in process? I'm worried they'll start garnishing my wages or something before I even get a chance to fight this.

0 coins

The overpayment notice should come within 30 days, but I've seen it take as little as a week or as long as 6 weeks. EDD isn't exactly consistent with their timeframes. When you get it, read it CAREFULLY because it will specify if they're claiming 'fraud' or just regular overpayment - that makes a huge difference for penalties and how they can collect.

0 coins

What's the difference between fraud and regular overpayment? The disqualification just said 'false statement' but I swear I didn't lie about anything!

0 coins

I GOT THE SAME THING!!! mine said "disqual - wilful misrep" and the overpayment notice came exactly 17 days later. They want me to pay back $5,890 which is IMPOSSIBLE right now. This whole system is rigged to screw over regular people. I tried calling them 57 times yesterday and couldn't get through ONCE. How are we supposed to fix problems if we cant even talk to a human??!!

0 coins

The system is definitely frustrating. Did you file an appeal? That's really the first step before anything else.

0 coins

You really need to talk to an EDD rep ASAP to find out exactly what "false statement" they're referring to. Could be something simple like reporting your work search activities incorrectly or a misunderstanding about your availability for work. I spent weeks trying to get through on the phone until I used this service called Claimyr that connects you with EDD without the endless calling. Saved me so much frustration - just go to claimyr.com and they have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10?si=TSwYbu_GOwYzt9km. Worth it to get actual answers instead of stressing about the unknown.

0 coins

Thanks for the tip! Has anyone else used this service? I'm desperate enough to try anything at this point. Just want to make sure it's legit before I waste more time.

0 coins

ya i used claimyr last yr when my account got froze. it worked but take like 30 min still but better than callin for days

0 coins

Thanks for confirming. I'll check it out tomorrow morning.

0 coins

i think theres a misunderstanding here. disqualification doesnt automatically mean you got an overpayment. sometimes they just stop future payments. have you actually received an overpayment notice yet? or are you just assuming youll get one?

0 coins

The disqualification notice specifically said I was disqualified for weeks I already got paid for, so I'm assuming there will be an overpayment notice. But you're right - I haven't gotten the actual overpayment notice yet, just the disqualification.

0 coins

To answer your question about payments during appeal - you don't have to start paying back during the appeal process, but interest may continue to accrue if the overpayment is confirmed. If your appeal is successful, the overpayment will be canceled. If not, you can request a waiver or payment plan. Don't ignore the notices though - always respond within the timeframes they give you.

0 coins

That's a relief! I'll definitely appeal as soon as I get the notice. Just waiting anxiously for it to arrive now.

0 coins

This happened to me back in November! They claimed I didn't report some income but I definitely did. Anyway, I got the disqualification notice on Nov 3rd and the overpayment notice arrived Nov 18th. So about two weeks in my case.

0 coins

What was the outcome of your situation? Did you appeal or pay it back?

0 coins

I appealed and won! Took almost 3 months for the hearing but I had all my screenshots showing I reported everything correctly. Judge reversed the whole thing.

0 coins

My girlfriend went through this exact situation last month when they claimed she wasn't available for work (she was). The timeline for her was: disqualification notice → overpayment notice 12 days later → she filed appeal → got hearing date 6 weeks later → had phone hearing with judge → decision came 2 weeks after hearing (she won). So the whole process took about 10 weeks from start to finish.

0 coins

It's good to hear that appeals can actually work! Did she have to have a lawyer or anything for the hearing?

0 coins

No lawyer - she just gathered all her evidence (screenshots, emails, etc) and explained her side clearly. The judge was actually pretty fair.

0 coins

UPDATE: I finally got through to EDD this morning!! Turns out my disqualification was because they thought I was working full-time when I was only doing part-time contractor work. The rep fixed it right on the spot and said my account should update in 48 hours. KEEP TRYING TO CALL THEM!! Sometimes you get lucky and find someone who actually helps.

0 coins

wow lucky u got someone helpful. most of them just read from scripts and dont fix anything

0 coins

Once you get the overpayment notice, make sure to thoroughly document everything. Here's my checklist for appeals: 1. Write out a clear timeline of events 2. Gather ALL communications with EDD 3. Pull together any evidence that shows you reported information correctly 4. Get a document that explains your work situation during the claim period 5. File the appeal within 30 days (don't wait until day 29!) 6. Request the hearing to be in your preferred format (phone or video) 7. If you miss the 30-day window, you can still appeal but need to explain why you were late The majority of appeals I've seen succeed are ones where people were organized and had documentation.

0 coins

This is incredibly helpful - thank you! I'll start gathering everything now so I'm ready when the notice arrives. Hoping I can get this sorted out without having to pay back money I legitimately needed and qualified for.

0 coins

TaxRefund AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
6,769 users helped today