


Ask the community...
I'm just wondering if anyone knows if there's a tax treaty between the US and Ecuador that might help with this situation? I know some countries have agreements to prevent double taxation.
There is no comprehensive tax treaty between the US and Ecuador specifically, which means there aren't the usual protections against double taxation that exist with many other countries. However, you can still claim a Foreign Tax Credit on your US taxes for taxes paid to Ecuador using Form 1116. This helps prevent paying full taxes twice on the same income, even without a formal treaty.
Based on what you've described, I'd strongly recommend getting professional tax advice before your grandfather sends any money back. The IRS tends to look at the economic reality of transactions rather than just the labels you put on them. Since your grandfather "considers you a partial owner" and you're expecting returns based on business performance, this could easily be viewed as an investment arrangement rather than a simple loan, even without formal ownership papers. This means any payments beyond your original $15,000 might be taxable as business income or capital gains. A few key points to consider: 1. Keep detailed records of your original $15,000 transfer with documentation showing it as startup capital 2. Any "thank you" payments tied to business success will likely be taxable income 3. True gifts from your grandfather (unrelated to the business) have different reporting requirements but aren't taxable to you 4. You'll definitely need to file FBAR if these international transfers put you over the $10,000 threshold The informal nature of your current arrangement is actually working against you tax-wise. Consider formalizing this as either a proper loan with interest or an actual investment with documented ownership percentages. This will make your tax obligations much clearer and help you avoid potential issues with the IRS down the road. Don't wait until the money starts flowing to figure this out - the structure you set up now will determine your tax liability later.
Something to consider - if you're paying more than half your mom's support and she qualifies as your dependent, make sure to look into the medical expense deduction too. Since she has dementia, there are probably substantial medical costs. If you itemize deductions, you can deduct medical expenses that exceed 7.5% of your adjusted gross income. This includes costs for diagnosis, treatment, equipment, and even some home modifications if medically necessary. Long-term care services and insurance can also qualify.
I'm dealing with a very similar situation with my father's retirement account that got transferred incorrectly. One thing that really helped me was getting everything documented properly from the beginning. Make sure you have copies of all the original annuity paperwork, the transfer documents, and any correspondence with the insurance company about reversing the ownership. You'll want to keep detailed records of exactly how much of that annuity income goes toward your mother's care - not just the direct deposits to her account, but any expenses you pay on her behalf using those funds. This documentation will be crucial if the IRS ever questions the dependency claim or support calculation. Also, consider talking to an Elder Law attorney if you haven't already. They often have experience with these exact situations and can help you navigate both the tax implications and make sure you're properly set up to handle her finances going forward. Some even offer free consultations for caregiving families. The good news is that once you get the ownership transferred back to her, this shouldn't happen again in future tax years. But definitely get professional help for this year's filing - the dependency claim combined with the income reporting makes this too complex for DIY tax software to handle properly.
This is really helpful advice about documentation! I'm curious about the Elder Law attorney suggestion - do they typically charge a lot for consultations on tax-related caregiving issues? I'm already looking at unexpected tax costs from this annuity mess, so I'm trying to be careful about additional expenses. But if it could save me money in the long run or help me avoid bigger problems, it might be worth it. Also, when you mention keeping records of expenses paid on her behalf using those funds - would things like groceries or household items count toward the support calculation? I'm trying to figure out exactly what qualifies.
These clowns at the IRS need to get it together fr... why we gotta jump thru all these hoops just to get OUR money back š¤”
Been in a similar situation - got my advocate assigned 3 weeks ago and finally got movement yesterday! They called me back within 48 hours of my initial voicemail which was promising. Make sure you answer when they call because they don't always leave detailed messages. In my case, they needed one additional document but once I faxed it over, they said 2-3 weeks for resolution. The wait is brutal but you're definitely in the home stretch now š
Anybody using TurboTax to check refund status? The app keeps showing different info than the IRS website and its making me nervous. IRS says my refund is approved but TurboTax still says "return received"??
The IRS Where's My Refund tool is always more accurate than TurboTax or any other tax prep software. The tax software companies don't have direct access to IRS processing systems - they're just estimating based on when you submitted through them. Always trust the official IRS status over anything else.
I can share my recent experience! My refund was approved last month with a deposit date of January 15th, and it actually showed up in my account on January 13th - two days early! I bank with a local credit union, and they seem to process ACH deposits pretty quickly. From what I've noticed over the years, the IRS date is more of a "by this date" guarantee rather than an exact arrival time. Once they release the funds to your bank, it really depends on how fast your financial institution processes incoming transfers. Some banks hold them until the official date, while others make them available immediately. Since you're already seeing "approved" status, you're in great shape! I'd say there's a decent chance you could see it a day or two before February 23rd, but I wouldn't stress too much if it comes exactly on that date. The important thing is that it's been approved and is on its way to you. Good luck with those bills!
This is really encouraging to hear! I'm also with a credit union so maybe I'll get lucky like you did. Two days early would be perfect timing for me. I've been checking my account obsessively but I guess I should just be patient since it's already approved. Thanks for sharing your experience - it definitely helps ease some of the anxiety about waiting!
Anastasia Smirnova
Has anyone used those donation receipt tracking apps? I tried ItsDeductible last year and it was ok but not great for higher value items.
0 coins
Sean O'Brien
ā¢I've been using Charitable for a few years and it's pretty good for tracking regular donations. Integrates with my bank account to catch recurring donations automatically. But for non-cash stuff over $500, I still have my accountant double-check everything.
0 coins
Paolo Rizzo
Your 18% donation rate is actually quite reasonable and shouldn't be a red flag by itself. I've seen clients donate 25-30% of windfalls without issues, especially when it's a one-time event like a property sale. The most important thing is having proper documentation for each donation. Since you mentioned keeping all receipts, make sure you have written acknowledgments from each charity for donations of $250 or more. These need to include the donation amount, date, and a statement that no goods or services were provided in exchange (or describe what was provided). One tip for future years: if you're planning to continue higher donation levels, consider establishing a pattern by documenting your charitable giving philosophy or creating a simple giving plan. This shows intentionality rather than randomness, which auditors prefer to see. The fact that TurboTax isn't flagging anything is also a good sign - their built-in audit risk assessment is pretty conservative. Your documentation sounds solid, so I wouldn't stress too much about it.
0 coins
Gianna Scott
ā¢This is really helpful advice! I'm curious about the "giving plan" you mentioned. Does this need to be something formal or just a simple document showing my intentions? Also, when you say "written acknowledgments" - do emails from the charities count, or does it need to be physical letters? I have a mix of both and want to make sure I'm covered if questioned.
0 coins