


Ask the community...
I asked my HR about this last yr and they said sometimes it looks like more taxes are taken because they also take the regular deductions from your bonus (health insurance, 401k, etc). So check ur bonus stub carefully to see what's actually being taken for taxes vs other stuff. Might explain why it feels like more than 22%!
Pro tip: if you want less tax withheld from your bonus, increase your 401k contribution just for that paycheck if your company allows it. I put 50% of my bonus straight into 401k last year and it lowered my taxable income. Double win!
Something nobody mentioned - if you get your bonus in a different calendar year, it can affect which tax year it counts for. My company pays year-end bonuses in January, so they count for the new tax year, not the year the bonus was earned for. Worth keeping in mind for planning purposes!
This is actually a really important point! My bonus pushed me into a higher tax bracket last year because it came in December. If it had come in January, my tax situation would have been completely different. Timing matters!
Something else to consider - do you have any 1099 income at all? Even a small amount would strengthen your position for putting the malpractice tail on Schedule C. Maybe a few medical consultations or chart reviews you could do? In my experience (tax preparer), the IRS is less likely to question the Schedule C treatment if you show at least some related income, even if it's minimal compared to the expense. Starting a legitimate business activity with even a small amount of income before filing would give you stronger footing.
Would moonlighting at an urgent care for even just a few shifts count for this? I'm in a similar situation (different professional liability insurance though) and wondering if even just a few thousand in 1099 income would help establish the business intent.
Yes, moonlighting at an urgent care as a 1099 contractor would absolutely help establish business intent. Even just a few shifts generating a couple thousand dollars would create a much stronger case that you were genuinely engaged in business activity related to the insurance expense. The key is making sure you're actually classified as an independent contractor (receiving a 1099) rather than a part-time employee (W-2). As long as you have some legitimate 1099 income from medical work, you'll be in a much better position to justify the large deduction on Schedule C.
Hey just a heads up - I'm an accountant and have worked with physicians in similar situations. Make sure you consider the impact on self-employment taxes too. If you report the tail on Schedule C with zero or minimal income, you'll show a loss that will offset ordinary income but won't create SE tax. However, if your husband has SE income from real estate, your tail expense can't offset his SE tax since it's not related to his business. Each Schedule C is treated separately. You might want to run the numbers both ways (Schedule C loss vs. possibly amortizing the tail over multiple years if you do any 1099 work in the future) to see what makes the most sense for your specific situation.
Thank you so much for this insight! I hadn't even considered the self-employment tax angle. The more I think about it, the more I'm leaning toward filing Schedule C with the full expense. I actually do have some very minimal income (around $3K) from chart reviews I did while transitioning between jobs. That should help establish business intent, right? I'm thinking I'll use some combination of the advice here - documenting everything thoroughly, including my correspondence with the locums company about credentialing, and making sure I'm prepared in case of an audit. The tax savings between Schedule C vs. effectively no deduction on Schedule A is just too significant to ignore.
Be really careful with the OIC process! I submitted one last year and it got rejected because I didn't include all my assets correctly. The IRS is VERY thorough in checking your financial situation. Make sure you account for: - All bank accounts (even small ones) - Retirement accounts (they count these too) - Any property or vehicles - Future income potential My advice is to be 100% transparent. They'll find everything anyway, and hiding assets is the fastest way to get rejected and possibly face worse consequences.
Do they really count retirement accounts? I thought those were protected. I have about $45k in my 401k but didn't think that would count against me for an OIC calculation.
Yes, they absolutely consider retirement accounts in your OIC calculation. While you're right that they can't directly seize most retirement accounts, they still view them as assets that could be used to pay your tax debt. The IRS typically includes a percentage of retirement account values in your "reasonable collection potential" calculation. They don't necessarily expect you to cash them out (especially given the penalties), but they do factor them into what they think you could potentially pay. This is one of the most common misunderstandings that leads to OIC rejections.
What happens if the IRS rejects your Offer in Compromise? Do they keep the 20% payment you sent with your application? I've been hesitant to apply because I don't want to lose that money if they say no.
They apply any payments you've made toward your tax debt, they don't just keep the money. So if your offer gets rejected, that 20% payment (or whatever payments you've made) will reduce your overall tax debt. It's not lost money.
Make sure you're tracking everything diligently! I sell crafts online and got audited last year because my reported income didn't match what the platforms reported to the IRS. Nightmare scenario. I recommend getting a separate bank account for your business transactions and using accounting software (even a basic one) from day one. Also keep receipts for EVERYTHING, even small purchases.
Thanks for the advice! Do you recommend any specific accounting software that's not too complicated for beginners? Also, can I just open a regular personal checking account for this or do I need a formal "business" account?
For beginners, I'd recommend something simple like Wave (it's free) or QuickBooks Self-Employed if you want something more robust but still user-friendly. Both let you track income and expenses, and can generate reports you'll need for taxes. For the bank account, a regular personal checking account works fine when you're starting out, but open one that's ONLY used for your business transactions. This makes tracking much easier and creates a clear separation that's helpful if you ever get audited. As you grow, you might want to upgrade to a proper business account for more features, but that's not necessary right away.
Don't forget about state taxes too! Everyone always focuses on federal but depending on your state, you might need to collect and remit sales tax on digital products. Each state has different rules about this. And some states have their own self-employment taxes on top of federal.
Amina Toure
Random tip for 1040NR filers that helped me: If you're confused about treaty benefits, there's a free IRS Publication 901 "U.S. Tax Treaties" that breaks down the basics for each country. I found it way more understandable than trying to read the actual treaty text. Also, don't forget that as a non-resident, you might not be eligible for certain tax credits like the standard Earned Income Credit. I made that mistake my first year and had to file an amended return.
0 coins
Oliver Zimmermann
ā¢Is Publication 901 updated for 2024 yet? I checked a few weeks ago and they still had the 2023 version online. Also, do you know if non-residents can claim education credits like the American Opportunity Credit? I took some classes last year.
0 coins
Amina Toure
ā¢You're right that the official IRS website still has the 2023 version, but they don't typically update Publication 901 every year - only when treaty provisions change significantly. The 2023 version should still be applicable for most countries for your 2024 taxes. For education credits, non-resident aliens generally cannot claim the American Opportunity Credit. However, if you're from certain countries with specific education provisions in their tax treaties (like China, India, or several European countries), you might qualify for different education-related benefits. You'll need to check the specific article in your country's treaty that addresses students or education expenses.
0 coins
Natasha Volkova
Does anyone know if we can e-file 1040NR? I tried using FreeTaxUSA but it didn't support non-resident forms, and I really don't want to paper file and wait months for a refund.
0 coins
Javier Torres
ā¢Yes, you can e-file a 1040NR but not with every software. I used OLT.com (OnLine Taxes) last year and was able to e-file my non-resident return. Sprintax also supports e-filing for 1040NR. Most free options don't support it though.
0 coins