< Back to California Unemployment

Will EDD stop my unemployment if I quit my new full-time job?

I just started a full-time job last week but I still have about $3,700 left in my UI claim balance. I've been certifying honestly and reporting my gross income from the new job. Here's the thing - I'm really struggling with this position (horrible management, totally different from what they described in the interview). If I decide to quit after just a couple weeks, will EDD automatically deny me benefits? Will they consider this job voluntary quit even though I've only been there briefly? I'm worried I'll lose all my remaining benefits just because I tried working somewhere that turned out to be toxic. Anyone dealt with something similar?

Yes, if you quit voluntarily without good cause, EDD will likely disqualify you from receiving benefits. When you quit, they'll schedule an eligibility interview to determine if you had "good cause" for leaving. Good cause means compelling reasons that would make a reasonable person who genuinely wants to stay employed leave their job. Poor management alone is typically not considered good cause unless you can document serious issues (harassment, unsafe conditions, etc.). Document EVERYTHING that makes the workplace intolerable - emails, texts, written warnings about conditions, medical notes if the job is affecting your health.

0 coins

Thanks for the detailed response. What if I get fired instead? I'm not planning to get fired on purpose, but honestly with how things are going, it could happen. Would that be different?

0 coins

I went through something rly similar last year. Started a warehouse job & it was NOTHING like they said in interview. Way more physical & dangerous than described. I quit after 3 weeks & lost my benefits for like 2 months while EDD investigated. They scheduled an eligibility interview (took foreeeever to get one) & I had to provide proof of why I quit. Eventually got my benefits back cuz I had emails showing they misrepresented the job + doctor note about back injury from lifting stuff I wasn't supposed to. Document everything!!!

0 coins

Wow, that sounds exactly like what I'm dealing with! They totally misrepresented what this position would involve. Did you have to appeal or did they approve you right after the interview?

0 coins

quit = no benefits sry

0 coins

NeonNinja

This is oversimplified and not entirely accurate. While quitting without good cause typically results in disqualification, the EDD does recognize legitimate reasons for voluntary quits. If OP can document misrepresentation of job duties, unsafe conditions, or other qualifying factors, they may still be eligible after an interview determination.

0 coins

i got laid off from my job n had to take the first thing i could find which was seasonal work at target. it was AWFUL hours and i quit. EDD cut me off completetly for like 6 weeks then had this phone interview thing. got denied cause i didnt have "good cause" whatever that means. system is rigged imo.

0 coins

That's what I'm afraid of... being stuck between a terrible job and no income at all. Did you try appealing their decision?

0 coins

NeonNinja

The key issue here is "good cause." When you quit voluntarily, EDD places the burden on you to prove you had compelling reasons that would cause any reasonable person in your situation to leave that job. Simply disliking management isn't enough, but if you can document unsafe working conditions, significant job misrepresentation, or harassment, you may qualify. Keep detailed records of any incidents, conversations, or evidence showing how the actual job differs from what was described during hiring. Also, try addressing your concerns with management or HR first and document those attempts - this shows EDD you tried to resolve issues before quitting. If you quit without good cause, you'll face a disqualification period.

0 coins

this 100%! i went through somthing similar. make sure u have ACTUAL PROOF not just ur word against theirs. emails texts written stuff etc. EDD is super strict about voluntary quits

0 coins

If your having trouble getting ahold of EDD to ask about this (which u probably will), I used a service called Claimyr last time when I needed to talk to an actual person at EDD. their website is claimyr.com and theres a video showing how it works https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10?si=TSwYbu_GOwYzt9km. It got me through to an agent in like 20 minutes when I'd been trying for days on my own. The agent I talked to was super helpful with my voluntary quit situation and explained exactly what I needed for the eligibility interview.

0 coins

Thanks, I'll check that out. I've been trying to get through to someone at EDD and it's impossible. I need to get specific advice about my situation before making any decisions.

0 coins

Zara Khan

Literally everyone on this thread is missing something HUGE. If you're working FULL TIME, you're already not getting UI benefits regardless of whether you quit or not! When you report full-time work and your gross earnings, EDD doesn't pay you for those weeks even if you have a remaining balance. Your claim stays open for the benefit year, but you don't get payments while fully employed. So if you're not getting money now anyway because of full-time work, the real question is just whether you'd be eligible again if you quit.

0 coins

You're right - I'm not getting benefits currently because my earnings are too high. My concern is about whether I'll be able to resume benefits if this job doesn't work out. I still have almost 4 months left in my benefit year.

0 coins

Since you asked about being fired - that's different from quitting. If you're fired for performance issues or not being a good fit, you typically CAN receive benefits. However, if you're fired for misconduct (stealing, excessive unexcused absences, violating major policies), you'd likely be disqualified. Just being bad at the job or not meeting expectations isn't misconduct. But I wouldn't recommend trying to get fired - that could potentially be considered misconduct if they can prove you were deliberately underperforming.

0 coins

Yup this is accurate. My friend got fired for "poor performance" (she just couldn't keep up with their crazy metrics) and she got approved for UI right away. EDD considers that a "no-fault" termination. But another guy I know got fired for being on his phone too much after multiple warnings & he got denied cuz that was "misconduct"

0 coins

wait how much of ur weekly benefit do u actually get if ur working part time? can u work like 10 hrs a week and still get some UI?

0 coins

NeonNinja

Yes, you can work part-time and receive partial unemployment benefits. EDD uses this formula: For each dollar you earn, they deduct $0.75 from your weekly benefit amount. So if your weekly benefit is $450 and you earn $300 gross, they'd deduct $225 ($300 × 0.75) and you'd receive $225 in UI benefits ($450 - $225). Once your earnings exceed your weekly benefit amount, you receive $0 for that week but remain on an active claim.

0 coins

Thanks everyone for the advice. I think I'm going to document everything about how this job was misrepresented and the issues I'm having. I'll try addressing it with my manager first to see if things improve, and keep all communication in writing. If I do end up quitting, at least I'll have some documentation for the eligibility interview. I really appreciate all the responses.

0 coins

That's the best approach. Remember that EDD takes these cases very seriously and the burden of proof is on you to show good cause. Keep your claim open by continuing to certify (reporting your earnings accurately) even if you're not receiving payments due to full-time work. That way if you do qualify after quitting, there won't be a gap in your claim. Good luck!

0 coins

TaxRefund AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
6,681 users helped today