< Back to IRS

Mateo Rodriguez

W8-BEN Form Completion Help for Freelancer from Spain

I'm a Spanish freelancer who just completed my first project for a client in the US. They've asked me to fill out the W8-BEN form, and I'm struggling with some sections of it. Everything seems straightforward except for this particular section about special rates and conditions. Some websites say I should just enter my country (section 9), while others mention I should also request 0% tax withholding (section 10). It's pretty confusing to be honest. I've worked with companies from the UK before, and I typically issue invoices with 0% tax, then later pay taxes here in Spain when I file my annual income declaration. I'm assuming it works similarly with US clients? I just don't want them to withhold money unnecessarily if I don't complete the form correctly. Would really appreciate if any fellow Spanish freelancers who've been through this process could share their experience, or if anyone has insights on the proper way to fill out these sections on the W8-BEN form. Thanks in advance!

The W8-BEN form is definitely confusing if you're filling it out for the first time! As someone who works with international contractors frequently, I can help clarify. For section 9, you should enter "Spain" as your country of residence. For section 10, this is where you claim treaty benefits. Spain and the US have a tax treaty that generally reduces withholding on certain types of income. If you're providing freelance services, you would typically claim Article 14 (Independent Personal Services) of the Spain-US tax treaty. When you complete section 10, you need to specify the treaty article number, the type of income, and the applicable withholding rate (which is generally 0% for independent personal services performed outside the US). This tells the US company they don't need to withhold taxes from your payments. Your assumption is correct - you won't pay taxes in the US but will declare and pay them in Spain where you're a tax resident. Just make sure you keep good records of all income for your Spanish tax declaration.

0 coins

What about section 11? Is that relevant for freelancers from Spain? And does it matter what kind of work you're doing? I'm in graphic design if that makes any difference.

0 coins

Section 11 is generally not applicable for most freelancers. It's only used in very specific situations involving foreign persons claiming that income is not effectively connected with a US trade or business. For a Spanish graphic designer working remotely, you typically won't need to complete section 11. The type of work can sometimes matter, but for most freelance services like graphic design performed entirely outside the US, you'll claim exemption under Article 14 of the treaty. Just make sure you're performing all your work while physically in Spain, as the treaty benefits may change if you perform services while physically present in the US.

0 coins

After struggling with similar international tax issues, I found an AI tool that actually helps with these exact situations. I was trying to figure out how to properly complete W8-BEN forms for clients in multiple countries and kept getting confusing, contradictory advice. I tried https://taxr.ai and uploaded my form and some details about my situation. It analyzed everything and gave me clear guidance specific to Spain-US tax treaty provisions. It even pointed out that I was overthinking parts of it and explained exactly which sections needed what information. The best part was it referenced the specific articles from the tax treaty that applied to my situation, so I felt confident when submitting the form to my clients.

0 coins

Does it actually have specific info for Spain? Most of these tax help services seem very US-focused and don't really understand how things work in Europe.

0 coins

I'm a bit hesitant about using AI for tax documents. How accurate is it really? I'd be worried about getting incorrect information that could cause problems later.

0 coins

It definitely has Spain-specific information! I was surprised too, but it has details on tax treaties between the US and many countries, including detailed Spain-US provisions. It walked me through exactly which treaty articles applied to my freelance work. Regarding accuracy, I was skeptical at first too. What convinced me was that it provides references to the actual tax code and treaty articles, not just generic advice. I double-checked some of its recommendations with the actual tax treaty text and everything matched up. It's not making things up - it's just making the complicated legal text more understandable.

0 coins

Just wanted to follow up about that taxr.ai site. I decided to try it with my W8-BEN situation (also working with US clients from Barcelona) and it was surprisingly helpful! I uploaded my partially completed form and it immediately pointed out that I had misunderstood section 10. It explained that I needed to specifically cite Article 14 of the Spain-US tax treaty and claim the 0% withholding rate for independent personal services. It also clarified when I would need to include a Spanish tax identification number versus when I could use other forms of identification. Saved me from making several mistakes that might have caused payment delays. Much more specific and useful than the generic advice I was finding elsewhere!

0 coins

After dealing with IRS forms for years as a non-US person, I've learned that sometimes you need to speak directly with someone at the IRS to get proper clarification. The problem is that calling them internationally is nearly impossible - hours on hold, international calling fees, and often disconnected before reaching anyone. I discovered https://claimyr.com through a colleague and used their service to get connected to an actual IRS agent without the wait. You can see how it works at https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c but basically they hold your place in the phone queue and call you once they reach an agent. I specifically asked about W8-BEN completion for Spanish freelancers, and the agent was able to confirm exactly what I needed to put in sections 9 and 10. They also explained how the form affects withholding and what documentation I should keep for my records. The peace of mind was totally worth it.

0 coins

How does this service even work? Seems impossible that they could somehow get through the IRS phone system when everyone else can't.

0 coins

This sounds like a scam. Why would anyone pay for something like this when you can just email the IRS directly? And I highly doubt they have any special access to IRS agents that regular people don't have.

0 coins

The service works by using automated technology to navigate the IRS phone system and hold your place in line. They don't have any special access - they're just using technology to handle the waiting part, which is the most frustrating aspect of calling the IRS. You definitely can't just email the IRS for specific tax questions like this - they don't offer that service for international tax questions. They direct you to call, which is exactly the problem. The IRS phone lines are notoriously busy, especially during tax season, with wait times often exceeding 2 hours. For international callers, that can mean substantial phone charges and often getting disconnected after a long wait.

0 coins

I need to apologize about my previous comment. I was really skeptical about Claimyr but decided to try it as a last resort after spending THREE DAYS trying to reach the IRS myself regarding my W8-BEN questions. It actually worked exactly as described. The service held my place in line (which took about 1.5 hours according to their tracker) and then called me when they reached an agent. I spoke directly with an IRS representative who confirmed exactly how to handle the treaty benefits section as a Spanish freelancer. The agent explained that I needed to cite the specific treaty article and that this would prevent the US company from withholding taxes. Would have saved me so much stress if I'd tried this earlier instead of guessing based on contradictory internet advice!

0 coins

Just to add a practical note from someone who's been freelancing for US companies from Madrid for about 3 years now - make sure you also understand how this impacts your "declaración de la renta" here in Spain. When you correctly fill out the W8-BEN with the treaty information, your US clients won't withhold any tax. That means you'll need to account for ALL of that income when you file taxes here. I set aside approximately 20% of all my US income throughout the year to cover what I'll owe. Also, keep in mind that you still need to charge VAT to US clients if you exceed the annual threshold, even though they're outside the EU. The rules changed a bit in recent years and caught me by surprise.

0 coins

Do you need to register for VAT even if you're just starting out with freelancing? I thought there was a minimum income threshold before you had to charge VAT.

0 coins

You're right that there's a threshold. In Spain, you don't need to register for VAT until your annual income exceeds €60,000 (though you can voluntarily register earlier if it benefits you). If you're just starting out as a freelancer, you likely won't need to charge VAT immediately. However, you still need to track your income carefully, because once you cross that threshold, registration becomes mandatory. Many freelancers find it easier to register from the beginning to avoid having to suddenly change their invoicing processes mid-year.

0 coins

One thing that tripped me up when I first filled out W8-BEN forms as a Spanish freelancer was the expiration date. These forms are valid for 3 years unless your circumstances change (like if you move to a different country or change your tax residency status). I lost a client because I didn't realize my form had expired and payments got held up. Now I keep a spreadsheet with all the forms I've submitted to different clients and when they expire, so I can proactively send updated ones. Has anyone used any of the tax software options to help manage this? I'm still doing it manually and it's becoming a pain as I get more international clients.

0 coins

I use FreeAgent for tracking all my international clients and invoices. It has a reminder feature you can set up for document expirations like W8-BEN forms. Not perfect but better than a spreadsheet.

0 coins

As a Spanish freelancer who's been working with US clients for over two years, I can confirm that the advice about Article 14 of the Spain-US tax treaty is spot on. When I first started, I made the mistake of not claiming treaty benefits and had 30% withholding taken from my payments - it was a nightmare trying to get that money back. For section 9, definitely put "Spain" as your country of residence. For section 10, you want to reference "Article 14 - Independent Personal Services" and claim 0% withholding rate. Make sure you're performing all work while physically in Spain, as this is crucial for treaty eligibility. One additional tip - keep detailed records of when and where you perform your work. I use a simple time tracking app that logs my location, just in case there are ever questions about treaty eligibility. Also, make sure your Spanish tax ID (NIF) is correctly entered in section 6 of the form. The good news is once you get the hang of it, the W8-BEN becomes routine. I now have a template saved that I just update with client information each time. Just remember to renew every 3 years!

0 coins

This is really helpful! I'm just getting started with US clients and was worried about the whole tax withholding situation. Quick question - when you mention using a time tracking app that logs location, do you have any specific recommendations? I want to make sure I'm properly documenting everything from the beginning rather than trying to recreate records later if needed. Also, did you run into any issues with your Spanish tax advisor understanding the US treaty provisions? I'm wondering if I should find someone who specializes in international freelancer taxes or if a regular tax professional here would be sufficient.

0 coins

IRS AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,087 users helped today