


Ask the community...
I'm in a similar situation but haven't filed yet because I wasn't sure if the overpayment would block me. This thread is super helpful! One thing I'm wondering about - if they take 25-30% from each payment, does that percentage stay the same until the overpayment is paid off, or do they adjust it based on how much you still owe? Also, has anyone had luck setting up a separate repayment plan so they don't have to take as much from your weekly benefits?
Great questions! From what I understand, the percentage they deduct usually stays consistent until the overpayment is fully recovered - so if they're taking 25%, they'll keep taking 25% of each weekly payment until you've paid back the full amount. As for separate repayment plans, yes, you can sometimes arrange that! You'd need to contact them directly to set up a payment plan, which might allow for smaller deductions from your weekly benefits. It's definitely worth asking about when you file your claim or speak to an agent.
I'm dealing with a similar overpayment situation right now - about $1,900 from 2022 that I'm still paying back through weekly deductions. Just wanted to add that when you do file your new claim, make sure to report ANY income accurately, even small amounts from odd jobs or gig work. That's how a lot of these overpayments happen - people forget to report something or don't realize certain income counts. The good news is that once you're in the system paying back the overpayment, they usually don't hit you with penalties or interest as long as you keep filing honestly. Also, keep copies of everything - your weekly certifications, any correspondence from DOL, etc. It helps if there are ever questions later.
This is exactly the kind of detailed advice I needed - thank you! I'm definitely going to be super careful about reporting everything this time. You mentioned keeping copies of weekly certifications and correspondence - do you recommend keeping physical copies or are digital screenshots enough? Also, when you say "certain income counts" that people don't realize, what are some examples of income that might get overlooked? I want to make sure I don't accidentally create another overpayment situation down the road.
I just went through this exact same frustrating experience a few months ago! After trying everything mentioned here, what finally worked for me was a combination approach: First, I logged in on a desktop computer (not mobile - this is crucial!) and looked for a section called "Benefit Year Information" or "Claim Summary" - it's usually in the main navigation menu. From there, I found a link to "Download Forms" or "Request Documents" that wasn't visible on mobile. If you still can't find it, try going to your original confirmation emails from when you first applied - NY unemployment automatically sends a copy of your monetary determination as an attachment, but it might be buried in your spam folder. The subject line was something like "UI Benefits Approved - Monetary Determination." As a last resort, I ended up calling at exactly 8:01 AM on a Wednesday morning and actually got through after only 45 minutes on hold (try mid-week, not Monday or Friday). The rep was super helpful and emailed me the document immediately while I was still on the phone. Don't let your leasing office charge you late fees over this - most are understanding about unemployment documentation issues if you explain the situation and show you're actively trying to get it!
This is such great advice! I really appreciate you sharing the exact section names to look for - "Benefit Year Information" and "Claim Summary" are terms I haven't tried searching for yet. The tip about checking spam folders for the original determination email is brilliant too - I bet a lot of us overlook that. It's encouraging to hear you actually got through in 45 minutes on a Wednesday morning, that gives me hope! I'm going to try the desktop approach first with those specific section names, then check my spam folder, and if all else fails I'll try calling mid-week like you suggested. Thanks for the reminder about explaining the situation to the leasing office too - hopefully they'll be understanding since this seems to be such a common problem with NY unemployment! 🤞
I just went through this EXACT same nightmare two weeks ago! After spending literally 4 hours searching their terrible website, here's what finally worked: Log into your account on a DESKTOP computer (not mobile - super important!), then look for a section called "Online Services" in the main menu. From there, click "Unemployment Insurance Services" and then look for "View/Print Determination Letters" - it should be under a submenu called "Forms and Documents." The link is tiny and easy to miss, but that's where they moved all the award letters after their recent website update. If you still can't find it, try going to your email and searching for "monetary determination" - they usually send an automatic copy when you first get approved, but it might be in your spam folder. As a backup plan, most landlords will accept your payment history printout if you explain the situation - I had to do this for my lease renewal and they were totally understanding once I showed them I was actively trying to get the official document. Don't let them charge you late fees over NY unemployment's terrible website design! You've got this! 💪
I've been following this thread and wanted to share something that might help others in similar situations. When I had to file for unemployment after being at a job for only 10 weeks, I discovered that NYS DOL has a benefit calculator on their website that can give you an estimate of what you might qualify for based on your work history. It's not 100% accurate, but it helped me understand whether it was worth filing before I went through the whole process. Also, I found that keeping a simple spreadsheet with dates, hours worked, and pay amounts made filing much easier when I had to report my earnings history. The partial unemployment option that others mentioned here is really valuable - I wish more people knew about it because so many employers seem to be cutting hours instead of laying people off these days. Your two years of previous work experience should definitely put you in a good position if you need to file.
That's a great tip about the benefit calculator on the NYS DOL website! I didn't know that existed and it would definitely help ease some anxiety about whether filing is even worth it. The spreadsheet idea is brilliant too - I've been kind of haphazardly keeping track of my reduced hours but having it all organized in one place would make the process so much smoother. It's really eye-opening to learn about all these resources and options that aren't immediately obvious when you're just trying to figure out your rights. Thanks for sharing your experience - it's reassuring to know that even with just 10 weeks at your job, your previous work history was enough to qualify. This whole thread has been incredibly educational!
I went through a very similar situation about 8 months ago - got hired at a new job and within 5 weeks they started cutting everyone's hours due to "budget constraints." I was panicking because I thought you needed to work somewhere for at least 6 months to qualify for unemployment. Turns out I was completely wrong! Like others have mentioned, NYS looks at your entire work history during the base period, not just your current job. My previous job of 18 months was more than enough to meet the wage requirements. What really surprised me was learning about partial unemployment benefits - I had no idea you could collect while still working reduced hours. I ended up filing and it made a huge difference in keeping me afloat while I looked for something more stable. The key thing I learned is to apply sooner rather than later if your situation deteriorates, because there's usually a waiting period before benefits start. Don't let the complexity of the system discourage you from applying if you need help - your 2 years of previous work should definitely qualify you.
Hey Santiago! I just want to echo what everyone else is saying - you're definitely not alone in feeling anxious about this process. I've been certifying for about 3 months now and it really does become routine. One thing that helped me was doing a "practice run" - I went through the certification questions without submitting just to see what they looked like. Also, for your job search activities, don't overthink it! Even simple things like updating your resume, browsing job boards, or reaching out to a contact counts. The key is just being consistent and honest. And definitely report that $180 - NYS DOL is pretty good about calculating the partial benefits automatically. You'll probably still get most of your regular amount. Hang in there, the first certification is always the scariest but you've got this!
@Zainab Mahmoud The practice run idea is brilliant! I didn t'even know you could do that. I m'definitely going to try that before I do my first real certification - it ll'help me see what to expect without the pressure of actually submitting. And you re'right about not overthinking the job search activities. I was stressing about whether browsing Indeed counts as a real "job" search activity, but it sounds like as long as I m'making an effort and being honest, I should be okay. Thanks for the reassurance about the partial benefits calculation too - I was worried they might just cut off all my benefits if I worked even a little bit.
@Santiago Diaz I completely understand your anxiety! When I first started certifying, I was so nervous I triple-checked every answer before submitting. Here's what helped me get comfortable with the process: The certification window is usually open from Sunday through Saturday, so you have the whole week to do it - no need to rush. I typically do mine on Tuesday mornings when I'm more relaxed. For job search activities, keep it simple - I use the notes app on my phone to quickly jot down "Applied to [Company] for [Position] via [Website/Email]" right after I apply. This way I'm not scrambling to remember at the end of the week. The $180 you earned definitely needs to be reported, but don't worry - they'll just reduce your weekly benefit by a portion of what you earned, you won't lose everything. Most importantly, the system will walk you through each question step by step, and you can always go back and change answers before you submit. Take your time, breathe, and remember that thousands of people do this successfully every week. You've got this!
Tyler Lefleur
I just wanted to share another method that worked for me when I couldn't find my account number anywhere - if you have the NYS DOL mobile app installed, sometimes the account information shows up more clearly there than on the desktop website. The app interface is a bit different and might display your account details in a more obvious spot. Also, if you received any automated phone calls from NYS DOL after filing your claim, they sometimes include your account number in the voicemail message. I know it's frustrating when such an important piece of information seems to disappear, but don't give up! Between all the suggestions everyone has shared here, you should be able to track it down. The system definitely needs better user experience design - having your account number prominently displayed on the main dashboard would save everyone so much hassle!
0 coins
Lydia Santiago
•Great point about the mobile app! I didn't even know NYS DOL had a mobile app - I'll definitely download it and see if that shows my account info more clearly. And you're absolutely right about checking voicemails - I actually do remember getting an automated call but I didn't listen to the whole message because I assumed it was just a generic confirmation. I'll go back and check that recording. It's really encouraging to see how many different ways people have found their account numbers. You're so right about the user experience - it shouldn't be this hard to find such basic information! Thanks for adding another helpful option to try.
0 coins
Aisha Khan
I had this exact same problem a couple months back and it was so stressful! After trying all the usual places (email, my.ny.gov dashboard, etc.), what finally worked for me was calling the automated phone system at 1-888-581-5812 and following the prompts for "claim information." Even though I didn't have my account number to enter initially, there's an option to use your SSN and date of birth instead, and then the system actually reads your account number back to you before proceeding. It's kind of buried in the menu options, but if you listen carefully to all the prompts, you'll find it. Also, once I got my account number this way, I immediately saved it in three different places - my phone notes, a screenshot, and wrote it on a sticky note by my computer. The NY unemployment system is definitely not intuitive, but don't panic about deadlines - they're usually pretty understanding if you explain you had trouble accessing your account info. Hope this helps!
0 coins
Ava Williams
•This is such a helpful tip about the automated phone system! I never thought to try calling and using my SSN instead of the account number I was looking for. That's actually brilliant - getting the system to tell you your own account number. I've been so focused on trying to find it online that I didn't consider the phone option might have a workaround. I'm definitely going to try this method since I've been going in circles with the website. And you're absolutely right about saving it in multiple places once you find it - I've learned that lesson the hard way with other important numbers that I thought I'd "definitely remember." Thanks for sharing this alternative approach, it gives me hope that I can get this sorted out today!
0 coins