
IRS
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
Title: Contribution limits on Roth IRA and 401k - are they separate or combined? 1 Super basic question here that I can't seem to find a clear answer to anywhere online. I'm trying to figure out if the contribution limits for my Roth IRA and 401k are completely separate or if they count together toward one overall limit. Specifically for 2025, would I be able to contribute the full $24,500 to my 401k AND also put the full $7,500 into my Roth IRA? Or is there a combined maximum where I'd be limited to $24,500 total between both accounts? I'm 32 so definitely under 50 (no catch-up contributions for me yet). Just trying to maximize my retirement savings but don't want to accidentally over-contribute and deal with penalties. Thanks in advance for any help!
I'm sort of in a bit of a predicament with my amended tax return. I needed to make some, um, corrections related to my small business deductions that I think I might have calculated incorrectly. Does anyone possibly know how long it typically takes to get your refund after filing an amended return? I've heard it might take longer than regular returns, but I'm not entirely sure. I'm a bit worried because I'm planning some inventory purchases that kind of depend on this refund. Thanks in advance for any advice!
My amended return took exactly 18 weeks and 3 days to process last year. The IRS received it on March 7, 2023, and I received my refund on July 14, 2023. The system updated at the 6-week mark, the 12-week mark, and then finally at the 18-week mark. The refund was $4,327 less $43.21 in interest penalties for a net of $4,283.79. For business planning purposes, I'd recommend setting a calendar reminder for Week 16 to check the status again, and don't make any financial commitments requiring this money until Week 20.
I'm going through something similar right now - filed my amended return about 8 weeks ago for some missed business expenses I discovered. The waiting is definitely nerve-wracking when you're trying to plan business purchases! From what I've learned lurking in various tax forums, the 16-20 week timeline seems pretty accurate these days. One thing that's helped me is setting up a monthly calendar reminder to check the "Where's My Amended Return" tool rather than obsessively checking it weekly. Also, I've started looking into alternative financing options for my business needs just in case the refund takes longer than expected. It's frustrating, but having a backup plan has given me some peace of mind while I wait for the IRS to do their thing.
I think this might be a basic question but I need some advice. I have an S Corp LLC with a dedicated business checking account where clients deposit payments made to my business name. I pay myself a monthly salary that totals around $24k annually from the business checking to my personal account, and I handle all the required income, social security, and other taxes on that amount. The issue is my business checking account has accumulated about $350k that's just sitting there earning nothing, while my personal savings account has a much smaller balance. I recently spotted a Wells Fargo offer for a high yield savings account at 4.5% interest if you deposit at least $250k and maintain that balance for 6 months. What I'm wondering is: Can I legally transfer $250k+ from my business checking account directly to a personal high yield savings account? Or would this violate some tax law or corporate structure rule? I don't want to mess up my S Corp status or create tax problems, but it seems wasteful to leave that much cash sitting with zero interest.
Not a tax professional, but I've owned an S Corp for 10+ years. One thing to consider - if your business consistently has $350k cash on hand, you might actually be OVER-paying taxes by keeping too much in the company. The IRS sometimes looks at excessive retained earnings as a sign you're trying to avoid taking distributions or salary.
I'd definitely recommend getting professional advice from a CPA who specializes in S-Corps before making any large transfers. While the other commenters are right about distributions being legal, there are several factors to consider beyond just the tax implications. First, make sure you're truly taking a "reasonable salary" - $24k annually might be too low depending on your industry and the amount of income your S-Corp generates. The IRS scrutinizes S-Corp owners who take minimal salaries while distributing large amounts, as it looks like you're trying to avoid payroll taxes. Second, consider the timing of a large distribution. If you take $250k out right before year-end, it could create cash flow issues for paying estimated taxes on your business income. The business high-yield savings account suggestion is solid - you keep proper separation while earning interest. But if you do decide to take a distribution, document everything properly in your corporate minutes and consider spreading it across tax years to manage the impact on your personal tax situation. Have you run projections on what your total tax liability would look like with an additional $250k distribution this year?
I'm totally confused by this letter I just got from the IRS. I filed Form 5329 a couple months back to fix an old tax return where I screwed up and didn't take the Required Minimum Distribution (RMD) from my retirement account on time. My financial advisor retired suddenly and I completely missed the deadline - my fault but still frustrating. Anyway, I sent in the 5329 with a letter explaining the situation and included a check for the penalty (around $875). Today I received this really vague letter from the IRS that just acknowledges they got my Form 5329 but doesn't actually say if they're accepting it, rejecting it, or what. The letter basically says "We received your Form 5329" and mentions my tax ID and the tax year, but then doesn't give any further instructions or tell me if I'm in the clear. Has anyone dealt with this before? Is this their normal process or should I be worried they're going to hit me with more penalties? Do I need to call them (ugh) or just wait for another letter? The whole RMD penalty situation has been stressful enough already.
Has anyone had success getting these penalties refunded? I'm in a similar situation where I paid about $1,200 in penalties for a missed RMD from my inherited IRA because the brokerage never notified me it was due. Currently waiting on my waiver request.
I successfully got a full refund of my RMD penalty last year. The key was being very specific about why it wasn't my fault (in my case, incorrect advice from my financial institution) and proving I corrected the mistake immediately when discovered. Took about 3 months to get the refund after submitting the waiver request.
I went through almost the exact same situation last year! That acknowledgment letter you received is completely normal - it's basically the IRS saying "we got your paperwork and we're processing it." The fact that they cashed your check is actually a good sign that they're moving forward with your submission. In my case, I waited about 10 weeks after that initial letter and then received a final notice that my Form 5329 was accepted and the matter was closed. No additional penalties, no follow-up required. The waiting is definitely nerve-wracking, but it sounds like you did everything right by including the explanation letter and paying the calculated penalty upfront. One thing I learned is that if the IRS had any major issues with your submission, they would have sent a more detailed letter asking for clarification or additional information. The generic acknowledgment usually means you're on the right track. Hang in there!
I'm a freelance web developer who specializes in creating responsive websites that work across all platforms. I've been thinking about buying a PlayStation 5 to test my websites on and make sure they display correctly through the PS5 browser. Since more people are using gaming consoles to browse the web these days, I want to ensure my clients' sites look perfect on these devices. Here's my question - can I legitimately write off a PS5 as a business expense on my Schedule C? I'd be using it primarily for testing websites and making sure my code renders properly on the PlayStation browser. The console would be about $499 plus tax, and I'd keep it in my home office where I do all my development work. I'm a bit nervous about claiming this since it's obviously something that could also be used personally for gaming. Would the IRS flag this as suspicious? How would I document it properly as a business expense? Do I need to track hours of business vs. personal use? Any guidance from others who've claimed similar tech devices would be super helpful!
Tax preparer here (not an accountant tho). The PS5 question comes up more than you'd think! Here's my take: Can you deduct it? Yes, partially. Should you deduct it 100%? Probably not. Will it trigger an audit? By itself, unlikely. The problem isn't the deduction itself but proving business purpose. Unless you NEVER use it for gaming (be honest!), claim a reasonable business percentage. Document EVERYTHING. Create a testing log showing dates, times, client projects, and specific testing performed. Keep emails or specs from clients requesting console compatibility. Take screenshots of your work on the PS5 browser. Deduct only the business-use percentage and keep it reasonable (50-80% depending on actual use). The IRS isn't dumb - they know a PS5 has personal utility.
would this also apply to a gaming PC? i build websites but also game on my computer after work hours
Yes, similar principles apply to a gaming PC. The key difference is that computers are much more commonly accepted as legitimate business tools for web developers, so the burden of proof is typically lower. For a high-end gaming PC, you'd still want to track business vs. personal usage and deduct accordingly. Document your work hours and keep records showing business use. If your business usage is the primary purpose (say 60%+ business use), you'll be on solid ground. Just be reasonable and honest with the allocation between business and personal use.
I'm a freelance graphic designer who faced a similar situation with my Apple Studio Display. I wanted to deduct it as a business expense but was worried about the IRS questioning such an expensive monitor. What helped me was creating a clear business justification document before making the purchase. I outlined exactly why this specific equipment was necessary for my work (color accuracy for client projects, screen real estate for complex designs, etc.) and kept detailed records of which clients required work that specifically benefited from the display's capabilities. For your PS5 situation, I'd suggest creating a similar justification document explaining why console testing is necessary for your web development business. Include details about your target clients, the importance of cross-platform compatibility, and how console browsing differs from desktop/mobile. This proactive documentation approach made me feel much more confident about the deduction and would probably help if you're ever questioned about it. The key is being able to clearly articulate the legitimate business need beyond just "it could be useful for testing." Show that it's actually necessary for serving your clients effectively.
Zara Malik
15 Does anyone know if the 401k limit includes employer matching? My company matches 5% of my salary, not sure if that counts toward the $24,500 limit.
0 coins
Zara Malik
Author25 The $24,500 limit is just for YOUR contributions (called "elective deferrals"). Employer matching doesn't count toward that limit. There's a separate, much higher overall limit ($69,500 for 2025) that includes ALL contributions to your 401k - your elective deferrals, employer matching, and any after-tax contributions.
0 coins
Giovanni Marino
This is such a helpful thread! I've been maxing out my 401k for years but never realized I could also do the full Roth IRA contribution on top of it. I always assumed there was some combined limit that would prevent me from doing both. Just to make sure I understand correctly - if I'm 28 years old and make $95,000 annually, I can contribute: - $24,500 to my 401k - $7,500 to my Roth IRA - And my employer's 4% match doesn't count against either of those limits Is that right? This could be a game-changer for my retirement savings strategy. I've been leaving money on the table by not opening a Roth IRA thinking I was already "maxed out" with just my 401k contributions.
0 coins