

Ask the community...
As someone who went through this exact situation with my spouse last year, I can confirm what others have said - you definitely report the EXPECTED 2025 income, not 2024. The SSA application specifically asks for estimated earnings for the year you'll be receiving benefits. A few things that helped us: - Write a brief explanation letter to include with your application detailing the business transition and how you calculated the $23K estimate - Keep monthly records once benefits start - even a simple calendar noting work days/hours - Consider the timing advice others mentioned about scheduling work after his 65th birthday in June when the earnings limit increases One thing I wish someone had told us: if his income ends up being significantly different from the estimate (more than a few thousand), contact SSA proactively rather than waiting for them to discover it during their annual review. It makes the adjustment process much smoother. The earnings test can seem scary but remember - any benefits withheld due to excess earnings get added back to your monthly benefit amount once you reach FRA, so it's not truly "lost" money, just delayed.
This is incredibly helpful, thank you! The explanation letter is a great idea - I hadn't thought of that. And I really appreciate you mentioning that withheld benefits get added back later. That makes me feel much better about the whole situation. We were worried it was just money lost forever. Your point about contacting SSA proactively if income differs significantly is noted - definitely don't want to deal with a surprise overpayment situation down the road.
I went through this same process with my dad who was also a self-employed contractor. One thing that really helped us was calling the local SSA office directly instead of the 1-800 number - we got through much faster and the person was able to walk us through the self-employment income reporting step by step. They specifically told us to be conservative with our income estimate rather than optimistic. It's much easier to deal with getting money back later than having to repay an overpayment. Since your husband's estimate of $23K is right around that earnings limit, you might want to estimate slightly lower (like $21K) to be safe, especially given the unpredictable nature of construction work. Also, make sure you understand the monthly vs annual test. Even if he stays under $23K for the year, if he has one really good month early in 2025 where he earns over the monthly limit, they can withhold benefits for that specific month. This is why the timing suggestion about scheduling more work after June is so smart. Good luck with the application! The self-employment rules make it more complicated but it's definitely manageable with good documentation.
Just want to echo what others have said - congrats on your citizenship! š I went through this update process about 6 months ago and it really wasn't as scary as I thought it would be. A few things that helped me: ⢠I called at exactly 8:00am on a Tuesday and got through in about 20 minutes ⢠The rep was super patient and explained everything step by step ⢠Make sure your address is current with them before you start - they need to mail you forms ⢠Keep a notebook handy during the call to write down reference numbers and what they tell you One thing I didn't see mentioned yet - they'll also ask if you want to register for selective service if you're male and under 26. Just a heads up so you're not caught off guard! The whole thing took about 3 weeks from start to finish for me. You've got this! šŖ
Thanks for the selective service heads up! I'm actually 28 so that won't apply to me, but that's definitely something I wouldn't have thought about. Good tip about keeping a notebook during the call too - I can see how easy it would be to forget important details when you're nervous. Did they give you a confirmation number or anything when you completed the process? I want to make sure I have some way to track that everything went through properly.
Hey Malik! Huge congrats on becoming a citizen! š I actually just finished this process about 2 months ago and wanted to share what worked for me. Here's my step-by-step breakdown: **Before calling:** - Have your naturalization certificate ready (keep the original safe!) - Make sure your current address is on file with SSA - Have a pen and paper ready for reference numbers **The call:** - I called 1-800-772-1213 at 8:05am on a Wednesday and got through in about 15 minutes - They'll verify your identity with SSN, DOB, and some other basic info - Tell them "I need to update my citizenship status from permanent resident to U.S. citizen" - They'll walk you through exactly what documents to send **What they mailed me:** - SS-5 form (Application for Social Security Card) - Cover letter with specific instructions - List of acceptable documents **Timeline:** - Mailed documents back within a week - Got confirmation letter about 3 weeks later - New card arrived about a week after that The rep I spoke with was really helpful and patient. Don't stress too much - they deal with this all the time! The hardest part is just getting through on the phone, but once you do, it's pretty straightforward. You've got this! šŖ Also, as someone else mentioned, definitely register to vote once this is done! š³ļø
This is such a comprehensive breakdown, thank you! @Mei Chen I m'bookmarking this for when I start my process next week. Quick question - when you say new "card arrived about a week after that, do" you mean they actually send you a new Social Security card? Or is it just a confirmation that your record has been updated? I wasn t'sure if getting a new physical card was part of the process or if it s'optional.
As a newcomer here, I've been following the HR 82 discussions with great interest since I'm also a federal retiree dealing with WEP. One thing I wanted to add that might help everyone understand the legislative process better - HR 82 actually passed the House in previous sessions but died in the Senate. The challenge isn't just getting House co-sponsors (which we have plenty of), but getting Senate leadership to bring it to a floor vote. The Senate version (S 597) has far fewer co-sponsors. For those checking their Social Security statements, also look for the "WEP Fact Sheet" that SSA sometimes includes - it explains your specific reduction amount and the years of substantial earnings that factor into the calculation. While I share everyone's frustration with the repeated delays, I think the key is understanding that this is as much a political timing issue as it is a fiscal one. The $196 billion cost estimate scares lawmakers, but if we can demonstrate strong constituent pressure across multiple states, that might finally push it over the finish line.
Welcome to the community! Your point about the Senate being the real bottleneck is spot on. I think many of us have been so focused on the House co-sponsor count that we've overlooked how much harder it is to get Senate movement. The difference in co-sponsors between HR 82 and S 597 really illustrates that gap. I hadn't thought about looking for the WEP Fact Sheet on my SS statement - that's a great tip! You're absolutely right about constituent pressure being key. Maybe we need to be contacting our Senators more aggressively rather than just assuming the House support will carry it through. It's encouraging to have someone with your perspective joining these discussions since navigating the legislative process can be so confusing for those of us just trying to understand how this affects our benefits.
As a newcomer to this community, I want to thank everyone for this incredibly informative discussion! I'm also a federal retiree (different agency than postal) and have been struggling to understand exactly how HR 82 would affect my situation. Reading through all these comments has been more helpful than hours of trying to research this on my own. What really stands out to me is how many different situations people are in - some under CSRS, some under FERS, different start dates, different prior work history - yet we're all dealing with the same WEP reductions in various ways. I especially appreciate the practical advice about checking the Social Security statement online and the tips for actually getting through to speak with an SSA representative. Like many of you, I've been cautiously following this bill for years and trying not to get my hopes up, but it's encouraging to see the level of knowledge and advocacy in this community. For those still trying to figure out their specific situations, I'd also suggest documenting everything you learn about your WEP calculation - it helps when talking to SSA representatives if you can reference specific numbers from your statement.
Welcome to the community, Jade! I'm also new here and have found this discussion incredibly valuable. Your point about documenting everything is excellent advice - I've started keeping a folder with all my SS statements, WEP calculations, and notes from any conversations with SSA representatives. It's amazing how complex this issue is and how many different scenarios people are dealing with. What's really helped me is creating a simple timeline of my work history showing which jobs paid into SS and which didn't, along with the years of "substantial earnings" that affect my WEP reduction. This has made conversations with SSA much more productive. Like you, I'm trying to stay cautiously optimistic about HR 82 while not counting on it actually passing. But at least now I understand my situation better thanks to all the knowledge sharing in this community!
As someone who just went through this process myself, I wanted to add that when you contact SSA about missing earnings, be prepared for it to take some time. In my case, it took about 6 weeks for them to review my documentation and update my record. They had to verify the information with my former employer. Also, since you mentioned planning to retire next year, keep in mind that if you're born in 1960, your full retirement age is 67, not the 66 and 10 months mentioned above. The FRA gradually increases based on birth year. You can find your exact FRA on the SSA website or in your online account. One more tip: if you do decide to claim early at 62, the reduction is permanent - it doesn't go back to the full amount when you reach FRA. So make sure you're comfortable with that lower monthly payment for the rest of your life before making that decision.
This is all really helpful information! I'm actually born in 1959, so my full retirement age is 66 and 10 months. But you're absolutely right about the permanent reduction if I claim at 62 - that's definitely something I need to factor in carefully. Six weeks to process the earnings correction seems reasonable, and since I'm not planning to file until next year anyway, that should give me plenty of time to get everything straightened out first. I really appreciate everyone sharing their experiences here - it's making me feel much more confident about navigating this whole process. I think my next steps are: 1) gather all my old tax documents, 2) submit the correction request to SSA, 3) wait for the updated calculations, and 4) then make an informed decision about when to claim. Thanks to everyone who contributed to this discussion!
Just wanted to chime in as someone who works in retirement planning - this whole thread is a perfect example of why it's so important to understand all the moving pieces with Social Security! I see this confusion all the time with clients. The survivor benefits piece that everyone identified is huge - when someone loses a spouse, they can often end up with a higher total monthly income from Social Security than they had when both spouses were alive, especially if the deceased spouse had higher earnings. One thing I'd add to the great advice already given: when you're reviewing your earnings record, pay special attention to years where you might have had multiple jobs or changed employers mid-year. Those transitions sometimes create gaps in reporting. Also, if you ever worked for tips (restaurant, salon, etc.), make sure those tip amounts were properly reported - I've seen cases where the base wage was recorded but not the tips. Since you're planning to retire next year, this is also a good time to think about Medicare enrollment timing if you're not already covered through an employer plan. The Social Security and Medicare timelines don't always align perfectly, so it's worth planning both together.
Kaylee Cook
I just helped my sister with her spousal benefits application two months ago, and the process was really straightforward! During the phone appointment, the SSA representative explained that they could accept the marriage certificate through their secure upload system. They sent us a link via email about 30 minutes after the call ended, and we were able to upload a PDF scan of the certificate with no issues. The key is having a clear, readable scan ready - we made sure both the front and back were captured even though the back was mostly blank. The whole application was processed in about 3 weeks. One tip: write down the confirmation number they give you during the upload process, as it helps if you need to follow up later. You should be all set without having to make that 45-minute drive!
0 coins
Keisha Jackson
ā¢This is really reassuring to hear! I was getting a bit stressed about the whole process after reading some mixed experiences here. Three weeks sounds very reasonable for processing time. I'll definitely make sure to get a high-quality scan of both sides of our certificate ready beforehand and write down any confirmation numbers they give me. Thanks for the practical tips - it's nice to hear from someone who just went through this recently with success!
0 coins
Austin Leonard
I'm currently going through the spousal benefits application process myself and had my phone appointment last week. The SSA representative was very clear that they now accept digital uploads for marriage certificates - no need to visit the office in person unless there's a specific issue with your document. During our call, they explained I could either upload through the my Social Security portal or they'd send me a secure email link. I chose the portal option and it was surprisingly easy. Just make sure your scan is high quality (at least 300 DPI) and shows the entire document clearly. The rep also mentioned that processing times are currently running about 2-3 weeks for spousal benefit applications when all documents are submitted digitally. You should be able to avoid that 45-minute drive to the office!
0 coins
Emma Morales
ā¢That's great to hear about the 2-3 week processing time! I'm new to navigating all of this Social Security stuff, so it's really helpful to get current information from people who are actually going through it right now. Quick question - when you uploaded through the my Social Security portal, did you need to create an account first or were you already set up with one? I'm wondering if I should get that sorted out before our phone appointment next week just to save time during the process.
0 coins