
Ask the community...
One more consideration for your planning: If you claim your own benefit early and later become eligible for survivor benefits, you would receive your own reduced benefit plus the difference between that amount and the survivor benefit you're eligible for (potentially with age reductions). This is called the "excess survivor benefit." For example (simplified numbers): - Your reduced age 62 benefit: $1,650 - Full survivor benefit at your FRA: $2,450 - If you take your benefit at 62 and your wife passes away when you're 63, you'd receive your $1,650 plus some portion of the $800 difference, depending on reduction factors. This is why getting a personalized calculation from SSA is so important - the actual math gets complicated.
don't forget that if you're collecting at 62 your already taking a big reduction on your own benefit. like 30% less than your FRA amount. so waiting til FRA for survivors makes sense if you can
This is correct. Claiming retirement at 62 results in a permanent reduction of about 30% from your FRA benefit amount. Survivor benefits are reduced by a different formula - approximately 28.5% if claimed at age 60, and decreasing as you approach FRA. By FRA, there's no reduction to survivor benefits. This creates potential strategies like claiming one benefit type early and switching to the other later.
Based on what you've shared, I recommend applying for benefits to start in July. Here's why: 1. You'll exceed the 2025 earnings limit by June, which would mean SSA would withhold some of your benefits anyway 2. The withholding could get complicated and potentially cause overpayment issues later 3. A one-month gap is manageable with some planning (vacation payout, small retirement account distribution, or savings) I'd suggest applying in March (4 months before) to ensure everything is processed in time. Also, remember that your first payment for July benefits would arrive in August, likely on the 3rd Wednesday based on your July 15th birthday.
One more thing to consider - if you're enrolling in Medicare at the same time, that starts the first day of your birthday month (July). So if you apply for both SS and Medicare together in March, your Medicare will begin July 1 regardless of when your SS benefits start. Just something to keep in mind for your overall retirement transition planning.
hey op somthing nobody said yet - if ur ex ever remarried then she CANT get benefits from ur record anymore. just making sure u know that part
I just went thru this with my sister who is on SSI!! She was able to switch to ex-spouse benefits when her ex retired and she gets like $1300 now instead of the $900ish from SSI. AND she can actually have a savings account now without losing benefits!!! It made a HUGE difference for her quality of life!!
Is your son getting SSI too?? If his condition is that severe he might qualify for childhood disability. My nephew has severe allergies and gets both survivor benefits AND SSI. The SSI helps pay for his special medical foods that insurance won't cover!!
This is partially correct but needs clarification. Yes, a child can potentially receive both survivor benefits and SSI, but the survivor benefits count as unearned income for SSI purposes and will reduce the SSI payment dollar-for-dollar (after a small exclusion). For many children, survivor benefits exceed the maximum SSI payment, making them ineligible for SSI unless their medical expenses are extremely high. However, in some states, qualifying for even $1 of SSI automatically qualifies the child for Medicaid, which could be valuable for medical coverage.
One thing nobody mentioned - when you apply for your mother's benefit, bring ALL the documentation about your son's condition with you! The 504 plan, doctor letters, hospital records, EVERYTHING. I made the mistake of not bringing my daughter's medical records and they gave me a hard time about proving she needed special care. They kept saying "but she gets survivor benefits already" like that was enough. You need to be super clear that you're applying for the mother's benefit based on having his father's child in your care, not applying for anything related to disability.
While bringing documentation is always good, there's actually no requirement to prove the child needs special care to qualify for mother's/father's benefits. The only requirements are that you're the surviving spouse caring for the deceased worker's child who is under 16 and receiving benefits. The child's medical condition doesn't affect eligibility for the mother's/father's benefit at all.
Update: I called my local office this morning and finally got through after about 30 minutes. They confirmed they DO have a secure drop box but recommended certified mail instead for forms like the W-4V. Apparently they process drop box items within 5 business days but can't guarantee tracking within their system. I'm going to send it certified mail tomorrow just to be safe. Thanks everyone for your advice!
Good choice going with certified mail! One other quick tip - after about 2 weeks, you can check your MySocialSecurity account online. Go to the Message Center and sometimes (though not always) there will be a confirmation that your withholding request was processed. Just another way to verify without having to call them again.
wait did u say retirement benfit or SSDI? cause theres diffrnt rules for disability tax stuff i think
I'm getting regular retirement benefits (just turned 66), not SSDI. But good point - I imagine there might be different considerations for disability benefits.
You're right that there are some differences, but the W-4V form is actually used for both retirement and disability benefits. The withholding percentages and submission process are the same. The main difference is that some SSDI recipients may not have enough total income to owe federal taxes, while most retirement benefit recipients will have other income sources that make their benefits taxable.
Thanks everyone for the advice! I'm going to gather all our documents and apply this week. I'll try calling again first to set up an appointment, but if I can't get through, I'll try that Claimyr service someone mentioned. I'll update once I hear back from SSA about my application!
I've been wrestling with this same decision. What complicates things for me is the earnings test while working. I plan to keep working part-time until 65, and if I claim at 62, I'll lose some benefits due to the earnings limit ($22,320 for 2025). However, once I reach FRA, SSA will adjust my benefit amount to account for months where benefits were withheld. Another factor to consider is that taking benefits at 62 might mean you pay taxes on Social Security for more years if you're still working with substantial income. Up to 85% of benefits can be taxable depending on your combined income. Anyone know if the recalculation at FRA for benefits withheld due to the earnings test fully makes up for the early claiming reduction?
The recalculation at FRA doesn't eliminate the early claiming reduction entirely. What happens is that SSA will adjust your benefit to give you credit for the months your benefits were completely withheld due to the earnings test. For example, if you claimed at 62 but had 12 months of benefits completely withheld due to earnings, at FRA they would recalculate as if you had claimed at 63 instead of 62. So you'd get a slightly higher percentage, but still less than your full FRA amount.
Thanks everyone for the information! Based on your advice, I'm thinking more carefully about this decision. One more question - does anyone know if delaying affects COLA increases? Like if I take reduced benefits now, do I also get reduced COLA adjustments going forward?
COLA increases are percentage-based, so they apply proportionally to whatever your benefit amount is. So yes, if you take reduced benefits at 62, your COLA increases will be calculated on that smaller amount. For example, with a 3% COLA, someone receiving $1,000 would get a $30 increase, while someone receiving $1,400 would get a $42 increase. This compounds over time, making the gap between early and delayed claiming grow larger each year with inflation.
The whole system is designed around traditional marriage and doesn't account for the MANY different types of committed relationships people have. I've been fighting this battle for YEARS with various government agencies. Even in states with domestic partnership registries, the federal government (including SSA) doesn't recognize them for benefit purposes. It's DISCRIMINATION, plain and simple!!!
You're right that Social Security rules were designed around traditional marriage models. However, it's worth noting that these rules have evolved somewhat - particularly after the Obergefell decision legalized same-sex marriage nationwide. SSA now has policies to provide benefits in some cases where couples couldn't legally marry previously. But for opposite-sex couples who chose not to marry, the options remain limited under current law.
My sister works for SSA and she says they get these questions all the time but their hands are tied by the law. Congress would need to change it to include domestic partners. Don't count on that happening anytime soon though...
Your sister is correct. Social Security is bound by Title II of the Social Security Act, which specifically defines who qualifies as a spouse or surviving spouse. The agency doesn't have authority to expand these definitions without Congressional action. Some states have pushed for changes, but federal benefit programs still generally require legal marriage.
i just remembered something - when this happened to me they said something about only making these adjustments if the new calculation would increase ur benefit by at least a certain $ amount. think it had to make a difference of at least $1 or something? somebody correct me if i'm wrong
One tip nobody's mentioned: when you do contact SSA about this, ask for both the recomputation AND a PEBES (Pre-Entitlement Benefit Earnings Statement). This will show you exactly which years of earnings they're using in your calculation. Super helpful for understanding if they've included all your work years properly!
Amara Eze
Have you looked into whether your school district offers a 457(b) deferred compensation plan? Many public employees affected by WEP focus on maximizing their tax-advantaged savings through these plans to make up for the reduced Social Security benefits. It might be a better use of your time than the retail job if the math doesn't work out favorably.
0 coins
Liam McGuire
•We do have a 457(b) plan! I'm contributing about 8% of my salary to it now, but maybe I should increase that instead of keeping the weekend job. That's something to think about.
0 coins
Giovanni Greco
my friend said there's a calculator on the SSA website specifically for WEP situations, did anyone here use it? was it accurate?
0 coins
Fatima Al-Farsi
•Yes, there is a WEP calculator on the SSA website. It's reasonably accurate if you input all your information correctly. However, for a truly accurate calculation, speaking directly with SSA is still the best option since they have access to your complete earnings record and can account for all the nuances of your situation.
0 coins