


Ask the community...
performance issues vs misconduct is a big difference though. if someone's just not good at their job that's not their fault really, they should get unemployment. if they're stealing or showing up drunk that's different
As someone who went through this recently, I can confirm what others are saying - you don't pay unemployment benefits directly to the employee. The NYS Department of Labor handles all payments from the trust fund that employers like you contribute to through payroll taxes. For performance issues (not misconduct), the employee will likely qualify for benefits, but this doesn't mean extra costs upfront for you. Your future UI tax rate could be affected if you have multiple claims, but that's calculated annually based on your overall claims history. Document everything well for your records, but performance terminations rarely disqualify someone from receiving benefits in NY.
This is really helpful clarification! So just to make sure I understand - the NYS Department of Labor uses the trust fund that all employers pay into, and then my future tax rate might go up based on how many claims are filed against my company overall? Is there a threshold where it really starts to impact your rates significantly?
I'm going through the exact same thing right now! It's so frustrating - been trying to get my waiting week credit for over 2 weeks and the system won't let me certify until I get it approved. I've tried calling every morning starting at 7:55am and throughout the day but just get that automated message saying to call back later. From reading all these responses, it sounds like contacting your state assembly member or senator might be the most reliable solution. Several people mentioned getting results within a few days that way, which is way better than the weeks of phone tag we're dealing with. I'm also seriously considering trying that Claimyr service that keeps getting mentioned. I hate that we have to pay a third party just to access benefits we're entitled to, but at this point I'm running out of options and patience. My savings are almost gone too. Thanks for posting this - at least now I know I'm not the only one dealing with this nightmare! The NY unemployment system really needs to be fixed. It shouldn't be this hard to get help when you're already struggling financially.
Ugh, I'm so glad I found this thread! I'm dealing with the exact same waiting week credit issue and it's been absolutely maddening. Like you, I've been calling every single day starting before 8am and just getting that stupid "all representatives are busy" message. It's like they don't want us to actually get help! I'm definitely going to try the assembly member route that everyone's talking about - seems like that's been the most successful approach from what I'm reading. Also might look into that Claimyr service if the assembly member thing doesn't work out quickly. It's ridiculous that we might have to pay someone just to get through to our own state agency, but honestly I'm getting desperate too. Stay strong - sounds like once you actually get someone on the phone the waiting week credit gets sorted pretty fast. It's just this impossible hurdle of actually reaching a human being that's killing us all!
I'm going through the exact same nightmare with the waiting week credit! Been calling for over 2 weeks now and can't get through to a single human being. The system won't let me certify online either - just keeps giving me that error about needing to request waiting week credit first. After reading through all these comments, I'm definitely going to try calling my assembly member tomorrow. So many people have had success that way and gotten their issues resolved in just a few days. That sounds way better than this endless phone tag with the unemployment office. I'm also bookmarking that Claimyr service as a backup plan. I hate that we might have to pay a third party just to access benefits we're legally entitled to, but honestly at this point I'm willing to try anything. My rent is due soon too and I can't keep burning through my savings like this. Thanks for posting this thread - it's oddly comforting to know I'm not the only one dealing with this broken system. The fact that so many of us are having the exact same problem shows how messed up NY unemployment really is right now. Hang in there everyone!
I'm dealing with this same issue right now and this thread has been incredibly helpful! I've been searching everywhere for my claim number and getting really frustrated with the NYS DOL system. Based on everyone's suggestions here, I'm going to try the automated phone line at 1-888-209-8124 first since that seems like the quickest solution. If that doesn't work, I'll check the "View Benefit Payment History" section that several people mentioned. It's such a relief to know I can still file my weekly claim using just my SSN and PIN as a backup option. Thanks to everyone who shared their experiences - it's crazy that we need an entire community discussion just to figure out how to find basic information in the system, but I'm so glad this resource exists!
I'm so glad this thread exists too! I just went through this exact same frustration a couple weeks ago and it's such a relief when you finally get it sorted out. The automated phone line really is your best bet - I was able to get my claim number in just a few minutes without any wait time. And yes, the backup option of using your SSN and PIN for weekly filing definitely takes the pressure off. It's honestly ridiculous that the NYS DOL system makes something so basic this complicated, but at least we can help each other navigate it. You've got this! @Payton Black
I just went through this exact same thing last week and it was so stressful! After reading through all these helpful suggestions, I wanted to add one more tip that worked for me. If you're still having trouble after trying the automated phone line and checking the "View Benefit Payment History" section, try clearing your browser cache and cookies before logging into my.ny.gov again. Sometimes the system gets glitchy and a fresh login session can make information appear that wasn't showing before. I also discovered that if you have any correspondence from NYS DOL in your my.ny.gov inbox (even if it's just application confirmations), your claim number is sometimes embedded in those messages even if it's not obvious. Don't give up - there are definitely multiple ways to find it, and worst case you can always file your weekly claims with just your SSN like others mentioned!
I'm dealing with this exact same nightmare! Been calling the 888-209-8124 number for almost 2 weeks straight with my claim stuck in "pending review" and it's absolutely maddening. Either immediate busy signals, 2+ hour holds that end in disconnection, or that infuriating "call volume too high" message. This thread is incredibly helpful though - way more useful than anything on the DOL website! I'm definitely going to try the Spanish line transfer trick tomorrow at exactly 8:00 AM based on all the success stories here. Also planning to have all my documents ready and do the rapid callback method if I get busy signals. It's so encouraging to read that most of these issues are simple 5-minute fixes once you actually reach an agent. Makes the broken phone system even more frustrating, but at least gives me hope that resolution is possible! Has anyone noticed if certain days of the week work better? I've been trying mostly Mondays but maybe mid-week would have less volume. Also seriously considering that Claimyr service as backup since the stress of constant failed attempts is really getting to me. Thanks everyone for sharing real solutions instead of the useless official advice - this community support is keeping me sane through this nightmare!
I've been dealing with this same nightmare for over a month now! My claim has been stuck in "pending review" since late February and I've called that 888-209-8124 number probably 400+ times with absolutely no success. The system is completely broken. Reading through this entire thread has been both frustrating and hopeful - frustrating because it confirms how widespread this problem is, but hopeful because of all the real strategies people are sharing. I'm definitely going to try the Spanish line transfer trick tomorrow morning at exactly 8:00 AM. The success rate with that method seems much higher based on everyone's experiences. I also just submitted a request through my assembly member's office after seeing multiple people mention that route. Found a specific unemployment assistance form on their website and got an auto-reply saying they'll contact DOL within 2 business days. The most infuriating part is knowing these are usually simple 5-minute fixes once you reach someone. Three weeks of stress and hundreds of failed calls for what will probably be a basic system glitch. At this point I'm seriously considering the Claimyr service too - my mental health can't take much more of this phone system nightmare. Thank you to everyone sharing what actually works instead of the useless official advice. This community support is literally the only thing keeping me sane right now. Will definitely update with results from tomorrow's Spanish line attempt!
Asher Levin
I'm currently in week 20 of my benefits and this thread has been a lifesaver! Reading everyone's experiences has helped me realize I need to start preparing now instead of waiting until the last minute. A few things I wanted to share that I've discovered while researching: 1. The NY Department of Labor has a "Rapid Response" program that's specifically designed for mass layoffs, but they also offer individual services for people whose benefits are ending. You can request a consultation to review all available programs at once instead of applying to each one separately. 2. For those mentioning SNAP benefits - there's actually a expedited application process if you're transitioning off unemployment. If your benefits end and you have less than $150 in liquid assets, you can get SNAP approved within 7 days instead of the usual 30-day process. 3. I found out that some union halls (even if you're not a member) offer free job placement services and sometimes have leads on jobs that aren't posted publicly. Worth checking even if you're not in a traditional union field. The biggest takeaway from reading everyone's stories is that being proactive makes all the difference. I'm starting my WIOA application next week and have already scheduled an appointment at my local Career Center. Thank you all for sharing such detailed and practical advice - this community support is incredible!
0 coins
Omar Farouk
•This is incredibly helpful information, especially about the Rapid Response program! I had no idea NYSDOL offered individual consultations for people whose benefits are ending - that sounds like it could save a lot of time and confusion compared to trying to figure out each program separately. The expedited SNAP application process is also really valuable to know about. Having that 7-day timeline instead of 30 days could make a huge difference for people facing immediate financial pressure when their UI benefits end. Your point about union halls is interesting too - I wouldn't have thought to check there as a non-union worker, but if they have access to job leads that aren't posted elsewhere, it's definitely worth exploring. I'm in week 21 myself and you're absolutely right about being proactive. Reading through everyone's experiences here has shown me that the people who had the smoothest transitions were the ones who started preparing weeks ahead of time rather than scrambling at the last minute. Thanks for sharing these additional resources - I'm going to look into that Rapid Response consultation right away!
0 coins
Yara Khoury
I'm currently in week 25 and this entire thread has been more informative than weeks of trying to navigate the official NYSDOL website! The amount of practical, real-world advice here is incredible. I wanted to share something I just discovered that might help others - if you call your local One-Stop Career Center and mention that your UI benefits are ending soon, they can often schedule you for what they call a "comprehensive assessment" before your benefits actually end. This assessment covers not just job search assistance, but also helps you identify which training programs you'd be the best candidate for and can even help you complete multiple applications in one appointment. I also learned that keeping detailed records of all your job search activities throughout your entire benefit period (not just the last 4 weeks) can be really valuable. If any retroactive extensions get passed or if you need to reopen a claim later, having that complete documentation makes the process much smoother. For anyone feeling overwhelmed by all the different programs mentioned here - I made a simple spreadsheet listing each program, application deadlines, eligibility requirements, and contact info. It's helped me stay organized and make sure I don't miss any opportunities. Happy to share the template if anyone wants it! The support and knowledge sharing in this community is amazing. Thank you to everyone who's taken the time to share their experiences and advice!
0 coins
Kai Rivera
•This is such a great idea about the comprehensive assessment at the One-Stop Career Center! I'm in week 23 and definitely going to call tomorrow to schedule one before my benefits end. Having someone help you navigate all the different programs and complete applications in one appointment sounds so much more efficient than trying to figure everything out separately. Your point about keeping detailed records throughout the entire benefit period is really smart too. I've been pretty casual about documenting my job search activities, but reading everyone's advice here has made me realize I should be much more thorough about that documentation. I would absolutely love to see that spreadsheet template if you're willing to share it! Staying organized seems to be such a key factor in successfully navigating this transition, and having a structured way to track all the different programs and deadlines would be incredibly helpful. This whole thread has completely changed my perspective from feeling anxious about my benefits ending to actually feeling prepared with a solid action plan. The community knowledge here is truly amazing - thank you for adding even more valuable resources to the conversation!
0 coins