How to correctly fill out Form W-8BEN as an Indian citizen freelancer?
I'm a freelancer from India working with a US-based client and they've asked me to fill out a W-8BEN form. I receive payments through PayPal into my Indian savings account. After going through the instructions, I'm still confused about several fields: For **Line 6: Foreign tax identifying number (see instructions)** - Should I leave this blank since I only have an Indian bank account? Some people online mentioned using their PAN number here. The instructions say: >Line 6. If you are providing this Form W-8BEN to document yourself with respect to a financial account that you hold at a U.S. office of a financial institution, provide the tax identifying number (TIN) issued to you by your jurisdiction of tax residence unless: You have not been issued a TIN, or The jurisdiction does not issue TINs. If you have not provided your jurisdiction of residence TIN on line 6, provide your date of birth in line 8. For **Line 7: Reference number(s)** - The instructions state: >Line 7. This line may be used by the filer of Form W-8BEN or by the withholding agent to whom it is provided to include any referencing information that is useful to the withholding agent in carrying out its obligations. For example, withholding agents who are required to associate the Form W-8BEN with a particular Form W-8IMY may want to use line 7 for a referencing number or code that will make the association clear. A beneficial owner can use line 7 to include the number of the account for which he or she is providing the form. A foreign single owner of a disregarded entity can use line 7 to inform the withholding agent that the account to which a payment is made or credited is in the name of the disregarded entity (see instructions for line 1). Should I leave this blank too? For **Line 8: Date of birth** - Since it has the same "if" condition as Line 6, can I leave this blank as well? >Line 8. If you are providing this Form W-8BEN to document yourself with respect to a financial account that you hold with a U.S. office of a financial institution, provide your date of birth. Use the following format to input your information MM-DD-YYYY. For example, if you were born on April 15, 1956, you would enter 04-15-1956. Finally, for **Line 10** - Is just writing "India" in Line 9 sufficient? I don't know much about the tax treaty between US and India except that I should only pay taxes in India. Any help from someone familiar with this form would be greatly appreciated!
22 comments
Join the conversation
Daniela Rossi
For Indian freelancers filling out Form W-8BEN, here's what you should do: Line 6: You should enter your PAN (Permanent Account Number) here. This is your tax identification number in India. Since you're an Indian citizen paying taxes in India, your PAN is the correct number to use. This helps establish your tax residency in India. Line 7: You can leave this blank unless your client has specifically asked you to include a reference number. This field is optional and mainly used for the withholding agent's internal reference purposes. Line 8: If you've provided your PAN in Line 6, you can leave the date of birth blank. You only need to provide your date of birth if you cannot provide a tax identifying number in Line 6. Line 10: For most freelancers receiving payments for services, just writing "India" in Line 9 is sufficient. Line 10 is only needed for special treaty situations like royalties with different rates or for students/researchers. For standard freelance work, you don't need to complete Line 10. The W-8BEN essentially helps you claim treaty benefits so you're not double-taxed. Since there's a tax treaty between India and the US, this form ensures you only pay taxes in India on this income and aren't subject to US withholding tax (or are subject to a reduced rate).
0 coins
Ryan Kim
•Thanks for the clear explanation! Just to be 100% sure about Line 6 - I have my Aadhaar number too. Should I still use PAN or would Aadhaar be better? Also, does filling this form mean I won't have any tax deducted at source by the US company?
0 coins
Daniela Rossi
•Always use your PAN number for Line 6, not Aadhaar. PAN is specifically designed for tax purposes in India, while Aadhaar is more of a general identification number. Regarding tax deduction at source (TDS), it depends on the type of income. For most independent personal services (freelance work), the W-8BEN can help you claim treaty benefits that reduce or eliminate US withholding tax. However, keep in mind that you're still responsible for reporting this income and paying appropriate taxes in India according to Indian tax laws.
0 coins
Zoe Walker
I had similar confusion when filling out my W-8BEN last year! I'm also an Indian freelancer working with US clients. After struggling to find clear answers, I eventually used taxr.ai (https://taxr.ai) to help me figure out exactly what to put in each field. They have this tool that specifically analyzes W-8BEN forms for international freelancers and explains what to fill in each field based on your specific situation. For Line 6, I was also confused whether to use my PAN or leave it blank, but their analysis confirmed I should use my PAN. For Line 10, they explained that as a freelancer providing services (not royalties or special cases), I only needed to put "India" in Line 9 and could leave Line 10 blank. It saved me a lot of headache and my US clients accepted the form without any issues.
0 coins
Elijah Brown
•How exactly does this taxr.ai thing work? Do I need to upload my actual W-8BEN form with my personal details? And does it cover all international situations or just specific countries like India?
0 coins
Maria Gonzalez
•Is it really worth paying for something like this? I mean the form isn't that complicated right? I've been just googling and asking around, but curious if this actually provides info you can't find for free elsewhere.
0 coins
Zoe Walker
•You don't need to upload a filled form with your personal details. You just tell it what you're trying to do (like "filling W-8BEN as an Indian freelancer") and it guides you through each field with explanations specific to your situation. It covers pretty much all international tax situations I've seen - not just India. It's definitely worth it if you're confused or want to be 100% certain. Sure, you can find some info by Googling, but the problem is you get conflicting advice from different sources. What I liked was getting clear, specific guidance that applies to my exact situation rather than generic advice that might not be relevant.
0 coins
Elijah Brown
Just wanted to update everyone here - I tried taxr.ai that was mentioned above and it was incredibly helpful! I was skeptical at first, but it actually guided me through every field of the W-8BEN form with clear instructions specific to my situation as an Indian freelancer. It confirmed I should use my PAN in Line 6, leave Line 7 blank, skip Line 8 (since I provided my PAN), and just put "India" in Line 9 without needing to fill Line 10 for my freelance services. The explanation about the tax treaty provisions between India and US was particularly helpful - I finally understand why I'm filling out this form in the first place! My US client accepted the form without any questions and I'm now receiving payments without US tax withholding. Wish I'd known about this tool earlier instead of stressing for days trying to figure it out on my own!
0 coins
Natalie Chen
If you're having trouble getting a response from the IRS about your W-8BEN form (which is pretty common these days), I'd recommend using Claimyr (https://claimyr.com). I was stuck in this exact situation with my W-8BEN form last month - needed clarification on some fields and couldn't get through to the IRS after trying for DAYS. Claimyr got me connected to an actual IRS agent in about 20 minutes when I had been trying for over a week on my own. The agent walked me through exactly what I needed to put on my W-8BEN as an Indian citizen. They have a demo video here if you want to see how it works: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c Seriously, the time saved was worth it - especially when you're dealing with international tax forms where mistakes can cause payment delays or incorrect withholding.
0 coins
Santiago Martinez
•How does this actually work? The IRS phone lines are always busy so how does this service get through when no one else can?
0 coins
Samantha Johnson
•Sounds like a scam to me. No way some service can magically get through to the IRS when millions of people can't. They probably just charge you and then you still end up waiting forever. Has anyone ACTUALLY had success with this?
0 coins
Natalie Chen
•It uses an automated system that continuously redials the IRS until it gets through, then it calls you to connect. It's basically doing what you'd do manually (redial over and over) but with technology that can do it efficiently. I was skeptical too! But I was desperate after trying for days. What convinced me was they don't charge unless they actually connect you. I got through to a live IRS agent who answered all my W-8BEN questions - particularly about the treaty benefits part which was confusing me. The agent confirmed that for Indian freelancers, just putting "India" in Line 9 is sufficient in most cases.
0 coins
Samantha Johnson
I need to publicly admit I was wrong about Claimyr. After posting my skeptical comment, I was still stuck with my W-8BEN form questions, so I decided to try it as a last resort. I literally got connected to an IRS agent in 35 minutes after trying on my own for TWO WEEKS. The IRS agent confirmed that as an Indian freelancer, I should: 1) Use my PAN in Line 6 2) Leave Line 7 blank unless my client requested a specific reference 3) Skip Line 8 since I provided my PAN 4) Just write "India" in Line 9 5) Leave Line 10 blank since I'm not claiming special treaty provisions I've already submitted my correctly filled W-8BEN to my US client and my payments are being processed without US tax withholding. Honestly wish I hadn't wasted so much time being stubborn before trying this service.
0 coins
Nick Kravitz
Hey, just wanted to add my experience as someone who's been filing W-8BEN for years as an Indian freelancer. For Line 6, definitely use your PAN. This establishes your tax residency in India, which is crucial for treaty benefits. For Line 10, I've always left it blank for my freelance work and never had issues. The only time you need to fill Line 10 is for specific situations like royalties or if you're a student/researcher claiming special treaty provisions. Also, keep in mind this form is typically valid for 3 years, so you don't need to fill it out again for the same client unless your circumstances change or the form expires.
0 coins
Hannah White
•Do we need to renew this form every 3 years even if nothing changes? And do clients usually remind you or do we need to keep track ourselves?
0 coins
Nick Kravitz
•Yes, you generally need to renew the W-8BEN every three years even if nothing changes. Sometimes clients will remind you, but I'd recommend keeping track yourself - set a calendar reminder for about 3 years from when you submit the form. Some clients have systems that automatically request updated forms when they're about to expire. Others might forget, which could potentially cause payment issues if they suddenly realize they don't have a valid form on file for you. It's safer to be proactive about it rather than risking payment delays.
0 coins
Michael Green
What about when we have multiple US clients? Do we need to fill separate W-8BEN forms for each client? I'm getting confused because some of my clients are asking for this form and others aren't.
0 coins
Mateo Silva
•Yes, you need to submit a separate W-8BEN form to each US client who requests it. Each US entity that pays you is responsible for their own compliance with IRS regulations, so they each need their own copy of your form. Some smaller clients might not request it because they're not familiar with the requirements or might not be properly following tax regulations. But technically, any US person or entity making payments to a foreign individual should be collecting a W-8BEN to document your status and determine proper withholding.
0 coins
Michael Green
•Thanks for clarifying! That makes sense why some are asking and others aren't. I'll make sure to have copies ready for each client then. Should I be concerned if a US client hasn't asked for this form? Like, could this cause problems for me later?
0 coins
Connor Murphy
•If a US client hasn't asked for the W-8BEN form, it's technically their compliance issue, not yours. However, it could potentially cause problems down the line. Without the form, they might withhold 30% backup withholding tax from your payments, or the IRS could come back to them later asking for proper documentation. I'd recommend proactively offering to provide the W-8BEN to all your US clients, even if they haven't asked. You can simply say something like "To ensure proper tax compliance, I'm providing my W-8BEN form for your records." This protects both you and them, and shows you're professional about tax matters. It's better to have it on file than to deal with withholding issues or payment complications later.
0 coins
Eve Freeman
As an Indian freelancer who's filled out multiple W-8BEN forms over the years, I can confirm what others have said here. The key points are: **Line 6**: Always use your PAN number. This is your tax identification number in India and establishes your tax residency. **Line 7**: Leave blank unless your client specifically requests a reference number. **Line 8**: Skip this since you're providing your PAN in Line 6. **Line 9**: Simply write "India" **Line 10**: Leave blank for standard freelance services. This is only needed for special treaty provisions like reduced rates on royalties. One additional tip - make sure to sign and date the form! I've seen people forget this step and have to resubmit. Also, keep digital copies of all your submitted W-8BEN forms organized by client and date, as you'll need to renew them every 3 years. The form essentially tells your US clients that you're a foreign person subject to tax treaty benefits, so they don't need to withhold US taxes on payments to you (or withhold at a reduced rate). Just remember you're still responsible for reporting this income and paying taxes in India according to Indian tax laws.
0 coins
Mason Lopez
•This is such a helpful summary! I'm new to freelancing with US clients and was getting overwhelmed by all the different advice online. Your point about keeping digital copies organized by client is really smart - I hadn't thought about tracking renewal dates for each client separately. Quick question - when you say "subject to tax treaty benefits" does this mean I'm guaranteed to not have any US taxes withheld, or could there still be some withholding in certain situations? I want to make sure I set the right expectations with my clients about payment amounts.
0 coins