


Ask the community...
ugh this system is so stressful!!! I'm dealing with something similar and I keep panicking that they're going to deny me. Two years at a job should count for something right?? Did they give you any severance or anything when they let you go?
I went through this exact same situation about 6 months ago - fired for "performance issues" after 18 months at a marketing firm. NYS Department of Labor actually approved my claim after about 4 weeks. The key thing that helped me was keeping all my employment records and being able to show I never had any disciplinary actions or formal performance improvement plans. When they called for the phone interview, I just explained honestly that I struggled to meet certain metrics but was never given coaching or warnings. My former employer didn't even contest it. Don't give up hope - performance terminations are way more common than people think and most get approved eventually.
This is so encouraging to hear! I'm in almost the exact same boat - accounting job, about 2 years, and no formal warnings either. It's reassuring to know that NYS Department of Labor actually looks at whether you had proper documentation and coaching opportunities. Did you have to provide any specific documentation during your interview, or was it mostly just explaining your side of what happened?
I've been dealing with NYS Department of Labor for months and their payment timing is so inconsistent! Sometimes I get paid the day after the pay date, sometimes it takes three days. The whole system is a mess honestly.
I had similar issues trying to get clear answers about payment timing from NYS Department of Labor directly. Spent hours on hold trying to reach someone. Actually found this service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that helps you get through to unemployment agents faster. They have a video demo at https://youtu.be/qyftW-mnTNI that shows how it works. Might be worth checking out if you need to talk to someone about payment issues.
I'm also new to unemployment and was wondering the same thing! From what I've experienced so far, the benefit pay date is definitely when they process it on their end, not when you actually get it. I've noticed that if the pay date falls on a weekend, it usually gets pushed to the next business day. One thing that helped me was setting up text alerts through my bank so I know right away when the deposit hits. Also make sure your direct deposit info is correct in your account - I had a friend who had delays because there was a typo in their routing number.
I'm going through the exact same nightmare right now! Lost my wallet in a recent move and they're asking for all these documents I don't have. Reading through these comments is giving me hope though - sounds like they'll accept way more alternatives than they make it seem. I found my old work badge that has my photo and I think I can get my landlord to email me something official with my address. For SSN I'm going to try requesting my tax transcript from the IRS website like someone mentioned. The key seems to be uploading SOMETHING and then calling to explain (even if you have to use one of those callback services people keep mentioning). Thanks everyone for sharing your experiences - this thread is more helpful than anything on the official DOL website!
Welcome to the club nobody wants to be in! 😅 It's crazy how many of us are dealing with the exact same situation. Your plan sounds solid - work badge for photo ID, landlord letter for address, and IRS transcript for SSN should definitely work. I went through this mess a few months ago and the biggest thing I learned is that the online portal is basically useless. It'll reject perfectly valid documents for no reason. But once you get a human on the phone who can actually look at your situation, they're usually pretty reasonable about accepting alternative docs. Good luck with everything - you've got this! 💪
I'm dealing with this exact situation right now too! Just got the verification email yesterday and panicking because I also lost my wallet recently. Reading through all these responses is so helpful - I had no idea they would accept things like expired passports or work IDs with photos. I think I can piece together what I need: I have an old student ID with my photo, my lease agreement for address proof, and I'm going to try downloading that IRS tax transcript someone mentioned for my SSN. It's reassuring to know so many people have gotten through this with creative document combinations. Thanks to everyone sharing their experiences - this community is a lifesaver when the official system feels impossible to navigate!
You're totally on the right track! Student ID + lease + tax transcript should definitely work. I went through this same mess about 6 months ago and that exact combo got me approved. The IRS tax transcript is clutch because it's an official government document with your full SSN on it. Just make sure when you upload everything that the photos are super clear - I had to resubmit twice because they said my pics were too blurry. And definitely try to call them after you upload to explain your situation, even if you have to use one of those callback services people keep mentioning. The human agents are way more understanding than the automated system. You got this! 🙏
Pro tip: if you use the card for grocery shopping, always choose 'credit' instead of 'debit' when they ask. Some stores charge extra fees for debit transactions but credit is usually free. Also works at gas stations.
Just want to add that Walmart Money Centers usually have free ATM access for KeyBank unemployment cards too. I've been using the one near me for months with no fees. Also, if you're ever in a pinch and need cash fast, some banks will let you do a counter withdrawal with ID even if you're not their customer - they might charge like $5-10 but it's better than those crazy bodega ATM fees you mentioned. And yes, online purchases work fine, I pay all my bills online with mine.
Thanks for mentioning Walmart Money Centers! I had no idea they were free for these cards. There's actually a Walmart SuperCenter about 10 minutes from my apartment so that could be really convenient. Quick question - do I need to go to the actual Money Center counter or can I just use any ATM inside Walmart? I want to make sure I don't accidentally use a fee-charging machine.
Yuki Yamamoto
I went through the exact same thing a few months ago! The "open" status had me confused too because I wasn't sure if it meant they were still reviewing my claim or if I was approved. But like others have said, "open" is actually the status you want - it means your claim is active and approved. The 2-3 week wait for first payment is standard, even though it feels like forever when you're stressed about bills. I got my first payment on day 16 after filing. Just keep doing your weekly certifications religiously and you should see that first deposit soon. Hang in there!
0 coins
Drew Hathaway
•Thanks for sharing your timeline! Day 16 gives me hope since I'm on day 14 right now. It's reassuring to hear from someone who went through the exact same confusion and waiting period. The stress is real when rent is due, but knowing others made it through helps a lot.
0 coins
Jamal Carter
I can definitely relate to this anxiety - I went through the same thing earlier this year! "Open" status is exactly what you want to see, it means your claim has been processed and approved. The 2 week wait you're experiencing is totally normal, though I know it doesn't make the stress any easier. My first payment came through at the 18-day mark. One thing that helped me was setting up text alerts through the NY.gov website so I'd get notified as soon as there was any update. Also, if you haven't already, make sure you're keeping track of your work search activities in writing - even though payments are delayed, the requirements still apply from day one. You're doing everything right by keeping up with the weekly certifications!
0 coins
KylieRose
•This is such great advice, especially about setting up the text alerts! I didn't even know that was an option. I'm definitely going to do that right now since constantly checking the website is making me more anxious. And you're absolutely right about keeping track of work search activities - I've been doing them but haven't been writing them down properly. Thanks for the reminder that the clock started ticking from day one, not from when payments begin. Your 18-day timeline is really encouraging too since I'm still well within that window.
0 coins