< Back to Texas Unemployment

TWC appeal hearing for termination due to 'call avoidance' - worth fighting?

I need some advice about my TWC appeal. I was let go from my job shortly after I relocated. At first, they didn't give a clear reason, but when I filed for unemployment, my employer claimed I was terminated for 'call avoidance' on two days I was actually absent from work (I had called in sick both days following company policy). I filed an appeal immediately and just got my hearing date scheduled for March 16th, 2025. Now I'm wondering if it's even worth going through with the appeal. Has anyone dealt with something similar? The hearing seems intimidating, and I'm not sure if I can win against my former employer. They're a large call center company and probably have HR people who handle these hearings all the time. I've been job searching for 6 weeks with no luck, and if I don't get unemployment approved, I don't know how I'll pay rent next month. Should I just give up on the appeal and focus 100% on finding any job I can? Or do I have a chance at winning this appeal?

Yara Sayegh

•

DO NOT give up on your appeal!! Especially if you followed company policy for calling in sick. The company is trying to categorize your absences as 'misconduct' to avoid paying unemployment, but that's not how it works. If you had approved absences, that's not misconduct. I was in a similar situation last year - my company tried claiming I was terminated for 'excessive absences' but I had doctor's notes for all of them. I won my appeal because I could prove I followed company policy. Make sure you have any documentation showing you called in sick according to policy (text messages, emails, call logs, etc). Also gather your employee handbook if you have it, especially the section about attendance policy. The TWC hearing officer will want to see evidence that you followed proper procedures.

0 coins

Connor Murphy

•

Thank you for the encouragement! I do have text messages showing I notified my supervisor both days, plus my doctor can verify I was sick. Do you think I need to have my doctor on the call too? The appeal notice mentioned I can have witnesses.

0 coins

NebulaNova

•

OMG the exact same thing happened to me!!! My boss tried to say I was avoiding calls when I actually had covid!! TWC is so rigged against employees sometimes it makes me FURIOUS. The whole system is designed to protect these big companies. My friend said appeals are almost impossible to win and companies always have lawyers. Is that true? I ended up just finding another job before my appeal date because I was so stressed about it. But now I wonder if I should have fought it.

0 coins

Yara Sayegh

•

That's actually not true at all. TWC appeal hearings are won by employees quite often, especially in cases like this where the employer is mischaracterizing absences as misconduct. Companies don't usually bring lawyers to TWC hearings - they typically just have an HR rep or manager participate. It's unfortunate you gave up on your appeal. For anyone reading this: ALWAYS go through with your appeal if you believe you were terminated unfairly. The worst that happens is you get the same denial.

0 coins

just make sure u show up for the hearing on time. my cousin missed his bcuz he wrote down the wrong time and TWC automatically ruled against him. cant appeal after that

0 coins

Paolo Conti

•

Definitely proceed with the appeal hearing. For a 'misconduct' disqualification to stick, your employer needs to prove you willfully disregarded their interests. Being absent with proper notification according to company policy is NOT misconduct. Prepare for your hearing by: 1. Gathering all documentation showing you properly called in (texts, emails, call logs) 2. Writing down a timeline of events 3. Reviewing your company's attendance policy 4. Practicing your explanation of events calmly and clearly Be aware the hearing will be recorded and conducted by phone. The hearing officer will swear you in, then usually let the employer speak first since they have the burden of proof in misconduct cases. Listen carefully and don't interrupt. When it's your turn, calmly explain your side. Good luck! Based on what you've described, you have a strong case.

0 coins

Connor Murphy

•

This is incredibly helpful - thank you! One more question: the hearing notice says it could last up to 45 minutes. Do they really take that long? I'm trying to plan my day around it.

0 coins

Amina Diallo

•

I had almost the exact situation last year. Call center job, they claimed I was avoiding calls when I was legitimately out sick with documentation. My hearing lasted about 30 minutes and I won! One tip - try calling TWC before your hearing to discuss your claim and get any specific advice. I spent THREE DAYS trying to reach someone by constantly redialing. Finally found Claimyr.com which got me through to a TWC agent in about 20 minutes. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/V-IMvH88P1U?si=kNxmh025COIlIzKh The agent I spoke with gave me specific advice on what documentation to have ready and how to present my case. Totally worth it since I ended up getting almost $12,000 in benefits over the next few months while job searching.

0 coins

Oliver Schulz

•

does that service actually work? I've been trying to reach TWC for a week about my claim status and can't get through. getting desperate!!!

0 coins

Amina Diallo

•

Yes, it worked for me and several people I know. Instead of spending days redialing TWC's number, I got through in about 20 minutes. The TWC agent I spoke with reviewed my case details and gave me specific advice for my hearing.

0 coins

im confused why would your employer say u did call avoidance when u wernt even at work? that doesnt even make sense. sounds like there lying to TWC which is illegal btw

0 coins

Connor Murphy

•

I think they're just trying to find any reason to deny my unemployment. My supervisor and I never got along well, and then when I had to relocate (which they approved initially), things got worse. Maybe they're confusing the dates or something? But I definitely wasn't at work those days to avoid any calls.

0 coins

Paolo Conti

•

This is actually a common tactic. Employers sometimes hope the employee won't appeal, or they try to use confusing terminology to make legitimate absences sound like misconduct. The burden of proof is on them though, so if you can show you followed proper call-out procedures, you should win your appeal.

0 coins

When i had my appeal hearing last month my former employer didn't even bother showing up! The hearing officer asked me a few questions and then ruled in my favor immediately. So just be prepared but know they might not even contest it when it comes down to it.

0 coins

NebulaNova

•

QUESTION: Does anyone know if you can get retroactive payments after winning an appeal? Like if the OP wins, will they get all the weeks paid from when they first applied? Asking for myself too actually lol

0 coins

Yara Sayegh

•

Yes! If you win your appeal, TWC will pay you for all eligible weeks from when you first started filing payment requests. That's why it's important to keep submitting your payment requests every two weeks even while your appeal is pending. If you don't keep requesting payments, you might not get paid for those weeks even if you win your appeal.

0 coins

Connor Murphy

•

Update: I really appreciate all the advice! I've decided to definitely go through with the appeal and have started gathering my evidence. I found text messages proving I called in sick both days, and I'm going to ask my doctor for documentation too. I feel much more confident now! Should I mention during the hearing that I think my supervisor had it out for me after I relocated? Or should I stick strictly to the facts about my absences?

0 coins

Paolo Conti

•

Stick mainly to the facts about following proper call-out procedures. Your personal conflicts with the supervisor aren't as relevant as proving you didn't commit misconduct as defined by TWC rules. If directly asked why you think they classified it as call avoidance, you can briefly mention the deteriorating relationship after relocation, but keep the focus on proving you followed policy for your absences.

0 coins

TaxRefund AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
6,589 users helped today