Can't reach IRS? Claimyr calls for you, so you don't have to wait on hold.
Claimyr is a pay-as-you-go service. We do not charge a recurring subscription.
Using Claimyr will:
- Connect you to a human agent at the IRS
- Skip the long phone menu
- Call the correct department
- Redial until on hold
- Forward a call to your phone with reduced hold time
- Give you free callbacks if the IRS drops your call
Ask the community...
- DO post questions about your issues.
- DO answer questions and support each other.
- DO post tips & tricks to help folks.
- DO NOT post call problems here - there is a support tab at the top for that :)
Join the conversation
Join the conversation
Yara Elias
This is such a helpful thread! I'm dealing with a similar situation with my 8-year-old's UTMA account. After reading all these responses, I'm realizing I need to completely rethink my approach. I've been doing the same gain harvesting strategy as Jessica, but now I'm understanding that between the kiddie tax threshold, potential financial aid implications, and the compounding effect of keeping money invested, I'm probably shooting myself in the foot. The state tax angle is particularly eye-opening - I'm in New York where we definitely have capital gains taxes, so even the "0% federal" scenario isn't truly tax-free for us. One question I haven't seen addressed: for those who switched from annual harvesting to a buy-and-hold strategy, did you have any issues with the cost basis tracking? I'm worried about having a messy mix of different purchase dates and basis amounts when it comes time to eventually sell everything.
Chloe Harris
This discussion has been incredibly helpful! I'm dealing with a similar situation with my 12-year-old's UTMA account, and like many of you, I've been second-guessing my gain harvesting approach. One aspect I'd love to get more clarity on: what happens if you're right at that $2,300 kiddie tax threshold? Is it worth trying to harvest gains up to exactly that amount each year, or does the administrative complexity make it not worth the effort? For context, my daughter's account has grown to about $35,000, and I estimate we could harvest around $2,000-2,500 in gains annually. We're in the 24% tax bracket, so exceeding the threshold would definitely hurt. Also, for those who mentioned using analysis tools - has anyone compared the results across different tools? I'm curious if they all reach similar conclusions or if there's significant variation in their projections. The financial aid angle is particularly concerning since we'll likely be applying for need-based aid. It sounds like the timing of when gains are realized during the college years could make a huge difference in aid eligibility.
Rami Samuels
ā¢Great question about threading that $2,300 needle! I've been in a similar situation and honestly found that trying to harvest exactly up to the threshold each year becomes more trouble than it's worth. Here's why: market timing makes it nearly impossible to predict exactly what your gains will be when you go to harvest in January. You might plan for $2,200 but end up with $2,800 due to market movements between when you calculate and when you execute. Then you're stuck either paying your higher rate on the excess or trying to do partial sales, which gets messy. Plus, with a $35k account, you're probably looking at this strategy for 6+ more years. The administrative burden of tracking everything annually, combined with the risk of accidentally exceeding the threshold, made me decide it wasn't worth the relatively small tax savings. Regarding the analysis tools, I've tried both taxr.ai and a couple others. They generally reach similar conclusions about the futility of harvesting in most situations, though they differ on the specific dollar projections. The key insight seems consistent across tools though - the compounding effect usually outweighs the tax benefits, especially when you factor in kiddie tax risks and financial aid implications. For college planning specifically, I'd recommend focusing more on timing any major realizations for years when your daughter won't be filing FAFSA (either before college or after graduation) rather than trying to optimize the annual tax treatment now.
Join the conversation
I had a similar situation with SoFi last month. Compared to my previous experience with Chase where refunds appeared exactly on the date WMR provided, SoFi held my refund for 4 additional business days for "security verification." When I called, they confirmed they had received it but wouldn't release it until their verification process completed. There was nothing I could do to expedite it. The representative matter-of-factly informed me this is standard procedure for government deposits over a certain amount at many online banks. The funds did eventually appear, but the delay was frustrating.
Ethan Brown
I'm going through this exact situation right now with my Chime account! Filed on March 3rd, got approved March 16th with a deposit date of March 21st, and still nothing. TBG told me the same thing - that they sent it - but Chime says they don't see any pending deposits. This is so stressful because I really need this refund for some unexpected expenses. Reading through everyone's experiences here, it sounds like this is unfortunately pretty common with online banks. I'm going to try calling Chime's fraud department directly like @Niko Ramsey suggested, and maybe request that refund trace from the IRS that @Katherine Shultz mentioned. Has anyone had success getting through to an actual person at TBG who could provide more specific information about when exactly they sent the deposit? Their customer service seems pretty limited when I called yesterday. Thank you @Danielle Mays for starting this thread - it's really helpful to know I'm not alone in dealing with this!
Join the conversation
Just to add another perspective - don't forget about depreciation recapture if you ever claimed any business deductions related to the car! Even if you used it for occasional business purposes or claimed it as a business asset, you might need to recapture some depreciation as ordinary income before applying capital gains treatment to the remaining profit. Also, keep detailed records of EVERYTHING - purchase price, improvement costs, restoration receipts, insurance appraisals, even photos showing the car's condition over time. The IRS can be pretty strict about documentation for collectible vehicles, especially with gains this substantial. If you don't have all your receipts, try to reconstruct what you can through bank statements, credit card records, or invoices from shops that worked on the car. One more tip: consider the timing of your sale. If you're expecting a lower income year coming up, it might be worth waiting to keep yourself in a lower tax bracket overall.
Great question about documentation! For business use vs personal use, the IRS expects you to maintain detailed records - typically a logbook showing dates, mileage, and business purpose for each use. If you only occasionally used it for car shows or business events, you'd need to document those specific instances. Without proper contemporaneous records, it's hard to prove business use, which actually works in your favor if you never intended to claim business deductions. Regarding installment sales - there's no minimum payment period required by law. You could structure it over 2-3 years if that works better for tax planning. The key requirements are: (1) you receive at least one payment after the tax year of sale, (2) you charge adequate interest (current IRS rates), and (3) you properly report the installment income each year. Just be aware that with collectibles, you'll still pay the 28% rate on the gain portion each year as you receive payments. One more consideration for anyone in this situation - if you never claimed any business deductions related to the car, then depreciation recapture isn't a concern and you can focus purely on the capital gains calculation. The bigger challenge is usually just documenting your basis (original cost plus improvements) accurately.
Great questions! Yes, you can elect out of installment treatment and recognize all remaining gain in a single year by filing Form 6252 and making the appropriate election. This gives you flexibility if your tax situation changes - maybe you have a year with lower income or significant losses to offset against. Regarding interest rates, the IRS publishes Applicable Federal Rates (AFRs) monthly in Revenue Rulings. You can find current rates on IRS.gov under "Applicable Federal Rates." The rate you use depends on the term of the installment payments - short-term (3 years or less), mid-term (over 3 but not over 9 years), or long-term (over 9 years). You must use at least the AFR that was in effect when you made the sale. One important note: even though this gives you flexibility, remember that with collectibles you're still looking at the 28% rate regardless of when you recognize the gain. The timing strategy is more about managing your overall tax bracket and potentially offsetting gains with losses in specific years.
Yes, you can elect out of installment treatment! You can choose to report all the gain in the year of sale by making an election on your tax return, or if you're already using installment treatment, you can elect to recognize all remaining gain in a future year. This is done using Form 6252 and making the appropriate election. This flexibility can be really valuable for tax planning - if you have an unexpectedly low income year, you could accelerate the remaining gain recognition. For the adequate interest rates, the IRS publishes Applicable Federal Rates (AFRs) monthly. You can find them on IRS.gov under "Applicable Federal Rates" - they're updated monthly and vary based on the term of the loan (short-term, mid-term, or long-term). For most installment sales, you'd use the mid-term AFR that was in effect at the time of sale. The rates are pretty reasonable and much lower than typical commercial lending rates. One important note: make sure any installment sale agreement is properly documented with a promissory note that includes the interest terms and payment schedule. The IRS can be picky about the formalities, especially with related party sales.
Join the conversation
State offset programs exist. They're legitimate. Most states participate. They intercept tax refunds. They apply them to debts. This includes child support. Also court fines. Even utility bills sometimes. Your best option? Call directly. Ask specifically about offsets. Request a debt verification letter. Document everything. Keep all records.
As someone who's dealt with state refund offsets before, I'd recommend creating a checklist to stay organized. First, pull your credit reports from all three bureaus - sometimes old debts show up there that you forgot about. Second, make a list of any government agencies you've dealt with in the past few years (DMV, courts, utilities if they're city-owned, etc.) and call each one to ask about outstanding balances. Third, if your state has a "Where's My Refund" tool, bookmark it and check it regularly once you file - some states will show offset information there. Finally, keep detailed records of all your calls and any payment arrangements you make. It's a pain, but being proactive is way better than the surprise you got last year!
Jade Santiago
To clarify what others are saying: The trace number becomes relevant during the final stage of refund processing. After your return is processed and approved, the IRS initiates an ACH transfer to your bank. This transfer carries a unique identifier (the trace number) that follows your money through the Federal Reserve system and to your financial institution. You typically won't need this information unless there's a delay or problem with the deposit reaching your account after showing 'funded' status.
0 coins
Yara Nassar
As a fellow new graduate, I totally understand the confusion! Think of the trace number like a tracking number for a package - except it's for your refund moving through the banking system. Here's what I've learned: Once your refund shows "funded," the IRS has released your money and it's traveling from the Treasury to your bank account. The trace number is created during this transfer process and helps identify exactly where your money is if it gets stuck somewhere along the way. Most of the time you'll never need it because your refund just shows up normally within 1-5 business days. But if your refund doesn't arrive after showing "funded" for more than a week, that's when the trace number becomes important - you'd call the IRS to get it, then provide it to your bank to help them locate the missing deposit. It's basically a safety net for when things don't go as planned!
0 coins