


Ask the community...
For those following this thread with similar concerns, there are actually three possible outcomes of an overpayment appeal: 1. Full reversal - The overpayment determination is completely eliminated 2. Partial reversal - The overpayment amount is reduced 3. Affirmation - The original overpayment determination stands In addition, if you do receive an unfavorable decision, remember that EDD is required to offer reasonable payment plans for overpayment recovery. They can't demand the entire amount immediately if you can demonstrate financial hardship. Standard payment plans can be as low as $25 per month depending on your situation.
I'm going through a similar situation right now - had my overpayment appeal hearing 3 weeks ago and the waiting is absolutely killing me! They're claiming I owe $4,200 for unreported earnings from 2023. Reading through all these responses is actually really helpful because I had no idea about the timeline or what to expect. The judge at my hearing was pretty neutral and didn't give any hints about which way it might go. I brought all my documentation including screenshots of the EDD website being down when I was trying to report, but you never know if it's enough. Thanks for posting this question - it's reassuring to know I'm not the only one dealing with this stress and uncertainty!
I'm so glad this thread is helpful for you too! It's crazy how stressful this whole process is. The screenshots of the website being down sounds like really good evidence - that shows you were trying to do the right thing and it wasn't intentional. From what I've read in these responses, having documentation like that really seems to help your case. Three weeks down means you're probably getting close to hearing something! I'm still only at about 2.5 weeks since my hearing so we're in similar boats. Fingers crossed for both of us that we get good news soon. The waiting really is the worst part.
btw make sure u activate ur money network card!!! my friend didnt realize she had to activate it and thought the payments werent coming thru but they were just sitting on the card lol. also u can set up direct deposit if u want on the edd website its way easier than using the card imo
Just wanted to add that if you're having trouble understanding your payment schedule, you can also check the "Certification History" section in your UI Online account. It shows all your past and upcoming certification periods with dates, so you can see exactly when you need to certify next and what weeks each payment covers. Also, pro tip: set up text or email notifications in your UI Online account settings. EDD will send you reminders when it's time to certify, which helps avoid missing deadlines. I learned this the hard way when I forgot to certify one time and had to wait an extra week for my payment! The whole system is definitely confusing at first, but once you get into the rhythm it becomes much more manageable. Good luck with everything!
This is such great advice! I just went and set up the notifications - wish I had known about this sooner. The certification history section is really helpful too, I can see my next certification date is coming up in 5 days. Thanks for sharing these tips, it's making the whole process feel way less overwhelming!
I just wasted 2 hours driving to my local workforce center only to find out they're closed on Wednesdays!!! Make sure you check the hours before going. So frustrated right now uuuuggh
This is a game changer! I've been struggling to get through to EDD for over a month about my benefit year ending. Called probably 200+ times and never got past the busy signal. I found my local America's Job Center using the CalJOBS website and went there yesterday morning around 9am when they opened. The staff were amazing - they knew exactly what I needed and showed me to their phone area. Got connected to an EDD rep in about 12 minutes! The agent was able to help me file my new claim right over the phone and explained everything clearly. Wish I had known about this sooner. For anyone reading this - definitely try it, but bring all your paperwork (W2s, pay stubs, etc) just in case they need info to help resolve your issue on the spot.
Thank you so much for sharing your experience! This gives me hope. I've been in the same boat - calling hundreds of times with no luck. My benefit year ended last month and I've been stuck in limbo. Going to try this first thing Monday morning. Did they ask for any specific documents when you got there, or just when you were on the phone with the EDD rep?
One thing that hasn't been mentioned yet - make sure you're checking both your online EDD portal AND your physical mail. Some appeal notices only come through mail, not electronically. I almost missed my hearing because I was only checking my online account. Also, if your hearing is scheduled by phone, they'll call exactly at the appointed time, and if you miss that call, it can be very difficult to get rescheduled. I'd recommend taking the entire day off work for your hearing date once you get it.
I'm going through the exact same nightmare right now! Filed my appeal in April and it's December with absolutely nothing. Like you, I was laid off due to company restructuring but my employer is claiming I quit. It's incredibly frustrating to see people waiting 9-12 months - I had no idea it was this bad when I filed. One thing I've learned from reading everyone's responses is to make sure you're doing everything possible while you wait: keep all your documentation organized, get statements from coworkers if possible, and definitely contact your assembly member's office like Sofia suggested. I'm also going to try that Monday morning calling strategy that Lilah mentioned. The financial stress is unbearable - 8 months without income while your former employer lies about why you left is just devastating. But seeing that people are actually winning these appeals when they have good evidence gives me some hope. Hang in there!
I'm so glad to see I'm not alone in this situation, but also frustrated that so many of us are dealing with the same broken system. It's outrageous that people are waiting almost a year for basic due process while struggling financially. I'm definitely going to try all the strategies mentioned here - the assembly member contact, the Monday morning calls, and making sure my contact info is updated with both systems. It's scary hearing about 12+ month waits, but at least now I know what I'm dealing with. Thank you for sharing your timeline - it helps to know others are fighting the same fight. We shouldn't have to go through this when we were legitimately laid off!
Maggie Martinez
I'm dealing with the exact same issue right now! Been trying for three days straight and getting nowhere. The most frustrating part is that I KNOW my account number is correct because I've triple-checked it against my paperwork. Has anyone found out if this is a widespread system glitch or if it's something on our end? I'm starting to wonder if they're having server issues but just not announcing it. Really hoping someone has a solution because like Diego said, we can't afford to miss out on benefits over a technical problem!
0 coins
Keisha Johnson
•I'm having the same exact problem! Started yesterday and I've tried everything - different browsers, clearing cache, even tried from my work computer. Nothing works. It's definitely feeling like a system-wide issue rather than something on our end. Maybe we should all try calling at the same time and flood their phones until they acknowledge there's a problem? This is so stressful when bills are due and we're depending on these benefits 😤
0 coins
Taylor Chen
I'm going through the exact same nightmare right now! Been stuck on this for over a week and it's absolutely maddening. What's really frustrating is that there's no clear error message - the system just acts like my account number doesn't exist when I KNOW it's correct. I've tried every browser trick in the book, called dozens of times, and even had my neighbor try entering it on their computer just to make sure I wasn't going crazy. At this point I'm convinced it's a system-wide glitch that they're just not acknowledging. Diego, have you had any luck with any of the suggestions here? I'm desperate for any solution at this point because rent is due next week! 😩
0 coins