
Ask the community...
I'm desperate for help with my NY unemployment situation. I filed a claim in November 2024 but have only received ONE WEEK of payments since then!!! Apparently there's some fraud flag on my account, but I've been trying to resolve this for FIVE MONTHS now. Every time I call NYSDOL, they give me the runaround and refuse to transfer me to a level III claims specialist. They just keep saying they'll "escalate" my case, but nothing happens. I've verified my identity through ID.me TWICE with video conferences. I've uploaded the confirmation emails multiple times to the portal. I even got a message through the online portal telling me to "contact DOL immediately for intake" - but when I called yesterday, the rep said that wasn't enough reason to transfer me to a specialist! I'm absolutely at my wits end. Does anyone know what else I can do? I KNOW this is a valid claim, and I'm pretty sure it's illegal for them to make me start a new claim when I've been waiting all these months for the payments I'm entitled to from my original claim. Any advice would be greatly appreciated!
Update: I tried calling again this morning using the specific language about Section 597.4 that was suggested, and it actually got me transferred to someone higher up! They still couldn't fully resolve my case on the spot, but they confirmed my ID verification is showing up in their system and said they're expediting my case review. They gave me a direct callback number and said I should hear something within 5-7 business days. Fingers crossed this actually leads to something! Thank you all for your suggestions.
That's great progress! Make sure to document the name of who you spoke with, their ID number if provided, the time of the call, and exactly what they promised. If you don't hear back in 7 business days, call that direct number and reference all these details. Keep us updated!
20h
Glad you're making progress! Just a heads up that those callback promises don't always happen. If you don't hear back in 7 business days, that's when services like Claimyr can really help because you can get back to a specialist directly instead of starting the whole process over.
20h
anybody else think its crazy that in 2025 we still have to jump through all these hoops just to get our benefits?? the whole system needs to be completely redone!!
AGREED!!!! And they wonder why people get so frustrated. Its like they WANT us to give up and stop claiming what we're entitled to. I bet they save millions by making the process so difficult that people just give up.
20h
I'm at my wits' end trying to verify my identity for my NY unemployment claim. I've attempted the ID.me verification process 5 times now with no success. The facial recognition keeps failing or timing out, and when I tried uploading documents, they said my address doesn't match (even though it does!). Has anyone been able to bypass ID.me and verify their identity by speaking with an actual NYSDOL agent on the phone? I've heard people mention this is possible but can't find solid info on how to do it. My benefits are on hold until this is resolved and I'm getting desperate.
my brother had this problem and he went to the actual unemployment office in person!! they helped him there and he didnt need to do id.me at all
That's interesting! Do you know which office he went to? I didn't even think about going in person.
19h
Just a correction - NYSDOL Career Centers can provide limited assistance, but most don't handle identity verification for unemployment claims directly. Some locations may help you connect virtually with a claims specialist, but it's not guaranteed at all locations. Always call ahead to confirm what services are available at your local office before making the trip.
19h
After seeing your post, I wanted to follow up. Were you able to get through to anyone? I know how stressful this waiting game can be.
Yes! I actually used that Claimyr service you mentioned and got a callback in about 30 minutes! The agent was super helpful and verified my identity right over the phone. Had to answer a bunch of questions about my work history and some personal info that matched my tax records. She said my payments should start processing within 3-5 business days. SUCH a relief after weeks of ID.me hell. Thanks for the suggestion!
19h
did u check ur payment history on the website? sometimes the money gets released but they dont send u a text or email
Just checked again - still says pending :( Will keep refreshing though!
19h
UPDATE: My payments just hit my account! Took exactly 2 days and 4 hours from when the block was removed. All 4 weeks came at once. So relieved right now!
Excellent news! Glad to hear it was processed quickly. This is consistent with the current timeframes we're seeing for accounts that have previously received payments.
19h
awesome!! told u it would be quick! 🙌
19h
I'm seriously about to lose it with this ID.me verification nightmare. Been trying since I opened a new claim in August 2025 and STILL haven't received any of my back unemployment payments. When I call unemployment, they tell me it's ID.me's fault and I need to complete verification with them. So I emailed ID.me support and guess what? They're saying everything is fine on their end and that it's unemployment's system that's the problem! I'm being ping-ponged between these two and meanwhile haven't seen a penny for months. Has anyone else dealt with this ridiculous ID.me verification loop? How did you finally get it resolved?
After using Claimyr to reach an agent, make sure to specifically request they check the "identity verification override" flag in your account. Many agents don't know this exists or don't think to check it. Also ask them to document in your case notes that ID.me verification is complete but not syncing properly, to help if you need to call again.
Thank you all for the helpful advice! Just wanted to update - I finally got this resolved! I used Claimyr to get through to someone at NYSDOL (took about 15 mins instead of the endless busy signals I was getting before). The agent I spoke with immediately found the problem - there was some kind of flag on my account that was preventing the ID.me verification from being accepted, even though it was complete. She removed the flag, manually verified my identity in their system, and my claim started processing right away. Three days later all my backpay hit my account! Such a relief after months of stress and being given the runaround.
congrats!! nothing better than finally seeing that money hit ur account after dealing with their bs for months lol. glad u got it fixed!
19h
The whole thing is RIDICULOUS!! We shouldn't have to jump through all these hoops to get benefits we paid into with our taxes!!! All this paperwork and waiting and appealing while bills are piling up. The system is designed to make us give up!!!
preach! i waited 12 weeks for my first payment last year after getting denied twice for stupid reasons
19h
I want to thank everyone for the amazing advice. I've decided to do the following: 1. Create a detailed timeline of my job search from November to January 2. Gather all my job application confirmations and interview emails 3. Write a clear statement explaining why I misunderstood when to apply 4. Request a hearing specifically in my appeal 5. Try calling again tomorrow to speak with a representative 6. If I can't get through after a couple more tries, I'll check out that Claimyr service I'll update this thread once I have news about my appeal. Fingers crossed I can get those backdated benefits!
That sounds like a solid plan! One last tip: when writing your statement, focus on facts rather than emotions. Include dates, specific actions you took, and concrete examples. Good luck, and yes, please update us on how it goes!
19h
Good luck! Your plan sounds really thorough. The timeline especially helped in my case.
19h
happened to my cousin too last week. they told her 7 days but it showed up in 5! so maybe ull get lucky
oh and btw make sure u activate the card the SECOND u get it. cause the activation line sometimes has long wait times too. this whole system is just waiting and more waiting lol
Thanks for the heads up! I'll definitely activate it right away. This waiting game is driving me crazy!
19h
I was in a similar situation last year - part-time work while in school. What I learned is that in NY, you need to be ready, willing, and able to work full-time to qualify for unemployment. If your school schedule restricts your availability too much, you might get denied. The agent I spoke with said they look at whether school would prevent you from accepting full-time work if it was offered. So be prepared to explain how you could manage both if needed.
That's exactly what I was wondering about! My classes are all in the evening, so I'm available during normal business hours. Sounds like I should mention that specifically when I call or file. Thanks for sharing your experience!
19h
After you get answers to your questions and decide to file, make sure you apply as soon as possible. Benefits aren't backdated to when you became unemployed - they start from when you file your claim. I waited two weeks trying to get all my questions answered first, and essentially lost two weeks of potential benefits because of it.
Oh wow, I didn't realize that. I'll definitely keep that in mind and not delay filing once I figure out if I qualify. Thanks for the heads up!
19h
Thank you everyone for the helpful advice! I'm going to start reporting my net income going forward, and I'm going to try to contact NYSDOL about getting an adjustment for the past 8 weeks where I overstated my income. I'll keep better records of all my expenses too.
Good luck with the adjustment! If you have trouble getting through on the phone, seriously consider using Claimyr. It saved me hours of frustration when I needed to fix an issue with my claim. Trying to call NYSDOL directly is practically impossible these days.
19h
i know someone who got in huge trouble for reporting wrong. they made him pay back like $8000! but that was cuz he didnt report ANY income not cuz he reported wrong type
That's an important distinction. The OP has been OVER-reporting income (reporting gross instead of net), which means they've been receiving LESS in benefits than they were entitled to. This is very different from under-reporting or not reporting income at all, which can indeed lead to overpayment notices and penalties.
19h
WAIT WAIT WAIT... So does this mean if I work 2 hours per day, 5 days a week (10 hours total), I lose 250% of my benefit? But if I work 10 hours in just 2 days (5 hours each day), I only lose 200%??? That makes NO sense! Why does it matter HOW the hours are distributed??
You've highlighted one of the quirks in NY's system. Yes, how you distribute your hours can affect your benefit amount. Each day is calculated separately with a maximum reduction of 100% per day. So working 10 hours across 5 days (2 hours daily) would reduce your benefit by 250%, while working the same 10 hours across just 2 days would reduce it by 200%. This is why many part-time workers try to consolidate their hours into fewer days if their employer allows it.
19h
That is INSANE. No wonder everyone is so confused! Thank you for explaining... I'm gonna see if my boss will let me work fewer days with more hours each day!
19h
Thank you all so much for the help! I think I understand now - I'll definitely answer YES to returning to work, and I'll track my hours meticulously. Since I'll be working 4 hours each day, 5 days a week, it sounds like I probably won't get any UI benefits, which is disappointing but at least I know what to expect. I'll keep certifying every week anyway to keep my claim active while I look for full-time work. Really appreciate all the explanations!
You're welcome! One last tip: even though you may not receive benefits while working those hours, continuing to certify each week is crucial. If your part-time job ends or your hours are reduced, you won't have to start a new claim. Good luck with the job search!
19h
Reginald Blackwell
Is anyone else having trouble certifying this week too? I wonder if it's related to the same maintenance issue. I keep getting an error message when I try to submit my weekly certification.
0 coins
Statiia Aarssizan
The certification system should be working normally. The maintenance is only affecting the payment history display. If you're getting an error during certification, you should contact NYSDOL directly as that's a different issue.
0 coins
20h
Write a comment...
Gabriel Ruiz
UPDATE: The payment history is back up this morning! Everything looks normal now and I can see all my past payments. Thanks everyone for your help!
0 coins
Misterclamation Skyblue
Confirmed - mine's working too now. Glad it was just temporary!
0 coins
20h
Write a comment...