IRS
CommunityGovernment Services
Can't reach IRS? Claimyr calls for you, so you don't have to wait on hold.
Claimyr is a pay-as-you-go service. We do not charge a recurring subscription.
Using Claimyr will:
- Connect you to a human agent at the IRS
- Skip the long phone menu
- Call the correct department
- Redial until on hold
- Forward a call to your phone with reduced hold time
- Give you free callbacks if the IRS drops your call
Ask the community...
- DO post questions about your issues.
- DO answer questions and support each other.
- DO post tips & tricks to help folks.
- DO NOT post call problems here - there is a support tab at the top for that :)
Why am I going to owe money to the IRS? Did my employer mess up my tax withholding?
I'm kinda freaking out right now. I just took a look at my final paystub from December and realized there might be a problem with my taxes. So for 2024, I made $68,475 in taxable wages and only had $5,230 in federal taxes withheld. I'm filing as single with no dependents. When I plugged everything into one of those online tax calculator things, it's saying I'm going to owe the IRS $318! What the heck? I filled out my W-4 correctly and clearly marked that I'm single with no dependents. If my employer was taking out taxes from each paycheck like they're supposed to, why would I end up owing money? I thought the whole point of withholding was so that I don't get surprised with a tax bill at the end of the year. Is there something I'm missing? Did my employer screw something up with my withholding? Or is this just how things work now and everyone ends up owing?
Join the conversation
What's the real difference between tax fraud and legitimate tax strategies?
I've noticed that the term 'fraud' gets thrown around a lot in tax discussions online, and I think the distinction between actual tax fraud and legitimate tax strategy is getting increasingly blurry. It makes me wonder where exactly we draw the line. For example, some people seem to think something becomes fraud simply because the underlying motivation is to reduce your tax burden. But isn't that literally what tax planning is supposed to do? Take my accounting practice - we're specifically hired to find legal ways to minimize clients' taxes, maximize deductions & credits, etc. The goal is always to pay the smallest legal amount of tax possible. But that doesn't make it fraud, right? Here's a specific scenario I've been thinking about: If a cash-basis business adjusts how aggressively they pursue collections from clients to shift income recognition from one tax year to another (maybe because tax rates are changing), is that legitimate strategy or crossing into fraud territory? I think we all agree that deliberately not reporting income or outright lying on your return is clearly fraud - the intent there is deliberate tax evasion. But strategic tax planning also fundamentally aims to reduce taxes owed. The difference seems important but sometimes gets lost in discussions. I know what constitutes actual tax fraud... just wanted to start a conversation about this. And maybe suggest we be careful about using the word 'fraud' when responding to what might actually be completely legitimate tax strategies.
Join the conversation
I think one clear line is disclosure. Tax strategy means organizing your affairs in a tax-efficient way but FULLY DISCLOSING everything required. Fraud always involves hiding something. For example, I run a consulting business and have clients in multiple states. I could set up my business headquarters in a low-tax state - that's strategy. But if I claim that's my headquarters while actually operating entirely from a high-tax state, that's fraud because I'm misrepresenting the facts. The IRS actually respects legitimate tax planning. They expect you to take advantage of deductions and credits you're entitled to. What they don't tolerate is misrepresentation or concealment.
What about aggressive interpretations of gray areas though? Like if the law isn't super clear about something and you take a position that benefits you tax-wise, but there's a decent chance the IRS would disagree?
That's where the concept of "substantial authority" comes into play. If you're taking a position in a gray area, the question becomes whether you have a reasonable basis for your interpretation. Tax professionals typically look for about a 40% chance of prevailing if challenged to consider there being "substantial authority" for a position. If you're taking an aggressive but supportable position, the key is proper disclosure. By filling out Form 8275 (Disclosure Statement) with your return, you're telling the IRS "here's my position on this gray area" rather than hoping they don't notice. This disclosure protects you from accuracy-related penalties even if the IRS ultimately disagrees with your interpretation. It separates aggressive-but-legitimate planning from attempting to hide something.
Does anyone know if the IRS has like an official definition of what counts as tax fraud vs legitimate planning? I'm trying to decide if I should report some side income that was paid in cash...
Not reporting cash income is pretty clearly fraud, not strategy. The IRS definition of fraud includes "intentional wrongdoing with the specific intent to evade a tax known to be due." If you received income, it's taxable regardless of payment method. Pretty much any tax professional would tell you that deliberately not reporting income crosses the line from strategy into fraud. Legitimate strategy would be looking at whether that income qualifies for any deductions or credits, or considering ways to offset it with business expenses if it's self-employment income.
Can I file crypto tax separately from my main tax return?
I'm getting so frustrated with my tax situation. My accountant keeps increasing his fees every year and blames it on the "missing transactions" in my crypto Form 8949 from the past 5 years. He claims he has to manually fill in tons of missing data points (about 30-40 transactions) and says it's super time-consuming. The main issue is that Coinbase doesn't have records of what I originally paid for crypto I bought 5-6 years ago, so he's having to piece things together. The fee increases have been ridiculous! Started at $450, then jumped to $650, then $1050, then $1300, and this year he hit me with a whopping $2400 bill! I'm wondering - can I just handle the crypto portion myself with TurboTax and let my accountant handle everything else? Would splitting it up like this even be possible? Or am I stuck paying these crazy fees for my full tax return? Any advice would be appreciated!
Join the conversation
My accountant tried to charge me $1500 extra for crypto this year too! I ended up using CoinTracker to generate my own 8949 and then just gave my accountant the final numbers for Schedule D. Cut my bill by like 60%. One thing to watch for - make sure whatever software you use calculates your gains using the same method your accountant has been using (FIFO, LIFO, etc). Switching methods midway can cause issues.
That's exactly what I'm worried about! Did your accountant give you any pushback when you showed up with your own 8949 already done? And did you tell them ahead of time or just show up with the completed forms?
My accountant was actually relieved when I showed up with the 8949 already completed. I did let her know ahead of time that I was going to handle the crypto portion myself so she wouldn't duplicate the work. She initially was concerned about the accuracy but after reviewing what I provided, she was comfortable using it. We confirmed I was using FIFO (First In, First Out) which is what she had been using all along. The key was making sure I gave her not just the summary figures but the detailed transaction listing so she could verify the work if needed. She ended up charging me her standard rate for the rest of my return without the crypto upcharge.
Has anyone tried just creating a separate LLC for crypto trading activities and filing that on its own tax return? I've heard some people doing this to keep the crypto complexity separate from their personal taxes.
That's actually a terrible idea for most people. Creating an LLC doesn't change how crypto is taxed - it's reported as pass-through income on your personal return anyway unless you elect corporate taxation. Plus you'd have all the extra compliance costs of maintaining a business entity, separate accounts, etc. Would likely cost MORE in the long run.
Thanks for the clarification! I figured it might be too good to be true. Seems like using specialized crypto tax software and then providing the completed forms to my accountant is the better approach based on all the advice here.
CPA completely unresponsive for weeks - Won't let assistant handle clients during medical leave
We decided to try using a CPA this year instead of doing our taxes ourselves. Throughout the whole process, communication has been spotty at best, but we figured maybe we were just being annoying with all our questions. The weird thing is, we never signed any formal agreement saying we hired her - she just took our tax documents and said she'd handle the filing. We had some email exchanges where she answered some questions but ignored others. Then around March 30th, complete radio silence. My husband went to her office today and found it dark and locked, but her assistant was there. Apparently, the CPA had some kind of medical emergency and "can't look at computer screens until May 1st." When my husband asked for our tax documents back, the assistant refused and said she wasn't allowed to give them to us. Even crazier, the CPA instructed her assistant to unplug the phones and not respond to ANY client emails! We have no idea if our taxes were filed, if an extension was requested, or anything. No notification about her medical situation either. What should we do next? We definitely don't want to pay her at this point, but we also don't want to get hit with late filing penalties. This has been a complete nightmare!
Join the conversation
This sounds like a nightmare! I'd be furious. One thing to add to what others have said - if your CPA won't give back your documents, you can get tax transcripts directly from the IRS that show most of the information from your W-2s, 1099s, etc. Go to irs.gov and search for "Get Transcript" - you can view and download them online if you create an account, or request them by mail. This might help you file on your own or with another preparer without having to wait for your documents back.
Thank you for this tip! I didn't know about the transcript option. Would this show whether our CPA filed an extension for us? That's our biggest concern right now since the deadline has passed.
Yes, your tax transcript would show if an extension was filed on your behalf. When you access your transcript, look for a transaction code 460, which indicates an extension was filed. It should appear with the current tax year date. It will also show if a return was filed (transaction code 150) or if any payments were made. The transcript is basically a complete record of all transactions with the IRS for your tax account, so it's super helpful in situations like yours when you're in the dark about what actions were taken.
Report her to your state's CPA board immediately! This is completely unethical. I went through something similar last year and wish I had reported my CPA sooner. You should also file IRS Form 14157 (Complaint: Tax Return Preparer) to report this to the IRS. The form is available on irs.gov. As for your documents, in most states it's illegal for her to withhold your original documents. You might need to threaten legal action to get them back.
I agree with reporting to the state board, but be careful with threatening legal action. I did that with my accountant and it just made everything more complicated. I'd try the certified letter approach first before escalating.
Missed filing my 2023 Federal & State tax returns completely - what should I do now?
I messed up big time last year and completely failed to file both my Federal and State tax returns for 2023. I was going through some really tough personal stuff after my marriage ended and just couldn't get myself to deal with anything financial or administrative. Depression hit me hard. Now I'm freaking out about the consequences. I own a house and I'm pretty sure I owe the IRS money for 2023 (probably around $4,500). I have no idea what penalties I'm facing or how to even start fixing this. Will they take my house? Put me in jail? The anxiety of not knowing is making everything worse. I know I need to file those returns, but I'm completely overwhelmed about approaching this situation. Has anyone dealt with something similar or know what steps I should take to get back on track with the IRS?
Join the conversation
Just got thru this exact same situation!! Missed filing 2023 due to a family health crisis. My advice is DO NOT IGNORE THE IRS NOTICES when they start coming. I made that mistake and ended up with a substitute return where the IRS calculated my taxes without any of my deductions or credits, and it was WAY higher than what I actually owed. File ASAP even if you can't pay right now. The failure-to-file penalty is much bigger than the failure-to-pay penalty, so at least stop that one from growing!!!
How long did it take before they filed a substitute return for you? I'm trying to figure out how much time I have before that happens to me.
If you're really overwhelmed, consider getting professional help from a tax attorney or an Enrolled Agent (EA) rather than just a regular tax preparer. They can represent you before the IRS if needed and might be able to negotiate penalty reductions. I spent about $800 on an EA when I had 3 years of unfiled returns, and they saved me over $3,000 in penalties through abatement requests and proper filing strategies. Sometimes spending money on professional help actually saves you more in the long run.
Kristian Bishop
Your employer is only withholding based on what you report on your W-4 and your salary at THAT job. The withholding system isn't perfect. A few things to check: 1. Do you have multiple jobs? That can mess up withholding. 2. Any investment income or interest from bank accounts? 3. Did you get any bonuses that were withheld at the flat 22% rate? The good news is owing $318 isn't a big deal at all. The IRS only cares if you owe more than $1,000 AND haven't paid at least 90% of your tax liability through withholding.
0 coins
Aaron Boston
AuthorThanks for the tips! You know, I did receive a year-end bonus of around $2,000 that was taxed differently than my regular paychecks. Could that be part of the issue? Also, I have a high-yield savings account that earned about $800 in interest last year.
0 coins
Kristian Bishop
Yes, both of those things definitely contributed to your situation! Bonuses are typically withheld at a flat 22% supplemental rate, which might not be enough if you're in a higher tax bracket. And the $800 in interest income has no withholding at all, so you'll owe taxes on that amount when you file. For next year, you have two options to avoid owing: increase your regular withholding by submitting a new W-4 with additional withholding on line 4(c), or make estimated quarterly tax payments for your interest income. For someone in your situation, adding about $30-40 in additional withholding per paycheck would likely cover these extra income sources.
0 coins
Kaitlyn Otto
Owing just over $300 is honestly not bad! I'm a payroll specialist and I always tell people that the goal should be to break even, not get a huge refund. A refund just means you gave the government an interest-free loan all year. For 2025, just log into your company's HR system and update your W-4. If you want to be really precise, use the IRS Tax Withholding Estimator tool on the IRS website. It's way more accurate than the old "claim 0 dependents" method everyone used to use.
0 coins
Axel Far
every time i use that irs withholding calculator thing i get different results lol. one time it said i should get an extra $50 taken out each check, then the next time it said i should get like $20 back each check. makes no sense
0 coins