
Ask the community...
Random question but has anyone noticed that the monetary determinations seem to be taking longer to process lately? When I filed last year it only took like 3 days to get mine but my friend just filed and has been waiting over a week now...
Of course they're taking longer! They just laid off 200 DOL workers in January while claims are increasing. It's all part of the plan to make the system so dysfunctional that people give up. Call your state representatives about this!
14h
FINAL UPDATE: My wage reconsideration was approved! It took almost 5 weeks, but I finally got a revised Monetary Determination showing my correct wages of $41,850. My weekly benefit amount increased from $318 to $504! They're also sending me retroactive payments for the difference on the weeks I've already certified. For anyone dealing with this issue, here's what worked for me: 1. Submitted all my W-2s and quarterly pay stubs through the messaging system 2. Got a letter from my employer confirming my wages 3. Called (multiple times) until I got through to someone who could check on the status Thanks to everyone who helped with advice. This forum was a lifesaver when I was stressing about this whole situation!
Congratulations! I'm still waiting on mine (it's been 3 weeks) and this gives me hope. Did they notify you by email when the determination changed or did you have to keep checking your account?
14h
They sent me an email saying I had a new message in my account. When I logged in, the revised determination was there. I'd recommend checking your account every few days though, just in case.
14h
This is exactly right. The alternative base period can make a huge difference in your benefit amount, especially if you had higher earnings in the most recent completed quarter. Make sure all your earnings documentation has dates clearly visible!
Thank you! I'll make sure to include all that info. I've put together a folder with everything from the past 5 quarters now. Feeling much more confident about submitting everything properly.
This is my very first time filing for NY unemployment. I submitted everything and completed the ID.me video verification on February 14, 2025. I did receive a letter about a week and a half ago showing a benefit amount, but it's not an official determination letter. I've been certifying every Sunday like I'm supposed to. It's now been 3 weeks since I filed and I haven't received any payment or status updates. Is this normal procedure? How long should I expect to wait before I see my first payment? Getting a bit worried since bills are piling up.
My sister works for the state (not unemployment but another agency) and she says they're super understaffed right now. That's why everything takes forever.
Update: I finally got through to someone this morning! There was apparently an issue with my employment verification that needed manual review. The agent cleared it up and said I should receive all my back payments within 3-5 business days. Thanks everyone for your help and suggestions!
How did you get through?? I'm still trying and can't reach anyone!!!
14h
I ended up using that Claimyr service mentioned above. It worked perfectly and saved me hours of redial frustration. Expensive but worth it in my situation.
14h
If you didn't have taxes withheld from your unemployment benefits, here's what you can do now: 1. Prepare for potential tax liability when you file 2. Consider making an estimated tax payment now to reduce penalties 3. Look into payment plans with the IRS if you can't pay in full 4. Check if you qualify for any tax credits that might offset some of the liability For future reference, you can elect to have 10% of your benefits withheld for federal taxes on the NY unemployment site.
Thank you for this info. I'm going to start setting aside some money now so I'm prepared when I file. Next time I'll definitely have taxes withheld!
14h
my brother said something about unemployment being taxed different in NY state vs federal? anyone know if thats true??
Yes, that's correct. Unemployment benefits are fully taxable at the federal level, but New York State does not tax unemployment benefits at the state level. So when you file your taxes, you'll include unemployment as income on your federal return, but you won't need to pay New York State income tax on those benefits.
14h
my sister works for NY unemployment and she says they get this question all the time!! the stimulus was from federal govt not from unemployment and its not taxed. but your unemployment benefits are 100% taxable so make sure you budget for that next time maybe?
Exactly right! I always tell people to opt for tax withholding when they first apply for NY unemployment. Much easier than getting hit with a big tax bill later!
14h
Update: I went back to my tax preparer with all this info and they admitted they made a mistake! They're redoing my taxes for free. Turns out I DO owe taxes on my unemployment income (about $870) but nothing on the stimulus. Thanks everyone for saving me from paying money I didn't need to!
Great outcome! For future reference, you can always select to have taxes withheld from your NY unemployment payments (it's about 10% for federal and a small amount for state). It makes filing taxes much less stressful since you won't have a surprise tax bill.
14h
That's really good to know. I'm definitely going to do that this time around.
14h
UPDATE: I was finally able to get through to a real person at NYSDOL! I used the Claimyr service that someone mentioned above, and it worked perfectly. The agent found the problem right away - turns out there was a flag on my account because I had an old claim from 2023 that had some kind of unresolved issue. The system was holding ALL my new payments because of this old problem that no one ever told me about! The agent removed the flag and said I should receive ALL my back payments within 3-5 business days. I'm trying not to get too excited until I actually see the money, but this is the first real progress I've made in a year! Thank you to everyone who offered advice. I'll update again once the payments come through.
This is exactly what I suspected - a system flag from a previous claim. I'm glad you were able to connect with someone who could identify and fix the problem. This happens more often than you'd think, and it's frustrating that the online system doesn't make these flags visible to claimants. The 3-5 business days timeline is accurate in my experience, especially for back payments. Make sure to check both your payment history in the portal and your bank account, as sometimes the portal updates before the deposit arrives.
14h
FINALLY some good news!! glad you got through to someone who actually knew what they were doing for once!!!
14h
FINAL UPDATE: All my back payments came through today!!! Over $19,000 in total (minus taxes). I almost cried when I saw the deposit. Thank you again to everyone who helped - especially the suggestion to try Claimyr to get through on the phone. If anyone else is stuck in payment limbo, don't give up!
That's wonderful news! I'm so glad you got your situation resolved and received all your back payments. It's unfortunate you had to wait so long, but this is a great reminder to always be persistent with unemployment issues - there's almost always a solution once you reach the right person.
14h
congrats!! bet that feels amazing after waiting so long!
14h
My sister got 6 weeks backpay after her citizenship papers got processed but it took like 2 months to get the money so don't expect it super fast
2 MONTHS??? I can't wait that long! My rent is due next week! 😱
14h
Once you get through to a claims specialist and they process your documents, payments are typically released within 3-5 business days. However, there is a backlog currently, so some claims are taking 7-10 business days to process. If you're facing immediate financial hardship, be sure to mention this to the claims specialist - they can sometimes flag accounts for expedited processing in hardship cases. Also make sure to check for any action items in your online account daily, as sometimes they request additional verification.
Thank you for that timeline. I'll definitely mention my financial situation when I call. I've been checking my account obsessively anyway, so I'll keep an eye out for any requests.
14h
I tried that Claimyr service someone mentioned when I was desperate in January. It actually worked - had me talking to a real agent in like 25 minutes after trying for weeks on my own. They fixed my issue on that call. Not saying you should have to pay to reach the government, but if you're desperate like I was, it might be worth it.
Thanks for sharing your experience. If I still can't get through after trying the early morning calls next week, I might consider this option. Just frustrating that it's come to this.
14h
Just wanted to follow up - did you ever get through to someone? Were you able to resolve your pending claim issue?
Yes! I actually got through on Monday morning by calling right at 7:30am. Had to wait about 40 minutes but finally spoke to someone who told me my claim was held up because of that questionnaire I mentioned missing. They pushed it through and my payment should be coming this week. Thanks everyone for the suggestions!
14h
my neighbor had same issue, he used that claimr thing someone mentioned abov & got thru in like 20 min after trying for days by himself. just sayin it works if ur desperate
I'm definitely getting desperate at this point... tax appointment is coming up fast. I'll try the specific phone sequence first thing tomorrow and if that fails, might have to look into that service.
14h
UPDATE: I got through this morning! Called right at 8:00am and followed the sequence that was suggested (press 2, then 2 again, then 3). Had to wait about 30 minutes but finally spoke to someone who confirmed they'll mail my 1099-G. Should arrive in 7-10 days which is cutting it close for my tax appointment but better than nothing. Thanks everyone for your help!
Great news! Glad you got it sorted out. For your tax appointment, if the form hasn't arrived yet, you can let your preparer know it's on the way. They might be able to estimate that amount for now and amend later if needed, or possibly reschedule to make sure everything is accurate the first time.
14h
Brooklyn Foley
Just to add some factual information that might help others: The backpay process for NY unemployment in 2025 involves several steps: 1. Filing the TC-12.3 form (Request for Retroactive Payment) 2. Assignment to a specialized backpay processor (not a regular claims examiner) 3. Review of your work and earnings history for the backpay period 4. Determination of eligibility for each week claimed 5. Processing of payments if approved The official timeframe is 10-15 business days, but in reality, it often takes 3-6 weeks. The key is making sure step #1 and #2 actually happen. Many claims get stuck because the form is filled out but never properly submitted into the processing queue. One tip: When you call, ask them for a "confirmation number" for your TC-12.3 submission. If they can't provide one, the form probably wasn't properly submitted.
0 coins
Elijah Knight
This is so helpful, thank you! I definitely wasn't given any confirmation number. I'll specifically ask for one when I call back.
0 coins
14h
Write a comment...
Marcus Williams
Just as a follow up - did you ever get this resolved? I'm curious whether you had to call back multiple times or if they actually processed your backpay claim after that first call where they completed the TC-12.3.
0 coins
Elijah Knight
I actually just called back today after checking my message center and finding no confirmation as you suggested. Had to wait almost 2 hours, but finally got through to someone who admitted the form was still sitting in a pending status. They said they've submitted it "for real this time" and gave me a confirmation number (finally!). They said I should get a message in my portal within 48 hours and then the review process would take about 2-3 weeks. Fingers crossed this time it actually happens!
0 coins
14h
Write a comment...