I switched from S-corp back to Sched C last year. For me it was a no-brainer since I only made like $35k profit and was paying almost $2k for tax prep plus that $800 CA fee. My accountant showed that I was LOSING money with the S-corp structure at my income level.

The threshold question is really key here. From what I've seen with my own consulting business, the S-corp structure typically becomes worthwhile when you're consistently hitting $40k+ in profit, but it also depends heavily on your state fees and accounting costs. At $30k profit, you're right on the borderline. The self-employment tax savings could be around $1,500-2,000 annually if you structure the salary/distribution split correctly, but that California $800 fee plus professional tax prep costs can easily eat into those savings. One thing to consider is the trend of your business - if you expect to grow beyond $40k profit in the next year or two, it might be worth keeping the S-corp structure in place. Converting back and forth between entity types can be more costly and complicated than just maintaining the structure through a lower-profit year. Have you calculated your total annual costs for maintaining the S-corp (state fees, accounting, payroll processing if applicable)? That's really the number you need to compare against your potential self-employment tax savings to make this decision.

Here's another angle to consider with your daughter's scholarship: If she's planning to go to grad school eventually, it might be worth strategically making some of the scholarship taxable during undergrad years when her income is super low. That way she preserves more scholarship money for later when the AOTC isn't available anymore. My daughter did this - we paid the first $4,000 of tuition out of pocket each year (getting the full AOTC on our return), and allocated some scholarship to room/board (making it taxable to her). Because her only income was that taxable scholarship portion, her tax rate was minimal. She ended up with extra scholarship money that carried over, which she used for a summer research program and the first semester of her master's program. Just something else to consider if grad school might be in the picture eventually.

One thing nobody's mentioned yet - if your daughter does any paid internships or has other income during college, that will affect the kiddie tax calculations too. My son had a full scholarship similar to your daughter's, but then got a paid research position in his sophomore year that pushed his income up. This complicated things because suddenly some of his scholarship income was being taxed at OUR marginal rate instead of his lower rate. We had to adjust our tax planning mid-year. Just something to keep in mind if she might work during school at all!

Has anyone used the IRS Tax Tool for Education Credits to figure this out? I tried using it but got confused when it asked about "qualified expenses paid with tax-free educational assistance" versus "qualified expenses paid by me." Not sure how to split these up correctly.

I went through this exact situation with my daughter two years ago and it was definitely confusing at first! You're on the right track with your understanding. A few key points that helped me figure it out: 1. You're correct that the scholarship money covering room and board becomes taxable income that needs to be reported somewhere - either on your return or your daughter's. 2. For the American Opportunity Credit, you can still claim it for any qualified expenses you paid out-of-pocket. Since you mentioned paying $650 for textbooks, that alone could qualify you for a partial AOC (up to $650 credit in this case). 3. The decision between reporting the taxable scholarship on your return vs. having your daughter file her own really depends on your tax bracket vs. hers. If the taxable scholarship amount is under the standard deduction ($13,850 for 2025), having her file separately usually saves money. 4. Don't forget about Form 8863 - you'll need it if you're claiming the AOC, and it helps calculate exactly how much scholarship money is taxable vs. non-taxable. One thing that really helped me was getting all the documentation together first - the 1098-T from the school, all scholarship award letters, and receipts for what you paid out-of-pocket. Having everything organized made the whole process much clearer. You can definitely still claim her as a dependent regardless of which approach you take for the scholarship taxation!

isnt there a way to get more than the $5250 tax free? my friend said something about working in an education field can make more of it tax free but idk if thats true

This is such a common issue with executive programs! I went through something similar with my part-time MBA. One thing that really helped me was understanding that you can actually optimize your tax situation by being strategic about when you request reimbursements from your employer. Since your program spans multiple years and you have some control over when you submit your passing grades for reimbursement, you might want to consider timing your requests to maximize the $5,250 exclusion each year. For example, if you complete multiple modules in 2024, you could potentially delay submitting some grade reports until early 2025 so the reimbursement comes in 2026 instead of 2025. Also, make sure you're tracking any fees that might be considered "qualified education expenses" beyond just tuition - things like technology fees, lab fees, or required course materials. These might qualify for education credits even if they don't qualify for the employer reimbursement exclusion. The timing mismatch you're dealing with is totally normal and the IRS understands this happens with employer programs. Just keep detailed records of everything and you'll be fine!

I completely understand your frustration! I went through something very similar last year with my 2/22 DD date. The waiting is absolutely nerve-wracking, especially when you really need that money. From what I've learned through my own experience and research, that 2/24 date is more of a "no earlier than" date rather than a guaranteed arrival date. The IRS releases the funds, but then it has to go through multiple processing steps before it hits your Credit Karma account. In my case, it took about 6 days total from the DD date to actually see the money in my account. I know it's hard to be patient when you're dealing with financial stress from your divorce, but it should arrive within the next few days. Keep checking your account and maybe also monitor your tax transcript to see if the status has updated to "refund sent.

I'm going through the exact same situation right now! My DD date was also 2/24 with Credit Karma and I'm still waiting. I've been checking my account obsessively every few hours and it's driving me crazy. Reading through these comments has been really helpful though - especially learning about the 5 business day processing window from IRS Publication 2043 that @Lauren Wood mentioned. I checked my tax transcript this morning and it shows "Refund Sent" with a 2/24 date, so I know the IRS has released it. Based on what everyone is saying here, it sounds like we just need to hang in there a few more days while it works through all the banking processing steps. The waiting is brutal when you need the money, but at least we're not alone in this!