


Ask the community...
Has anyone ever successfully disputed one of these offsets? I had a similar situation last year where they took my entire refund for a tax debt I was sure I'd already paid. I ended up finding proof of payment and had to go through this whole process to get my money back.
Yes! I disputed an offset successfully about two years ago. The key is documentation and persistence. I had to send in form 12277 "Application for Withdrawal of Filed Form 668(Y), Notice of Federal Tax Lien" along with all my proof of payment. Took about 8 weeks but I got the full amount returned to me.
I'm sorry you're going through this stress - the uncertainty is definitely the worst part! Based on what others have shared here, it sounds like you have several good options to get answers quickly rather than waiting weeks for the official notice. That Treasury Offset Program number (800-304-3107) seems like your best first step since it's automated and will tell you immediately what agency took your refund and for how much. At least then you'll know if it's actually IRS debt or something else like student loans or state taxes. If it does turn out to be related to that 2022 payment plan you mentioned, don't panic - even if you missed a payment or there was some administrative mix-up, these things can usually be resolved. The important thing is getting the full picture of what happened so you can take the right next steps. Keep us posted on what you find out! This community has been really helpful for people in similar situations.
I ran into this exact issue last year! Schwab didn't report some of my smaller distributions on the 1099-DIV, and when I called them, they said distributions under $10 don't need to be reported on the form according to IRS rules. Is your distribution possibly split across multiple small payments that individually fall below reporting thresholds?
This is a great question that many new investors face! Based on what you've described, it sounds like you've discovered the distribution in your Schwab Tax Center was classified as "return of capital," which explains why it didn't appear on your 1099-DIV. Here's the key takeaway: return of capital distributions are NOT taxable income in the year you receive them, so you don't need to report that $175 as dividend income on your current tax return. However, you do need to track it because it reduces your cost basis in the ETF. Think of it this way - the ETF is essentially returning part of your original investment to you, rather than paying you profits (which would be taxable dividends). When you eventually sell the ETF, you'll calculate your capital gain or loss using the reduced cost basis. Since this is only your second year investing, I'd recommend keeping a simple spreadsheet to track these adjustments. Most brokerages like Schwab will automatically adjust your cost basis in their systems, but having your own records is always helpful. You're being very responsible by double-checking everything - that attention to detail will serve you well as your investment portfolio grows!
Has anyone here actually filed with a mix of 1042-S and 1099 forms from different brokers? I'm in the same boat and I'm afraid it might trigger an audit! I'm using TurboTax and it doesn't seem to handle this situation well.
I did this last year. Used both forms as they were provided. Had to file a 1040NR for the 1042-S income and include a statement explaining why I had both types of forms. No audit, no issues. Just be sure to keep good records of all your trades regardless of how they're reported!
I've been through this exact situation! As an F1 student, you should generally be receiving 1042-S forms from all brokers, not 1099s. The difference comes down to how each broker classified your tax status when you opened your accounts. When you opened your Robinhood account, you likely filled out a W-9 form (or they incorrectly assumed you were a U.S. person), which is why they issued a 1099. With TDAmeritrade, you probably completed a W-8BEN form declaring your foreign status, which is why they correctly issued a 1042-S. For your tax filing, you should report the information exactly as provided on each form. The 1042-S doesn't itemize individual transactions because it's focused on reporting income subject to withholding (like dividends) rather than capital gains. However, you're still required to report all your capital gains and losses on Schedule D and Form 8949, even if they're not detailed on the 1042-S. You'll need to manually track your TDAmeritrade trades using their transaction history in your online account. It's tedious with 60+ trades, but necessary for proper reporting. I'd also recommend contacting Robinhood to update your tax classification for future years so you receive consistent forms from all brokers.
This is really helpful, thank you! I'm also an F1 student dealing with similar broker inconsistencies. One quick question - when you say to contact Robinhood to update the tax classification, what exactly should I ask them to change? Should I request they switch me from W-9 to W-8BEN status, or is there specific language I should use to make sure they understand the change needed? Also, did you find any issues when filing with the mixed forms? I'm worried the IRS might question why I have different reporting from different brokers in the same tax year.
Pro tip: if u get on an income based repayment plan BEFORE filing taxes they usually won't offset. Worked for me last year!
bout 3 weeks start to finish. Worth every minute of the hassle tho
Been through this nightmare myself last year. Yes, DOE offsets are definitely happening in 2024 - they resumed in October 2023 after the COVID pause ended. I had my entire refund taken except for the refundable portions like CTC and EITC. The key is to act FAST if you want to avoid it. Call the Federal Student Aid contact center at 1-800-621-3115 immediately to discuss rehabilitation or consolidation options. Even if you're already in the offset process, getting into a payment plan can sometimes stop future offsets. Don't wait - tax season moves quick and once that refund is gone, it's gone!
Rita Jacobs
Just wanted to add some reassurance from personal experience - I had a similar situation last year with about $4,500 in back taxes when I needed to renew my passport for a work trip. I was panicking thinking they'd deny my application, but it went through without any issues at all. The key thing is that $59,000 threshold everyone mentioned is absolutely correct. The IRS has to formally certify your debt as "seriously delinquent" before the State Department will deny passport services, and they only do that for much larger amounts. One tip though - if you're still worried about the accuracy of your balance, you can request a tax account transcript online through the IRS website. It's usually more up-to-date than the regular balance inquiry and will show all payments they've received, even if they haven't posted to your main account yet. That might give you peace of mind before deciding whether to pay the full amount. Your passport application should be fine, but definitely get it submitted soon given the processing delays everyone's experiencing!
0 coins
Sydney Torres
ā¢This is really helpful, thank you Rita! I didn't know about the tax account transcript option - that sounds like exactly what I need to verify my payments went through. I'll check that out right away since it might be more current than the regular online system. It's such a relief to hear from someone who went through the same thing. I was definitely overthinking this whole situation. I'm going to get my passport application submitted this week and then focus on getting that payment plan sorted out once the IRS systems are back up. Thanks for the practical advice!
0 coins
Isabella Tucker
I can definitely relate to the stress you're feeling! I went through something similar a couple years back when I owed about $2,800 to the IRS and needed to renew my passport for a family emergency overseas. Like others have mentioned, the $59,000 threshold is accurate - your $3k debt won't affect your passport application at all. But I wanted to share what worked for me regarding those payment delays you're seeing. When my payments weren't showing up online either, I called the IRS automated payment line (1-888-353-4537) instead of trying to reach a live person. You just need your SSN and the payment confirmation numbers. It was able to confirm my payments had been received even though they weren't reflected in the online account yet. Much faster than waiting on hold for hours! Also, don't stress too much about getting the exact balance perfect before making a payment. If you end up overpaying slightly, the IRS will either apply it to future tax years or send you a refund. It's better to have peace of mind and get your taxes current than to keep worrying about a few dollars here or there. Good luck with your passport application - you should be totally fine!
0 coins