


Ask the community...
Your employer doesn't have any responsibility to make sure your withholding is correct. That's entirely on you. I always double-check my first few paystubs at any new job to make sure everything looks right. For federal income tax on $12,700, you should have been withholding around $1,200+ for the year (roughly 10%). When you only saw $96 total, that should have been an immediate red flag.
Yeah, I definitely see that now. I just never thought to check since I assumed they knew what they were doing. Is there a good rule of thumb for how much should be withheld?
A good rule of thumb for single filers with one job and no dependents is to expect roughly 10-15% of your gross pay to be withheld for federal income taxes. The exact percentage varies based on your income level, but if you're seeing significantly less than 10%, that's usually a sign something's wrong. For your income level around $12,700, you should expect to see roughly $100-125 in federal withholding per month. When you see numbers way below that (like $8 per month), it's definitely time to talk to HR or payroll.
This is why I always fill out a new W4 claiming ZERO exemptions even though I could claim more. I'd rather get a refund than owe money. Last year I got back almost $3k!
Don't forget about state taxes too! Depending on your last state of residence in the US (California in your case), you might still have state filing requirements. California is particularly aggressive about claiming residents, even those living abroad. Since you left as an infant, you probably have a strong case for not being a CA resident, but you might need to formally break residency to be safe.
I hadn't even thought about state taxes! Do I need to file something specific with California to establish that I'm not a resident there? I literally haven't lived there since I was 11 months old.
Since you left as an infant, you should be fine without formally breaking residency - you never established it as an adult. California typically looks at factors like where you have a driver's license, voter registration, bank accounts, etc. Since you have none of these connections to California, you have a very strong case for non-residency. However, to be absolutely safe, you could include a brief statement with your federal returns explaining that you left California as an infant and have no connections to the state. In rare cases, people file Form 540NR (California Nonresident Return) with zero income to formally establish non-residency, but this is usually unnecessary for someone in your situation who never established California ties as an adult.
Has anyone in a similar situation considered renouncing US citizenship? I'm a dual UK/US citizen who's never lived in the States and the annual filing requirements are just so burdensome. Wondering if it's worth it for OP to just cut ties completely rather than dealing with this compliance nightmare forever.
Renouncing is definitely an option but costs $2,350 in government fees alone, plus you need to be tax compliant for 5 years before renouncing! And if your net worth is over $2 million or your average annual tax liability exceeds $168,000 over the last 5 years, you could face an exit tax. Definitely not a quick or cheap solution.
To answer the original question directly - the filing requirement thresholds for 2024 (filing in 2025) are: - Single, under 65: $13,850 - Head of household, under 65: $20,800 - Married filing jointly, both under 65: $27,700 But there are special rules if: - You're self-employed and earned more than $400 - You owe special taxes like alternative minimum tax - You have untaxed tips - You receive health insurance credits Even if you're not required to file, you should ALWAYS file if taxes were withheld from your paychecks to get a refund!
Is there a deadline to file if you're just trying to get a refund but aren't required to file? Like if I didn't file for 2022 but had withholding, can I still get that money back?
Yes, there's definitely a deadline. You have 3 years from the original due date to file a return and claim a refund. For 2022 returns (which were due April 18, 2023), you have until April 18, 2026 to file and claim any refund you're owed. If you miss that 3-year window, you lose the refund completely - the money becomes property of the U.S. Treasury. So if you had withholding for 2022, you should definitely file before April 2026 to get that money back.
Has anyone used the free filing options on the IRS website? I'm in a similar situation making under $12k and wondering if its worth paying for TurboTax or if the free options are good enough?
The IRS Free File is actually really good for simple tax situations. If you made under $73,000, you can use it. I used it last year for my W-2 income and it was straightforward. Just go to IRS.gov and search "Free File." Don't go directly to TurboTax's website if you want the free version - go through the IRS Free File portal to make sure you actually get the completely free version. TurboTax's website often upsells you to paid versions even if you qualify for free filing.
Estate planning attorney here. The biggest misconception I see is people focusing solely on the federal estate tax exemption. Here are the top 5 reasons my clients with modest estates (under $1M) still need proper planning: 1. Probate avoidance - saves thousands in court costs and months of time 2. Incapacity planning - critical if you become unable to manage affairs 3. Blended family protection - ensures assets go where YOU want, not by default rules 4. Asset protection - shields inheritance from your children's potential divorces/creditors 5. Privacy - keeps your financial affairs private instead of public record I recently had a client with a $900k estate who saved their heirs approximately $27k in probate costs and 14 months of time by using a proper trust rather than just a will.
How often do trusts need to be updated? If I create one now in my 40s, will I need to keep paying lawyer fees to maintain it as laws change?
Trusts should be reviewed approximately every 5 years or after significant life events (marriage, divorce, births, deaths, moving to a new state, substantial changes in assets). Most people need 2-3 updates over their lifetime. You don't necessarily need to pay lawyer fees for every review. Many attorneys offer maintenance programs where you pay a small annual fee for unlimited questions and periodic reviews. Otherwise, you might pay for a review session every 5 years which typically costs 1/3 to 1/2 of the original trust creation fee. Major law changes might require updates, but those don't happen frequently for the fundamental trust provisions most people need.
When my grandma died, her estate was about $800k. She had a simple will but no trust. It took us 16 MONTHS to get through probate!!! The court fees, attorney costs, and executor fees added up to almost $35,000!!! That money could have stayed in the family. The worst part wasn't even the money - it was the stress and family fighting that happened because everything was in limbo for so long. My aunt and dad ended up not speaking for years because of disagreements during the process. Now my parents (who have about $1.2M) have set up a trust even though they're nowhere near the estate tax threshold. They said the cost was around $3,000 for everything, which is WAY less than what we lost with grandma's estate.
Did your parents use a lawyer or one of those online services? I've been looking at some of the DIY trust websites that are like $500 instead of thousands.
Natasha Orlova
One important thing nobody has mentioned - make sure you're looking at the specific rules for any state tax reciprocity agreements. Some states have agreements that let you only pay taxes to your home state even if you work in the other state. Also, the "183-day rule" isn't universal. Each state has different thresholds for when they consider you a resident for tax purposes. Some are based on property ownership or "permanent place of abode" requirements that go beyond just counting days.
0 coins
Zainab Omar
ā¢Thanks, I had no idea about reciprocity agreements. Do you know if Colorado has those with either Washington or Arizona? And what exactly counts as a "permanent place of abode" - would staying with my brother count?
0 coins
Natasha Orlova
ā¢Colorado doesn't have reciprocity agreements with Washington or Arizona, unfortunately. Reciprocity is more common among neighboring states in the Midwest and East Coast. Regarding "permanent place of abode" - this varies by state, but generally staying with a family member temporarily wouldn't qualify. However, if you have your own dedicated room that you maintain year-round, some states might consider that as evidence of residency. For Arizona specifically, they look at whether you have a residence available for your use year-round, even if you're not physically present. Since you stay with your brother only occasionally, it likely wouldn't trigger their residency rules unless you have other substantial connections to Arizona.
0 coins
Javier Cruz
Just a heads up about Washington state - while they don't have income tax, if you're doing any kind of consulting or business work while there (not just regular employment), you might be subject to their Business & Occupation tax. Caught me by surprise when I was working remotely from Seattle for a few months.
0 coins
Emma Wilson
ā¢This! I got hit with an unexpected B&O tax bill because I didn't realize my freelance work counted even though I was only temporarily in Washington. Make sure you're tracking what type of work you're doing in each location.
0 coins