Someone filed for NY unemployment in my name - now I'm fighting to clear identity theft
I just found out someone has been collecting unemployment benefits in my name since December 2022! I only discovered this when I got a weird tax form in April showing over $8,300 in benefits I never received or applied for. I immediately called ny unemployment but after waiting 2 hours, they just told me to file a fraud report online and contact the police. Filed a police report, submitted the fraud form on the website, and froze my credit. It's been almost 6 weeks and nothing has happened. The online form just disappeared into the void, and my calls keep getting disconnected after hours of waiting. Meanwhile, I'm worried about owing taxes on money I never got and my social security number being compromised. Has anyone else dealt with this? What else can I do to get this resolved?
50 comments
Carmen Lopez
This happened to my cousin back in 2021. Totaly nightmare. She had to send in copies of her ID, birth certificate, social security card, and utility bills just to prove she wasn't the one filing. Took her like 7 months to fully resolve it. Def file an identity theft report with the FTC at identitytheft.gov and notify the credit bureaus. They should give you a case number you can use with ny unemployment to track it.
0 coins
Yuki Ito
7 MONTHS?! What am I supposed to do about the taxes in the meantime? Did your cousin have to pay taxes on the fraudulent unemployment?
0 coins
1M
Carmen Lopez
Yea it was brutal. She had to file her taxes normally but included a form called Identity Theft Affidavit (Form 14039) explaining the situation. Her tax guy helped her with it. The IRS evenchually sorted it out but it took forever.
0 coins
27d
AstroAdventurer
identitytheft.gov is legit advice tho ๐ they'll actually walk you through all the steps you should take. Better than the useless advice from unemployment
0 coins
25d
Write a comment...
Andre Dupont
After trying to reach ny unemployment for weeks with no luck, I finally found a service that actually worked to get someone on the phone. Used claimyr.com and within 45 minutes I had an actual human helping me with my fraud case. Talking to an agent got my case prioritized and they helped me fill out all the right paperwork. Best decision I made after wasting days on hold. Check out their explanation video: https://youtu.be/Rdqa1gKtxuE
0 coins
Zoe Papanikolaou
is this for real? been trying to reach them for 3 weeks about a similar issue
0 coins
1M
Andre Dupont
Yeah totally worked for me. They basically wait on hold for you then call you when a real person picks up. Saved me hours of my life and got my fraud case moving.
0 coins
27d
Jamal Wilson
sounds too good to be true... unemployment phone systems are notoriously impossible ๐คจ
0 coins
26d
Andre Dupont
I was skeptical too but was desperate after weeks of trying. It actually worked - they connected me to an agent who started my fraud investigation properly. Check their reviews if youre unsure, but it saved me so much headache.
0 coins
25d
Mei Lin
yeah right, another 'miracle solution'... what's the catch? ๐
0 coins
25d
Andre Dupont
The catch is you don't waste 4 hours of your life on hold lol. Seriously tho, talking to a real person made all the difference for my case. They knew exactly what forms I needed and put notes in my file.
0 coins
25d
Write a comment...
Liam Fitzgerald
Been there! Someone stole $11k in benefits using my info last year. You NEED to: 1. Get an Identity Protection PIN from the IRS immediately so no one can file taxes as you 2. Contact Social Security Administration to make sure your work record is correct 3. File a report with your local district attorney's office - some have special unemployment fraud units 4. KEEP CALLING unemployment - document every call with date/time 5. Call your state rep/senator's office - they have staff who can escalate these cases Just using the online portal won't cut it. This is unfortunately incredibly common since the pandemic. The unemployment systems are still overwhelmed with fraud cases. I eventually got mine resolved by connecting with a live agent through claimyr.com who flagged my case for the fraud department and stopped any further payments being issued in my name. Don't give up - this can be fixed but you have to be super persistent!
0 coins
Yuki Ito
Thank you for the detailed response! I didn't even think about getting an IRS PIN or contacting SSA. Did you have to file your taxes differently because of this?
0 coins
27d
Liam Fitzgerald
Yes! When I filed, I included Form 14039 (Identity Theft Affidavit) and attached a statement explaining the unemployment fraud. My accountant also helped me draft a letter. Definitely recommend getting a tax professional if possible.
0 coins
25d
GalacticGuru
calling your state rep is KEY. my unemployment issue sat for months until I got my assembly member involved. suddenly things started moving.
0 coins
25d
Amara Nnamani
That claimyr site actually works? I've been trying to reach a human at ny unemployment for my identity theft case for like 2 weeks straight
0 coins
25d
Liam Fitzgerald
It did for me. I was super skeptical but after wasting literally days on hold, I tried it and got through to someone who actually knew what they were doing. Made all the difference.
0 coins
25d
Write a comment...
Giovanni Mancini
lol welcome to the club. NY unemployment security is a joke. My wife, my brother, AND my neighbor all had this happen. The department is so understaffed they take forever to fix it.Your talking months not weeks to resolve.
0 coins
Write a comment...
Fatima Al-Suwaidi
Contact your STATE REPRESENTATIVE!!! This is the only thing that worked for me with the exact same issue. I spent 3 months trying to fix it through normal channels and nothing happened. Called my assembly member, their office had a direct contact at unemployment, and my case was resolved in 10 days. Do this yesterday!
0 coins
Yuki Ito
That's a great idea! Did you just call their local office? Did they need any specific info from you?
0 coins
25d
Fatima Al-Suwaidi
Just called the local office and explained my situation. They had me fill out a consent form so they could inquire on my behalf, and then asked for copies of the tax forms showing the fraud. Super easy process actually!
0 coins
25d
Dylan Cooper
This is the way. Representative's offices have staff whose entire job is constituent services. They can cut through red tape like nothing else.
0 coins
25d
Write a comment...
Sofia Morales
The unemployment system is totally broken. I had a similar issue and it took EIGHT MONTHS to resolve. Keep calling, document everything, and be prepared for a long battle. So sorry youre dealing with this.
0 coins
Write a comment...
StarSailor
Serious question - has anyone actually gotten through to a human at ny unemployment lately? I've been trying for days and just get disconnected.
0 coins
Dmitry Ivanov
I finally got through after calling at exactly 8:00am monday morning. Still waited 1hr 45min but at least didn't get disconnected.
0 coins
25d
Ava Garcia
Try calling the fraud department directly instead of the main line: 888-598-2077. Sometimes less busy.
0 coins
25d
Miguel Silva
Honestly I gave up and used claimyr.com - they got me through to a person within an hour. was a game changer after weeks of trying.
0 coins
25d
Write a comment...
Zainab Ismail
make sure you put a fraud alert on your credit reports with all three bureaus! and check your credit report for any other weird activity. fraudsters who do unemployment scams often hit other things too.
0 coins
Yuki Ito
Already did that, along with a credit freeze. Should I be checking anything else?
0 coins
25d
Zainab Ismail
Good! Also check your bank statements for any small random charges - scammers often test accounts with tiny transactions. And check your earnings record with Social Security to make sure no one's working under your SSN too.
0 coins
25d
Write a comment...
Connor O'Neill
bro the exact same thing happened to me. someone filed for $13,470 in benefits using my info. took me 5 months of constant calling to get it fixed. keep ALL documentation, get a case ID number, and whatever you do, don't stop following up.
0 coins
Write a comment...
QuantumQuester
Have you checked your mail carefully? NY unemployment should have been sending notices to your address all along if someone was claiming in your name. Sometimes they look like junk mail though.
0 coins
Yuki Ito
I moved about 8 months ago, so it's possible they were sending stuff to my old address. I did set up mail forwarding but who knows if everything came through correctly.
0 coins
25d
QuantumQuester
That explains it! The scammer probably knew you moved and took advantage of the gap. Make sure unemployment has your current address for all future correspondence.
0 coins
25d
Write a comment...
Yara Nassar
NY unemployment identity theft is epidemic right now. I work at a legal aid office and we're seeing dozens of these cases every week. The system is completely overwhelmed. Your best bet is getting help from either your state rep as others suggested OR through the Attorney General's office - they have a special task force for unemployment fraud now.
0 coins
Keisha Williams
Wait the AG's office can help? What's the contact info for that task force?
0 coins
25d
Yara Nassar
You can file a complaint with the NY AG at https://ag.ny.gov/labor/unemployment-fraud. They can't help with every case but they're prioritizing large-scale or severe fraud cases.
0 coins
25d
Write a comment...
Paolo Ricci
literally in the same boat rn. someone claimed $9,500 in my name last year. the worst part is I actually DID need unemployment for a few months this year and got denied because of the fraud case on my account ๐ก
0 coins
Write a comment...
Amina Toure
has anyone here actually had success getting the IRS to remove fraudulent unemployment from their tax transcript? thats where im stuck now
0 coins
Oliver Zimmermann
I did! Filed Form 14039 with my taxes plus a written statement. Took about 4 months but they eventually removed it and sent an updated transcript.
0 coins
25d
CosmicCommander
same. but I had to provide the letter from unemployment confirming the fraud investigation first.
0 coins
25d
Write a comment...
Natasha Volkova
dont forget to notify your employer too! sometimes these scammers will also try to file benefits against your current job
0 coins
Write a comment...
Javier Torres
When this happened to me, I was getting absolutely nowhere with phone calls and online forms. I finally broke down and hired an identity theft attorney who knew exactly who to contact and what to say. Within 3 weeks my case was resolved. Not cheap but worth every penny after months of frustration.
0 coins
Yuki Ito
Can I ask roughly how much that cost? I'm willing to pay for help at this point but don't want to get ripped off.
0 coins
25d
Javier Torres
I paid $1500 for the whole process, but this was in 2021 when these cases were at peak volume. Might be less now. Check if your employer offers any legal insurance or identity theft protection services - sometimes they cover this kind of thing.
0 coins
25d
Write a comment...
Emma Davis
Check if there's a Way2Go debit card associated with the fraudulent claim. Sometimes the scammers have these cards mailed to different addresses. That info can help track them down.
0 coins
Write a comment...
Malik Johnson
your bank may have resources to help too! I work at a credit union and we have a whole department that helps members with identity theft. they can't fix the unemployment issue directly but can help protect your other accounts and credit.
0 coins
Write a comment...
Isabella Ferreira
How did you even find out? Now I'm paranoid someone could be collecting in my name and I wouldn't even know...
0 coins
Yuki Ito
I only found out when I got a 1099-G tax form showing unemployment income I never received. You could request a wage and income transcript from the IRS to see if there's anything fishy on your record.
0 coins
25d
Isabella Ferreira
Thx for the tip, definitely gonna check that out. This is terrifying tbh
0 coins
25d
Write a comment...