


Ask the community...
Have you considered asking the company to reclassify you as an employee instead of a contractor? If you were working regular hours at their location using their equipment, you might actually legally be an employee not a contractor. Companies sometimes misclassify workers as contractors to avoid paying employment taxes and benefits. It's actually pretty common in retail. If you were treated like a regular employee in practice, you might have been misclassified. Just something to consider if you're still working there or plan to in the future!
This is really good advice. I got misclassified at a job last year. The IRS has a form you can file - SS-8 I think? - to request a determination of worker status. If they rule in your favor, the company has to pay both halves of those FICA taxes instead of you paying self-employment tax.
Just wanted to chime in as someone who went through this exact situation a couple years ago! I worked what felt like a regular retail job but got hit with a 1099-NEC at tax time. One thing I wish I'd known earlier - even though you have to file Schedule C and pay self-employment tax, you might qualify for the Qualified Business Income (QBI) deduction under Section 199A. This can give you up to a 20% deduction on your self-employment income, which helps offset some of that extra tax burden. Since your income was only $2,100, you should definitely qualify (the income limits are much higher). Most tax software will calculate this automatically once you enter your Schedule C info, but it's worth double-checking that it's being applied. Also, definitely track ANY expenses related to this work - even small things like work shirts, phone usage, or gas for work trips add up. I missed out on probably $200-300 in deductions my first year because I didn't think they mattered. Every little bit helps when you're dealing with that 15.3% self-employment tax on top of regular income tax!
This is super helpful advice! I had no idea about the QBI deduction - that could really help offset some of the self-employment tax hit. My tax software didn't mention anything about it when I was putting in my info, so I'll definitely need to double-check that it's being calculated. You're absolutely right about tracking expenses too. I was so focused on the big picture that I didn't think about smaller things like the work polo shirt I had to buy or the extra phone usage when my manager would text about schedule changes. Even if it's only saving me $50-100, that's still money in my pocket! Thanks for the realistic perspective on what to expect with the tax burden. It's reassuring to hear from someone who actually went through this situation successfully.
I've been following this thread and wanted to add my perspective as someone who went through a very similar situation. The "wait and report after leaving" strategy mentioned by others is actually quite effective, but I'd also suggest documenting everything NOW while you're still there. Start keeping detailed records of: your work schedule, any emails showing you're required to be in the office, descriptions of your ongoing duties vs. project-based work, and any communications about your employment status. Take screenshots of job postings if they advertised your position differently than how you're classified. This documentation will be crucial whether you decide to approach your employer directly, file with the IRS, or report after finding a new job. I made the mistake of not documenting enough in my situation, and it made proving my case much harder later. Also, consider checking if your company has an HR department or if decisions are made by one person. Sometimes the person doing payroll doesn't fully understand classification rules, and bringing it to HR's attention (framed as a compliance question) might resolve it without drama. But definitely have that documentation ready first, just in case.
This is excellent advice about documentation! I'm actually in a very similar situation to the original poster and had been putting off keeping records because I wasn't sure what would be relevant. Your list is really helpful - I hadn't thought about screenshotting the original job posting, but that's brilliant since mine definitely described the role differently than how I'm being treated. One question though - how detailed should I get with the documentation? Like, should I be tracking every single interaction or just the ones that clearly show control/supervision? And is it better to keep digital copies or physical printouts in case they try to revoke my email access if things go south?
Great question about documentation detail! You'll want to focus on quality over quantity - capture the interactions that clearly demonstrate behavioral control, financial control, and relationship factors that the IRS uses for classification. Key things to document: set work schedules/hours, meetings where you receive direct supervision, any training you're required to attend, use of company equipment/software, and communications showing you can't work from other locations. Digital copies are definitely safer since they can't revoke access to your personal devices. Forward important emails to a personal account, take photos of schedules/notices with your phone, and save everything to cloud storage they can't access. Also document the contrast between your treatment and the W-2 employees - like if they get benefits, flexible schedules, or different supervision that you don't receive. The job posting screenshot is crucial because it often shows the employer's own understanding of the role as ongoing employment rather than project-based contractor work. Keep everything organized by date so you can show a clear pattern of employee-like treatment over time.
One thing I haven't seen mentioned here is checking if your company has any policies or employee handbook that might inadvertently contradict your contractor classification. Many employers slip up by including 1099 workers in employee-only policies or expecting them to follow the same rules as W-2 staff. Also, since you mentioned the other admin has been there 12 years, that's actually a huge red flag for the IRS. Long-term "contractor" relationships, especially for ongoing administrative work, are classic misclassification cases. The IRS specifically looks for situations where someone performs the same role for years as evidence of an employer-employee relationship rather than true independent contracting. You might want to research what happened to other companies in your industry who got caught doing this. Sometimes showing your employer news articles about similar businesses facing penalties can be more persuasive than citing IRS regulations directly. It makes the risk feel more real and immediate. And honestly, given that you're new and they've been misclassifying the other admin for over a decade, this company is probably sitting on a pretty significant tax liability if the IRS ever investigates. That might actually work in your favor if you do decide to have a direct conversation about reclassification.
This is really smart advice about checking company policies! I never would have thought to look for contradictions like that, but it makes total sense that they might accidentally treat contractors like employees in their internal documentation. The point about the 12-year "contractor" is especially eye-opening - I was actually thinking that person's long tenure might work against me, but you're right that it's probably making the company's situation worse from an IRS perspective. If they've been misclassifying someone for over a decade, the back taxes and penalties could be enormous. Do you have any suggestions for how to research penalties other companies faced? I'm not sure what search terms would be most effective, or if there are specific databases or news sources that track these kinds of cases. Having concrete examples of similar businesses getting penalized would definitely strengthen my position if I decide to approach management directly.
I feel your pain! I was doing the same thing until I learned transcripts don't update daily. Like others said, Friday mornings are when most updates happen, but it's not guaranteed every week. The IRS processes returns in waves, so some people wait weeks between updates. Save yourself the stress and check once a week max - your mental health will thank you! š
Same here! I was checking multiple times daily and it was driving me nuts. The Friday morning update schedule makes total sense now. One thing I learned - the IRS also does some updates on Wednesday nights around midnight EST, but it's less common. Also worth noting that during peak tax season (Feb-April), the systems can be slower and updates might be delayed by a day or two. Setting a weekly reminder for Saturday morning to check has been a game changer for my sanity! š¤Æ
One important aspect that hasn't been mentioned yet is the potential for double taxation and how to avoid it. Since you're Hong Kong-based, you'll likely need to report your US Amazon income on your Hong Kong tax return as well. Hong Kong operates on a territorial tax system, so if your business operations are conducted from Hong Kong (sourcing, management, etc.), you may be subject to Hong Kong profits tax on the same income that's being taxed in the US. To avoid double taxation, you can typically claim a foreign tax credit in Hong Kong for taxes paid to the US. However, the mechanics of this depend on your specific business structure and how you characterize the income in each jurisdiction. Also, consider the Branch Profits Tax if you operate through a US branch rather than a subsidiary. Non-resident aliens engaged in US trade or business through a branch may be subject to an additional 30% branch profits tax on earnings that aren't reinvested in the US business. I'd strongly recommend consulting with tax professionals in both jurisdictions before making your final structure decision. The initial setup cost is usually much less than the potential penalties and complications from getting it wrong.
This is exactly the kind of comprehensive analysis I was hoping to see! The double taxation aspect is something I completely overlooked when researching this. I'm particularly concerned about the Hong Kong territorial tax system interaction. If I'm managing the business from Hong Kong but selling through US warehouses, it sounds like I could get hit with taxes in both jurisdictions on the same income. The Branch Profits Tax is also news to me - that 30% rate sounds brutal on top of regular income taxes. Would forming a US subsidiary instead of operating as a branch help avoid this? And how do you determine what constitutes "reinvestment in the US business" for purposes of avoiding the branch profits tax? @Owen Devar - Do you have experience with the foreign tax credit process between US and Hong Kong? Is it straightforward to claim, or does it require extensive documentation?
@Joshua Wood Great questions! The foreign tax credit process between US and Hong Kong can be complex but is definitely manageable with proper documentation. For the US side, you d'use Form 1116 to claim foreign tax credits for Hong Kong taxes paid on the same income. Hong Kong requires detailed documentation showing the US taxes paid, which you can get from your US tax returns and payment records. The key is maintaining clear records that trace the same income being taxed in both jurisdictions. Regarding the Branch Profits Tax - yes, forming a US subsidiary like (a US LLC or corporation instead) of operating as a branch can help avoid this tax entirely. A subsidiary is treated as a separate US entity, so there s'no branch "profits to" tax at the additional 30% rate. For reinvestment, the IRS looks at whether earnings are kept in the US business operations versus being distributed or constructively distributed to the foreign owner. Things like expanding inventory, opening new product lines, or keeping profits in US business bank accounts typically qualify as reinvestment. One strategy many Hong Kong sellers use is forming a US LLC that elects corporate tax treatment, which can provide more flexibility in timing distributions and managing the overall tax burden between jurisdictions. The upfront consultation costs with tax pros in both countries are really worth it - I learned this the hard way after initially trying to navigate it alone!
As someone who went through this exact process last year from Hong Kong, I can share some practical insights that might help clarify things. The key decision point is really about your risk tolerance and compliance complexity. Here's what I learned: **Structure Decision:** I ended up forming a US LLC (single-member, electing disregarded entity status) rather than using a Hong Kong company. This simplified my US tax filing significantly - I file Form 1040-NR as an individual rather than dealing with corporate forms like 1120-F. The liability protection was worth the extra complexity. **Nexus Reality:** Don't get too caught up in where you "manage" the business. The moment your products sit in Amazon warehouses, you have US nexus. I tried arguing that my business was managed from Hong Kong, but my tax advisor quickly shut that down - physical inventory presence trumps management location. **State Tax Strategy:** Focus on the big states first. California, Texas, Florida, and New York will likely be where most of your inventory ends up. Register proactively in these states rather than waiting for notices. Amazon's sales tax collection helps, but you still need to handle income tax registrations. **Practical Timeline:** Get your EIN first (you can apply online as a foreign person), then set up your business bank account, THEN start selling. Trying to sort out the tax structure after you're already generating income is much more complicated. The Hong Kong side is actually simpler than the US side - just make sure you're claiming foreign tax credits properly to avoid double taxation. Happy to answer specific questions about the process!
This is incredibly helpful, thank you for sharing your real experience! I have a few follow-up questions based on your journey: 1. When you formed the US LLC as a single-member disregarded entity, did you still need to file any annual state-level reports or maintain a registered agent? I'm trying to understand the ongoing compliance costs beyond just tax filing. 2. For the proactive state registrations you mentioned - did you register for income tax purposes in those states before you actually had sales there, or did you wait until Amazon confirmed they were storing inventory in those locations? I'm worried about registering too early and creating unnecessary compliance burdens. 3. On the EIN application - did you run into any issues applying as a Hong Kong resident? I've heard mixed reports about whether the online application works smoothly for foreign applicants or if you need to call/mail instead. Your point about getting the structure right before generating income really resonates. I'd rather spend a bit more upfront on proper setup than deal with messy retroactive fixes later. @Chloe Martin - Also curious if you ended up needing that tax professional consultation in both jurisdictions like others suggested, or if you were able to handle the Hong Kong side yourself?
Fatima Al-Mansour
Have you considered looking into other assistance programs instead of potentially risky tax situations? There are programs specifically designed to help people in your situation while waiting for disability approval. Many states have emergency assistance for families with newborns. Also, there are charities that help with car repairs for people who need transportation for medical reasons. These might be better options than depending on tax strategies that could cause problems later.
0 coins
Dylan Evans
ā¢This! I was in a similar situation and found that my county had a program specifically for car repairs for low-income residents. Saved me almost $800 on transmission work. Definitely worth looking into legit assistance programs.
0 coins
Zainab Omar
I understand you're in a tough financial situation, especially with a new baby and needing reliable transportation for medical appointments. However, I'd strongly encourage you to be very careful about the dependent claiming situation. From what you've described about your previous experience, it does sound like it may not have been entirely legitimate. The IRS dependent rules are strict - your sister would need to provide MORE than half of your total support for the entire year, and you'd need to meet the income requirements. Given that you mentioned having a baby recently, you might actually qualify for some additional tax credits yourself if you file your own return (like the Child Tax Credit), which could be more beneficial than being claimed as someone else's dependent. Before making any decisions, I'd really recommend getting professional advice. You could use one of the free tax preparation services available to low-income individuals, or even contact the IRS directly to understand your specific situation. The last thing you want is to face penalties or have to pay back benefits later when you're already struggling financially. Have you looked into local assistance programs for new parents or people awaiting disability approval? Many communities have emergency assistance funds specifically for situations like yours.
0 coins