


Ask the community...
This whole gig economy unemployment thing is such a mess. Half the time they don't know how to handle our situations and we get stuck in adjudication forever while they try to figure out if we qualify or not. The system wasn't designed for people like us.
I'm in a similar situation as an Uber driver in NYC - my earnings have dropped significantly over the past few months. From what I've researched, you'll definitely want to gather all your documentation before applying. Besides the 1099s and bank statements others mentioned, I'd also recommend keeping your Uber driver app earnings statements and any tax returns where you reported this income. The NYS Department of Labor website has a section specifically for independent contractors that walks through the eligibility requirements. One thing I learned is that they calculate your benefit amount differently than for traditional employees, so don't expect the same formula. Also consider applying sooner rather than later since there can be waiting periods and backlogs like others have mentioned.
Thanks for sharing this detailed info! I'm also dealing with reduced earnings and didn't realize there was a specific section for independent contractors on their website. Do you happen to know if there's a minimum earnings threshold you need to meet to qualify? I'm worried my income might be too low since I was only doing this part-time before things got really slow.
The whole system is such a pain honestly. I've been dealing with NYS Department of Labor for years with my restaurant and they change the rules constantly. Just make sure you keep detailed records of everything because they WILL ask for documentation later.
Just went through this process myself a few months ago! @Liam O'Sullivan is spot on about the $300 threshold. One thing that helped me was calling the NYS Department of Labor early in the morning (like 8 AM sharp) - seemed to have better luck getting through then. Also, make sure you understand the difference between employees and independent contractors because that affects your UI liability. If you're just doing consulting work solo with 1099 contractors, you're probably not liable yet. But definitely get clarity before you start paying anyone regularly!
That's a great tip about calling early! I never would have thought of that timing strategy. Quick question - when you say 1099 contractors don't count toward the threshold, does that include if I'm paying the same contractor regularly throughout the year? Like if I have one person I work with consistently but they're still technically a contractor?
I had the worst time trying to reach someone at NYS Department of Labor when I had questions about my claim. Spent hours calling and either got busy signals or got disconnected. Finally found this service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that actually got me through to a real person at the unemployment office. They have this video demo showing exactly how it works: https://youtu.be/qyftW-mnTNI. Saved me so much frustration dealing with the phone system.
Is that service legit? I'm always worried about giving my info to third parties when it comes to unemployment stuff.
@Mateo Perez Thanks for sharing this! I ve'been trying to get through to NYS DOL for days about my reduced hours situation. Did you have to pay anything for the Claimyr service or is it free to use?
Just wanted to add that if you do quit and apply for benefits, NYS Department of Labor will contact your employer to verify the reason for separation. If your employer disputes your claim and says you quit without good cause, you'll have to go through an adjudication process that can take weeks. Make sure you have solid documentation if you're going to claim constructive dismissal.
Pro tip: take screenshots of everything and keep a spreadsheet. NY unemployment system is notorious for glitches
Hey! I went through the exact same thing last month. That waiting week showing $0 is normal - it's unpaid by design. The real issue is why nothing else is showing up after 04/28. Check if you have any pending issues under "Claim Status" - could be identity verification, work search requirements, or they need more info. Also make sure you're certifying on the right days (usually Sunday-Tuesday). If everything looks clean on your end, definitely call or use one of those callback services people mentioned. Don't stop certifying though - you'll lose those weeks if you do! Keep records of everything in case you need to prove you were certifying.
Dmitry Ivanov
I've been dealing with this nightmare for over a month now! Tried everything - calling at different times, using multiple phone numbers, even had my mom try calling from her landline. The "higher than normal call volume" message is such a joke at this point. I'm seriously considering that paid service @Paige Cantoni mentioned because I'm losing my mind here. Has anyone tried showing up in person at a local office? I know they prefer phone calls but I'm desperate. Also wondering if there's a specific time of day that works better - like maybe right after lunch when some people might have given up for the day? This whole system is broken and we're the ones suffering for it. 😡
0 coins
Zainab Abdulrahman
•@Dmitry Ivanov I totally feel your frustration! I ve'been going through the same thing for about 3 weeks now. Regarding showing up in person - I actually tried that last week and they basically told me all services are by phone/online only unless you have a scheduled appointment which (you can only get by... calling them 🙄 .)Such a catch-22! I did notice slightly better luck calling around 2:30-3pm on Wednesdays, maybe because that s'when fewer people are trying? Still took forever but at least I didn t'get an immediate busy signal. The paid service is starting to look more tempting every day - might be worth it just for our sanity at this point!
0 coins
Abigail bergen
I'm going through the exact same thing right now! Been trying for almost 2 weeks and it's incredibly frustrating. I've been following some of the advice here - trying to call right at 8am, staying on hold even when it says long wait times, and being persistent. Yesterday I tried calling 28 times throughout the day with no luck. I'm seriously considering that paid service @Paige Cantoni mentioned because at this point my time and sanity are worth way more than $20. Has anyone noticed if certain days of the week are better than others? I was thinking maybe mid-week might be less busy than Mondays when everyone's trying to call after the weekend. This whole situation is just unacceptable - we shouldn't have to jump through hoops like this to access services we're entitled to!
0 coins
Diego Mendoza
•@Abigail bergen I m'right there with you! Just joined this community because I m'dealing with the exact same nightmare. Been trying to get through for about 10 days now and it s'maddening. I ve'read through all these comments and I m'definitely going to try the 8am sharp strategy tomorrow - seems like that s'the most consistent advice. Really considering that paid service too even though it bugs me that we have to pay extra for something that should just work. Has anyone tried calling multiple numbers at the same time? Like having family members call different departments and then ask for transfers? Might be worth a shot at this point. This whole system is completely broken and it s'affecting real people s'lives! 😤
0 coins
Liam Fitzgerald
•@Abigail bergen @Diego Mendoza I ve been'lurking here for a while dealing with the same issue! Finally got through last week after 19 days of trying. What worked for me was calling exactly at 8:00:00 AM on a Tuesday using the main unemployment number, then immediately pressing the option for payment issues "even though" that wasn t my'actual problem - that queue seemed shorter. Once I got a human, I explained my real issue and they transferred me to the right department without making me call back. Took 3.5 hours on hold total but I finally got my claim resolved. The key is NOT hanging up once you re in'any queue, even if it s the'wrong one. Also had my phone plugged in and on speaker the whole time. Don t give'up - it really does work eventually!
0 coins