Unemployment non-pay excess earnings holiday pay how to appeal with Nevada DETR?
So my employer paid out holiday pay when they laid me off in January and now Nevada DETR hit me with a non-pay week saying I had excess earnings that disqualified me from benefits for that week. The thing is I wasn't even working - I was already laid off, they just included the holiday pay in my final check as part of standard company policy. I had no idea this would tank my claim for that week. I tried calling the CSS line to get someone to explain the whole excess earnings determination but couldn't get through after like 8 attempts. My CSS portal just shows the non-pay status with zero explanation of how they calculated the excess amount or whether the holiday pay should even count as wages in this situation. Has anyone dealt with this specific scenario where severance-adjacent holiday pay triggered an excess earnings week? And more importantly has anyone successfully appealed it and gotten the week reinstated? I'm looking at roughly $680 in lost benefits and I really need to understand if fighting this is worth the effort or if the appeal process is just a black hole.
84 comments

Sean O'Donnell
Holiday pay tripping the excess earnings rule - yeah this is actually a known headache with Nevada DETR. The thing that matters most here is whether the holiday pay was tied to a specific date of work or just a lump payout in your final check. If it was assigned to a specific pay period by your employer, DETR may treat it as wages earned in that week regardless of when you actually stopped working. That determination drives everything else in your appeal. First thing I'd do in your shoes is pull your separation paperwork and find exactly how your employer coded that holiday pay - as terminal vacation payout, as pay for a specific holiday date, or just a general final compensation amount. That coding is going to be the backbone of any appeal argument you make. Nevada UI rules say that payments made in lieu of notice or as a one-time separation amount can sometimes be excluded from the weekly wage calculation, but holiday pay that's tied to an actual calendar holiday often gets treated differently. The appeals process itself isn't a black hole if you go in with documentation - you have 11 days from the determination date to file your appeal through the CSS portal.
0 coins
StarSeeker
AuthorThe coding question is exactly what I can't figure out - my final pay stub just says 'holiday' as the earnings category. Does that hurt me or help me in an appeal?
0 coins
Sean O'Donnell
Ambiguous coding can actually work in your favor. If DETR can't clearly establish it was tied to a specific workday, you have grounds to argue it should be treated as a separation payment rather than weekly wages. Document that the stub only says 'holiday' with no specific date attached.
0 coins
Zara Ahmed
wait so the 11 day clock - does that start from when you got the letter or when the determination was actually made in the system bc those were different dates for me
0 coins
Luca Esposito
Same thing hit me back in spring, holiday pay from my last paycheck created an excess earnings non-pay week even though I hadn't worked in two weeks at that point. The appeal form is under the Determinations section in CSS - look for the link that says 'Appeal This Determination' right next to the non-pay week entry. What I wish someone had told me is that the burden is on you to show the payment shouldn't count as remuneration for that specific week. I had to get a letter from my former HR department clarifying how they classify holiday pay in final checks. Without that letter my appeal probably would've gone nowhere.
0 coins
StarSeeker
AuthorHR letter - ok that's a concrete step I can actually take. Did they give you any pushback about writing it or was it pretty standard?
0 coins
Luca Esposito
Mine was pretty cooperative honestly, I just emailed HR and explained I needed clarification on how the holiday pay was categorized for unemployment purposes. Got a response in two days. The letter just needed to state it was a standard final pay policy payment not tied to hours worked.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
This is good advice but also worth noting that some HR departments will refuse to write those letters so have a backup plan like payroll records showing no actual hours were worked that holiday week
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
Trying to get through to an actual DETR agent to ask about the excess earnings calculation before you appeal is honestly the move - you want to know exactly what numbers they used before you write your appeal statement. I burned three days trying to reach someone and kept getting the busy signal or the system cutting me off mid-hold. Someone in another thread pointed me to Claimyr, claimyr.com, they have a demo video at https://youtu.be/Mc9FNfOF_yY showing how it works. It basically gets you connected to a live DETR rep without you having to sit there redialing for hours. I used it specifically to ask how my employer-reported wages were entered and that info completely changed how I framed my appeal argument. Worth it just for that conversation alone.
0 coins
StarSeeker
AuthorHow specific was the agent about the calculation - like did they actually walk you through the wage amount they were using?
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
Yeah the agent pulled up the employer wage report and read me exactly what figure was submitted. Turned out my employer had coded it differently on the DETR wage report than on my pay stub which is exactly the kind of discrepancy you want to know about before you write an appeal.
0 coins
GalaxyGuardian
Is this legit? I'm always sketched out by third party services when it involves government benefits stuff
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
I get the hesitation, I had it too. It just connects you to the actual DETR phone line, you're still talking to a real state agent. It's not some separate benefits service or anything like that.
0 coins
Aisha Abdullah
The excess earnings calculation itself is worth understanding before anything else - DETR takes your weekly benefit amount and adds a small disregard buffer, and if your reported earnings for the week exceed that combined amount you get zero for the week instead of a reduced payment. For most people that buffer is pretty small so even modest holiday pay pushes you over. The question in your appeal is whether the holiday pay should have been attributed to that specific week at all. Payments that aren't tied to actual services rendered during the claim week have been successfully argued out of the calculation before. Your $680 is definitely worth the effort of appealing.
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
Does the disregard amount change based on your WBA or is it a flat number for everyone?
0 coins
Aisha Abdullah
It's calculated as a percentage of your weekly benefit amount, not a flat number, so it scales with what you were approved for. The specific percentage is in your award letter but most people never look at that section until they hit an excess earnings week.
0 coins
StarSeeker
AuthorSo theoretically if the holiday pay gets reclassified as not tied to that week, the excess earnings determination goes away entirely and the week gets paid out at my full WBA?
0 coins
Aisha Abdullah
That's the goal of the appeal, yes. If the ALJ agrees the payment shouldn't be attributed to that claim week, the non-pay determination gets reversed and you'd receive your full WBA for that week.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
Genuine question - did you file your weekly claim for that non-pay week or skip it because you assumed you wouldn't get anything? Because if you didn't file you've got a whole separate problem on top of the appeal.
0 coins
StarSeeker
AuthorI did file it, I just got the non-pay determination after. So the week is in the system, it just shows as zero payment due to the excess earnings finding.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
Ok good, that's the right situation to be in for an appeal. I've seen people skip filing when they expect a non-pay week and then they can't appeal what was never formally determined. You're set up correctly.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
This is an underrated point - always file even when you think you won't get paid, the determination itself is what creates the appeal rights
0 coins
Andre Laurent
UGH the excess earnings thing is THE WORST and DETR's explanations are absolutely useless. I went through this last year when my company paid out accumulated holiday hours and I lost TWO weeks because they spread the payment across two pay periods in their reporting. Filed an appeal, waited three months, and got a hearing scheduled only to have my former employer not even show up. Eventually got one week reinstated and had to fight for the second separately. The system is designed to exhaust you into giving up. APPEAL EVERYTHING even if the amount seems small because these things set precedent for your whole claim.
0 coins
StarSeeker
AuthorThree months for a hearing date - is that typical or was that an unusually long wait?
0 coins
Andre Laurent
That was about average from what I've seen people report. The appeals unit is backlogged constantly. Set a calendar reminder to follow up after 6 weeks if you haven't heard anything.
0 coins
AstroAce
The employer not showing up thing happened to me too and I still lost my appeal somehow, still have no idea how that's even possible
0 coins
Andre Laurent
Appeals where the employer doesn't appear should default in the claimant's favor in most situations but somehow DETR still manages to find ways around it, document everything and be ready to argue your own case regardless
0 coins
Zoe Kyriakidou
Before my appeal hearing I actually called DETR using Claimyr to ask specifically what documentation the appeals unit finds most persuasive for excess earnings disputes. The agent I reached had worked with the appeals unit before and said a written employer statement combined with payroll records showing no actual hours worked in the disputed week is basically the gold standard. She also said to explicitly reference the Nevada UI statute language in your written appeal statement because ALJs notice when claimants have done their homework. That call saved me a ton of guesswork.
0 coins
StarSeeker
AuthorThe statute reference - do you know which specific section covers how holiday pay gets categorized?
0 coins
Zoe Kyriakidou
I'd look at NAC 612 sections dealing with 'remuneration' definitions, that's where the wage attribution rules live. Your appeal statement should quote the relevant language and argue your holiday pay doesn't meet the definition of remuneration for that specific week.
0 coins
Jamal Brown
Does citing statutes actually make a difference or does the ALJ just look at the employer's wage report and call it done?
0 coins
Zoe Kyriakidou
From what I was told it makes a real difference in close calls. ALJs have discretion in how they weigh evidence and showing you understand the legal framework makes your argument more credible than just saying 'this doesn't seem fair.
0 coins
Mei Zhang
Something nobody has mentioned yet - when you file the appeal through CSS make sure your written statement is detailed and not just a few sentences. I made the mistake of writing like three lines because I thought I'd explain everything at the hearing. But if the appeals unit does a preliminary paper review and your written statement is weak they can deny before it even gets to a hearing stage. Write everything out - what the holiday pay was for, how it appeared on your stub, that you weren't working that week, that your employer includes it as standard separation policy. Treat the written statement like your whole case might hinge on it.
0 coins
StarSeeker
AuthorCan you add documentation attachments to the CSS appeal submission or is it just a text field?
0 coins
Mei Zhang
There's an attachment option in the appeals section of CSS. Upload everything - pay stub, any HR correspondence, your original separation notice. The more contemporaneous documentation the better.
0 coins
Liam McConnell
Agree with this completely, I went into my hearing assuming I'd explain things verbally and the ALJ kept referring back to what I'd written in the initial appeal statement as if that was the definitive record
0 coins
GalaxyGuardian
Honest question for anyone who's been through this - does appealing a non-pay excess earnings determination affect your ability to keep receiving benefits on your other weeks while the appeal is processing? I'm in a similar situation and scared to rock the boat.
0 coins
Sean O'Donnell
Filing an appeal on one determination doesn't freeze your whole claim. You keep filing weekly claims and receiving payments on weeks that aren't in dispute. The appeal is just for that specific determination.
0 coins
GalaxyGuardian
Ok that's a huge relief because I was afraid appealing would flag my account for some kind of additional review on all my weeks
0 coins
Luca Esposito
The fear is understandable but no, they're treated as separate determinations. Though I'd still keep detailed records of all your weekly filings and job search contacts during the appeal period just in case.
0 coins
Amara Oluwaseyi
Just went through an excess earnings appeal that I won two weeks ago so this is fresh. The key argument that worked for me was establishing the concept of 'when earned vs when paid.' Holiday pay that was accrued during your employment but paid out after separation should theoretically be attributed to the accrual period, not the week you received the check. If you can show through payroll records or an HR letter that the holiday pay was for a holiday that occurred before your separation date, you're arguing it was earned pre-separation and shouldn't count against post-separation weeks. That framing got my determination reversed.
0 coins
StarSeeker
AuthorThis is exactly the angle I needed - the holiday in question was actually in December and I was laid off in early January, so the holiday predates my separation.
0 coins
Amara Oluwaseyi
That is a genuinely strong fact pattern for you. The holiday was clearly earned before your separation and the payment timing was just administrative. Document the December holiday date, your separation date, and make the 'when earned' argument explicitly in your appeal statement.
0 coins
Zara Ahmed
This when-earned framing - is this something DETR formally recognizes or is it more of a logical argument you're making to the ALJ?
0 coins
Amara Oluwaseyi
It's both - there's a basis in how Nevada UI rules treat certain types of deferred compensation, and the ALJ has discretion to apply that reasoning to holiday pay situations. It's not a slam dunk but it's a recognized line of argument.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
Quick thing that tripped me up - the appeal deadline is 11 calendar days from the mailing date on the determination notice, not 11 days from when you received it or when you read it. If you're close to that window, file the appeal today even if your documentation isn't complete yet. You can supplement with additional documents later but you can't file after the deadline passes.
0 coins
StarSeeker
AuthorI got the notice four days ago so I have some time but I'm not waiting around. Filing the initial appeal statement this weekend.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
Smart, don't sit on it. Even a thorough appeal statement written in a few days is better than a rushed one written on day 10.
0 coins
AstroAce
Does the CSS portal actually show you the deadline date anywhere or do you have to count it yourself from the letter?
0 coins
Nia Thompson
You have to count it yourself in my experience, the portal doesn't display an appeal-by date. Count from the date printed on the notice, not from when you logged in and saw it.
0 coins
Jamal Brown
My cousin went through something almost identical - holiday pay in final check, non-pay week, the whole thing. She ended up getting the week reinstated but only after the hearing, the initial paper review denied her. So don't be discouraged if you get a denial on the first review, the hearing stage is where these cases actually get argued properly and the ALJ can hear your full explanation.
0 coins
StarSeeker
AuthorHow long between the initial denial and the hearing date in her case?
0 coins
Jamal Brown
About six weeks between the initial denial and getting the hearing date, then another three weeks until the actual hearing. So roughly two months total from initial appeal to resolution.
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
Two months is rough when you're waiting on that money, especially for someone who is already dealing with the stress of being laid off
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
For the appeal statement itself I'd structure it in three clear sections. First, the factual background - your layoff date, the holiday date, how the payment appeared in your final check. Second, the argument for why the holiday pay shouldn't be attributed to your claim week - the 'when earned' argument mentioned above works here. Third, the relief you're requesting - reversal of the excess earnings determination and payment of your full WBA for the disputed week. Keep each section focused and factual, avoid emotional framing, ALJs respond better to clear logical arguments than to 'this isn't fair' type statements.
0 coins
StarSeeker
AuthorThree-section structure - copying this down. The factual background section should include documentation references or save those for the attachments?
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
Reference them in the text and attach the actual documents. Something like 'as shown in the attached payroll record dated X, no hours were worked during the week of Y.' Makes it easy for the ALJ to cross-reference your statements with the evidence.
0 coins
Liam McConnell
This is how I should have written mine. I just wrote a narrative paragraph and the ALJ had to do all the work of pulling out the relevant facts. Clear structure really does make a difference.
0 coins
CosmicCaptain
Something I want to flag - I had excess earnings issues and completely failed to get through to DETR for weeks trying to understand my situation before appealing. A friend told me about Claimyr and I used it to finally reach an agent who explained that my employer had reported my holiday pay under the wrong week entirely - it was a data entry error on the employer's side. If I had just filed the appeal without knowing that, I would have been making arguments about the wrong thing. The agent at DETR actually flagged the reporting error while I was on the call and initiated a correction request. Sometimes the right answer isn't even an appeal, it's a correction to what the employer submitted.
0 coins
StarSeeker
AuthorEmployer reporting error - I hadn't even considered that could be what happened here. So DETR's excess earnings determination is entirely based on what the employer reports and not independently verified?
0 coins
CosmicCaptain
That's my understanding - DETR takes the employer's wage report at face value unless challenged. If the employer made an input error in what week they attributed the holiday pay to, that flows directly into your determination. Calling to verify what was actually submitted before appealing is worth doing.
0 coins
Amara Oluwaseyi
This is a genuinely important point. Appeal the determination but also verify the underlying employer wage submission is accurate. Two separate issues that can both affect your outcome.
0 coins
AstroAce
Does anyone know if you can have someone help you at the hearing - like can you bring a friend who understands this better than you do or do you have to represent yourself?
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
You can bring a representative to your hearing. It doesn't have to be an attorney - it can be a family member or friend who helps you organize and present your case. You just need to let the appeals unit know in advance.
0 coins
AstroAce
That's good to know, I definitely would want someone with me because I completely freeze when anyone official asks me questions
0 coins
Luca Esposito
Legal aid organizations in Nevada sometimes help with UI appeals at no cost too if the amount is significant enough to warrant it - worth looking into if you feel like you need proper representation
0 coins
Liam McConnell
One more thing about the hearing itself - the hearings are conducted by phone now, not in person. So you'll get a call at your scheduled time and argue your case over the phone with the ALJ and potentially a representative from your former employer on the line too. Have all your documents in front of you, have your notes organized, and be somewhere quiet with no interruptions. I lost points in my hearing because I had to keep searching for documents and it made me sound unprepared.
0 coins
StarSeeker
AuthorEmployer representative on the call - are they usually from HR or does the company sometimes send a legal person?
0 coins
Liam McConnell
In my experience it was just an HR person, not a lawyer. But they do tend to have the payroll records in front of them so be prepared for them to cite specific numbers from the employer's submission.
0 coins
Andre Laurent
Or they don't show up at all like mine didn't, which should help you but somehow doesn't always
0 coins
Zara Ahmed
I'm kind of in the middle of a similar situation so this thread is gold for me. Slightly different though - mine was PTO payout not holiday pay specifically. Does the same appeal logic apply or is PTO treated differently by DETR?
0 coins
Aisha Abdullah
PTO payouts are generally treated similarly to holiday pay in terms of the excess earnings analysis. The same 'when earned vs when paid' argument applies - if the PTO was accrued during employment it was earned pre-separation even if paid in the final check.
0 coins
Zara Ahmed
What documentation would I need for a PTO appeal specifically - would an HR letter still be the main thing or is there something different?
0 coins
Aisha Abdullah
HR letter plus any internal PTO policy documents showing how PTO accrues and is paid out would strengthen your case. If your employer has a written policy that PTO is paid as standard separation compensation that documentation is valuable.
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
Filing my own appeal this week after reading this thread. Quick sanity check - when DETR sends the appeal confirmation, does it actually show the hearing date right away or does the hearing date come in a separate notice later?
0 coins
Sean O'Donnell
Separate notice in my experience. The initial confirmation just acknowledges the appeal was filed. The hearing notice comes later with the date, time, and dial-in information.
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
And both come through CSS portal or do they also mail them?
0 coins
Sean O'Donnell
Both - they post to your CSS portal and also mail paper copies. Watch both channels because sometimes the portal updates before the mail arrives and you don't want to miss the hearing date.
0 coins
Mei Zhang
Set up email notifications in CSS if you haven't already so you get alerted when new documents post to your account
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
Coming back to add something since my appeal got resolved last week - I want to second the advice about calling DETR before you finalize your appeal strategy. I'd been spinning my wheels writing an appeal statement based on what I thought happened and when I finally got through using Claimyr the agent told me there was a note in my file from the initial claims examiner that actually explained their reasoning. Knowing their actual reasoning let me address it directly instead of guessing. The agent also told me what documentation they would have needed to decide differently at the initial review stage which basically told me exactly what to include for the ALJ. That call was more valuable than hours of forum research.
0 coins
StarSeeker
AuthorNotes in your file from the claims examiner - I had no idea that was something you could access by calling. So there's context behind the determination that doesn't show on the CSS portal?
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
Exactly. The portal just shows you the outcome, not the reasoning. The examiner's notes explain what factors they weighted and why they landed where they did. For an appeal you really want to know that.
0 coins
Amara Oluwaseyi
This is true and underutilized. The examiner's notes are essentially a roadmap to what you need to rebut in your appeal statement.
0 coins
Jamal Brown
This thread has genuinely changed how I'm approaching my own situation, thank you to everyone who posted real detail here
0 coins