< Back to California Disability

EDD denying SDI claim despite sufficient contributions - how to prove payments and appeal?

I'm so frustrated with EDD right now. They told me I don't qualify for disability insurance because I didn't pay enough into SDI. But I have all my pay stubs showing I've paid way more than the minimum $300 they require! Has anyone else dealt with this? How did you prove your contributions? I'm worried about my appeal and could use some advice on how to handle this situation.

Tom Maxon

I found a way to solve proving SDI contributions to EDD, watch this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E2g6BmUfD-c

0 coins

-

Eli Wang

Unpopular opinion: maybe we should privatize unemployment insurance? The government clearly can't handle it efficiently.

0 coins

-

Cassandra Moon

Because private insurance companies are sooo much better? 🙄

0 coins

-

7M

Zane Hernandez

Terrible idea. That would just make it even harder for people who need help to get it.

0 coins

-

7M

Genevieve Cavalier

Interesting thought. What would that even look like in practice?

0 coins

-

7M

William Schwarz

Bruh, I feel your pain. EDD is a hot mess. Took me 6 months to get my claim sorted. Hang in there and keep pushing!

0 coins

-

Vanessa Chang

idk man, maybe double check your math? Not trying to be a jerk, but I've seen people mess up their calculations before. Make sure you're only counting SDI deductions and not conflating it with other taxes.

0 coins

-

Isaac Wright

Thanks for the suggestion, but I've triple-checked my math. I'm 100% certain I've paid more than $300 into SDI.

0 coins

-

7M

Vanessa Chang

Fair enough. Just wanted to make sure. EDD can be a real pain in the ass. Hope you get it sorted!

0 coins

-

7M

Grace Johnson

I've heard rumors that EDD is updating their system soon. Anyone know if that's true or just wishful thinking?

0 coins

-

Jayden Reed

Lol, they've been saying that for years. I'll believe it when I see it.

0 coins

-

7M

Nora Brooks

My cousin works in IT for the state (not EDD tho) and says it's actually happening this time. Fingers crossed! 🤞

0 coins

-

7M

Ella Knight

This is why we need to overhaul the entire unemployment system. It's designed to be confusing and difficult on purpose. Vote for politicians who prioritize fixing these broken systems! 💯

0 coins

-

William Schwarz

It's true. We need to hold our elected officials accountable for improving these essential systems.

0 coins

-

7M

Noah Irving

have you tried reaching out to your local assembly member? They can sometimes help cut through the red tape 🤔

0 coins

-

Isaac Wright

I didn't even know that was an option! How do I find my assembly member?

0 coins

-

7M

Noah Irving

Just google "[your city] assembly member". They usually have a form on their website for constituent services. Good luck!

0 coins

-

7M

Vanessa Chang

My friend did this and it really helped move things along. They have more direct channels to communicate with EDD.

0 coins

-

7M

Olivia Evans

Have you tried sacrificing a goat to the EDD gods? Might be more effective than actually dealing with their bureaucracy 😂

0 coins

-

Isaac Wright

Lol, at this point I'm willing to try anything! 🐐

0 coins

-

7M

Sophia Bennett

Instructions unclear. Sacrificed my paycheck to EDD instead. Still no benefits. 😭

0 coins

-

7M

Aurora St.Pierre

yall ever notice how these government systems always work perfectly when they want money FROM us, but never when they're supposed to give money TO us? 🤔

0 coins

-

Grace Johnson

It's like a universal truth at this point! We definitely need reform.

0 coins

-

7M

Connor Murphy

have you tried calling them? sometimes talking to a real person can clear things up faster than dealing with paperwork

0 coins

-

Isaac Wright

I've been trying for days but can never get through 😫 It's so frustrating!

0 coins

-

7M

KhalilStar

Lol good luck with that. I spent 3 weeks trying to get someone on the phone. EDD's phone system is a joke

0 coins

-

7M

Amelia Dietrich

I found a way to get through! There's this site called claimyr.com that has a calling tool. It dials the menu, waits on hold, and then connects you when an agent picks up. Costs $20 but totally worth it. Here's a video about it: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

-

7M

Aiden Chen

guys, i know its frustrating but remember the edd workers are just doing their jobs. theyre probably overwhelmed too. be kind when u call!

0 coins

-

Zoey Bianchi

Found the EDD employee 👆

0 coins

-

7M

Aiden Chen

Nah, just someone who's worked in customer service. A little kindness goes a long way!

0 coins

-

7M

Madison King

Ive been in the same boat. here's what worked for me: 1. Made a spreadsheet with all my SDI contributions 2. Took clear photos of each paystub 3. Wrote a letter explaining the situation 4. Sent it all by certified mail AND faxed it 5. Called every day until I got through It took about 3 weeks, but they finally fixed it. Don't give up!

0 coins

-

Isaac Wright

This is super helpful, thank you! Did you use a specific format for your spreadsheet?

0 coins

-

7M

Madison King

Np! I just made a simple table with columns for date, gross wages, SDI deduction, and a running total. Keep it simple and clear 👍

0 coins

-

7M

Kaiya Rivera

This happened to my cousin. Turns out EDD had some of his wages recorded under the wrong SSN. Double-check that all your wages are correctly attributed to you!

0 coins

-

Katherine Ziminski

That's such a good point. A small error like that can cause major issues with your claim.

0 coins

-

7M

Christopher Morgan

Pro tip: if you can afford it, hire an employment lawyer. They know all the ins and outs of dealing with EDD and can often get things resolved much faster.

0 coins

-

Aurora St.Pierre

Great suggestion! Lawyers can navigate the system more efficiently.

0 coins

-

7M

Julian Paolo

have u checked ur spam folder? sometimes edd emails end up there and they mightve asked for more info

0 coins

-

Ella Knight

Great tip! I've missed important emails before because they landed in spam.

0 coins

-

7M

Lola Perez

Hey OP, as frustrating as EDD can be, there are a few more things you can do beyond what's already been suggested. It may be worth contacting a union or a local nonprofit that specializes in workers' rights for additional guidance. These organizations often have experience dealing with EDD and can provide free assistance or resources tailored to your situation. Similarly, attending local community meetings where elected officials are present could provide you an opportunity to voice your concerns directly. Lastly, maintaining a calm demeanor, documenting everything, and using all available channels to communicate will increase your chances of resolving this issue swiftly. Hang in there!

0 coins

-

Daniel Price

Plot twist: what if we all just stopped paying into SDI? 🤔 Jk jk... unless? 👀

0 coins

-

Olivia Evans

Haha, imagine the chaos! But seriously, we need to address these issues.

0 coins

-

7M

Katherine Ziminski

EDD is such a clown show 🤡 I swear they make these "mistakes" on purpose to discourage people from claiming benefits. Stay strong and don't let them gaslight you!

0 coins

-

Madison King

It's sad that so many of us feel this way about the system. There's definitely room for improvement.

0 coins

-

7M

Lucy Taylor

Ugh, classic EDD nonsense. I went through something similar last year. Here's what you need to do: 1. Gather ALL your pay stubs showing SDI deductions 2. Calculate the total amount you've paid into SDI 3. Write a clear, concise letter explaining the situation 4. Include copies of your pay stubs with the letter 5. Send everything via certified mail so you have proof they received it Don't let them brush you off! Keep pushing until they acknowledge your evidence.

0 coins

-

Ethan Scott

Hang in there, OP! We're all rooting for you. Don't let the bastards grind you down! 💪

0 coins

-

Lauren Johnson

Hey, former EDD employee here. Here's some insider advice: 1. Always appeal. Many claims are initially denied due to automated systems. 2. Be persistent but polite. The person on the other end is probably overworked and underpaid. 3. Use exact language from EDD's website/forms in your communications. 4. Keep a log of every interaction - date, time, who you spoke to, what was said. 5. If possible, try to get things in writing (email or letter) rather than just phone calls. Good luck! The system sucks, but don't give up.

0 coins

-

Isaac Wright

Wow, thank you so much for this insider perspective! This is incredibly helpful.

0 coins

-

7M

Jade Santiago

As someone who's been struggling with EDD for months, this advice is gold. Thanks for sharing!

0 coins

-

7M

Caleb Stone

Quick question - is there a specific department or extension that's best to ask for when calling?

0 coins

-

7M