


Ask the community...
I went through this same identity verification nightmare last year! What finally worked for me was sending in Form 14039 (Identity Theft Affidavit) by certified mail with copies of my ID. Even though I hadn't actually had my identity stolen, this form triggers a manual review of your case and gets assigned to the Identity Theft department. About 3 weeks after sending it, I got a call from an IRS identity theft specialist who worked with me to verify my identity and release my refund. The whole process took about 6 weeks from mailing the form to getting my refund, but at least it worked!
Wouldn't filing an identity theft form when your identity wasn't actually stolen cause more problems? I'm worried that might flag my account in a bad way for future years.
That's a good question. When you can't verify your identity through normal channels, the IRS actually recommends filing Form 14039 with the box checked for "I received a notice from the IRS and believe someone may have used my SSN." Since you received notices about identity verification, this is technically accurate. It doesn't create problems for future years - actually, it creates an extra layer of protection. After resolving my case, they added additional security to my tax account and gave me a special PIN to use for future filings. Made me feel more secure, honestly!
Does anybody know if going to the appointment with a TAX PRO who prepared your return helps with these identity verification issues? My cousin said her accountant went with her and it made everything go smoother.
I'm a tax preparer and yes, this can definitely help! If we prepared your return, we can go with you to the appointment and bring our records which often helps verify everything more quickly. We can also contact the Practitioner Priority Service on your behalf, which is a special IRS hotline only for tax professionals that usually has much shorter wait times.
Another option to consider is calling the IRS directly at 800-829-1040. If you explain that your W2s were returned to sender and you can't reach your employer, they can sometimes help. You'll need your social security number, personal info, and an estimate of your income/withholding (check your last paystub of the year). If your employers are being unresponsive, the IRS might even contact them on your behalf. Just be prepared to wait on hold for a long time when you call.
Have you actually managed to get through to the IRS this way recently? I tried calling that number three times last week and couldn't get past the automated system - it just disconnected me after saying they had too many calls.
I've gotten through in the past, but you're right that it's extremely difficult during peak tax season. Your best chance is to call right when they open (7am EST) and be prepared to navigate through several automated menus. Choose the option for "having a problem with your taxes" rather than "need forms" to increase your chances of reaching a person. I should have mentioned that this approach requires a lot of patience and might take multiple attempts. If time is crucial, some of the other options people have suggested might be faster.
Don't forget to check if your W2s are available on the SSA website! Go to https://www.ssa.gov/myaccount/ and create an account if you don't have one. Sometimes you can view your W2 information there even if you don't have the physical forms.
The SSA site only shows your lifetime earnings record, not current year W2 details. That won't help with filing taxes for this year. You need the actual W2 or the IRS wage transcript.
My brother is an enrolled agent and says if you have proof the agent falsified data, you should absolutely report it. He said that while most revenue agents are professional, there are a few bad apples who feel pressured to meet certain quotas. Keep in mind that for a formal misconduct complaint, you'll need more than just "they were mean" or "they interpreted my deductions differently." You need clear evidence of actual falsification or lying. Examples would be: - They claimed you never submitted documents that you have proof of submitting - They used income figures that clearly contradict your W-2s or 1099s - They disallowed deductions for reasons that contradict written IRS guidance Don't report just because you're upset about being audited. But if there was actual misconduct, definitely report it!
Thanks for the advice. I definitely have clear evidence. The agent claimed I never provided certain bank statements which I have delivery confirmations for. They also calculated my business income using figures that completely ignored several legitimate business expenses that were clearly documented and submitted. When my CPA pointed this out, the agent just ignored it. The most frustrating part was when they claimed certain deductions weren't eligible when the actual IRS publications specifically list them as qualifying expenses.
Those examples sound exactly like the kind of evidence needed for a legitimate complaint. The fact that you have delivery confirmations for documents they claimed you never provided is particularly important - that's a clear factual dispute, not just a difference in interpretation. I'd recommend organizing all this evidence chronologically in a simple document that clearly outlines each instance of misconduct. Include dates, specific claims made by the agent, and your contradicting evidence. This will make it much easier for TIGTA to investigate. My brother says the more specific and factual your complaint is (rather than emotional), the more seriously it will be taken.
Has anyone considered that maybe the agent wasn't lying but just incompetent? I had a revenue agent who made tons of mistakes during my audit but it seemed more like they didn't understand business expenses for my industry rather than intentional deception. Still frustrating but not necessarily malicious.
There's definitely a difference between incompetence and fraud. I've dealt with both. Incompetence is when they make calculation errors or misapply tax law because they don't understand it. Fraud/lying is when they claim you never sent documents that you have proof of sending, or when they intentionally ignore valid deductions. The key difference is usually in how they respond when corrected. An incompetent agent will usually acknowledge mistakes when pointed out clearly. A dishonest one will double down or ignore evidence that contradicts their position.
One thing nobody's mentioned - if any of your new appliances are energy efficient, you might qualify for energy credits under the Inflation Reduction Act. We got about $840 back on our taxes last year after installing a new energy efficient water heater and upgrading our electric panel. Check out Form 5695 for residential energy credits. The rules changed in 2022 so some of the online advice is outdated. Pretty sure electrical panel upgrades can qualify for a credit now!
Do you know if there's an income limit for claiming these energy credits? I heard somewhere that if you make over a certain amount you don't qualify for them.
There aren't income limits for the basic Residential Clean Energy Credit (Part I of Form 5695) which covers things like solar panels and geothermal heat pumps. You get 30% of the cost back as a credit regardless of income. For the Energy Efficient Home Improvement Credit (Part II of Form 5695) which would cover things like insulation, windows, doors, and potentially some electrical work, there also aren't income limits currently. However, there are maximum credit amounts depending on the type of improvement. For example, there's a $600 limit for certain high-efficiency exterior windows and a $500 limit for certain exterior doors.
Has anyone used TurboTax to handle home improvement stuff? I'm trying to figure out if their basic version covers this or if I need to upgrade to deluxe or premier?
Emma Davis
Quick tip from someone who went through this: Make sure all your tax RETURNS are filed up to date before applying for any Fresh Start options. Even if you can't pay what you owe, having all returns filed is a prerequisite. Also, if you're self-employed now, make sure you're making your estimated quarterly tax payments going forward. The IRS is much more likely to work with you on old debt if you're compliant with current taxes. I learned this the hard way!
0 coins
Malik Johnson
ā¢Do you know if there's a waiting period for the Fresh Start Initiative? Like, can you apply if you just became unable to pay your taxes this year, or do they expect you to have been struggling for a certain amount of time?
0 coins
Emma Davis
ā¢There's no specific waiting period for the Fresh Start Initiative programs. You can apply as soon as you realize you can't pay your tax debt in full. The qualification is based on your current financial situation, not how long you've been struggling. What matters more is demonstrating that you can't pay the full amount without causing financial hardship. This is where documenting your income, expenses, assets, and debts becomes important. They want to see that you're making a good faith effort to comply with tax laws going forward, but genuinely can't address the past debt in full immediately.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
Has anyone used a tax professional for the Fresh Start application process? I'm trying to decide if it's worth paying someone or just doing it myself. My situation isn't super complicated but I'm worried about saying the wrong thing and messing up my chances.
0 coins
Ravi Sharma
ā¢I used a tax pro for my Offer in Compromise under Fresh Start. Cost me $1,500 but they got my $32k tax debt settled for $8k, so definitely worth it in my case. If you're just doing a simple installment agreement though, you might be able to handle it yourself.
0 coins