Social Security Administration
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
I'm trying to understand the Social Security earnings limit for my husband who plans to retire early at 63. From what I've researched, there's a monthly limit of $1,950 during the first year of retirement (the grace year rule). What confuses me is how the benefit withholding works if he exceeds this amount. If I'm understanding correctly, Social Security will pay his monthly benefits throughout the first year, but then they'll "claw back" full monthly check amounts in the following year until any overpayment is settled? Is this right? We're considering having him file for benefits in November 2025 (with first payment in December), so if he ends up owing back one month's worth, they would just withhold one check in 2026. By 2026, he'll be able to stay under the annual earnings limit. Does my understanding of this process sound accurate? I'm planning to wait until I'm 70 to file for my own benefits, so I'm trying to maximize our household strategy. Thanks in advance for any clarification!
Quick question about survivor benefits and self-employment! I'm 65 and currently receiving Social Security survivor benefits from my late spouse. I operate a small flower farm that will bring in about $20,000 in 2025. I know this is under the annual earnings limit (about $23,000), so I thought I was fine. BUT I just realized I'll be working well over 45 hours per month to cultivate and sell these flowers (I'm not exactly a quick farmer lol). Does the SSA consider hours worked for self-employment differently than the dollar amount earned? I'm worried they might reduce my survivor benefits because of the hours even though my income is under the limit. Has anyone dealt with this situation before? Just trying to understand if I need to cut back on my farming hours to protect my benefits.
Just to clarify an important point about self-employment: While the 45-hour rule isn't relevant for survivor benefits, SSA does have a special test for self-employed people that can be applied in certain circumstances. They can evaluate if you're providing significant services to your business despite low reported income. However, this is primarily applied in situations where there's reason to suspect income manipulation - like a business owner suddenly reporting minimal income after retirement while continuing to work the same hours. For a small flower farm with modest income like yours, this is extremely unlikely to be an issue. Just keep good records, report your income honestly, and you should be fine with your survivor benefits as long as you stay under the annual earnings limit.
I work part-time for a local nonprofit while also receiving survivor benefits, and I've been through this exact concern! The key thing to remember is that for survivor benefits, SSA only cares about your earnings, not your hours worked. The confusion often comes from disability benefits (SSDI) where they do have that substantial gainful activity test that looks at hours. For your flower farm, as long as your net self-employment earnings stay under $23,380 for 2025 (assuming you haven't reached full retirement age), you're good to go regardless of whether you work 45 hours or 85 hours a month. Just make sure you're tracking all your legitimate business expenses properly since those reduce your countable income. I'd still recommend calling SSA to confirm for your peace of mind, but based on my experience and what I've learned, your hours shouldn't be an issue at all. Good luck with your flower farm - it sounds lovely!
Just checked my Social Security account to see if there was any message about the 2025 COLA increase yet (there wasn't), but I noticed something concerning - my survivor benefits are showing as 'Suspended' for January 2025! Not inactive or reduced, but completely suspended. I'm turning 65 next month and expected to see Medicare Parts A & B premiums being deducted starting then, but wasn't expecting a full suspension. I know the 2025 earnings limit is $22,320 before penalties kick in, and I estimate my annual income will be around $24,000, so I might be slightly over. I thought they would just withhold my February 2025 payment to account for the overage, not suspend benefits entirely in January. Has anyone dealt with this before? Is this related to Medicare enrollment or the earnings limit? Planning to call SSA on Monday, but any insights before then would be helpful!
After reviewing the other comments, I want to add something important: The suspension might be temporary and administrative rather than punitive. When your Medicare enrollment processes at the same time as earnings limit calculations, SSA sometimes places a temporary hold on benefits while their system updates. This doesn't always mean you'll miss a payment. When you call, ask specifically if this is an administrative suspension related to multiple simultaneous changes in your record. If so, it might resolve automatically before your January payment date. Also, confirm whether they're using your estimated earnings from your Medicare enrollment paperwork or if they've received different information that might have triggered this suspension. Sometimes employers report projected annual earnings that differ from what beneficiaries estimate.
Great advice. I've seen numerous cases where these administrative suspensions resolve themselves before the payment date. It's SSA's system putting a temporary hold while multiple changes process simultaneously. Though it's still worth calling to confirm, as sometimes there are legitimate issues that need addressing.
I'm going through something similar right now! Just turned 65 in December and my survivor benefits also show a weird status change. In my case, it wasn't suspended but showed "under review" for about 3 weeks before returning to normal. What I learned from calling SSA is that their computer systems often flag accounts when multiple life events happen close together - like turning 65, Medicare enrollment, and having reportable earnings all at once. One thing that might help while you're waiting to call: log into your my Social Security account and check if there are any action items or messages you might have missed. Sometimes they send notifications about required documentation that can cause temporary suspensions if not addressed promptly. Also, if you have direct deposit set up, keep an eye on your bank account around your normal payment date. Even if the online status shows "suspended," the payment might still process normally if it's just a display glitch while their systems update. This happened to my neighbor last year - scary online status but the money still came through on time. Definitely still call on Monday to get it sorted, but don't panic if you see the suspended status over the weekend. These Medicare transition issues are unfortunately common but usually get resolved quickly once you get through to the right department.
My mom passed away in April. I've been trying to figure out if I qualify for Social Security's lump-sum death payment ($255). I filed for it online 3 weeks ago but just got a letter saying I was denied. When my mom received this benefit after my dad died in 2001, it seemed pretty straightforward. The denial letter mentions something about 'living with the deceased at time of death' but I was her caregiver for the last 2 years (though I maintained my own apartment). I paid for the funeral expenses ($8,700) and have all the receipts. Does anyone know what the current eligibility requirements are? I'm 42 and not receiving any SS benefits myself. Do I need to appeal this decision or am I truly not eligible?
My cousin told me funeral homes sometimes know about other benefits or assistance programs! maybe ask them?
I'm sorry for your loss, Scarlett. Going through all this paperwork and bureaucracy while grieving is really tough. Just wanted to add that if your mom was a veteran or married to a veteran, there might be VA burial benefits available - up to $796 for burial expenses plus a burial plot allowance if she's buried in a private cemetery. It's separate from Social Security and has different eligibility rules. Also, some states have their own death benefit programs or burial assistance that aren't tied to federal Social Security rules. It might be worth checking with your state's social services department to see if there are any local programs available. The whole system really needs updating - $255 hasn't changed since 1954 when the average funeral cost was around $700. Now with funerals costing $8,000+ it's almost insulting. Hang in there and keep asking questions - sometimes there are benefits people don't know about.
I've been putting off applying for SSI for my 35-year-old son who has a severe cognitive disability from a childhood TBI (traumatic brain injury). He's never been able to hold employment due to memory issues and processing delays. I recently discovered his father (we separated years ago) set up a Roth IRA for him that now contains about $5,200. I know SSI has the $2,000 resource limit, and I'm worried this will disqualify him. Should I have him withdraw these funds before applying? Would SSA consider this a transfer of resources? I feel terrible for waiting so long to apply - I kept hoping his condition would improve enough for supported employment, but his doctors now say that's unlikely. Any advice on handling the Roth IRA situation before submitting his application would be greatly appreciated.
just wanted to say ur a good mom for helping ur son!!! my mom helped me get on ssi when i was 19 (im 32 now) and it changed my life. dont feel bad about not doing it sooner, ur doing it now and thats what matters!!
As someone new to navigating disability benefits, I want to say how helpful this thread has been! I'm dealing with a similar situation with my adult daughter who has developmental disabilities, and I had no idea about the 36-month lookback period or the difference between SSI and DAC benefits. One question - if someone spends down resources appropriately before applying, how long should they wait between spending the money and submitting the application? Is there a recommended timeframe to avoid any appearance of impropriety, or is it more about having proper documentation of legitimate expenses? Also, @Marcus Marsh - don't beat yourself up about waiting. Sometimes we need time to process and accept our loved one's needs, and that's completely human. You're taking action now, which is what matters.
Max Knight
To answer your follow-up questions about bonuses and timing: 1. For year-end bonuses: Under Social Security rules, bonuses count when they're earned, not when they're paid. However, a year-end performance bonus is typically considered earned when it's paid. So if your husband receives a bonus in December 2025, that would likely count toward December's earnings. 2. Regarding starting benefits in January 2026: If he begins benefits in January 2026, that becomes his "grace year" and he can use the monthly earnings test for all of 2026. This means he could earn any amount in January-November but still receive benefits for any month he earns under the monthly limit (which will be slightly higher in 2026 due to COLA). These earnings test rules are genuinely confusing, so it's smart to plan carefully. I'd recommend scheduling an appointment with SSA about 3-4 months before your husband plans to retire to discuss your specific situation.
0 coins
Madeline Blaze
AuthorThank you so much for this detailed explanation! Based on everyone's advice, I think we'll have him retire in December 2025 and start benefits in January 2026. That way, we can use the monthly earnings test throughout 2026 as he transitions to part-time consulting work. I really appreciate everyone's help with this complicated topic. We'll definitely schedule that appointment with SSA to confirm our understanding before making any final decisions.
0 coins
Lola Perez
Just wanted to add one more consideration for your planning - if your husband does any consulting work after retirement, make sure he understands how self-employment income is treated under the earnings test. Self-employment income counts when it's earned (not when paid), but there's also a "substantial services" test. Even if his monthly earnings are under the limit, if SSA determines he's performing "substantial services" in self-employment, he could still lose benefits for that month. Generally, working more than 45 hours per month in self-employment is considered substantial, but it can be less depending on the type of work and other factors. This is another good reason to discuss his specific post-retirement plans with SSA when you schedule that appointment. Good luck with your planning! It sounds like you're being very thoughtful about optimizing your household Social Security strategy.
0 coins