< Back to California Unemployment

Will EDD disqualify me if I quit a new job after 3 days due to job being beyond my skills?

I'm in a really difficult situation and need advice about my EDD benefits. I was laid off when my company downsized last month. I filed for unemployment and received payment for my first week, but my second week is still on hold for some reason. During my third week, I started a new job that seemed promising, but after just 3 days, I'm realizing it's completely wrong for me. The position requires technical skills way beyond what was described in the interview. My supervisor constantly makes me feel incompetent, and I leave work every day with crippling anxiety. I've been in the workforce for over 25 years and have only needed unemployment twice (both from companies closing), so I'm not someone who jumps from job to job. My question is: if I quit this new position after only working 3 days and report those work hours, will EDD consider that 'refusing suitable work' and disqualify me? I need to keep receiving benefits while I search for a job that actually matches my skill set. Has anyone dealt with something similar? How should I handle reporting the 3 days I worked, and what happens if I don't return to this job?

AstroAce

•

You need to be careful here. EDD can potentially disqualify you for quitting without 'good cause.' However, if the job duties are significantly different from what was described during hiring, that could qualify as good cause. Make sure you document EVERYTHING - save the job listing, any emails about job duties, and write down specific examples of tasks that were beyond your skills. When you certify, accurately report the days/hours worked, and when asked why you're no longer working there, select 'quit' and be prepared to explain. They'll likely schedule an eligibility interview to determine if you had good cause. Don't panic though - you can definitely present your case that the job misrepresented the required skills/duties.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

•

Thank you for the detailed response. I don't have the job description in writing but the interview definitely didn't mention the complex database management they expected me to know from day one. Should I try to get something in writing from them about the actual job requirements before I quit? I'm scared about the eligibility interview - how long do those typically take to schedule?

0 coins

Chloe Martin

•

i quit a job after 2 days last yr and EDD still paid me. just tell them the job wasnt as described and ur mental health was suffering. they usualy understand if the job isnt a good fit

0 coins

Diego Rojas

•

This is BAD advice. EDD doesn't just automatically pay you if you quit because it "wasn't a good fit." You need legitimate good cause or you WILL be disqualified. I went through this last year and had to appeal a disqualification. It depends entirely on the specific situation and how the interviewer evaluates your reasons.

0 coins

The key issue here is whether EDD will determine you had "good cause" to quit. Based on my experience helping clients with similar situations, here are some legitimate reasons EDD typically accepts: 1. Job duties substantially different from what was advertised/promised 2. Work environment that is hostile or abusive 3. Work conditions that affect your health (including mental health with documentation) 4. Unsafe working conditions When you certify, you must report the hours worked accurately. When asked why you're no longer working there, you'll select "quit" and then be prompted to provide an explanation. Be specific about how the job misrepresented the required skills and how it's affecting your health. They'll schedule an eligibility interview where you'll explain in detail. Documentation is critical - if you have texts/emails showing the stress, any medical documentation about anxiety, or anything in writing about the job duties, save it all. EDD will make a determination based on your interview and any evidence you provide.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

•

This is so helpful, thank you. I do have texts to my sister where I was describing how stressed I was after each day, and I have an appointment with my doctor next week where I can discuss the anxiety it's causing. I'm just worried about that gap between quitting and whenever they schedule the eligibility interview - will I still receive benefits during that time?

0 coins

You'll continue certifying as normal, but they typically put payments on hold pending the interview result. The interview could take 2-6 weeks to schedule (they're backed up). If determined eligible, you'll receive all back payments. If determined ineligible, you can appeal within 30 days. The doctor's documentation will be extremely helpful - make sure they understand the situation and document the work-related anxiety. Good luck!

0 coins

Sean O'Donnell

•

I went through EXACTLY this last year. I took a job that was advertised as basic customer service but when I got there they wanted me doing complex financial reconciliations I had no training for. I quit after a week and had the same fears about my benefits. Here's what happened: I certified honestly, reported my work hours, and selected that I quit. My payments went to pending, and they scheduled an eligibility interview about 3 weeks later. The interviewer asked detailed questions about the job duties vs. what was described in the interview. I explained calmly that the position required skills I didn't have and wasn't trained for. They ruled in my favor and all my pending payments were released. The most frustrating part was trying to reach EDD while waiting for the interview to check on my claim status. I discovered a service called Claimyr (claimyr.com) that got me through to an EDD rep in about 20 minutes instead of spending days redialing. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10?si=TSwYbu_GOwYzt9km. It really helped ease my mind to talk to someone directly while waiting for the interview.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

•

That's a huge relief to hear someone had almost the identical situation and it worked out. Did you have any documentation or was your verbal explanation enough? I'm definitely going to need to speak with EDD directly to check on both the held week from before and then about this situation, so I might try that service while waiting.

0 coins

Sean O'Donnell

•

My verbal explanation was enough, but I did have the original job posting saved which helped. The interview was pretty straightforward - they just wanted to establish that I didn't quit without good cause. Be honest, specific, and unemotional in explaining the mismatch between your skills and what they expected. And definitely call to check on that held week - could be an identity verification issue or something simple they need from you.

0 coins

Zara Ahmed

•

THE EDD SYSTEM IS RIGGED TO DISQUALIFY PEOPLE!!!! I had almost the SAME situation and they denied me because I "should have tried harder to resolve the situation with the employer" before quitting. They make up any excuse not to pay! It's all about WHO you get for your interview and if they're having a good day or not. The whole system is designed to frustrate people into giving up!!!!

0 coins

AstroAce

•

While I understand your frustration, this isn't universally true. EDD decisions are based on specific facts and circumstances of each case. Some people do need to demonstrate they tried to resolve workplace issues before quitting. OP's situation might be different if the job genuinely required skills they don't possess and weren't in the job description.

0 coins

StarStrider

•

im confused about something in your post. you said they held your second week? did you get a disqualification notice or something for that week? might wanna fix that issue first before adding this new complication. sometimes weeks get held for random verification stuff that has nothing to do with work stuff.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

•

You know what, you're right! I should find out why that week is on hold before I make things more complicated. I didn't receive any specific notice - it just says "pending" in my UI Online account. I'm going to try calling them tomorrow morning about that specific issue first.

0 coins

One additional point that hasn't been mentioned: If you decide to quit, try having a conversation with your supervisor first about the skill mismatch. Say something like: "I'm finding that this role requires technical skills beyond my experience level that weren't discussed during the hiring process. Is there additional training available or perhaps a more suitable role?" EDD may ask if you tried to resolve the situation before quitting. Having this conversation (even if it doesn't change anything) strengthens your case that you had good cause to quit. Document when you had this conversation and what was said.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

•

That's excellent advice. I'm going to try having that conversation tomorrow. If they're unwilling to provide training or accommodate the skill gap, at least I'll be able to tell EDD I tried to resolve the situation before quitting. I'll take notes right after the conversation so I remember the details.

0 coins

Chloe Martin

•

btw did u ever find out why they held that week? sometimes edd just randomly holds payments for id verification or quarterly income review. happened to me 2x last yr

0 coins

Omar Zaki

•

I haven't been able to reach anyone yet. I'm going to try calling right when they open tomorrow. The timing is weird because it was just my second week, so I don't think it would be a quarterly review. Maybe ID verification? But wouldn't they send me a notice?

0 coins

AstroAce

•

After reading through all the comments, I think you should take these steps in order: 1. First, try to resolve the held week issue - call EDD or check for notices in your UI Online inbox 2. Have a documented conversation with your supervisor about the skill mismatch 3. If nothing changes, quit with a formal notice that references the skill mismatch 4. Report your work accurately when certifying 5. Prepare all your documentation for the eligibility interview 6. See your doctor to document the anxiety this is causing This strategic approach gives you the strongest case for continuing benefits. Remember that while quitting is always scrutinized by EDD, they do understand legitimate mismatches between job requirements and employee skills, especially when it affects your wellbeing.

0 coins

Omar Zaki

•

Thank you for laying it out so clearly. I'll follow these steps exactly. I'm actually feeling less anxious now having a plan. I'll update after I talk to my supervisor and EDD.

0 coins

TaxRefund AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
6,725 users helped today