


Ask the community...
This is such an incredible success story! Congratulations on winning your appeal and getting your payments released so quickly! 🎉 As someone who just discovered this community while dealing with my own EDD nightmare, reading through your entire journey from the initial hearing to getting paid has been incredibly informative and inspiring. Your case with the 60% hour reduction being classified as "voluntary quit" is exactly the kind of wrongful denial that seems to plague EDD's system. The fact that you meticulously documented everything and the judge saw right through EDD's weak arguments gives me so much hope for others facing similar situations. What really stands out to me is how proactive you were about calling EDD immediately after getting your favorable decision. It's ridiculous that their system doesn't automatically process appeal victories, but your experience shows that being persistent really pays off. Getting through on your third try and having the rep manually release your payments within hours is exactly the kind of outcome everyone here is hoping for. Thank you for taking the time to update this thread throughout your entire process - from the initial anxiety about waiting for the decision, to celebrating the victory, to successfully getting your payments released. Your timeline of 7 business days for the decision and next-day payment release after calling provides such valuable insight for others navigating this broken system. Stories like yours make this community so valuable for people fighting these wrongful denials!
Thank you so much! It really has been such a rollercoaster of emotions these past few weeks. I'm still kind of in disbelief that it's actually over and the money is coming. You're absolutely right about being proactive - I think if I had just waited for EDD's system to automatically update, I'd probably still be sitting here checking my account every day! The rep I spoke with even mentioned that appeal decisions sometimes get "stuck" in their system and need manual intervention. It's crazy that we have to chase them down for money we're legally entitled to, but at least now I know the process works if you stay on top of it. Best of luck with your own case - this community really is amazing for support and practical advice. Don't give up fighting whatever wrongful denial you're dealing with!
Wow, what an incredible journey to follow from start to finish! As someone completely new to this community (just joined after getting my own EDD denial), your story gives me so much hope and practical guidance. The fact that you went from anxiously waiting for your decision to actually getting paid in just over a week is amazing. Your case really highlights how broken EDD's initial review process is - a 60% reduction in hours being called "voluntary quit" is absolutely ridiculous. Of course you had to find other work! It's so encouraging that the judge saw right through their weak arguments and that the EDD rep couldn't even properly defend their position. The timeline you've shared has been invaluable - 7 business days for the decision, then getting payments released the very next day after calling EDD directly. I'm definitely taking notes on calling right at 8 AM and having all the case numbers ready. It's frustrating that we have to chase them down for money we're legally entitled to, but your proactive approach clearly worked. Thank you for being so generous with updates throughout this whole process. Reading about your victory gives everyone here fighting similar wrongful denials the motivation to keep pushing forward. Congratulations again on getting through this nightmare - you absolutely deserved this win! 🎉
This thread has been such a lifesaver! I'm brand new here after getting completely blindsided by my own EDD denial last week. Reading your entire journey from that initial anxiety about waiting for the decision to actually celebrating getting your payments released has given me such a clear roadmap of what to expect. The 7-day timeline for the decision and then getting payments the very next day after calling shows that persistence really does pay off. It's insane that EDD's system doesn't automatically process favorable appeals - like, isn't that the whole point of winning?? But knowing that calling them directly at 8 AM with your case number ready can get things moving immediately is gold. Your 60% hour reduction situation being called "voluntary quit" is exactly the kind of nonsense so many of us are dealing with. Thanks for sharing every step of this process - it's going to help so many people! 🙏
This is such a frustrating situation, but you're definitely not powerless here! I went through something very similar when EDD retroactively reviewed my pandemic claim in late 2023. A few things that might help based on my experience: **Check your UI Online message center thoroughly** - sometimes there are notices buried in there that are easy to miss, especially if you weren't logging in regularly after finding new employment. **Look for any "pending eligibility" flags** - when you log into your account, check if there are any unresolved eligibility issues that might have triggered the mass disqualification. Sometimes it's something as simple as a missing document they requested years ago. **Get your employer's business license records** - if the manufacturing plant officially closed due to COVID, there should be public records showing this. Your county clerk's office or business licensing department might have documentation of the closure that could strengthen your appeal. **File for financial hardship** - even if the appeal takes time, you can request that they don't pursue collection during the appeals process due to financial hardship. This might help protect future tax refunds while you fight this. The good news is that legitimate pandemic unemployment claims have a very high success rate on appeal when proper documentation is provided. Since your husband worked at the same place for 3+ years before a documented COVID closure, you have strong evidence of legitimate eligibility. Don't give up - this sounds like exactly the type of case that gets overturned once a human reviews it properly!
Thank you for all this detailed advice! I just checked the UI Online message center and you're absolutely right - there were some old messages from 2022 that I completely missed because we weren't logging in regularly after he found work in Nevada. One of them mentions "additional documentation required for eligibility review" but doesn't specify what documents they needed. This is probably what triggered everything! I'm going to include screenshots of these missed messages in our appeal to show we genuinely didn't see them due to the move and not actively monitoring the account. The tip about getting business license records is brilliant too - I'll contact the county where his plant was located to see if they have official documentation of the COVID closure. Really appreciate you mentioning the financial hardship option as well - $28k would definitely qualify as hardship for us! Feeling much more prepared to tackle this now with everyone's guidance.
I'm so sorry this happened to you - this is becoming an epidemic and it's absolutely infuriating how EDD is handling these retroactive reviews. What you're describing is almost identical to what happened to my sister's family last year. A couple of additional things that might help that I haven't seen mentioned yet: **Request a "stay of collection" immediately** - while your appeal is pending, you can request that EDD halt any collection activities including future tax intercepts. File this along with your DE 1000M appeal form. **Check if your husband's employer filed a "mass layoff" notice with the state** - companies that laid off large numbers of employees due to COVID were often required to file WARN notices or similar documentation with the state. This could be powerful evidence that his layoff was legitimate and COVID-related. **Document your good faith efforts to comply** - the fact that he certified every two weeks and reported when he found part-time work shows he was following all the rules. Make sure to emphasize this in your appeal. The most important thing is that you're taking action now. These mass disqualifications are largely being done by computer algorithms, and when actual humans review cases with proper documentation, the vast majority of legitimate claims are being reinstated. Your husband's 3+ year employment history before a documented COVID business closure should make this a straightforward win once you get in front of a real person. Stay strong and don't let them bully you into just accepting this. The system is broken but your rights are still intact!
This is incredibly helpful - I had no idea about requesting a "stay of collection" to prevent future tax intercepts while we're appealing! That's definitely going to be a priority since we can't afford to lose another tax refund while fighting this. The WARN notice idea is genius too - I'm going to contact both the county and state labor departments to see if his employer filed any mass layoff documentation when they shut down. Having official state records of the COVID closure would be huge for our case. You're absolutely right about emphasizing his good faith compliance - he was so careful to follow every rule and report his part-time work properly when he found it. It really shows this isn't fraud, just EDD's broken system catching legitimate claims in their net. Thank you for the encouragement - reading everyone's experiences here has completely changed my mindset from panic to determination. We're going to fight this with everything we've got!
They typically give you options for the first payment. You can usually arrange to make it within 7-10 days of setting up the plan. Make sure you have your bank account information ready when you call. They'll also ask about your income and expenses to determine a monthly payment amount that's feasible for your situation.
I went through something similar last year. EDD can definitely take your federal refund through the Treasury Offset Program, but there's usually a process and notice period. The key is acting fast - once I called and set up a payment plan, they stopped the federal intercept process. One tip that helped me get through to EDD faster: call exactly at 8:00 AM when they open, and if you get the busy message, hang up and immediately redial. Sometimes it takes 20-30 tries but you'll eventually get through. Also have your EDD customer account number ready and all your financial info for setting up the payment plan. Good luck - don't give up on trying to reach them! It's worth the effort to protect that bigger federal refund.
I'm new here but wanted to chime in after reading your story - what you experienced is absolutely terrible and you 100% made the right decision to leave that toxic environment. Your safety and wellbeing are more important than any job. I haven't been through the EDD appeals process myself, but I work in employment law and can tell you that your case sounds very strong. The key factors working in your favor are: 1) You have documented evidence of the harassment, 2) You properly reported it to HR, 3) HR essentially admitted they couldn't help because the harasser was the owner, and 4) You had no reasonable alternatives left. California law specifically recognizes that employees shouldn't have to endure illegal harassment to keep their jobs. The initial denial is frustrating but unfortunately common - EDD often denies first and hopes people don't appeal. Stay strong and definitely file that appeal! With your documentation and witness statements, you should have a good chance of success.
Thank you so much for the legal perspective - it's really reassuring to hear from someone who works in employment law that my case looks strong. I keep second-guessing myself and wondering if I should have tried something else first, but you're right that I literally had no other options when the person harassing me was the owner. The fact that HR basically admitted in writing that they couldn't help should definitely work in my favor. I'm gathering all my documentation now and feeling more confident about filing the appeal. It's encouraging to know that the initial denial is common and doesn't necessarily reflect the strength of my case.
I'm so sorry you're going through this - what a horrible situation to be put in! As someone new to this community, I've been reading through all the advice and wanted to add my support. You absolutely did the right thing by leaving that toxic environment, and you deserve those benefits while you search for a safer workplace. One thing I noticed that might help strengthen your appeal: make sure to emphasize the timeline of events clearly. Document exactly when the harassment started escalating, when you reported to HR, and when they essentially told you there was no recourse. This timeline will help show the judge that you didn't just quit impulsively - you tried to resolve it through proper channels first and only left when it became clear there was no other option. Also, if you haven't already, try to get that HR response in writing if it was verbal. Even a follow-up email saying something like "Per our conversation yesterday about my concerns regarding [owner's name], I understand that internal resolution isn't possible given the reporting structure" could be helpful documentation. You've got a strong case and great advice from everyone here. Don't let EDD discourage you - file that appeal and fight for what you deserve!
Thank you Emma! That's really smart advice about getting the HR response documented if it was just verbal. Fortunately I do have that email I mentioned where our HR coordinator basically admitted they couldn't help because the owner was my direct supervisor. Reading everyone's responses here has been so helpful - I was feeling really defeated after getting that denial letter, but now I understand that initial denials are common and I actually have a much stronger case than I initially thought. The timeline approach you suggested makes a lot of sense too - showing that this wasn't an impulsive decision but rather a last resort after trying proper channels. I'm definitely going to file the appeal and fight for this!
Ravi Gupta
Hey Yara! Welcome to the community! I can see you've received absolutely incredible advice from everyone here - this thread has become such a comprehensive resource for understanding unemployment benefits! As someone who works in HR and helps people navigate these situations regularly, I just wanted to reinforce what everyone has said: your friend's information was completely incorrect, and your $6,000 claim balance is definitely just for this specific benefit year. You can absolutely apply for unemployment again in the future if needed. What I love seeing in this thread is how you've gone from panic to having a solid action plan. The systematic approach everyone has helped you develop - with tracking spreadsheets, networking strategies, and understanding the certification process - is exactly what leads to successful job searches. One small addition to all the great advice: since you're a CPA, consider reaching out to your former employer's clients (if your employment agreement allows it). Many businesses need accounting help during year-end closing and might be looking for someone with your exact experience. Just make sure to handle any potential conflicts of interest appropriately. You're asking all the right questions and clearly have the right mindset now. With the strong accounting job market and all these excellent strategies, I'm confident you'll find something great well before you exhaust your benefits. The unemployment system is there to support you during this transition - use it as intended and focus your energy on landing that next opportunity!
0 coins
Rhett Bowman
Hey Yara! Welcome to the community! I can see you've gotten absolutely amazing advice from everyone here - this thread is incredibly comprehensive and helpful! As someone who just went through unemployment myself (also in finance), I wanted to add one quick tip that really helped me stay motivated during the job search process. I created a simple "wins tracker" alongside my job application spreadsheet - I'd log things like positive recruiter responses, interview invitations, networking connections made, etc. It helped me see progress even when I wasn't getting immediate job offers. Also, since you mentioned being laid off from accounting, make sure to ask your former employer for a strong reference letter before too much time passes. Having that ready to go can really speed up the application process when potential employers request references. You've clearly got such a solid plan now thanks to everyone's advice here. The combination of understanding the EDD system properly (that $6,000 is definitely just for this benefit year!) plus all the practical job search strategies people have shared should set you up for success. With your CPA license and the strong accounting market heading into year-end, I bet you'll find something excellent well before that 2-3 month timeline you mentioned. Don't stress about "using up" your benefits - focus that energy on finding your next great opportunity! You've got this!
0 coins