
Ask the community...
Anyone else notice how the NY unemployment website is like deliberately confusing about stuff like this??? They should just have a big FAQ that answers common questions but instead it's like they WANT you to make mistakes!
OMG YES!!!! I've thought this exact thing! The website feels like it was designed in 1997 and never updated. And when you finally find what looks like the right page, the information is so vague it could mean anything. So frustrating!!!!
19h
Just to add one more data point: I worked with several clients in this exact situation last tax season. The definitive answer is that you DO need to file a NY non-resident return and pay NY state taxes on your unemployment compensation if the benefits were paid by NY state, regardless of where you currently reside. NJ will give you a credit for taxes paid to NY on the same income to prevent double taxation. You'll need to complete both the NY IT-203 (non-resident return) and include a credit for taxes paid to another jurisdiction on your NJ-1040. This is spelled out in the instructions for both forms, though I agree it's not easy to find on the regular unemployment website.
Thank you! This is extremely helpful. I feel much more confident about how to handle this now. Will definitely file the NY non-resident return.
19h
Anybody else notice that the website says "If you received unemployment benefits in 2024, your 1099-G will be available by January 31, 2025" but it's clearly not working for everyone? Classic NYSDOL overpromising and underdelivering!
yup - their definition of "available" is pretty loose lol... technically the forms exist somewhere in their system but good luck actually GETTING one without spending hours on the phone
19h
For anyone still having issues, here's the official process: 1. Primary method: NY.gov account > My NY.gov > Tax Documents > 1099-G 2. Alternative method: Call the dedicated 1099-G request line at 1-877-355-5676 (operates 24/7) 3. Last resort: Submit Form TC-10 (Tax Document Request Form) through your online account If you've tried all these methods and still can't get your form, you have the right to file a complaint with the Taxpayer Advocate Service at 1-877-777-4778. They can often help resolve the issue more quickly. And remember, by law, the department must provide your tax form within 10 business days of a written request.
Thanks for all this info. I managed to find mine in the "My Online Forms" section as someone else suggested. The organization of the website is terrible, but at least I have my form now!
19h
Fantastic! The licensing board threat usually works wonders for contractors. They can't risk their business license over a few weeks of pay. Let us know if you get the money!
my cousin is a construction worker n this happens ALL THE TIME with 1099 people in every industry. its a huge problem in ny. once ur paid make sure u report them anyway so they cant do this to the next person 👍
When I tried calling NYSDOL to set up tax withholding, I couldn't get through for two weeks. Finally used Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got connected to an agent in about 20 minutes. Was able to set up the withholding and also fix another issue with my claim. Totally worth it to avoid the headache of trying to get through on my own.
Does it cost $$$? Im already broke from owing all these taxes!
19h
Update: I set up an IRS payment plan online - it was actually pretty easy! For anyone in the same situation, I'm paying about $35/month over 72 months with a small setup fee. Will try to pay it off faster when I can, but this takes the pressure off for now. For NY state taxes, I had to call and it took a while, but got on a 24-month plan for that portion. Thanks everyone for the advice!
Glad you got it sorted out! That's a very manageable payment. Just remember that interest continues to accrue on the unpaid balance, so paying it off faster when you're able will save you money in the long run.
19h
I've called the NY unemployment office three times this week and each time they keep asking me for 'personal identification' before they'll help with my claim issues. I'm not sure what exactly they're looking for? I already gave them my social security number and NY.gov ID, but they keep saying they need 'additional personal identification' to verify my account. What is this supposed to mean? I'm getting really frustrated because I've been waiting on my benefits for over 2 weeks now and every call just leads to more confusion! Does anyone know what specific documents or info they're looking for? Thanks!
This happens because there's been so much fraud with unemployment claims. My neighbor works for NYSDOL and they told me they're required to get multiple verification points before discussing ANY account details now. It has something to do with the new identity protection regulations that went into effect in January. Just be patient with the agents - they're just following the rules they have to follow.
I get WHY they're doing it but they should at least TELL PEOPLE what they need instead of just saying "personal identification" and leaving us confused!!! That's the frustrating part!
19h
UPDATE: I called again this morning with all my info ready (SSN, PIN, claim ID, driver's license, address) and got through much more easily! The agent even apologized and said they should be more specific about what they mean by "personal identification" because lots of people get confused. My issue is now resolved and my payment should be processed within 3 business days. Thanks everyone for your help!
Great news! Glad it worked out. It's always a good idea to have all your documentation ready before calling. Hope your payments come through quickly!
19h
Thanks for posting the update! This will help other people who might be confused by the same terminology.
19h
the DOL is COMPLETELY INCOMPETENT!!!! i had 5 determination letters ALL saying different things. spent 4 months fighting with them and almost got EVICTED waiting for them to figure out their own system. you better believe they'll blame YOU for THEIR mistakes too!!! system is designed to make us give up!!!!
Don't give up hope! To answer your question about backpay - yes, I did get all the money for those 6 weeks once they fixed the error. They were actually pretty quick about the backpay once the judge made the correction. Only took about 3 days to hit my account after the hearing.
I just got laid off and I'm filing for NY unemployment for the first time. The website is asking me to verify my identity through ID.me but I've never used this before. Is this new? Do I absolutely have to create an ID.me account to get my benefits? The whole process seems confusing and I'm worried about sharing all my personal info on this site. Has anyone gone through this recently? Any help would be really appreciated!
My sister works at the DOL call center and she said they get SO many calls about ID.me issues. She recommends using Chrome browser and making sure your webcam is working properly before starting. Also don't try to rush through it - take your time and read each step carefully.
That's good advice, thanks! I'll make sure to use Chrome when I do it.
19h
Update: I went ahead and created the ID.me account today. It wasn't as bad as I expected! Took about 15 minutes total. The facial recognition worked on the second try. Now I'm just waiting for it to link to my unemployment account. Thanks everyone for the help and advice!
Great to hear! The linking usually happens within 24-48 hours. Once that's done, you should be able to complete your claim and start your weekly certifications. Just remember to certify every week, even if your claim status is still pending.
19h
Wait a minute I'm confused now. Is this about NY state tax refunds or federal tax refunds? Because I thought NY was doing their own separate adjustment for unemployment taxes in addition to the federal one? Can someone clarify?
This is referring to the federal tax adjustment for unemployment benefits received in 2021. New York State generally conforms to federal tax treatment of unemployment benefits, but they implement these changes separately. If you're specifically looking for a NY state tax refund, you would need to check your NY state tax account, not the federal IRS transcripts we've been discussing. The NY Department of Taxation and Finance has a separate system for checking refund status.
19h
Thanks everyone for all the helpful information! I finally got my transcript and found the codes - looks like I'm getting a small refund (code 846) scheduled for next week. For anyone else looking, definitely check the Account Transcript and look for those transaction codes 291 and 846. And make sure you're looking at the right system depending on whether you're checking federal or NY state refunds!
congrats on finding your refund! did u have to do anything special to get it or was it automatic?
19h
anybody know if u can get partial benefits while waiting for the hearing decision? my friend said he did but i think hes confused
No, unfortunately that's not correct. When benefits are held pending an ALJ decision, there is no partial payment option in New York. Your friend may be confusing this with partial benefits while working reduced hours, which is a different situation entirely.
19h
Update from my experience earlier this year: I was finally able to get some insight into my case status by contacting my local Workforce1 Career Center. While they couldn't expedite anything, the staff person there had access to slightly more detailed status information than what shows on the online portal. Might be worth a visit if there's one near you.
That's really helpful, thank you! There's a center about 20 minutes from me. I'll try going there tomorrow to see if they can tell me anything more specific about my case status.
19h
Felix Grigori
Has anyone tried going to the actual unemployment office in person? I'm wondering if that might be faster than dealing with the phone nightmare.
0 coins
Felicity Bud
Most local offices are appointment-only now after the update. I tried walking in two weeks ago and was turned away. Had to schedule an appointment online and the earliest they had was 3 weeks out. The whole system is backed up everywhere unfortunately.
0 coins
19h
Write a comment...
Taylor To
UPDATE: I finally got through to someone! Used the Claimyr service that someone mentioned above and got connected to an agent in about 20 minutes. The rep confirmed exactly what you all said - my claim got caught in their post-update verification process. She manually reviewed my claim, verified my identity, and released all my payments! Should have the money in 2-3 business days. THANK YOU everyone for all the advice and support here. This community is amazing.
0 coins
Savannah Glover
Great news! Glad you got it resolved. Just make sure you continue to certify weekly without interruption while waiting for the payment to process.
0 coins
19h
Kevin Bell
nice!! gives me hope mine will get fixed soon too
0 coins
19h
Write a comment...