ESD denied my remaining benefits after quitting new job - options?
I'm freaking out right now. I was on unemployment for about 9 weeks when I got offered a position that seemed perfect. Took the job, stopped filing, and officially started 3 weeks ago. Well, turns out the workplace is TOXIC. Manager screams at staff, constantly changing expectations, and the job duties are nothing like what was described in the interview. I quit yesterday after another blowup. Tried to file for UI again today and the system asked about why I left this job. When I put 'quit' it gave me this warning about possibly being disqualified. Does this mean I've completely lost ALL my remaining unemployment benefits? I still had like 14 weeks left on my claim! Anyone dealt with something like this? Is there a way to explain the situation to ESD?
18 comments
Freya Ross
You're not automatically disqualified, but you'll need to provide good cause for quitting. ESD considers things like significant changes in working conditions, safety issues, or hostile work environments as potential good cause. Document EVERYTHING about that toxic environment - emails, texts, any proof of the manager's behavior. You'll likely go through adjudication where they'll investigate your reason for leaving. Be very specific about how the actual job differed from what was described in the interview.
0 coins
Butch Sledgehammer
•Thank you! Do you know how long adjudication usually takes? I'm worried about paying rent.
0 coins
Leslie Parker
ur probably screwed. they almost NEVER approve benefits when u quit. they make it nearlt impossible unless ur boss like literally attacked you or something. the system is such BS
0 coins
Sergio Neal
•Not true. I quit a job last year and still qualified for benefits. It depends on your situation. The key is documenting everything and being specific about why the conditions were untenable. ESD doesn't expect people to work in truly hostile environments, but they do need evidence.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
This literally just happened to me last month!! I quit a warehouse job after 2 weeks because they made us lift stuff WAY heavier than they told us in the interview without proper equipment. My claim went to adjudication for like 3 weeks but I eventually got approved because I could prove the job was different than described. Hang in there!
0 coins
Butch Sledgehammer
•That gives me some hope... I should have taken screenshots of the job listing to compare with what I was actually doing. Did you have to do a phone interview?
0 coins
Juan Moreno
When they put you in adjudication, you'll be waiting FOREVER to get through to anyone at ESD. I was in a similar situation and spent weeks trying to reach someone. I finally used Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got through to ESD in about 20 minutes instead of waiting days or weeks. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ?si=26TzE_zGms-DODN3. Definitely worth it when you're desperate to resolve an adjudication issue like this.
0 coins
Butch Sledgehammer
•I've never heard of that service but I'll check it out if I can't get through. Did ESD end up approving your claim after quitting?
0 coins
Amy Fleming
I work in HR and deal with this frequently. Here's what you need to know about quitting and UI: 1. Washington state recognizes "quit with good cause" which includes substantial deterioration in work conditions 2. Document SPECIFICALLY how the job differed from what was promised 3. Did you attempt to resolve the issues with management before quitting? ESD will ask this 4. Be prepared for a fact-finding interview where both you and the employer will give statements The key is being able to demonstrate that any reasonable person would have quit under those circumstances. It's not impossible to qualify after quitting, but you need to build your case carefully.
0 coins
Freya Ross
•This is spot on. The fact-finding interview is crucial. Make sure you have dates, specific incidents, and any documentation ready. Be professional, stick to facts, and avoid emotional language even if you're justifiably upset about the situation.
0 coins
Alice Pierce
wait so if u get a job while on unemployment and it doesnt work out, u lose all ur benefits?? thats messed up! doesnt that discourage people from taking jobs??
0 coins
Amy Fleming
•It's more nuanced than that. If you quit without good cause, then yes, you can be disqualified. But if the job truly misrepresented the position or created a hostile work environment, you can still qualify. The system is designed to encourage work but not force people to stay in truly unsuitable positions. It's case-by-case, which is why documentation is so important.
0 coins
Sergio Neal
I went through something similar in January. My advice: 1. Immediately file an appeal if you get denied 2. Request a copy of your employer file from ESD 3. Get statements from any coworkers willing to corroborate the toxic environment 4. Print any emails or texts that show the job was different than described 5. Be ready to wait - my adjudication took 5 weeks In my case, I eventually got approved retroactively and received back payment. Document EVERYTHING and be persistent. The system isn't easy to navigate but you do have rights.
0 coins
Butch Sledgehammer
•Thanks for the detailed advice! Did you continue filing weekly claims during the adjudication period even though they weren't being paid? I'm not sure if I should keep filing while this gets sorted out.
0 coins
Sergio Neal
YES! Keep filing your weekly claims even while in adjudication! That's super important. If you stop filing and then eventually get approved, you won't get paid for weeks you didn't claim. The system will show them as pending until a decision is made.
0 coins
Butch Sledgehammer
•Ok that's really good to know - I'll make sure to keep filing every week. Thank you!
0 coins
Esteban Tate
My sister is a claims specialist at ESD (not speaking officially!!!) and she says they get this situation ALL THE TIME. Big thing they look for: did you try to resolve the issues before quitting? If you can show you talked to a supervisor or HR about the problems before walking out, that helps your case a lot. Also I heard the average adjudication time right now is like 4-5 weeks so prepare financially if possible.
0 coins
Savanna Franklin
•4-5 weeks is crazy long! They really expect people to just survive with no income for over a month??
0 coins