
Ask the community...
I went through this IRMAA mess once. Just sharing what worked for me - I wrote a detailed letter explaining exactly what happened with our unusual one-time income situation. I was super specific about dates, amounts, and why it wasn't recurring income. Attached bank statements showing how the money came in and went right back out for the specific purpose. Got approved pretty quick. The more documentation the better!
Thank you! That's really helpful. I'm gathering all our documentation now - the 401k withdrawal statement, contractor invoices, and a copy of the relevant portion of the will showing the inheritance arrangement. Fingers crossed!
Gd luck with it. The whole medicare/SS system is so confusing. I've been on SSDI for 5 yrs and still don't understand half of it. They never explained IRMAA could even apply to disabled ppl under 65!!!!
You're right that it's poorly explained. IRMAA applies to anyone on Medicare, regardless of age or whether you qualify through disability or age. The income calculations are based on your modified adjusted gross income (MAGI) from two years prior. For 2025 IRMAA determinations, they're using your 2023 tax returns. That's why one-time income spikes can affect you two years later, even if your current income is much lower.
My husband had this same worry last month! I told him not 2 worry about it. My sister works for SSA and she says they're always like a year behind on the website. The computer systems they use are from the stone age lol. But she said everything still counts toward ur benefits even if it doesn't show up right away on the website.
Thanks everyone for the great information! I was definitely overthinking this. I'll stop worrying about the 2024 earnings not showing up yet. Does anyone know if I should be checking my earnings record for accuracy every year? I've never really paid attention to it before now that retirement is getting closer.
Yes, it's a good practice to check your earnings record annually. If there are errors (missing earnings or incorrect amounts), there's a 3-year, 3-month, and 15-day time limit to correct them. After that, it becomes much harder to make changes. Since your retirement is approaching, verifying past years is important - especially high-earning years that will factor into your benefit calculation.
Absolutely check it regularly! I discovered my employer failed to report one quarter back in 2017, and I had to get that fixed. Your benefit amount is based on your highest 35 years of indexed earnings, so missing wages can directly impact your monthly payment amount. The SSA statement will also show your estimated retirement benefits at different claiming ages (62, FRA, 70), which is helpful for planning.
THIS is why our system is BROKEN!!!! My grandfather worked for the railroad for 42 YEARS and his benefit is BARELY enough to live on now. Why can't seniors collect everything they've earned and paid into??? Meanwhile Congress gives themselves raises every year!!!
I know right?? The cost of everything keeps going up but benefits barely change. My mom's medicine alone is almost $300/month AFTER insurance!
One last thing to consider - if your father has limited income and resources despite his RRB benefits, he should definitely apply for the Medicare Savings Programs. They can help pay Medicare premiums and in some cases deductibles and copayments. This could free up a significant amount of his monthly income. Also, many states have pharmaceutical assistance programs for seniors that can help with medication costs beyond what Medicare Part D covers. These programs won't increase his RRB payment directly, but they can effectively increase his available monthly income by reducing his healthcare expenses.
Thank you all for the helpful information! I feel much better knowing that since I'm past my FRA, my vacation payout won't reduce my Social Security benefits. I hadn't considered the tax implications, so I'll definitely keep that in mind and probably set aside some money for taxes next year. I'm glad I asked before starting the process - this community has been so helpful!
i think i saw something on the ssa website about a benefit estimator or calculator you can use? maybe try that to get rough numbers before deciding. good luck!
The SSA calculators unfortunately don't handle survivor benefits with windexing very well, especially for deaths that occurred many years ago. They're designed more for retirement benefit estimates based on your own work record. That's likely why the office told her they couldn't provide estimates without an application.
This reminded me of my situation with my late wife's benefits. What complicated things for me was that I was still working while trying to collect survivor benefits. The earnings test reduced my benefit until I reached FRA. Are you still working? If so, that's another factor to consider before claiming early.
Yes, I'm still working part-time (about $22,000/year). I completely forgot about the earnings test! That's another good point to consider. Do you remember what the threshold was before benefits were reduced?
For 2025, the annual earnings limit is around $22,330 if you're under FRA for the full year. They deduct $1 in benefits for every $2 you earn above that limit. The year you reach FRA, the limit is much higher (around $59,520), and they only deduct $1 for every $3 over the limit. After you reach FRA, there's no earnings test at all. Since you're right at the threshold, you might want to carefully manage your income if you decide to claim early.
I think what might be confusing you is that your ex-husband is likely affected by WEP (which reduces his own earned benefit) while you're affected by GPO (which reduces spousal benefits). The recent legislation mainly addressed WEP, not GPO. From my understanding, the changes to WEP might increase your ex's benefit somewhat, but won't directly impact your GPO reduction. However, there might be some indirect effect if his primary insurance amount increases. The calculation is pretty complex, so it's definitely worth contacting SSA for a personalized review. The recent changes are still being implemented, so even the agents might need to double-check the updated rules.
One more thing to consider - when did you get divorced? If it was within the last couple of years, make sure SSA knows you were married for over 10 years (38 years in your case). Sometimes they miss that detail, which is crucial for ex-spouse benefits. Also, are you 62 or older? That's another requirement for ex-spouse benefits.
i get these all the time lol. one time they said my ssn was suspended for suspicious activity and i needed to call right away to fix it. another time they said i qualified for a cost of living increase if i verified my info. all BS. just delete and move on with your day.
Important to note: The legitimate ways SSA will contact you are: 1. Letters through USPS mail 2. Secure messages in your mySocialSecurity account 3. Scheduled phone calls that YOU arranged 4. In-person appointments at SSA offices If you're expecting communication from SSA about benefits (retirement, survivors, disability, SSI), always log into your mySocialSecurity account directly or call the official number. Never call numbers provided in unexpected texts or emails. The rise in these scams coincides with more Baby Boomers reaching full retirement age (FRA) and applying for benefits. Scammers know this demographic is actively engaged with SSA right now.
my cousin waited til last week of deadline to file reconsideration and then his internet went out! ended up having to drive 2 hours to nearest SSA office that had appointments! dont wait!
One more thing I forgot to mention - make sure you're seeing doctors who are willing to fill out an RFC (Residual Functional Capacity) form for you. That carries a lot more weight than just regular medical records. Your neurosurgeon might be willing to complete one after your consultation. This was a game-changer for my case after my initial denial.
Yes, you can find RFC forms online, or the SSA can provide one. It's essentially a detailed form where your doctor documents exactly what you can and cannot do physically (sitting, standing, lifting, etc.). Since the SSA denied you because they think you can return to your previous work, having your doctor specifically address why you cannot perform those job duties on an RFC form is extremely valuable evidence.
You should definitely look into whether itd be better to wait until FRA to claim! My sister claimed at 63 and really regrets it now.
I've definitely considered waiting, but between some health concerns and immediate financial needs, I think claiming now makes more sense for my situation. I know the math usually favors waiting if you live long enough, but family history suggests I might not make it to the break-even point!
Makes sense! Everyone's situation is different for sure.
WHY DOES SOCIAL SECURITY MAKE EVERYTHING SO COMPLICATED??? The earnings test, the taxation thresholds, the application process - it's like they WANT us to make mistakes! And then they send those scary overpayment notices! The whole system needs to be simplified.
Noland Curtis
Just a follow-up thought - since your regular payment came on the 23rd, which is right on schedule, this likely isn't a payment date adjustment. When SSA changes your payment date (which happens sometimes due to various administrative reasons), they would move your entire payment to a different day, not split it across two days. Are you receiving both Social Security retirement/disability AND SSI benefits? Sometimes people who qualify for both get payments on different days of the month, and occasionally one program might have an adjustment payment.
0 coins
Raul Neal
•No, I only receive Social Security retirement benefits, not SSI. That's why this is so puzzling to me. Based on everyone's comments, it sounds like it's most likely some kind of adjustment or correction. I'll wait for the letter and then update everyone here when I find out what it was!
0 coins
Vanessa Figueroa
Has anyone here ever noticed that the SSA website sometimes updates with info about these kinds of payments BEFORE you actually get a letter in the mail? I always check there first when anything weird happens with my payments. Sometimes they have an explanation posted in my message center before the letter arrives.
0 coins
Muhammad Hobbs
•YES!! The message center sometimes has the info but GOOD LUCK finding it!! That website is IMPOSSIBLE to navigate sometimes!!! I asked my granddaughter to help me find stuff there because I get lost every time!!!
0 coins