

Ask the community...
As a green card holder who's been working in the US for about 3 years now, this discussion has been absolutely eye-opening! I had no idea about the complexity involved in collecting Social Security benefits abroad as a non-citizen. The real-world experiences shared here are invaluable. I'm particularly concerned about the point raised regarding the 35-year averaging formula. If I only work in the US for 10-12 years before potentially returning to my home country, those 23-25 years of zeros being averaged in could significantly reduce my benefits. Has anyone done the math on what the actual impact might be? For example, if someone earns at the Social Security wage base for 10 years but has 25 zero years, roughly what percentage of "full" benefits might they expect? Also, I'm curious about the interaction between US Social Security and foreign pensions. My home country (Canada) has its own pension system that I paid into before coming to the US. I know there's a totalization agreement between the US and Canada, but I'm still unclear on how benefits from both systems would work together practically. Would I be able to collect from both simultaneously, or are there coordination rules that might reduce one or the other? The documentation advice everyone's shared is fantastic - I'm going to start organizing everything systematically right away. Better to be over-prepared than scrambling for documents years from now! Thank you all for sharing your knowledge.
As a new green card holder who just started my Social Security journey, this thread has been incredibly educational! I'm amazed by how much practical knowledge everyone has shared here - it's exactly what you can't find in the official SSA publications. I wanted to add something I discovered recently that might be helpful for others just starting out: the Social Security Administration has a really useful publication called "Social Security Credits" (Publication No. 05-10072) that explains exactly how the credit system works for different types of workers, including those on various visa statuses. It helped me understand that even my part-time work during my student years (when I was authorized to work on campus) counted toward my credits. Also, for anyone tracking their progress like I am, I learned that you can actually see a detailed breakdown of your earnings by year in your my Social Security account, which helps you verify that all your employers properly reported your wages. I caught one small discrepancy from a part-time job that I was able to get corrected quickly. One question I have after reading all these experiences: for those who mentioned keeping detailed documentation, do you recommend storing everything digitally, physically, or both? I'm starting to accumulate quite a bit of paperwork between immigration documents, tax records, and now Social Security tracking materials. Any specific organization systems that have worked well for managing all this over the long term? Thanks to everyone for creating such a valuable resource - I'm definitely bookmarking this thread for future reference as I continue planning my path to those 40 quarters!
I'm new to this community but unfortunately experiencing almost the identical situation! Had my phone appointment for my daughter's auxiliary benefits 7 days ago and was told it was approved for $1,325 monthly. The rep was very confident and said we'd receive the approval letter "within 5-10 business days" and the first payment would follow shortly after. So far nothing has arrived - no letter, no payment, and my online account shows zero updates. Reading through everyone's experiences here has been incredibly reassuring because I was starting to worry something had gone wrong with our application. It's really eye-opening how consistently SSA seems to give these optimistic timelines that rarely match reality. Based on all the shared experiences in this thread, it's clear I should prepare for the 3-4 week timeline instead of the 5-10 days they promised. Eva, I hope you get your letter and payment soon - the waiting is so stressful when you're counting on that income for budgeting purposes! Thank you for starting this discussion, it's been invaluable to see that these processing delays are unfortunately normal rather than an exception. The consistency of everyone's experiences really shows this is a systemic issue with SSA's timeline estimates.
I'm new to this community but unfortunately experiencing a very similar situation! Had my phone appointment for my daughter's auxiliary benefits 3 days ago and was told it was approved for $1,205 monthly. The rep seemed so confident and said we'd receive the approval letter "within 7-10 business days" with the first payment following shortly after. While it's still early, reading through all these experiences has been incredibly eye-opening about how unrealistic SSA's timeline promises appear to be. It's both reassuring and concerning to see such a consistent pattern of delays - everyone seems to get told 5-10 days but the reality is 3-5 weeks or longer. Eva, I really hope you get your letter and payment soon after all this waiting! Thank you for starting this thread - it's been invaluable for setting realistic expectations rather than stressing over their optimistic estimates. I'll make sure to update when (hopefully!) my approval finally comes through so others can track real timelines versus SSA's promises.
Welcome to the community, Mei! I'm also new here and unfortunately in a very similar situation. Even though it's only been 3 days for you, reading through this entire thread has been such a reality check about SSA's timeline promises. The pattern is so consistent - they tell everyone 5-10 days but the actual experience seems to be 3-5 weeks minimum. It's both comforting to know we're not alone in this, but also frustrating that they keep giving these unrealistic estimates. Based on everyone's shared experiences, I'm now mentally preparing for the longer timeline instead of getting anxious when their optimistic deadline passes. The waiting is definitely nerve-wracking when you're trying to plan finances around that expected income. I hope both you and Eva get your approvals soon - this community has been incredibly helpful for managing expectations during this stressful process!
Welcome to the community, Mei! I'm also new here but unfortunately dealing with a very similar situation with my son's auxiliary benefits. I had my phone appointment just 2 days ago and was told it was approved for $1,180 monthly with the same "7-10 business days" promise. Reading through this entire thread has been such an eye-opener - it's honestly both comforting and frustrating to see how consistently SSA gives these unrealistic timeline estimates. The pattern is so clear from everyone's experiences here that we should expect 3-4 weeks minimum rather than their optimistic 7-10 days. While it's early for both of us, at least we know what to realistically expect based on this community's shared experiences. The waiting is definitely stressful when you're budgeting around that expected income, but this thread has been invaluable for setting proper expectations. I hope both you and Eva get your letters and payments soon - I'll make sure to update when mine comes through so we can all track these real processing times!
Thanks everyone for the helpful advice! Sounds like 3 months before is the sweet spot. Going to start gathering my documents now so I'm ready to apply in February. One last question - is it better to apply online or should I make an appointment at my local office?
Online is generally faster and more convenient. The SSA website will walk you through each step and you can save your progress if needed. Local offices still have appointment backlogs in many areas. That said, if your situation is complex (foreign work history, survivor benefits, etc.), an in-person appointment might be better.
I just went through this process myself last year! Applied exactly 3 months before my FRA birthday and everything went smoothly. One tip that saved me time - create your my Social Security account online first if you haven't already. You can review your earnings history and get an estimate of your benefits before applying. Also, certified copies of documents work just fine - you don't need originals. The online application took me about 30 minutes and I was able to save it partway through when I realized I needed to grab my bank routing number. Got my first payment right on schedule!
That's really reassuring to hear from someone who just went through it! I hadn't thought about creating the my Social Security account first - that's a great tip. Good to know about the certified copies too since finding my original birth certificate might be a hassle. Did you notice any difference in processing times between different months, or does it seem pretty consistent as long as you give them that 3-month window?
For your April benefits (since your birthday is March 12th), applying now is perfect timing. For documents, they usually just need to see the originals if you apply in person, or uploads/copies if applying online. They'll notify you if they need anything else. Also, an important tip: Create your "my Social Security" account online before applying if you haven't already. This lets you track your application status and eventually view/manage your benefits. It's much easier to set this up before you're in the middle of the application process.
As someone who just went through this process last year, I can confirm that applying 3-4 months ahead is the sweet spot. I applied exactly 4 months before my intended start date and everything went smoothly. One thing I wish I'd known earlier - if you're still working when you apply, make sure to report your expected earnings accurately. SSA has an annual earnings limit if you're under full retirement age, but since you're turning 67 (full retirement age), you won't have to worry about earnings limits. Also, double-check that all your employers properly reported your wages over the years by reviewing your Social Security Statement online - any discrepancies are much easier to fix before you apply rather than after. The online application saved me a lot of time compared to going to the office. Best of luck with your application!
KhalilStar
I'm so sorry for your loss, Sean. My heart goes out to you and your mom during this incredibly difficult time. I lost my father last year and went through this exact same process with my mother, so I understand how overwhelming it can feel when you're trying to navigate government benefits while grieving. Everyone here has provided such comprehensive and helpful advice - this community truly is amazing. I just wanted to add one small tip that made a difference for us: when your mom calls SSA, suggest she keeps a glass of water nearby. Grief can make your throat feel tight or dry, especially when you're trying to explain personal details to a stranger over the phone. Having water handy helped my mom stay comfortable during what turned out to be about a 45-minute conversation. Also, I noticed several people mentioned the callback option - definitely use that! It saved us from hours of frustration on hold. The representative who called us back was incredibly patient and compassionate, and she walked my mom through not just the $255 death benefit application but also helped her understand all her survivor benefit options in detail. You've gotten such valuable information here about benefit comparisons and timing strategies that could really impact your mom's long-term financial security. The fact that you're researching all of this for her shows what a caring son you are. Take it one step at a time - you've got this, and this community has your back if you need any follow-up support along the way.
0 coins
Val Rossi
I'm so sorry for your loss, Sean. Having just joined this community, I'm truly moved by the outpouring of support and detailed guidance you've received here. Everyone has provided such valuable information about both the $255 death benefit and the much more significant survivor benefits your mom may be eligible for. As someone new to navigating these types of benefits, I wanted to say how helpful it's been to read through all the practical advice - from calling SSA at 8 AM and using the callback option, to having all documents organized beforehand and understanding the benefit comparison strategies. The tip about keeping water nearby during the call really shows how thoughtful this community is about the human side of dealing with bureaucracy during grief. It's clear that while the $255 death benefit is a small token, the ongoing survivor benefits could make a meaningful difference in your mom's financial security. The fact that she could potentially receive 71.5% to 100% of your father's benefit amount is significant information that goes far beyond what most people would know to ask about. You're being such a wonderful advocate for your mom during this incredibly difficult time. Having all this knowledge and a clear plan of action should make the SSA call much less daunting. I hope the process goes smoothly for both of you, and please know that this community will be here if you need any additional support along the way.
0 coins