


Ask the community...
Reality check: EDD gets millions of calls but has maybe 500 agents total. The math will never work for everyone to get through manually. At some point you need alternative solutions to actually reach a live person.
I feel your pain so much! I'm in the exact same boat - been trying for weeks with my pending claim and getting nowhere with manual calling. After reading through all these comments, I think I need to seriously consider using one of those auto-dialer services. The math everyone's sharing really shows how broken the manual approach has become. Has anyone had success getting their pending claims resolved once they actually got through to an agent? I'm worried that even if I manage to connect, they still won't be able to fix my issue.
@Connor O'Brien I'm dealing with the exact same pending claim nightmare! Been stuck for 3 weeks now and reading everyone's attempts here is both reassuring and terrifying. The statistics people are sharing about call success rates really opened my eyes - I had no idea it was mathematically this broken. I think I'm going to try the Wednesday 2-3pm window that @Zoe Papadopoulos mentioned for maybe one more week, but honestly after seeing @Connor Gallagher s'success story with Claimyr, I m'leaning toward just using the auto-dialer too. My sanity and lost work time are worth more than the stubborn pride of doing it manually at this point.
@Connor O'Brien I totally understand your frustration! I was in a similar situation with a pending claim and felt the same way about whether it would even get resolved once I got through. From what I've seen in this thread and my own experience, most pending claims really are just missing paperwork or simple verification issues that agents can fix quickly once you actually connect. The real challenge is just getting that connection. After reading all these success stories with Claimyr and seeing the math breakdown that @Mei Wong shared about millions of calls vs 500 agents, I think the auto-dialer route makes the most sense. I was stubborn about doing it manually too, but sometimes you have to use the tools available to work within a broken system. Good luck whatever you decide!
One more important point: make sure you meet the earnings requirement to qualify for UI. You need to have earned at least $1,300 in your highest-earning quarter during your base period, or at least $900 in your highest quarter and 1.25 times that amount across the entire base period. Based on your hourly wage, you should easily qualify if you've been working consistently, but it's something to be aware of. Also, start your work search requirements immediately after filing - EDD requires three work search activities per week for most claimants now.
I've been at this job for 3 years full-time, so I should definitely meet the earnings requirement. The work search activities - does applying for jobs online count? Or do I need to do in-person applications too?
Online applications definitely count! EDD accepts various work search activities including online job applications, attending job fairs, networking events, and even creating/updating professional profiles like LinkedIn. You just need to keep detailed records of each activity - employer name, position applied for, date, and method of contact. Some people also count skills training or career workshops as work search activities. The key is documenting everything in case EDD audits your work search log.
I went through a very similar situation about 6 months ago! The key thing that helped me was getting my boss to acknowledge in writing (via email) that I had requested to withdraw my resignation but he was choosing not to accept it. I sent him an email saying something like "As we discussed, I am withdrawing my two weeks notice and would like to continue my employment, but you indicated you prefer to proceed with my departure in May." He replied confirming that was correct. When EDD called him, his story matched mine exactly because we both had the same email thread. Got approved without any issues after the phone interview. The whole process took about 3 weeks from filing to first payment. Document everything and you should be fine!
This is such smart advice! Getting that email confirmation was genius - it creates a clear paper trail that protects you if stories get mixed up later. I'm definitely going to send my boss an email like that to document our conversation about me wanting to stay but him choosing to let me go anyway. Did you have to wait long for the phone interview after filing, or did it happen pretty quickly?
To summarize what we've discussed for your situation: 1. You need at least $1,300 in your highest quarter OR $900 in your highest quarter plus 1.25x that amount total 2. Your base period would be January 2024-December 2024 if filing now 3. Since you were on unemployment during part of that period, you might need to use the Alternate Base Period 4. The ABP would include your recent $4,800 in earnings 5. You should apply and let EDD determine if you qualify 6. Consider using a calling service if you need to speak with an EDD representative for clarification Finally, once you apply, make sure to certify for benefits every two weeks even while your claim is pending determination.
Just wanted to add - if you do get approved for a new claim, there's a one-week waiting period before you can receive benefits, even if you're eligible. This is different from continuing an existing claim. Also, make sure to keep detailed records of your job search activities from day one, as EDD may audit your work search requirements at any time. I learned this the hard way when they asked for 6 months of job search documentation retroactively. Good luck with your application!
Thanks for mentioning the waiting period! I had completely forgotten about that from my first claim. Do you know if the waiting period applies even if you've already served one on a previous claim? Also, regarding the job search requirements - are they still requiring 3 job contacts per week, or has that changed recently? I want to make sure I'm prepared before I start certifying.
I'm dealing with this exact situation right now too! Just wanted to add something I learned from my tax preparer that might help - if you use accounting software like QuickBooks Self-Employed or even just a basic spreadsheet to track your 1099 income going forward, it makes the quarterly breakdown SO much easier for future claims. I wish I had started doing this earlier because trying to reconstruct quarterly earnings from bank statements and random invoices was a nightmare. For this current claim, I ended up calling my biggest 1099 clients to ask when they paid me last year since some of my records were incomplete. Also, heads up that if you have multiple 1099 clients, you might need to enter each one separately in the EDD system depending on how it prompts you. I had three different clients and the system treated each as a separate "employer" which was confusing but ultimately worked out fine. One more thing - make sure to save a PDF copy of your completed application before submitting it. The EDD system timed out on me twice while I was entering all the 1099 details and I had to start over. Super frustrating when you're trying to get all those quarterly amounts entered correctly! Hope this helps and good luck to everyone navigating this process. The mixed income thing definitely makes it more complicated but it's totally doable with the right preparation.
@Jessica Nolan That s'such good advice about the accounting software! I ve'been doing everything manually and it s'definitely a mess trying to piece together quarterly amounts after the fact. Do you know if EDD accepts screenshots from QuickBooks or similar software as documentation if they ask for proof during the review process? I m'thinking it might be worth setting something up now even though I m'already filing, just to have better records going forward if I need to file again in the future. Also, the multiple 1099 clients thing is something I hadn t'thought about - I have two regular clients plus some one-off projects. Did you end up grouping the smaller one-time clients together somehow or did you really have to enter each individual client separately? The EDD system already seems overwhelming without having to create like 6 different employer "entries!"
@Jessica Nolan Great point about saving a PDF copy! I learned that lesson the hard way when the system crashed on me right at the end. For the multiple clients question - I had a similar situation and ended up grouping my smaller one-off clients under Self-Employed "- Freelance Design as" one entry, then listed my two bigger regular clients separately. The EDD rep I spoke with during my phone interview said this was totally fine as long as the total income amounts were accurate. They care more about getting the right quarterly totals than having every single client listed individually. Just make sure you can explain your grouping if they ask about it during review!
This is such a timely thread for me! I'm in the exact same boat - lost my main W-2 job two weeks ago but have been doing some freelance writing on the side for about a year. Reading through everyone's experiences has been incredibly helpful, especially about the quarterly breakdown approach. I wanted to add one thing I discovered while preparing my application - if you use payment platforms like PayPal, Venmo for Business, or Stripe for your freelance work, they usually have built-in reporting features that can show you earnings by date range. I was able to pull quarterly reports directly from PayPal which saved me hours of digging through bank statements. Just go to the "Reports" section and you can filter by custom date ranges for each quarter. Also, for anyone worried about the phone interview process - I actually just had mine yesterday and it was way less intimidating than I expected. The rep was really understanding about mixed income situations and mainly just wanted to verify that I had legitimate 1099 work and that my W-2 job loss was involuntary. The whole call took maybe 15 minutes and she approved my claim on the spot. One tip: have your actual 1099 forms handy during the call, not just your tax return. She asked me to read off the specific amounts from two of my 1099s to cross-reference with what I had entered in the system. Thanks to everyone for sharing your experiences - this community knowledge is so much more practical than trying to navigate EDD's confusing website alone!
@Mikayla Davison This is so helpful! I completely forgot about PayPal s'reporting features - I ve'been using it for most of my freelance payments and was dreading having to manually calculate everything from bank statements. Just logged in and found exactly what I need under the Reports section. This is going to save me so much time! Also really reassuring to hear that your phone interview went smoothly. I ve'been stressing about that part since everyone talks about how backed up EDD is, but 15 minutes and approved on the spot sounds way better than I was expecting. Did they give you any timeline for when your first payment would come through after the approval? Thanks for the tip about having the actual 1099 forms ready too - I was just planning to have my tax return but I ll'make sure to dig out all the individual forms just in case.
StarSailor
Have you considered looking into job training programs? Sometimes EDD offers extensions if you're enrolled in approved training. Might be worth checking out!
0 coins
Natalie Adams
I went through this exact same situation a few months ago! What ended up working for me was filing an appeal through the online portal - sometimes there are computational errors in how they calculate your remaining balance. Also, check if you qualify for any of the federal extension programs that might still be available. In the meantime, make sure you're still certifying for benefits even if it shows $0, because if an extension gets approved, you don't want to miss out on back payments. The whole process is super confusing, but don't give up! 💪
0 coins