


Ask the community...
This is a great question and I can see why it's confusing! I went through something very similar with my dental practice setup. One crucial thing to double-check is the timing for 2024 tax benefits. While the plan needs to be established by December 31, 2024, you actually have until your S Corp's tax filing deadline (including extensions, so potentially October 15, 2025) to make the actual contributions and still get the 2024 tax deduction. Also, don't feel embarrassed about asking your accountant again! This stuff is genuinely complex, and even tax professionals sometimes need to research the specifics. I'd recommend framing it as "I want to make sure I understand the implementation steps correctly" rather than asking for the explanation again. One practical tip: when you do set this up, make sure your S Corp payroll system can handle the timing of the profit sharing contributions. Some payroll providers need advance notice to process these correctly, especially if you're making the contribution near the filing deadline. I learned this the hard way when my payroll company needed three weeks to set up the proper coding! The separate entity approach really does work well for situations like yours - it gives you much more control over your retirement planning without getting tangled up in the LLC's existing arrangements.
This is really helpful, especially the point about payroll system timing! I hadn't thought about that aspect. Quick question - when you say the contribution deadline is the tax filing deadline including extensions, does that mean we could potentially wait until we see how the rest of our 2024 tax situation shakes out before deciding on the exact contribution amount? That would actually be really helpful for planning purposes. Also, thanks for the encouragement about asking my accountant again. You're right that it's complex stuff and I shouldn't feel bad about needing clarification!
Yes, exactly! That's one of the big advantages of the profit sharing plan structure - you have flexibility on the contribution timing and amount. You can wait to see your full 2024 tax picture before deciding how much to contribute, as long as you make the contribution by the filing deadline (including extensions). This is actually a huge benefit compared to traditional 401(k) deferrals which have to be made from payroll during the tax year. With profit sharing, you can optimize based on your actual income, other deductions, and overall tax strategy. Just make sure your plan document is properly drafted to allow for this discretionary contribution approach. Some plans require specific contribution formulas or percentages, while others allow the employer (your S Corp) full discretion on the amount each year. Your TPA should be able to help structure the plan document to give you maximum flexibility while staying compliant. And definitely don't feel bad about asking questions - I probably asked my tax advisor the same profit sharing questions at least five times before it all clicked!
This is such a helpful discussion! I'm actually an enrolled agent who works with a lot of medical professionals in similar situations, and I wanted to add a few key points that might help clarify things: First, regarding the controlled group rules that several people mentioned - this is absolutely critical to get right. Since your husband has 50% ownership in the LLC through his S Corp, you'll definitely need to consider the aggregation rules for contribution limits. The good news is that profit sharing contributions are calculated separately from 401(k) deferrals, but the total combined contributions across all plans are still subject to the annual limits. Second, I'd strongly recommend getting a formal plan document review before implementing anything. While the concept is straightforward (S Corp establishes profit sharing plan for its employee), the execution involves specific language around eligibility, vesting schedules, and distribution rules that need to comply with ERISA requirements. One thing I haven't seen mentioned is the potential impact on your husband's Social Security benefits calculation. Since profit sharing contributions reduce current W-2 income, there could be a long-term trade-off between current tax savings and future Social Security benefits. For most people the current tax savings win out, but it's worth considering especially for younger professionals. Also, make sure to factor in the ongoing administrative costs - annual Form 5500 filing, potential audits if assets exceed $250k, and TPA fees. These costs are usually worth it for the tax savings, but good to budget for them upfront. Feel free to reach out if you need any clarification on the compliance aspects!
Thank you so much for this comprehensive breakdown! As someone just starting to understand retirement planning, the point about Social Security benefits is something I hadn't even considered. Could you clarify what you mean by "profit sharing contributions reduce current W-2 income"? I thought the contributions were made by the employer (S Corp) and wouldn't directly reduce the employee's (husband's) reported W-2 wages. Or are you referring to the fact that higher contributions might lead to structuring lower salary vs distributions to maximize the retirement benefits? Also, regarding the Form 5500 filing - is this something that needs professional help, or is it manageable for a small S Corp with just one participant? I'm trying to get a sense of the total ongoing costs involved. The ERISA compliance aspect sounds pretty complex too. Would you recommend working with a specialized attorney for the plan document review, or is this typically something a good TPA can handle? Thanks for offering to help with clarification - this kind of expert insight is exactly what I was hoping to find!
Late to this thread but if ur still looking for those W2s u should try checking the IRS website directly. The IRS actually gets copies of W2s from employers and sometimes u can access them through the "Get Transcript" feature on irs.gov if your employer actually submitted them to the IRS. Saved me last year when my W2 got lost in the mail!!
Just be aware the Get Transcript feature on irs.gov won't have your W-2 info until several weeks after employers submit them to the IRS. And if your employer is generally disorganized enough to not send your W-2 to you, they may not have submitted it to the IRS either.
Another option if you're still stuck is to check if either ByteWave or DataCrunch use a third-party payroll provider like ADP, Paychex, or Workday. Many employees don't realize they can often access their W-2s directly through these systems even when HR isn't responding. Try logging into any payroll portals you used while employed - sometimes the W-2s are automatically posted there in January even if the company doesn't proactively send them out. You might also want to check if either company has been acquired or merged with another company, which could explain the communication issues. If all else fails and you need to file soon, I'd recommend the combination approach others mentioned: use the IRS contact services to get official pressure on your employers while simultaneously using your final paystubs to prepare your return as a backup. Having multiple strategies running parallel will give you the best chance of meeting filing deadlines without stress.
This is really helpful to know! I'm also new to the US tax system and filed around the same time (2/12) with a DDD of 3/6. I've been obsessively checking the SBTPG website multiple times a day and getting increasingly worried that something went wrong since it still shows "not funded." Reading about everyone else's experiences with the phone system being more accurate is such a relief. I'm definitely going to call their automated line today instead of relying on the website. It's so confusing coming from a different country where the systems were much more straightforward and consistent. Thanks for sharing this - it's exactly what I needed to hear to stop panicking about my refund!
I totally understand the panic! I'm also new to the US system and went through the exact same worry cycle. The inconsistency between different platforms is really frustrating when you're not familiar with how things work here. I called the SBTPG automated line yesterday after reading this thread and it was such a relief to get updated information. Their phone system said my funds were already sent even though the website still showed nothing. It's definitely worth calling - the automated system will ask for your SSN and give you the real status. Don't stress too much about the website lag, it seems to be a known issue with their system!
This is exactly what I needed to see today! I'm also dealing with my first US tax season and filed 2/13 with a DDD of 3/5. The SBTPG website has been showing absolutely nothing for days and I was starting to think something went wrong with my filing. It's so reassuring to know this website lag is a common issue and that the phone system is more reliable. I just called their automated line and sure enough, it says my refund was sent to my bank yesterday! Coming from a country where tax refunds were processed much more transparently, this whole experience has been pretty stressful. But reading everyone's similar experiences here makes me feel much better about the process. Thanks for starting this thread - it's been incredibly helpful for those of us navigating this system for the first time!
I successfully navigated an identical audit situation last tax season. For the EIC verification, I provided my W-2 and final paystub showing YTD earnings. For Child Tax Credit, I submitted: (1) birth certificate establishing relationship, (2) school records showing your address, and (3) medical records with both names. For Head of Household, I included: lease agreement, three utility bills from different months, and property insurance showing I maintained the household. The IRS accepted everything without follow-up questions and released my refund approximately 6 weeks after submission. The key was providing clear documentation for each specific requirement without overwhelming them with extraneous paperwork.
Just went through this exact same audit combo last year - EIC, Child Tax Credit, and Head of Household. Here's what worked for me: For EIC, your W-2 is absolutely sufficient (don't send all those paystubs). For Child Tax Credit, birth certificate + school enrollment records showing your address will do it. For HOH, I sent my lease agreement, 3 utility bills (spread throughout the year), and a brief letter explaining how I maintained the household. The IRS processed everything in about 5 weeks. Pro tip: organize everything in the order they list it in their letter, use a simple cover sheet, and send certified mail. Don't overthink it - they just need to check the boxes that you qualify for what you claimed.
This is exactly the kind of detailed breakdown I was hoping for! Really appreciate you sharing your successful experience with the same audit combination. The timeline of 5 weeks for processing is reassuring too. I'm definitely going to follow your organizational approach - putting everything in the order they listed and using that cover sheet idea. Quick question though - when you sent the brief letter explaining how you maintained the household for HOH, did you include specific dollar amounts or just a general explanation of your responsibilities?
Justin Chang
I'm going through the exact same frustrating experience! Filed on March 12th, accepted March 14th, and I've been stuck on "Your tax return is being processed" for almost 2 weeks now. I also claimed EITC this year for the first time after my hours got cut at work and my income dropped enough to qualify. Reading through all these comments has been such a huge relief - I honestly thought something was seriously wrong with my return since I keep seeing people on Facebook posting about getting their refunds already. Now I understand that those people probably didn't claim any refundable credits that require the extra verification steps. The obsessive checking is so real! I've been hitting that "Where's My Refund" tool probably 5+ times a day even though I know it's completely pointless since it only updates weekly. I'm definitely going to try the Sunday-only checking rule that several people mentioned - my anxiety levels will probably thank me for it. It's really helpful to know that 21-25 days is the normal timeframe for EITC returns right now. I was starting to spiral thinking I'd be one of those horror stories waiting months, but this seems to just be the reality of filing during peak season with credits that need manual review. The wait is definitely stressful when you're counting on that money for bills, but at least now I have realistic expectations instead of just wondering what's wrong. Thanks everyone for sharing - it really helps to know we're all in this processing limbo together!
0 coins
ShadowHunter
ā¢I'm dealing with the exact same situation! Filed March 15th, accepted March 16th, and I've been staring at that "processing" message for almost 2 weeks now. I also claimed EITC this year since I qualified for the first time due to a change in my employment situation. This entire thread has been such a lifesaver - I was seriously starting to panic thinking my return got lost or flagged for some reason. Seeing so many people with nearly identical timelines and circumstances makes me feel way less alone in this. The explanation about EITC requiring extra fraud prevention steps totally makes sense, even though the waiting is torture when you need that money. I'm definitely guilty of the obsessive checking too! I've probably refreshed that tool at least 10 times today alone, which is completely ridiculous since I know it only updates weekly. The Sunday-only checking strategy sounds like a much healthier approach - going to try that starting this week. It's really reassuring to hear that 21-25 days is standard for EITC returns this year. I was getting worried I'd be waiting months like some of the horror stories you hear about. Now I can at least have realistic expectations and stop checking every day hoping for a miracle update. Thanks for sharing your experience - it really helps to know we're all riding out this same frustrating wait together!
0 coins
Aria Park
I'm experiencing the exact same situation! Filed on March 18th, accepted March 19th, and I've been stuck on "processing" for about 10 days now. I also claimed EITC for the first time this year since my income qualified me after switching to a lower-paying but more stable job. This thread has been incredibly helpful and reassuring - I was starting to get really anxious seeing friends on social media already getting their refunds while mine hasn't budged. Now I understand they probably didn't claim any refundable credits that require the extra verification time. The daily checking obsession is so relatable! I've been refreshing that "Where's My Refund" tool constantly throughout the day, which is completely pointless since I now know it only updates weekly. I'm definitely going to adopt the Sunday-only checking strategy that everyone's mentioned - my stress levels will definitely benefit from that. Knowing that 21-25 days is normal for EITC returns this year really helps set realistic expectations. I was starting to worry I'd be one of those people waiting months, but it sounds like this is just the standard processing time for returns with credits during peak season. The wait is definitely nerve-wracking when you're counting on that money, but at least now I know what to expect. Thanks everyone for sharing your experiences - it's so comforting to know we're all going through this same waiting game together!
0 coins