


Ask the community...
Remember that the judge is supposed to be neutral. They're not on your employer's side or your side - they're just trying to determine what actually happened based on the evidence. Try to present facts rather than emotions, even though I know this situation is really stressful financially.
Dylan, I went through a similar situation about 8 months ago when my employer claimed I was terminated for misconduct but it was really just a disagreement over procedures. The most important thing I learned is to focus on the specific incident they're claiming as misconduct - don't let them bring up unrelated performance issues or personality conflicts. Take notes during the hearing because you might need to reference what was said if you decide to appeal further. Also, if your employer makes any statements that contradict what they told you when you were fired, point that out to the judge. Inconsistencies in their story can really help your case. The whole process took about 4 months total for me but I did eventually get my benefits restored with back pay.
This is really helpful advice, especially about taking notes during the hearing. I hadn't thought about documenting inconsistencies in their story. Four months is a long time but at least you got the back pay eventually. Did you have to do anything special to get them to process the back benefits or did it happen automatically once you won?
Thanks Ethan, this is exactly the kind of detailed advice I was hoping for! I'm definitely going to take notes during the hearing - that's something I wouldn't have thought of. The inconsistency point is really important too because I remember my supervisor giving me one reason when I was fired but the termination paperwork said something slightly different. I'm glad to hear you eventually got everything resolved even though it took so long. Did you represent yourself or did you end up getting a lawyer for any part of the process?
I just went through this exact same process about 6 weeks ago! The waiting period after the hearing is honestly the worst part because you just have no idea which way it's going to go. But based on what you're describing - having documented emails about safety concerns that were ignored - you actually sound like you have a really strong case. That's exactly the kind of "good cause" evidence that tends to win appeals for voluntary quits. A few things that might help while you wait: 1) Keep filing your weekly claims even while waiting for the decision (you won't get paid yet but it keeps your claim active), 2) The decision will show up in eServices usually a day or two before the paper copy arrives in the mail, and 3) Try not to read too much into how the hearing "felt" - I thought mine went terribly but I actually won! The timeline is usually 2-3 weeks like others mentioned. Hang in there and try to stay positive - documented safety concerns are one of the strongest reasons for a successful voluntary quit appeal.
This is so helpful, thank you! I've been continuing to file my weekly claims like you suggested, but I wasn't sure if that was the right thing to do. It's reassuring to hear from someone who went through this recently and had a positive outcome. I keep second-guessing whether I had enough documentation, but I do have a pretty solid paper trail of the safety issues I reported. How long did it take to get your back payments after you won?
I'm going through something similar right now - had my appeal hearing two weeks ago and still waiting for the decision! The anxiety is killing me. From what I've read here and researched online, it sounds like you have a really solid case with all that documentation about safety concerns. That's exactly the kind of evidence that shows "good cause" for leaving. One thing that's helped me manage the stress is setting up notifications in my eServices account so I get an alert as soon as anything changes. Also, I started keeping a little journal of all the timeline info people have shared here - helps me feel more in control when I can see the typical patterns. Really hoping you get good news soon! The fact that you took the time to document everything and report it through proper channels before leaving shows you were acting reasonably. Keep us posted on what happens!
I'm in almost the exact same situation! Had my hearing 10 days ago and checking eServices obsessively every day. The waiting is absolutely brutal - I can't focus on anything else. Your idea about keeping a journal is actually really smart, I might start doing that too. It's so reassuring to hear from people who have been through this process and know what to expect. Fingers crossed we both get positive decisions soon! The documentation really does seem to be the key factor from everything I'm reading here.
I went through something very similar a few months ago and was absolutely panicking! Like others have said, the key is calling ESD as soon as possible to correct it. When I finally got through (took me about 4 tries over 2 days), the agent was actually really understanding and said they see this mistake constantly. One thing that helped me was having my work schedule/timesheet ready when I called, so I could give them the exact dates and hours. They were able to make the correction on the spot and it didn't affect my benefits since I was still under the threshold. For stopping your claim when you go back to work full-time, you really can just stop filing - no formal closure needed. Your claim will automatically go inactive after 4 weeks of not claiming, but it stays open for the full year in case your employment situation changes. Congrats on the new job and don't stress too much about this - you're doing the right thing by fixing it proactively!
Thanks for sharing your experience! It's really comforting to hear from someone who went through the exact same thing. I'm definitely going to have all my paperwork ready before I call - that's a great tip. It sounds like ESD agents are pretty used to dealing with this kind of mistake, which makes me feel a lot better about the whole situation. I was worried they'd think I was trying to game the system or something, but it sounds like they can tell the difference between honest mistakes and intentional fraud. Really appreciate you taking the time to share the details of your experience!
I just wanted to add my experience since I went through this exact same thing about 6 months ago! I was reporting income based on when I got paid instead of when I worked, and I was terrified when I realized my mistake. What really helped me was calling first thing in the morning (around 8:05 AM) right when the lines opened - I got through on my second try that way instead of calling during peak hours. The agent was super helpful and explained that this is literally one of the most common mistakes they see, especially for people new to unemployment. She fixed my previous weeks on the spot and even explained the rule more clearly: you report hours for the Sunday-Saturday week you actually performed the work, regardless of when the paycheck arrives. Simple once you know it, but definitely confusing at first! The whole call took maybe 15 minutes and saved me weeks of stress. Definitely call ASAP though - they told me that self-reporting mistakes early shows good faith and makes the whole process much smoother.
I went through this exact situation about 6 months ago with a temp agency placement that lasted 5 months. The agency kept giving me the runaround about "maybe next week" for new assignments, so I finally just filed for unemployment benefits. Best decision I made! Got approved within about 2 weeks and have been collecting ever since while looking for permanent work. The key things that helped me were: 1) Filing immediately after my assignment ended rather than waiting around, 2) Being very clear on the application that my "assignment was completed" rather than saying I quit or was fired, and 3) Keeping all my paperwork from the temp agency just in case. Don't let anyone make you feel guilty about filing - you worked, you paid taxes, and you're entitled to these benefits just like anyone else whose job ended. The temporary nature of the work doesn't disqualify you at all in Washington state.
This is really reassuring to read! I'm in almost the same boat - my temp assignment just ended after 6 months and the agency is being vague about future opportunities. Your point about filing immediately rather than waiting around really hits home. I keep second-guessing myself about whether I should file, but hearing from someone who went through the exact same process and got approved makes me feel much more confident. I especially appreciate the tip about being specific with the separation reason - "assignment was completed" sounds much clearer than just saying "job ended." Thanks for sharing your experience and for the reminder that we earned these benefits!
I've been working temp assignments through agencies for about 3 years now and have filed for unemployment between assignments several times - never had a single issue! The process is exactly the same as if you were laid off from a regular job. My advice: file immediately when your assignment ends (don't wait for the agency to "maybe" find you something), be clear that your assignment was completed rather than saying you quit, and keep all your documentation from the temp agency. Washington state treats temp work the same as any other employment for UI purposes. You paid into the system through your paychecks, so you've absolutely earned these benefits. Don't let anyone make you feel like temporary work somehow doesn't "count" - it definitely does!
This is incredibly helpful! As someone new to temp work, I was really worried about whether filing for unemployment would somehow be "wrong" or if there would be complications because the job was temporary. Your experience over 3 years really puts things in perspective - it sounds like this is a normal part of how temp work functions. I especially appreciate you emphasizing that we earned these benefits through our paychecks. Sometimes it's easy to forget that we've been paying into the system just like everyone else. Your advice about filing immediately and being clear about the separation reason is going to be really useful when I submit my application. Thanks for taking the time to share your experience!
Oscar Murphy
I went through a similar appeal process about 6 months ago and won my case. One thing that really helped me was organizing all my documents in chronological order - termination letter, any HR communications, performance reviews, etc. The judge appreciated having everything laid out clearly. Also, practice explaining your situation out loud beforehand so you're not stumbling over words during the hearing. The judges are used to dealing with nervous people, but being prepared definitely helps your case. The whole process took about 8 weeks for me from filing to decision, but it was worth the wait when I got my back pay.
0 coins
Yara Khoury
•That's really helpful about organizing documents chronologically! I hadn't thought about that but it makes total sense. Did you have any trouble getting your termination paperwork from your employer? I'm worried they might not cooperate since they're probably the ones who contested my claim in the first place.
0 coins
Lincoln Ramiro
•You should be able to get copies of your termination paperwork through HR even if they contested your claim. It's your employment record and they're legally required to provide it. If they give you trouble, you can also request it through the Department of Labor or mention during your appeal hearing that your former employer refused to provide documentation. That actually looks bad for them. I'd suggest calling HR and asking politely first - sometimes they'll just email you copies without any hassle.
0 coins
Emily Thompson
I'm going through the same situation right now - got denied and just filed my appeal last week. Reading through everyone's experiences here is really reassuring. One question I have is about the timing - if I file my weekly claims during the appeal process and end up losing, do I have to worry about owing money back? I'm confused about what happens if you're receiving benefits during an appeal versus appealing an initial denial. Also, has anyone had success appealing a "job abandonment" determination? That's what they're claiming in my case even though I had to leave due to unsafe working conditions.
0 coins