Can I preserve my 3k capital loss carryforward when filing with no income?

I'm a foreign national with some short term capital losses carried forward from when I was a US tax resident. For 2024, I'm considered a non-resident and have zero US source income, but I'm still filing a 1040NR to maintain the capital loss carryforward. The issue I'm running into is that when I'm preparing my taxes, the software is automatically using $3,000 of my carried forward losses against zero income, essentially wasting it by declaring my net income as negative $3,000. I was planning to save these losses to offset future taxes and penalties when I eventually withdraw from my IRA and HSA accounts. But Schedule D line 21 seems to be forcing me to use up $3,000 of the carryforward even though I have no income to offset! Is this how it's supposed to work? Am I really required to burn through $3k of my losses when I have no income to offset? Is there any way to preserve my entire capital loss carryforward amount for future years when I'll actually have US taxable income?

0 coins

20 comments

Kara Yoshida

•8M

The tax code is a bit frustrating in this situation. Unfortunately, what you're seeing is correct - the system is designed to use up to $3,000 of capital losses against ordinary income each year, regardless of whether you have income to offset or not. When you file as a non-resident with no US source income, Schedule D still processes the capital loss carryforward according to standard rules, which means you "use" $3,000 per year even if you have no income to offset. The IRS doesn't have a mechanism to "pause" the usage of capital loss carryforwards when you have no income. What you might want to consider is whether you need to file a return at all for a year with no US source income. As a non-resident alien with no US source income, you typically aren't required to file. By not filing in years with no income, you might be able to preserve those losses until you return to US tax residency or have US source income again.

0 coins

Kara Yoshida

•8M

That's an excellent question. If you don't file a return during years with no US income, you would still maintain your capital loss carryforward. The key is documentation - keep copies of your previous tax returns showing the capital loss carryforward amount. When you later file a return with US income, you would report the full carryforward amount from the last filed return. The IRS doesn't require continuous filing to maintain capital loss carryforwards. The losses remain available until used or until they expire (which they don't under current law). Just make sure you have proper documentation of the loss amount from your last filed return to substantiate your claim when you do file again.

0 coins

Philip Cowan

•8M

After struggling with a similar capital loss carryforward situation last year, I found this amazing tool at https://taxr.ai that really helped figure out the optimal strategy. I was a dual-status taxpayer with complex investments and wasn't sure how to handle my carryforward losses when moving between countries. The tool analyzed my situation and explained exactly how the capital loss carryforward works across tax years with different residency statuses. It even showed me how to structure my documentation for future years when I wasn't required to file. Saved me from making some major mistakes that would have cost thousands!

0 coins

Philip Cowan

•8M

The tool specifically addresses non-resident filing requirements and has a whole module dedicated to capital loss treatment for different residency statuses. It shows which forms you need and how to properly document carryforwards when you're not filing every year. It's designed exactly for situations like yours. For complex international situations, it actually offers more consistent advice than some CPAs I consulted. The system is built on thousands of real tax scenarios and IRS rulings, so it catches those international nuances that general tax preparers often miss. Unlike a general CPA, it specializes in these exact cross-border situations.

0 coins

Caesar Grant

•8M

Just wanted to follow up - I tried taxr.ai after posting here and it was incredibly helpful! I uploaded my previous returns and documentation, and it immediately identified the optimal strategy for my non-resident capital losses. What surprised me was how it explained the documentation requirements for "pausing" my capital loss usage during non-filing years. The tool generated a complete explanation of how the loss carryforward works with my specific residency pattern, with citations to the relevant tax code sections. It even created a document I can include with future returns to explain the gap years. This is exactly what I needed - clear guidance on handling my capital losses while living abroad.

0 coins

Gemma Andrews

•8M

If you're going to need to deal with the IRS about this capital loss carryforward issue, good luck reaching them directly. I spent weeks trying to get through on the international taxpayer line with no luck. Then I found https://claimyr.com and used their service. You can see how it works here: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c They got me connected to an actual IRS agent within 24 hours. The agent confirmed that I could maintain my capital loss carryforward during non-filing years as a non-resident, but recommended specific documentation to include when I file again. Was absolutely worth it to get official guidance instead of stressing about whether I was doing it right.

0 coins

Gemma Andrews

•8M

They use a sophisticated system that navigates the IRS phone tree and waits on hold for you. When they finally reach an agent, you get a call to connect with that agent immediately. So yes, they're making the call, but they're handling all the waiting and navigation that can take hours or days of repeated attempts. The value isn't just "making a call" - it's avoiding the frustration of calling multiple times, waiting on hold for hours, getting disconnected, and repeating. For international callers especially, timing the calls during US business hours can be extremely difficult. I was skeptical too until I tried it and got connected after weeks of failing on my own.

0 coins

Lena Schultz

•8M

I need to eat my words here. After posting my skeptical comment, I decided to try Claimyr since I'd been struggling to reach the IRS about my own international tax situation for nearly a month. I'm absolutely shocked - they got me through to an IRS agent yesterday morning. The agent confirmed exactly what I needed to know about my capital loss carryforward from when I was a US resident. They explained I can "pause" using the losses by not filing in years without US income, and resume claiming them when I have US source income again by referencing my last filed return. For anyone dealing with these complex international tax situations, getting definitive answers directly from the IRS provides incredible peace of mind. I've wasted so much time with useless hold music and disconnections - wish I'd found this service months ago.

0 coins

Mae Bennett

•8M

Another option to consider: if you anticipate having US source income in the near future (within a year or two), it might be worth exploring if you could generate some minimal US source income this year just to take advantage of the $3k loss offset. Perhaps some small consulting work or other activity that would generate a small amount of US source income to "use" the loss against. Just make sure the income is actually US-sourced and reportable on a 1040NR. This isn't worth it if you won't have US income for many years, but could be strategic if it's just a temporary pause in your US income stream.

0 coins

Mae Bennett

•8M

Exactly! If you generated $3,000 in US source income (properly reported on your 1040NR) and then applied $3,000 of your capital loss carryforward against it, you'd effectively "zero out" - using the loss productively rather than wasting it against no income. You'd likely end up with zero tax liability (assuming no other complications), and you'd be getting value from the capital loss that would otherwise be wasted. Just make sure any consulting or other work is properly structured to be US-source income reportable on a 1040NR, as the sourcing rules can be complex for services performed outside the US.

0 coins

Emma Wilson

•5M

I went through a very similar situation a few years ago when I transitioned from US resident to non-resident status. The forced $3,000 annual usage of capital losses against zero income was incredibly frustrating, especially when I knew I'd have significant US income again in the future. What I learned from my tax attorney is that you have two main options: either accept the annual $3,000 "waste" by continuing to file, or skip filing entirely during years with no US source income to preserve the full carryforward amount. The key insight is that as a non-resident with no US source income, you're generally not required to file a return at all. I chose to stop filing during my zero-income years and documented everything carefully. When I resumed filing three years later with US source income, I was able to claim the full original carryforward amount. Just make sure you keep detailed records of your last filed return showing the capital loss carryforward balance - this becomes your reference point when you resume filing. The IRS doesn't penalize you for gaps in filing when you have no filing requirement, and your capital losses remain valid indefinitely under current law.

0 coins