< Back to California Unemployment

Jean Claude

Can I get UI benefits based on previous employers if I quit my toxic job?

So I'm in a really toxic work environment right now - micromanaging boss, unrealistic deadlines, and coworkers throwing each other under the bus daily. It's seriously affecting my mental health and I can't take it anymore. I've been here for about 7 months, but before this I worked at two stable jobs for nearly 4 years combined with no issues. I know that voluntarily quitting usually disqualifies you from unemployment, but I'm wondering if EDD might consider my previous employment history when making a determination? Like, could they possibly use my wage credits from those previous employers instead of my current toxic job? Or am I completely out of luck if I quit, regardless of the circumstance? I'm trying to weigh my options before making any decisions. Can't really afford to be without income for long, but this workplace is becoming unbearable. Any insights would be super helpful!

Charity Cohan

•

Unfortunately, it doesn't work that way with EDD. Your unemployment claim is based on a specific base period (typically the 12-15 months before you file), and ALL employers during that period are considered part of your claim. EDD doesn't cherry-pick which employer to assign to your claim. If you voluntarily quit without good cause, you'll likely be disqualified regardless of your previous work history. The only exceptions are if you can prove you had "good cause" to quit - like unsafe working conditions, significant changes to your job duties, discrimination, harassment, etc. General toxicity can be hard to prove unless you have documentation. Have you considered looking for another job while still employed? That's usually the safest route.

0 coins

Jean Claude

•

Thanks for the reality check. I was hoping there might be some way around it. I am looking for other jobs but it's been slow going. Do you know if having medical documentation of work-related stress/anxiety would help establish "good cause"? My doctor suggested taking a leave but I'm worried they'll just make things worse when I return.

0 coins

Josef Tearle

•

just quit, who cares. i was in the same boat 2 yrs ago, hated my boss so much i walked out. didnt get UI but found new job in 3 weeks. sometimes ur mental health is more important then $$$$

0 coins

Shelby Bauman

•

This is terrible advice. Not everyone can afford to go without income for weeks or months. OP should absolutely not just quit without having something else lined up unless they have significant savings.

0 coins

Quinn Herbert

•

I've been through the EDD system a few times, and here's what I can tell you from experience: 1. Your claim uses your highest-earning quarter in the base period to calculate your weekly benefit amount. All employers in your base period contribute to your total available claim balance. 2. If you quit, you WILL face an eligibility interview where you must prove you had good cause. This means you need to show you tried to resolve the issues before quitting (speaking with HR, using internal processes, etc). 3. Mental health reasons CAN qualify as good cause, but you need documentation. Get your doctor to document your work-related stress/anxiety NOW, before quitting. 4. Consider requesting a formal workplace accommodation first based on your doctor's recommendation. If they deny reasonable accommodation, that strengthens your UI case. 5. Document EVERYTHING. Toxic behavior, unreasonable demands, any communication about your concerns. Best approach is still finding another job first, but if you absolutely must quit, build your case methodically.

0 coins

Jean Claude

•

This is incredibly helpful, thank you! I never thought about requesting accommodation first - that's smart. I have a therapy appointment next week and will definitely ask for documentation. Also going to start keeping a detailed log of incidents at work.

0 coins

Salim Nasir

•

When i quit my last job i got denied benefits at first but i appealed it and won because i could prove harassment. you gotta have PROOF tho, like emails or texts or witnesses. they dont just take ur word for it. btw goodluck even getting anyone on the phone at EDD to answer questions. i tried for 2 weeks straight and always got the "too many callers" message. so frustrating!!!!

0 coins

Hazel Garcia

•

I had the same problem getting through to EDD last month! After days of frustration, I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) and they got me connected to a rep in about 20 minutes. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10?si=TSwYbu_GOwYzt9km Totally worth it because the EDD rep was able to solve my issue right away instead of me stressing for another week. Just sharing since calling EDD is nearly impossible these days.

0 coins

Salim Nasir

•

omg wish i knew about that sooner!!! took me literally 83 calls one day before i got through

0 coins

Laila Fury

•

Have yuo checked if your situation qualifies as a 'constructive discharge'? Thats when working conditions are so bad that any reasonable person would quit. Technically EDD can see that as the employer pushing you out, not you quitting. But its REALLY HARD to prove unless youve got solid evidence!!!!

0 coins

Quinn Herbert

•

Great point about constructive discharge! It's definitely hard to prove, but possible if the workplace conditions are truly intolerable. Documentation is absolutely critical - contemporaneous notes about incidents, emails, texts, witness statements if possible, and medical documentation. The standard is that the conditions would cause a reasonable person to quit.

0 coins

Shelby Bauman

•

I'm curious why you say you "know" your claim will be denied from your current employer. Have you had previous experience with this? Just to clarify - employers don't approve or deny unemployment claims; EDD makes that determination based on the facts presented by both parties. In my experience as an HR professional (though I'm not with EDD), here are some legitimate reasons that might qualify for "good cause" if you quit: - Significant reduction in hours or pay - Material changes to job duties or working conditions - Discrimination or harassment (documented) - Unsafe working conditions - Medical reasons that employer won't accommodate General toxicity or not liking your boss usually doesn't qualify unless you can demonstrate how it crosses into one of these categories. Just something to consider.

0 coins

Jean Claude

•

You're right, I shouldn't assume what EDD will decide. I think I meant that I expect my employer to contest it since they'll probably claim everything is fine. I appreciate the list of legitimate reasons - the medical angle might be my best option since I can document that.

0 coins

Josef Tearle

•

WRONG! My cousin qualified for disabilty AND unempoyment at the same time when she quit her cashier job! EDD pays people all the time who quit. Its all about how u explain it to them!!

0 coins

Charity Cohan

•

That's actually not possible. You cannot collect disability and unemployment simultaneously - they're mutually exclusive programs. Disability is for when you cannot work due to medical reasons, while unemployment requires you to certify you're able and available for work. Your cousin might have received one benefit and then switched to the other, but definitely not both simultaneously.

0 coins

Quinn Herbert

•

One more thing to consider: if you do quit and file for UI, be prepared for a potentially long wait while EDD investigates. Your employer will be asked to provide their side of the story, and then EDD will schedule an eligibility interview with you (which can take weeks to get). During this time, you won't receive any benefits. If you're eventually approved, you'll get backpay, but you need to be able to financially sustain yourself during the investigation period. And regardless of what happens, continue to certify for benefits every two weeks while your claim is pending. If you don't certify and later get approved, you won't receive payments for weeks you didn't certify.

0 coins

Jean Claude

•

That's a really important point about the wait time. I have about 2 months of expenses saved up, but it sounds like I should try to stretch that further if possible. And good reminder about continuing to certify even while waiting for a determination!

0 coins

I went through a similar situation last year and want to share what worked for me. I was dealing with a verbally abusive supervisor who was creating an impossible work environment. Here's what I did: 1. Started documenting everything immediately - dates, times, witnesses, exactly what was said/done 2. Got my doctor involved early - they documented my anxiety and stress symptoms as work-related 3. Filed a complaint with HR first (even though I knew they wouldn't help much) 4. When HR didn't address it properly, I requested FMLA leave for stress/anxiety 5. Used that time to job hunt intensively When my leave was up and nothing had changed, I quit with a resignation letter that clearly outlined why (referencing my previous complaints and medical documentation). I filed for UI immediately and got approved after the eligibility interview because I had a paper trail showing I tried to resolve things through proper channels first. The key is building your case BEFORE you quit. Don't just walk out - that makes it much harder to win an appeal. Take Quinn's advice seriously about the accommodation request - it shows good faith effort to stay employed. Also, start applying for jobs NOW while you're still employed. Even if this workplace is toxic, having income while job searching gives you so much more leverage and peace of mind.

0 coins

James Johnson

•

This is exactly the kind of strategic approach I needed to hear! Thank you for sharing your experience. It sounds like you really built a solid case by going through proper channels first. I'm going to follow your playbook - start documenting everything now, get my doctor to officially document the work-related stress, and file that HR complaint even if I don't expect much. The FMLA angle is brilliant too since it gives me time to job hunt while still being employed. Really appreciate you taking the time to lay out the step-by-step process!

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,087 users helped today