Will I receive 100% of my husband's reduced Social Security benefit or his PIA amount as a survivor?
I'm stressing about survivor benefits and how they'll work in my situation. My husband is 74 and started claiming Social Security at 63 (reduced benefit). I'm 66 now and began collecting my own retirement benefit when I was 65. His monthly check is about $1,850 while mine is only $1,390. I've been trying to understand what would happen if he passes away before me. Would I receive his current reduced amount ($1,850) or would it be based on what he would have received at his full retirement age (his PIA)? I've read conflicting information online and the SSA website is confusing me even more! Does anyone know for sure how survivor benefits are calculated in this specific situation? Also, would I need to apply for survivor benefits immediately after his passing or is there a grace period? Any insight would be really appreciated!
18 comments
Bethany Groves
As a widow, you would receive the higher of: (1) your current benefit OR (2) the amount your husband was receiving at the time of death (including any cost-of-living adjustments). Since his benefit is higher than yours, you would receive his $1,850. The PIA calculation only comes into play if the deceased started collecting VERY early (before 60) or died before claiming benefits. Since your husband is already collecting, what you see is what you would get as a survivor. You have up to 12 months to apply for survivor benefits without losing any payments (they can be retroactive), but I recommend applying within the first month or two after his passing to avoid any financial strain.
0 coins
Sebastián Stevens
•Thank you for explaining! So to be clear, I would just receive his current $1,850 payment and NOT some higher amount based on his PIA? I thought maybe there was some adjustment for the fact that he took reduced benefits early.
0 coins
KingKongZilla
The previous comment isn't entirely accurate. There's a special rule that applies to your situation. As a surviving spouse, you would receive what's called the "Greater of" amount, which is the larger of: 1. The reduced benefit your husband was receiving at death, OR 2. 82.5% of your husband's Primary Insurance Amount (PIA - what he would have received at FRA) This is known as the "widow's limit" provision. So you need to find out what your husband's PIA was - the amount he would have received at his Full Retirement Age - and calculate 82.5% of that. If that's higher than his current $1,850, you'd get that amount instead. You should call SSA directly and ask them to calculate both numbers for you to determine which would be higher in your specific case.
0 coins
Sebastián Stevens
•This is exactly the type of conflicting information that's been confusing me! So there IS potentially a higher amount I could receive based on his PIA, not just his reduced benefit? I'll definitely ask about this "widow's limit" when I talk to SSA.
0 coins
Rebecca Johnston
My mom just went thru this last year when my dad died. SSA automatically gave her dad's benefit since it was higher than hers. They didnt say anything about any complicated calculations or PIA stuff. Just switched her to his amount on the next payment. Think it took like 6 weeks to process tho.
0 coins
Sebastián Stevens
•Thanks for sharing your mom's experience. Did she have to go into an office or was she able to handle everything over the phone?
0 coins
Nathan Dell
When my spouse passed in 2023, I found it IMPOSSIBLE to get through to anyone at Social Security to file for survivor benefits!!! Kept getting disconnected after waiting 2+ hours each time. Tried for WEEKS! Eventually used a service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that got me connected to an actual SSA agent in less than 20 minutes. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/Z-BRbJw3puU Once I finally talked to SSA, they explained that since my spouse claimed early, I would get the higher of either their actual benefit amount OR 82.5% of their PIA (as someone mentioned above). In my case, the 82.5% calculation was higher, so that's what I received.
0 coins
Maya Jackson
•i was gonna suggest going to the local office in person but your Claimyr suggestion sounds way better than sitting in that waiting room for 5 hours! might try that myself for my disability appeal
0 coins
Tristan Carpenter
My condolences on thinking about this difficult situation. When my husband passed, I was so confused too. But actually both of those commenters are kind of right. There's a special rule when the deceased took reduced benefits, and you DO need to know his PIA to figure out what you'd get.
0 coins
Sebastián Stevens
•Thank you. It's hard to plan for these things, but I want to be prepared financially. I'm going to try to find out what his PIA is so I can calculate both scenarios.
0 coins
Amaya Watson
Ok, let me clarify because there's a lot of confusion here. The RIB-LIM rule (Retirement Insurance Benefit-Limitation) is what applies in your situation. Here's the simple version: As a widow, you will receive the HIGHER of: 1. Your current benefit 2. Your husband's benefit amount at time of death 3. 82.5% of your husband's PIA Note that #3 only applies if your husband took reduced benefits before his FRA. Since he started at 63, this applies to you. For example, if his PIA (benefit at FRA) was $2,300, then 82.5% would be $1,897.50. Since that's higher than his reduced $1,850, you'd get the $1,897.50. But if his PIA was $2,200, then 82.5% would be $1,815, which is LESS than his current $1,850, so you'd get the $1,850. The only way to know for sure is to ask SSA what his PIA is.
0 coins
Sebastián Stevens
•Thank you for breaking it down so clearly! This RIB-LIM rule is exactly what I needed to understand. I'll definitely need to find out his exact PIA to see which amount would apply in my case.
0 coins
Rebecca Johnston
Don't survivor benefits also depend on your age when you claim them? Or is that only if you're under FRA?
0 coins
Amaya Watson
•Good question. Yes, if you claim survivor benefits before your FRA, they're reduced. But the original poster is already 66, which means she's at or past her FRA (depending on her birth year). So she would receive the full survivor benefit without reduction.
0 coins
Maya Jackson
all this pia and fra and rib-lim stuff is why i hate dealing with SS. they make everything so complicated!!! my friend's husband died last yr and she said she just got whatever he was getting, period. no fancy math involved
0 coins
KingKongZilla
•Your friend likely got that result because her husband's current benefit was higher than the 82.5% of PIA calculation. The SSA automatically gives you the highest amount you're entitled to, but they don't always explain the calculations unless you specifically ask. That's why it seemed straightforward to her.
0 coins
Tristan Carpenter
Don't forget you'll need his death certificate and your marriage certificate when you apply for survivors benefits! Took me forever to find our marriage certificate when my time came.
0 coins
Sebastián Stevens
•That's a really good reminder - I should probably locate those documents now and keep them somewhere accessible. Thank you!
0 coins