IRS
CommunityGovernment Services
Can't reach IRS? Claimyr calls for you, so you don't have to wait on hold.
Claimyr is a pay-as-you-go service. We do not charge a recurring subscription.
Using Claimyr will:
- Connect you to a human agent at the IRS
- Skip the long phone menu
- Call the correct department
- Redial until on hold
- Forward a call to your phone with reduced hold time
- Give you free callbacks if the IRS drops your call
Ask the community...
- DO post questions about your issues.
- DO answer questions and support each other.
- DO post tips & tricks to help folks.
- DO NOT post call problems here - there is a support tab at the top for that :)
Is my Education Credit (AOTC) refund amount over $1,000 correct?
Has anyone else experienced this with their education credits this year? I'm totally confused about the refundable amount for the American Opportunity Tax Credit (AOTC). I thought the maximum refundable portion was capped at $1,000, but I'm getting weird numbers from different tax software. I entered all my education expenses and 1098-T information into both TaxAct and TurboTax just to double check. TaxAct is showing me a refund of like $2,400 specifically from education credits! TurboTax is a bit more reasonable but still shows $1,402 for the AOTC portion. This doesn't seem right based on what I've read about the $1,000 limit. I've used both software programs before and they've been reliable, but these numbers are making me nervous. Are there some new rules for 2024 I'm not aware of, or am I entering something wrong? Maybe there's another education credit being applied that I don't know about?
Join the conversation
Comparing Cashapp Tax (formerly CreditKarma) vs FreeTaxUSA for rental property owners
I've been using TurboTax for years but finally decided to break up with Intuit this tax season. Wanted to share my experience using both FreeTaxUSA and Cashapp Taxes (formerly CreditKarma) since I have a slightly more complex situation with a couple rental properties, depreciation tracking, and various rental expenses. Both platforms got me to the exact same refund amount, which was reassuring. But the experience between them was pretty different. FreeTaxUSA was WAY easier to navigate between sections. You can jump around using tabs and links to specific areas you need to edit. With Cashapp, I found myself clicking through endless questions just to modify one field that was at the end of a sequence - super annoying when you need to make a simple change! The biggest difference was that FreeTaxUSA successfully imported my previous year's TurboTax data, including all my rental property depreciation schedules. Only had one small number that was slightly off. Cashapp doesn't seem to have this import capability beyond basic personal info. For rental owners, FreeTaxUSA generated a detailed Depreciation and Amortization report similar to what TurboTax provides. This is crucial for audit protection and future tax filings. I couldn't find anything like this in Cashapp, though their support claimed something similar should be available but couldn't tell me where to find it. Anyone else try both? Other experiences with rental properties on either platform?
Join the conversation
Has anyone had issues with the state return portion of Cashapp Tax? I tried using it for my rentals that are in a different state from where I live and it seemed confused about how to handle the income allocation. Ended up switching to FreeTaxUSA and it handled the multi-state situation much better.
Yes!! Cashapp was a disaster for my multi-state situation. I have rentals in Colorado but live in Texas. It kept trying to make me file resident returns in both states and the support was clueless. FreeTaxUSA correctly set up non-resident return for the rental state.
I had exactly the same experience! The software seemed to get confused between resident and non-resident state filing requirements. It kept prompting me to enter information that wasn't relevant to my situation. FreeTaxUSA immediately recognized that I needed a non-resident return for the state where my rental was located. The questionnaire was much more straightforward and accurately allocated income to the appropriate states. Their state filing support is definitely superior for rental property owners with multi-state situations.
Does anyone know if either of these can handle depreciation recapture if you sell a rental? I might sell one of my properties next year and I know that's a tax nightmare with the different rates for regular gains vs depreciation recapture.
FreeTaxUSA handles it pretty well. I sold a rental last year after owning it for 9 years and it walked me through calculating the recaptured depreciation at the 25% rate separate from the long-term capital gains. Just make sure you have good records of all the depreciation you've taken over the years!
Does COE (College of Education) permit double taxation on education expenses? I feel like I'm losing my mind...
So I'm a third-year teacher working in a public school district and I recently started a Master's program through my state's College of Education. I was told by colleagues that I could deduct my education expenses on my taxes, but when I spoke with the bursar's office, they said something that made no sense to me. Apparently the tuition I'm paying ($4,200 per semester) is subject to both state and federal taxes, even though I'm using my post-tax income to pay for it? I specifically asked if I could deduct these expenses when I file my taxes next year, and they said "the College of Education program is already factored into state education budgets" whatever that means. This feels like I'm being double-taxed on my education expenses! I'm paying with money I've already been taxed on, and then can't deduct it even though it's directly related to my career? Is this actually how it works or am I missing something? I've heard other teachers talk about education tax credits and deductions so I'm completely confused. Has anyone else dealt with this? Does COE actually have some special tax status I don't know about? Help!
Join the conversation
Just FYI - I work in university administration (not at a COE) and what that bursar told you is complete nonsense. There's no special tax status for Colleges of Education that prevents students from claiming education tax benefits. My guess is the person you spoke with was confused about how the institution itself is funded or taxed, which has absolutely nothing to do with your personal tax situation as a student paying tuition. ALWAYS consult with a tax professional rather than university administrative staff about tax matters. We're not trained in personal tax law and shouldn't be giving that kind of advice to students.
That's what I suspected! I was so confused because it directly contradicted what other teachers in my district told me about their education expenses. Is there any documentation I should specifically request from the university to help with claiming education credits?
You should definitely request Form 1098-T from your university, which shows your tuition payments and is required for claiming education credits. Also keep all receipts for required books, supplies, and equipment as these can sometimes be included in qualified education expenses depending on the credit you're claiming. Make sure the 1098-T shows your payments rather than just amounts billed. Some universities only report billed amounts by default, which can cause issues with your tax filing. You may need to specifically request a 1098-T that shows actual payments made during the tax year.
Has anyone here successfully claimed both the LLC (Lifetime Learning Credit) AND deducted professional development expenses on Schedule C if you do some independent consulting work? I've been told different things by different tax preparers.
You can potentially do both but NOT for the same expenses. If you claim certain expenses for the LLC, you cannot also deduct those same expenses on Schedule C. It would be considered double-dipping. However, if you have enough education expenses, you could use some for the LLC (up to the $10k limit) and then deduct additional, separate expenses on Schedule C if they're directly related to your self-employment work.
Thanks for clarifying! That makes sense - I wasn't sure if it was an either/or situation or if I could split the expenses between the two. I'll make sure to track which expenses I'm applying to each category.
Tax deductions for self-rental arrangement in our primary residence - legal strategy?
I wanted to get some feedback on a tax strategy we're considering for our new home purchase: 1. My husband works in software development making around $240k annually (W2 income) 2. I'm primarily a stay-at-home mom but also work as a licensed real estate agent managing our portfolio of 5 rental properties. I satisfy the material participation requirements, so we can offset rental losses against regular income 3. We're planning to purchase a new primary residence in the $2M range Here's what we're thinking: Instead of buying the house directly, we'd purchase it through an LLC and then rent it to ourselves at fair market value. The LLC would operate at a loss of approximately $45k annually due to property taxes, mortgage interest, and other expenses. Since I qualify as a real estate professional and meet material participation requirements, we could potentially deduct these losses against my husband's substantial W2 income. This approach looks like it would save us significantly compared to a traditional purchase. We've consulted with a tax professional who indicated this should work fine as long as we're charging ourselves legitimate market rent. Does anyone have experience with this strategy? Are there potential issues or pitfalls we should be aware of? Would appreciate any insights!
Join the conversation
Be VERY careful with this strategy! I tried something similar in 2023 and ended up being audited. The issue wasn't the self-rental itself but the "economic substance" of the arrangement. The IRS argued that the transaction lacked a legitimate business purpose beyond tax avoidance. Some things that tripped me up: - Not having proper insurance (needs to be landlord insurance, not homeowner's) - Using personal accounts for some property expenses - Not having a formal lease with all proper terms - Not being able to prove fair market rent (you need comparable properties) The audit cost me more than I ever would have saved, plus I had to amend three years of returns. Just be absolutely certain your documentation is bulletproof if you go this route.
This is exactly the kind of real-world experience I was hoping to learn from. Would you mind sharing what documentation the IRS specifically questioned during your audit? And did you qualify as a real estate professional or were you trying a different approach?
The documentation they zeroed in on was my activity log for proving real estate professional status. I claimed to meet the requirements but my records were inconsistent and some activities I counted weren't considered "material participation" by the auditor. I did qualify as a real estate professional based on hours, but they questioned whether I was truly spending more time on real estate than my primary job. They wanted to see detailed, contemporaneous records - not just a spreadsheet I created after the fact. They also scrutinized whether the rent I charged myself was truly market rate, asking for multiple comparable properties and professional rental assessments. One major issue was commingling of funds between personal and business accounts. They viewed this as evidence I wasn't treating the LLC as a separate entity. Make sure every expense goes through separate accounts and that you have a formal process for paying rent that looks like a true landlord-tenant relationship.
Has anyone considered the insurance implications of this arrangement? Most homeowner's policies won't cover claims if you're technically renting from an LLC that you own. You'd need a landlord policy for the LLC and a renter's policy for yourselves. Also, what about mortgage considerations? Many residential mortgages have occupancy clauses requiring the borrower to occupy the property. If the LLC takes the mortgage but doesn't occupy it, you might be violating the terms.
Good points. Also worth mentioning that mortgage rates for investment properties are typically higher than primary residences, often by 0.5-1%. So even if you find a lender willing to do this arrangement, you'll likely pay more for the mortgage, which could offset some of the tax savings.
W2-C Form Received After Filing: Do I Need to Amend My Tax Return?
Hey everyone, I'm freaking out a bit here. So I already filed my 2024 taxes back in February, and then yesterday I get this W2-C form in the mail from my employer. Apparently they accidentally listed income for Pennsylvania when I never actually worked there at all (I've been in Arizona the whole time). The W2-C basically shows they're removing about $7,800 of income from PA and properly assigning it to AZ where I actually live and work. The federal info is all the same - same total income, same withholding amounts. It's just this state allocation issue. Do I need to file an amended return now? I've never dealt with a W2-C before and I'm worried I'll mess something up. I already got my federal refund about 3 weeks ago, and I'm waiting on my AZ refund still. Would really appreciate any advice on what I need to do here!
Join the conversation
One thing nobody's mentioning - check if the W-2C affects your county or city taxes too! Some places have local income taxes that piggyback off state reporting.
This!!! I had a W-2C a couple years ago and completely overlooked my city taxes. Ended up getting a notice 6 months later for underpayment and penalties 😭
Thanks for bringing this up! Fortunately Arizona doesn't have county income taxes, just state-level. So I think I'm ok on that front but it's definitely something important for others to consider.
Keisha Jackson
Different tax softwares display education credits differently on the summary screens, which causes so much confusion! In my experience: - TurboTax tends to show the "impact" of the AOTC on your refund, not just the refundable amount - H&R Block typically separates the refundable and non-refundable portions more clearly - TaxAct sometimes lumps all credits together which makes it look like you're getting more back The key is to look at Form 8863 in the actual PDF of your return. Line 8 is your total AOTC, and line 8c specifically shows the refundable portion which cannot exceed $1,000 per eligible student.
0 coins
Paolo Moretti
Is there any way to see this breakdown before finalizing the return? I'm using TaxAct and it's just giving me a big total number for "education credits" without splitting it up.
0 coins
Keisha Jackson
Yes, in TaxAct you can view the forms directly before filing. Go to the "Review" section, then look for an option like "View Tax Forms" or "Preview Tax Return." Find Form 8863 (Education Credits) in the forms list. On that form, you'll see the breakdown with line 8c showing specifically how much is refundable. In general, any good tax software should let you preview the actual IRS forms before filing. This is the best way to see exactly what's happening with your credits, rather than relying on the simplified summary screens which can be misleading.
0 coins
Amina Diop
I got audited last year specifically for AOTC and learned the hard way what happens when software gets it wrong! Make sure you have documentation for ALL your qualified education expenses: 1) Your 1098-T from your school 2) Receipts for required textbooks and supplies (even if not purchased from the school bookstore) 3) Receipts for required course-specific fees not included on 1098-T 4) Proof you were enrolled at least half-time for at least one academic period The IRS specifically looks for people claiming the refundable portion of AOTC incorrectly. Double check that you're eligible - you must be pursuing a degree, cannot have completed 4 years of college already, and need to meet the income requirements.
0 coins
Oliver Weber
Did you end up owing money back after your audit? I'm worried because I claimed some textbooks but don't have all the receipts.
0 coins